Ubuntu Software Called Spyware Over Search Feature

But there's this big bully named Micro$loth who's been shoehorning OEMs and retailers for over a decade now. :D

SHHH! Don't mention that name... or you might summon the god of the heat-less sun! :eek:
 
I can understand not wanting to use Ubuntu for these reasons, but if you're still using Android, Google, Microsoft, iOS and OS X, then you're being hypocritical and applying a double standard.

Hypocritical? People don't have a choice of not being spied upon. That is unless you mean they should stop using cell phones and internet connected computers altogether - that that is their alternative and would keep them from being "hypocrites." They don't have a choice about their personal info and their search queries being amassed and sold. Especially in the mobile phone market with those OS's and search engines.

Now it seems we have a major Linux distro - the major Linux distro - selling out and doing basically the same shit. Yes, people can switch distros - and they should, if for no other reason than to send a message. Still doesn't make it ok or something that should just be accepted because everyone else does it.

How about there be a fucking law against these software companies collecting/amassing people's personal habits/thoughts and selling that shit?
 
SHHH! Don't mention that name... or you might summon the god of the heat-less sun! :eek:

oh-my-bad.jpg


:D
 
Wait, we have a forum member named beto, and one named pelo...
Is beto just pelo, but upside-down?

We've reached the nexus of the universe, pelo/beto is arguing with himself!
Run for cover before the singularity of Ubuntu is reached and we all become a part of Microgoogapple Corp.!!!
 
Hypocritical? People don't have a choice of not being spied upon. That is unless you mean they should stop using cell phones and internet connected computers altogether - that that is their alternative and would keep them from being "hypocrites." They don't have a choice about their personal info and their search queries being amassed and sold. Especially in the mobile phone market with those OS's and search engines.

Now it seems we have a major Linux distro - the major Linux distro - selling out and doing basically the same shit. Yes, people can switch distros - and they should, if for no other reason than to send a message. Still doesn't make it ok or something that should just be accepted because everyone else does it.

How about there be a fucking law against these software companies collecting/amassing people's personal habits/thoughts and selling that shit?

Oh, dearie me. I must have the new iPhone but it logs my location and targets me with ads? What am I to do?

How about not buy it. Because...you know... you're not going to use Ubuntu for that reason then why not opt to make the same choice with your mobile phone?

And, yes, I'm arguing with myself. But I'm never going to beat me! I'll never let myself win the argument!
 
SPY ON THIS, BIATCH!!!

:p

Pretty much. People consider smartphones a necessity and live with the annoyances that come with it. They use Google despite the tracking. They'll use MS with their ads as well. Yet with all of these it's considered "okay" or accepted that it comes with the territory, but don't feel strongly enough to quit using these services. But as soon as a Linux distro decides to approach $$$ from the same angle everyone throws a bitch fit.
 
But as soon as a Linux distro decides to approach $$$ from the same angle everyone throws a bitch fit.

That's right. Because Linux users are different and Linux distros are supposedly anti-mainstream and not about the money.

People consider smartphones a necessity and live with the annoyances that come with it. They use Google despite the tracking. They'll use MS with their ads as well. Yet with all of these it's considered "okay" or accepted that it comes with the territory, but don't feel strongly enough to quit using these services.

You almost can't buy a phone that isn't a "smartphone." Not in the US anyway. The providers are pushing everyone into them. I still use the lowest tech phone my provider carries and they are phasing those low end phones out completely. Every time I go in there I have to fight with them when they tell me I have to have a data plan so they can sell me one of their spyware infested phones. Try buying a phone without GPS. I haven't been looking at phones in awhile but I would bet money that phone doesn't exist. Most of the phones don't even allow for the GPS to be turned off.

