Ultimate Gravitational Waves Demo

The drill gag at 5:30 cracked me up, and the roach at 8:55. But seriously a really good demo, and very well explained.
 
I'm failing to see how making a spiral pattern using two off set wheels demonstrates gravitational waves.
 
I'm failing to see how making a spiral pattern using two off set wheels demonstrates gravitational waves.

The two wheels represent massive objects (like two stars or two black holes) in orbit around each other. Which is what was detected by LIGO. If you don't understand what the waves represent, you should re-watch the part of the video where he talks about the "speed of light" of his "universe".
 
This was fantastic. I rather enjoyed the whole video. Thanks for finding this Steve.
 
Gravity is particles, not waves. All this video does is perpetuate an untrue myth about gravity theory.
 
As far as I know, gravitons have not been tested for yet.
Fermilab | Science | Inquiring Minds | Questions About Physics
Let me know if you know something I dont.
Your link basically demonstrated my point. No one really knows exactly how gravity works, but evidence is leaning more towards it being particle based. The LIGO experiment was an anomaly, and the OP video is preaching waves as gospel. These people who put all their faith in gravity waves, I call them "wavers," they're as bad as creationists trying to say they can use science to prove God.
 
Your link basically demonstrated my point. No one really knows exactly how gravity works, but evidence is leaning more towards it being particle based. The LIGO experiment was an anomaly, and the OP video is preaching waves as gospel. These people who put all their faith in gravity waves, I call them "wavers," they're as bad as creationists trying to say they can use science to prove God.
What evidence is there leaning towards the graviton? Granted I've been "out of the game" for a while, but I would still think that someone discovering a spin-2 boson would have been news I would have heard. And calling LIGO an anomaly? Now while it is true that it might be but calling a scientific experiment that showed results as invalid while pounding your chest about some particle that can't even be renormalized by mathematicians then having the audacity to call others as "wavers" is just silly.
 
I don't know the names of the videos, but I watched a few that showed math concepts in a different way (ex correlation between sin and cos). I wanted my math professors to watch these - I would have been understood what we are doing (and why!) so much earlier. This guy's video is like that to me. I'm subscribing now.
 
Gravity is particles, not waves. All this video does is perpetuate an untrue myth about gravity theory.
Your link basically demonstrated my point. No one really knows exactly how gravity works, but evidence is leaning more towards it being particle based. The LIGO experiment was an anomaly, and the OP video is preaching waves as gospel. These people who put all their faith in gravity waves, I call them "wavers," they're as bad as creationists trying to say they can use science to prove God.
What evidence is there leaning towards the graviton? Granted I've been "out of the game" for a while, but I would still think that someone discovering a spin-2 boson would have been news I would have heard. And calling LIGO an anomaly? Now while it is true that it might be but calling a scientific experiment that showed results as invalid while pounding your chest about some particle that can't even be renormalized by mathematicians then having the audacity to call others as "wavers" is just silly.

Now you're just arguing over semantics. Waves and particles are both valid, it depends on how you measure. LIGO measured for waves, another experiment could try to find gravitons, and they'd both be valid. Honestly I can barely fathom how you could know enough to even make the above argument without knowing about the wave-particle duality. Either pay more attention in high school physics class where they teach this, know more than a five minute google search before arguing a point, and/or stop arguing just for the sake of argument.
 
Your link basically demonstrated my point. No one really knows exactly how gravity works, but evidence is leaning more towards it being particle based. The LIGO experiment was an anomaly, and the OP video is preaching waves as gospel. These people who put all their faith in gravity waves, I call them "wavers," they're as bad as creationists trying to say they can use science to prove God.

You mean the two independent LIGO findings, both of which were scrutinised and cross-checked for months were anomalies?

Also, as explained above, at the quantum level, there is no differentiation between waves and particles, and more importantly, The idea of a graviton particle does not invalidate Einstein's theories.
 
What evidence is there leaning towards the graviton? Granted I've been "out of the game" for a while, but I would still think that someone discovering a spin-2 boson would have been news I would have heard. And calling LIGO an anomaly? Now while it is true that it might be but calling a scientific experiment that showed results as invalid while pounding your chest about some particle that can't even be renormalized by mathematicians then having the audacity to call others as "wavers" is just silly.
Particles of gravity must exist in order for Quantum Field Theory to be used to describe anything.
Now you're just arguing over semantics. Waves and particles are both valid, it depends on how you measure. LIGO measured for waves, another experiment could try to find gravitons, and they'd both be valid. Honestly I can barely fathom how you could know enough to even make the above argument without knowing about the wave-particle duality. Either pay more attention in high school physics class where they teach this, know more than a five minute google search before arguing a point, and/or stop arguing just for the sake of argument.
You want to have your cake and eat it too. You sound exactly like Ken Ham, saying God and science can be both valid. Linking a wikipedia article describing your own personal religion doesn't help your argument, neither does your ad hominem.

You mean the two independent LIGO findings, both of which were scrutinised and cross-checked for months were anomalies?

Also, as explained above, at the quantum level, there is no differentiation between waves and particles, and more importantly, The idea of a graviton particle does not invalidate Einstein's theories.
A couple months ago my mom prayed to God that she would get a raise. My brother also independently prayed for my mom to get a raise. She got her raise, so obviously this is evidence that God exists and performs miracles.
 
Religion or politics, guaranteed to always be that debris on the conversation rails to knock that train over.

Can't just enjoy a video anymore...
 
Your link basically demonstrated my point. No one really knows exactly how gravity works, but evidence is leaning more towards it being particle based. The LIGO experiment was an anomaly, and the OP video is preaching waves as gospel. These people who put all their faith in gravity waves, I call them "wavers," they're as bad as creationists trying to say they can use science to prove God.
Theoretical physics.
Also why do you think it isn't a wave also? Light is a particle and a wave if I remember correctly?
 
Theoretical physics.
Also why do you think it isn't a wave also? Light is a particle and a wave if I remember correctly?

Photons demonstrate behaviors found in both waves and particles. The same can likely be said for gravity.
 
Back
Top