Understanding When The NSA Discloses Cyber Vulnerabilities

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The NSA would like to take this opportunity to let you know that they still do what they want, when they want. Thank you for your cooperation.

We have also established a disciplined, rigorous and high-level decision-making process for vulnerability disclosure. This interagency process helps ensure that all of the pros and cons are properly considered and weighed. While there are no hard and fast rules, here are a few things I want to know when an agency proposes temporarily withholding knowledge of a vulnerability.
 
Well, how could they every use FUD (fear / uncertainty / doubt) if most folks didn't know?
 
This is great. NSA finds vulnerabilities to hack into other systems. However, by not disclosing the vulnerability, they leave their own systems, and those of all government agencies exposed.
 
This is one reason I'm very torn about the NSA's mission.

NSA says "We need to keep this vulnerability so we can attack other countries attack plans against us"

Meanwhile millions of credit card numbers, social security numbers and personal information is breached every year leading to millions if not possibly hundreds of millions of dollars in identity theft.

You know if a drug company withheld evidence that their drug could cause problems, but we wasn't to keep it around because our competitor is using it on their CEO, there would be a MASSIVE lawsuit.

To assume someone will not think of a similar exploit is just foolish.

And NSA has yet to prove that keep vulnerabilities protects the USA. How did the Chinese get the plans to the JSF aircraft? Apparently even with their best people, they still can't protect our most vital secrets.

My disgust with the NSA is not because I don't believe in their mission. My disgust is how they are going about doing it. I'm not anti national security. I'm not anarchist. I'm not violent. I'm anti hypocritical and anti short-sighted.

NSA should be focusing on shoring up critical systems and isolating them from outside attack. No documents or data of vital national interest should be allowed to be connected to the internet. They should be 100% isolated on their own net, like the early days or DARPA. Expensive: Yes? Keeping power plants, factories, and militaries from shutting down at a keypress? Priceless.
 
You know if a drug company withheld evidence that their drug could cause adverse health problems, but the drug company didn't want to disclose the health risk, because their main competitor was using it, there would be a MASSIVE lawsuit.
 
You know if a drug company withheld evidence that their drug could cause adverse health problems, but the drug company didn't want to disclose the health risk, because their main competitor was using it, there would be a MASSIVE lawsuit.

Thanks for the extra emphasis :)
 
This is great. NSA finds vulnerabilities to hack into other systems. However, by not disclosing the vulnerability, they leave their own systems, and those of all government agencies exposed.

What makes you come to that conclusion?

I say that because, as an example, there are many software applications, etc, that the Government doesn't allow on their systems. They disable many things that others consider useful. So their level of risk is not the same as our level of risk, specially true for the DoD and Intelligence service classified networks, which are isolated and heavily encrypted.
 
NSA should be focusing on shoring up critical systems and isolating them from outside attack.
Not their job, it's someone else' job to do that stuff. The NSA's job is Intelligence Collection and protecting Military Networks, Military, not the everyone else, that's someone else' job.
 
How did the Chinese get the plans to the JSF aircraft?

Well when the Government insists that we need to import skilled specialists from other countries and that businesses have to hire them then you wind up with foreign engineers designing our stuff for us. Come on, it's like asking China to build our next warplane for us and expect them to not know what it can do.
 
What makes you come to that conclusion?
Jumps to defend against allegations of wrong doing.

Not their job, it's someone else' job to do that stuff.
Denies responsibility.

Well ... then you wind up with foreign engineers designing our stuff for us.
Blames foreigners when clear example of failure is given.


Good god, we have found the perfect government employee.
 
What makes you come to that conclusion?

I say that because, as an example, there are many software applications, etc, that the Government doesn't allow on their systems. They disable many things that others consider useful. So their level of risk is not the same as our level of risk, specially true for the DoD and Intelligence service classified networks, which are isolated and heavily encrypted.

Does that include not allowing flash or java?

You d realize these are government employees. The same government employees who can't get their tax systems off XP despite years of knowledge that XP was being phased out.

So which drugs are you smoking?
 
Not their job, it's someone else' job to do that stuff. The NSA's job is Intelligence Collection and protecting Military Networks, Military, not the everyone else, that's someone else' job.

Power stations and military contractors are valuable strategic assets which might be attacked by foreign powers. And you are going to tell me that the NSA shouldn't be protecting them?

Oh wait I get it now, you are trolling. No one with half a brain is that f'n daft
 
Does that include not allowing flash or java?

You d realize these are government employees. The same government employees who can't get their tax systems off XP despite years of knowledge that XP was being phased out.

So which drugs are you smoking?

Sound argument. I heard Joe from the gubmit spends 20 hours a week administering IRS networks running XP, and the other 20 hours a week working on top secret DoD networks.
 
Back
Top