Most people don't even know the extent to which they are being spied upon and having their privacy invaded but, even if they did, they don't have a choice for the most part. And these aren't "annoyances." It is fucking spying and the selling of their customer base. It's predatory and should be illegal. People shouldn't have to quit using the service in order to have some piece of mind and privacy. People shouldn't have to completely forgo a new tech just to maintain their privacy. The industry makes enough money off of users as it is without abusing peoples privacy to make an extra buck. The industry shouldn't be doing what it's doing. Between the authoritarian surveillance state and these software and telecom giants, people have lost all privacy. THAT is how it should be viewed. Not that it just "comes with the territory if you want a phone" or because you use google to search for things you are accepting of that crap.

Like I said, luckily with Linux, there are other distros to turn to. That simply isn't the case for people using the more mainstream OS's. They don't have anywhere to go and now even the most noob-user accessible Linux distro has decided to join the customer pumping.

It's irritating.
 
Mint is a noob OS at best; well that explains it's popularity, lol.
However, LMDE is one of my favorite Debian-distros, and one of the more stable variants in my opinion.

rather curious with where cinnamon and mate is going to go. still avoiding ubuntu like the plague.
 
Been known for a while that Mint has surpassed Ubuntu. Ever since they introduced Unity UI to it.

http://www.zdnet.com/the-5-most-popular-linux-distributions-7000003183/

Not only is that article complete and utter bullshit but the funny reality is ubuntu is ahead of mint by hundreds of millions... :rolleyes:

Read my links on the last page, its nonsense. Mint is not even at 20 million users while ubuntu has been over 400 million even with unity. Which actually gained them more users...
 
rather curious with where cinnamon and mate is going to go. still avoiding ubuntu like the plague.

Cinnamon is amazing, and will keep getting better. Clement Lefebvre is doing an amazing job directing the desktop. I honestly see no reason for MATE, Cinnamon is basically a GTK3 version of MATE (a modified Gnome 3 Shell) with an enhanced Applications Menu, better compositing and more functionality. They're practically doing the same thing twice maintaining MATE, which is counter-productive, imo.
 
On the subject.... there is a considerable difference between you searching ....

GOOGLE'S

... hard drive publicly over the internet, and them "anonymously" compiling information to sell. :eek:

And someone, like Ubuntu, searching....

YOUR

... personal hard drive, and selling that information. :mad:

In this world of the NSA, FBI, search warrants and no-sting-king search warrants, they already can strip away any alleged "anonymity" from internet searches. Why wouldn't people find it unacceptable to effectively have information stored on their own personal hard drives end up in the realm of the new public-law-enforcement world.

Sure, if you are honest, you have nothing to fear, yada yada yada. FUCK THAT. :eek::rolleyes:
 
They aren't searching your HDD...

See what happens when you read clueless people's comments and don't bother reading the actual article or even other articles? You make posts like that ^^
 
On the subject.... there is a considerable difference between you searching ....

GOOGLE'S

... hard drive publicly over the internet, and them "anonymously" compiling information to sell. :eek:

And someone, like Ubuntu, searching....

YOUR

... personal hard drive, and selling that information. :mad:

In this world of the NSA, FBI, search warrants and no-sting-king search warrants, they already can strip away any alleged "anonymity" from internet searches. Why wouldn't people find it unacceptable to effectively have information stored on their own personal hard drives end up in the realm of the new public-law-enforcement world.

Sure, if you are honest, you have nothing to fear, yada yada yada. FUCK THAT. :eek::rolleyes:

Amazon search queries =/= hard drive information. It's not like the amazon shopping lens is scanning your entire /home directory and sending indexes to Canonical - that isn't how it works. Stallman is exaggerating the issue, and perpetuating his twisted FUD. Don't listen to that fucking nut.
 
^ Yeah, he and Linus are definitely two peas in a pod.
Whatever, neither of them represent the modern GNU/Linux community.

They both have the same credibility at this point that John Romero has in the gaming community.
 
Breaking News!!

Mark Shuttleworth of Canonical has made a new spyware version of Ubunt wants to see all of your porno.

Also, Kate Middleton. Just how big is her penis?

That and more at 11
 
^ Yeah, he and Linus are definitely two peas in a pod.
Whatever, neither of them represent the modern GNU/Linux community.

