Understanding Free-to-Play Monetization

John_Keck

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 3, 2010
Messages
379
Here in the western gaming world there’s a stigma attached to free-to-play games with aggressive monetization practices. Most companies that try a free-to-play (F2P) business model offer either a small, roped off section and/or mostly aesthetic character augmentations. The author of this article claims that this practice usually generates $7.50 per user per month on average, but a large user base. The other type of F2P model includes a very aggressive store which sells both functional and aesthetic items, leading to a smaller, more loyal user base which spends on average of $50/month.

In summary: because so few players actually pay anything for F2P games, the less aggressively you offer opportunities for paying users to support you, the less likely you are to be successful. And while it is possible to imagine a game that accomplishes this without selling functional items, progress accelerators, etc, that’s a hard feat to pull off.
 
So you're expected to fork out $60 - $120 dollars per year for aesthetical tat, and $600 plus per year to get all the tools and abilities? Are they mad? Knobby Crotchitch business 101. Don't you just love capitalism?
 
These "Free to Play" games actually, when it comes down to it, wind up costing about 10 times more than a game like World of Warcraft, to get the same basic level of stuff.. It's free, but you hardly get any inventory or storage.. By the time you purchase storage space for 1 character, you're already paying as much as if you'd just freaking play WoW.

It's just another form of wallet rape.
 
If you ask me they would get a lot more subscribers if they just used both F2P and P2P models. $5 dollars a month and having the option to buy items/gold is a good deal for a triple A game such as WoW. Hopefully not charging a arm and a leg for items either, maybe something cheap but also have the option of playing for it.

I think if they could find a good balance of game quality and price to pay for the game they'll make some money and keep a good player base. Unlike whats been happening with Tabula Rasa, Warhammer, and a lot of the other MMOs that are/have sunk.

I think where things are going wrong is a lot of developers are expecting people to spend $15 dollars a month on a new MMO when all their friends and people they know are playing WoW. They need to undercut Blizzard to steal their customer base, they aren't going to do it by going head to head with them.
 
GW is free to play, but it does have aesthetic upgrades for purchase along with multiple game sections which work a lot like the WoW expansions except you can play any one of the 3 without buying the other 2 (or the complete pack).
 
I think the LOTRO model will be the future, subscription if you want it which includes everything. While the free to play part they give you the basic things, and you unlock things like extra bags and character slots and also the content, like zones(no weapons or items for sale). I will not mind playing the LOTRO model because it won't be a model where you have to spend $400-1000 to stay competitive.
 
RuneScape has managed this model fine for years now.

F2P gets updates and a fair chunk of stuff.
P2P gets way more updates and ridiculously more stuff.

Unfortunately the game has lots of grinding, an immature (i.e., young) player-base and a tendency to cause RSI, but in terms of money, Jagex does very well indeed from it and its growing number of other Java games.
 
I recently got suckered into trying DDO by some friends, and whatever DDO is doing, it seems to be really working. Don't care what some opinion article thinks.
 
Big issue I've had with F2P games. Micro transactions that actually affect gameplay.

All games should start on completely even ground for all players. There should be no bonuses or quirks of any kind.
 
I recently got suckered into trying DDO by some friends, and whatever DDO is doing, it seems to be really working. Don't care what some opinion article thinks.

That's the thing, Turbine knows how to do it in a way where you don't feel like you are getting screwed over.
 
being i know nobody that does this and i know tons of gamers that play free to play games:
its bs

if 100 users dont spend any and 1 guy spends 100/mo = 1$ not 7 or 50.

however there is a very good potential market. even low cost games like fat princess
15$ original sale

2-5$ every few months for updates. not 50$ lol
 
I can't get to the article for whatever reason so do not know the scope of the it but the Asian market for F2P games with micro transactions to be better than the next dude is insane. Can't say I understand it since most of the Asian games I see are cookie cutter piles of shit /shrug. Maybe I have not seen many.

IIRC the stabbings and beatings in Korea centered around online games and items were with F2P games. Some folks take this crap pretty seriously.

Personally, I avoid them like the plague unless they offer no decisive advantage to the fellow willing to part with gobs of cash. ESPECIALLY the PvP games. F2P sounds good and all until you get assraped all day by folks who invest too much money into a game...it's bad enough getting assraped by those folks who turn a game into their life's work and reason for being on the planet. I generally suck at PvP though so ignore my hate.
 
How prevalent are computer rental shops stateside?
 
That's the thing, Turbine knows how to do it in a way where you don't feel like you are getting screwed over.

If you haven't played this game, a few things that they have gotten right.

1. No, they don't require "wallet rape". The old method of paying $15/month is still there, and gets almost everything you can buy in the store (of course they allow you to keep spending, but the returns steadily diminish).

2. Free to play, pay for content. About 1/3 of the content is free. This is roughly the same size as doom, classic wolfenstein, and quake, so gives you plenty free fun before you are addicted.

3. Pay for content, not pay to win. While someone mentioned Runescape allows buying "ridiculously more stuff", the best way to "buy" equipment is to buy the content and play to get the good stuff to drop (note that all content is included in the $15/month deal). Also note that "the good stuff" is often "bound to account", meaning you can't mosey over to the auction house and buy it in game (or through a gold farmer). You also get to pay ~$10 (for the shared bank, not per transaction. Included in $15/m) if your wizard pulls a great axe of pwnage (bound to account) and you want to give it to your barbarian.

[more in depth blather follows, the above is enough to understand while DDO gets it right, rather than the articles "f2p is always this way" point.]

I should point out that this might not be as stable as it looks. Turbine appears to have solved the f2p issue, but they just got bought out by Time-Warner. Never underestimate corporate greed to kill the golden goose. There are plenty of gripes that DDO is pushing pay-to-win (or at least right now pay-to-be-adequate). The DDO store makes a good percentage of money off of sp pots (mana potions) that are expensive in game and allow for careless play. They have also recently added stuff that are neither cosmetic nor vendor trash. These include potions of beholder immunity (this ought to be included in those "fight beholder" ads. In other f2p games you fight traffic, in ours you can fight our specially proprietary monster, or p2p to nerf it) and mummy immunity. Note that beholder immunity drastically changes a few quests and is either expensive or a huge grind fest to get in game (I've never bothered, but have slightly altered my specs to kill them easier - favored enemy aberration). In other news they added just-barely-non-vendor-trash weapons to the DDO store, some acid weapons.

Note to new players: don't do what the www.gamespy.com reviewer did. Don't buy weapons/armor with turbine points (about the only thing you might consider is that $.05 (in points they give you) bottle in exchange for a resurrection cookie, otherwise save your points for content). You will be given a roughly +1 weapon 10 minutes into the game. In another 10 minutes, you will get a weapon that works as well (in the beginner section anyway) as the acid weapons. Buy the time you leave Korthos (the beginner section), you should be able to afford both weapons (you want a weapon of lesser reptile bane) and armor from the auction house (remember to use the buyout option if you haven't coughed up any real money, you can only have one bid at a time).
 
How prevalent are computer rental shops stateside?

Rare I would guess. I don't even know how to search for them online due to a lack of common name.

Everyone I know buys their systems and plays at home.
 
Rent-A-Center and Aarons come to mind. Pretty sure RAC is nationwide more or less. You will be renting a shitbox though.
 
Rare I would guess. I don't even know how to search for them online due to a lack of common name.

Everyone I know buys their systems and plays at home.

Valve lists 2 certified "Steam Cyber Cafe's" in the state of Mass.
1 in Maine
3 in NH
 
I started CrimeCraft last night and I have to say for a free game I really like it.
 
Back
Top