They both have the same credibility at this point that John Romero has in the gaming community.

Meh I wouldn't put Stallman and Torvalds in the same zipcode in almost any category.
 
^ Yeah, he and Linus are definitely two peas in a pod.
Whatever, neither of them represent the modern GNU/Linux community.

They both have the same credibility at this point that John Romero has in the gaming community.

Eh.. More like two peas in different pods, so i'd wager against that. lol

People like Shuttleworth, Torvalds, Eric Raymond, Bruce Perens, and Alan Cox pretty much have the same Balanced and Fair pragmatism about open source n' whatnot - thus they're more favored in the community.
 
This was news like 4-5 months ago, why the rehash?
 
Stallman is absolutely right in this case. Ubuntu 12.10, unlike those elements that came before it reflects poorly on the FOSS and Linux community because of certain business/development decisions that end up compromising privacy. Part of the upsurge in Linux interest on the desktop has been due to not only the increasing viability of the experience, but also because of the divergent image of other OS offerings. As Microsoft, Apple, Google, and other products become more locked down and put profit (especially from advertising and data mining posed beneath a veneer designed to obfuscate their actions) before what the user wishes to do with their own device, Linux and FOSS has been shown as an alternative. Having one of the most visible desktop-focused Linux distros act like this proves harmful to the entire community.

For those that aren't aware, the new Ubuntu 12.10 has the following "features" set ON AS DEFAULT
1. The desktop "search" feature, searches the Internet as as well. Note that the Unity desktop used on Ubuntu now, much like Windows 8, encourages users to "search for stuff on their PC" instead of browsing for them, using menus, launchers and the like. So when you search for "BBQ pictures" to see your pictures of a recent outdoor party, you're also greeted by not only results on your computer, but also pictures of grills and links from the Internet, such as from Google and ads for grills from Amazon. This is a huge security risk, made worse for low-tech users who may not understand that all these things are local objects on their PC and completely asinine for a default setting.
2. Those Amazon links are embedded with Canonical (the company behind Ubuntu)'s affiliate ID, so if you should happen to click and buy one of those suggested grills, they get a cut.

Now, to effect the above two features, it doesn't just make those searches direct from your PC, but actually sends all the data through Canonical's servers, under the claims of "anonymizing" the data, as CEO Mark Shuttleworth puts it.... " We are not telling Amazon what you are searching for. Your anonymity is preserved because we handle the query on your behalf. Don’t trust us? Erm, we have root. You do trust us with your data already. You trust us not to screw up on your machine with every update. ". Yeah, that sounds really trustworthy. "We've already got you by the balls, so you know... what do you have to lose?". I want someone with that attitude tasked with ensuring my privacy.. Its no wonder people are switching to Linux Mint - which is often defined as "Ubuntu without the stupid".

Ubuntu could have handled this just a bit differently and avoided the ire of privacy advocates and those who are frustrated with anything that sets Linux back a step. The first and most simple thing would have been to ensure that the desktop "search" function was purely an offline search of the local machine by default. Users should have to make the conscious choice to integrate online, remote data into such a search and it should be well labeled and warned when they attempt to do so, to ensure understanding. Give users the option to activate a variety of elements for desktop searching, from Google, to Amazon, DuckDuckGo and others, but let them make the choice. Secondly, when it comes to the Amazon lens, or any sort of embedded affiliate/moneymaking issue, it is crucial to inform the user of the complete parameters thereof and give them the choice to opt-in - while leaving opt-out the default. When a user activates the Amazon lens, they would see something like the following "Using the Ubuntu Amazon search lens will enable you to add results for Amazon shopping as part of your desktop search. In order for Canonical, the team behind Ubuntu, to continue to bring you quality software we ask that you opt-in to allowing our affiliate ID to be appended to Amazon searches. This does not confer any of your private information to Ubuntu or to Amazon, but simply results in Ubuntu getting a small financial reward whenever you buy something on Amazon after clicking on it in our lens. Please consider supporting Ubuntu in this manner - it doesn't cost you a thing! If you wish to enable Ubuntu Affiliate Support click X. If you wish to enter an Amazon Affiliate ID of your choosing, click Y and enter the ID of your choice in the text box, or if you wish to browse the Amazon search lens without any Affiliate ID at all, click Z" Giving users the choice, and full understanding of that choice should be paramount, especially when profit is involved. Many, with a good understanding of the issue would be willing to allow the Ubuntu affiliate ID to be appended to their search to support the company.



Ubuntu has made great strides in advancing the desktop Linux experience, but over the past few versions they've been making more and more questionable decisions, with this being the latest and one of the most dramatic. Stallman is right to criticize them. Canonical making these decisions is harmful to FOSS and Linux as a whole and they should that users won't tolerate such things. Ideally, they will refine and make changes similar to those I cited above, as it would be a loss to the community to have to explain why, after years of using Ubuntu to introduce Linux to newcomers on the desktop, that it is now "bad" and something else needs to be used instead.
 
^ +1
This is why I have given up on Ubuntu beyond 10.xx. RIP classic Ubuntu.
 
When Dell has offered linux on desktop systems i recall hearing they didnt sell well..

Problem is, the avg Joe know windows, not linux... Linux needs to advertise and educate.
 
Ubuntu 12.10, unlike those elements that came before it reflects poorly on the FOSS and Linux community because of certain business/development decisions that end up compromising privacy. Part of the upsurge in Linux interest on the desktop has been due to not only the increasing viability of the experience, but also because of the divergent image of other OS offerings. As Microsoft, Apple, Google, and other products become more locked down and put profit (especially from advertising and data mining posed beneath a veneer designed to obfuscate their actions) before what the user wishes to do with their own device, Linux and FOSS has been shown as an alternative. Having one of the most visible desktop-focused Linux distros act like this proves harmful to the entire community.

Exactly.
 
When Dell has offered linux on desktop systems i recall hearing they didnt sell well..

Problem is, the avg Joe know windows, not linux... Linux needs to advertise and educate.

You can advertise and educate all you want. MS is so entrenched it will take years of pissing everyone off for anyone else to have a shot at the mainstream market.
 
They never have (at least in the US), but his predictions and concerns have largely turned out to be correct over the years. Hes basically the Cassandra of the software world.

Perhaps. But it's easy to beat the free software drum when you make your money off being an academic huffing glue in your ivory tower.
 
When Dell has offered linux on desktop systems i recall hearing they didnt sell well..

Problem is, the avg Joe know windows, not linux... Linux needs to advertise and educate.

They sold fine, at least their netbooks did. The issue with Dell is and has been two-fold: they hide their Linux options on their website without so much as a tiny link to it from their homepage and they have often price the Linux version higher than the Windows version.

For proof of said netbook sales see http://blog.laptopmag.com/one-third-of-dell-inspiron-mini-9s-sold-run-linux

I'd considered buying one myself; unfortunately, by the time I had the money they no longer sold them, which is yet another problem with Dell.
 
The Internet is for losers. No one can spy on your freaky fetish for naked pine trees if you don't do the whole online thing or waste your time with a "multimedia" computer. Pfft @ people who think it's kewl to get on usenet or access a BBS cuz they're all dumb-dumb heads who think this online stuff will actually be anything but a fad to replace a walkman for entertainment.
 
You may point us to the coolest ascii porn site.
 
Perhaps. But it's easy to beat the free software drum when you make your money off being an academic huffing glue in your ivory tower.

Whether or not people agree with what he says, hes a brilliant guy and is (or at least was) an awesome developer as well.

People with his kind of skillset and accomplishments are rewarded in academia and I fail to see how that is a bad thing given that lives frugally and goes to great lengths to avoid being a hypocrit. He is a valuable voice for user/consumer rights even if many don't like how he argues for them.
 
Back
Top