Ubuntu Changes Plans for Windows 8 Secure Boot

Heatlesssun is worried since he works for Microsoft.
But yes, you are 110% correct.

Stop with your nonsense. I do not work for Microsoft. I've stated many times thatK I've work al in the financial sector for nearly 20 years now. Your disregard of facts is astonishing.
 
Stop with your nonsense. I do not work for Microsoft. I've stated many times thatK I've work al in the financial sector for nearly 20 years now. Your disregard of facts is astonishing.

You've stated many times on this forum that you work as a developer for Microsoft, which is why you have such a need to work with Windows 8 so much.
Now all of a sudden you don't? :confused:
 
You've stated many times on this forum that you work as a developer for Microsoft, which is why you have such a need to work with Windows 8 so much.
Now all of a sudden you don't? :confused:

I think this is where I may have got the idea you worked for Microsoft:

No, it's just that I got my first good job as a developer working a project that used Windows for Pen Computing about 20 years ago and I've just been a tablet fan since. I simply believe that a computer should be able to do anything, go with you anywhere. Something you can play games on, do math homework with a pen, do spreadsheets, read, watch a movie. Whatever one wishes to do. Hybrid tablet devices and Windows 8 can do it all. Some will say that that is a jack of all trades and a master of none, but Excel works just it always has on my Windows 8 devices as my Windows 7 devices. So does Angry Birds with touch and that's a desktop app. So does everything else. Yes the UI is different but there are no functional boundaries.

The way I see it is that if Windows 8 fails all were going to get are incremental iPad upgrades forever and a new Android version every week and no one will try to make powerful and flexible solutions anymore. And that will suck.

After reading through a few old threads, yeah, you don't work for Microsoft.
My sincere apologies, I really did think you still worked there. :( :eek:
 
After reading through a few old threads, yeah, you don't work for Microsoft.
My sincere apologies, I really did think you still worked there. :( :eek:

Thanks. I'm often accused of being a Microsoft employee, fan, paid shill or whatever nonsense and its pretty obvious that people that say those things, as much as they may complain about my posts, have never actually bothered to READ a single thing I've ever posted here.
 
Thanks. I'm often accused of being a Microsoft employee, fan, paid shill or whatever nonsense and its pretty obvious that people that say those things, as much as they may complain about my posts, have never actually bothered to READ a single thing I've ever posted here.

That makes sense, just try to be a bit nicer about it though.
If we're still dicks after that, well, just flame the hell out of us and eventually we'll get the point. :p
 
That makes sense, just try to be a bit nicer about it though.
If we're still dicks after that, well, just flame the hell out of us and eventually we'll get the point. :p

I can honestly say that in all the debates about Windows 8, I've been far more civil than most. I've never have once ridiculed anyone for their opinion of Windows 8. I have definitely pointed out when I thought someone didn't know what they were talking about in regards to Windows 8, particularly when it comes to tablets. Most people in this forum are looking at Windows 8 as Windows 7, as a desktop only OS and have no idea what how it functions on tablets, and it's beyond obvious to a person like me that's used Windows on tablets for a decade.

It's much easier and more macho for one to call someone an employee or a shill than for one to admit that they might not understand something with which they have no experience.
 
yeah i can only wonder... like 23,466 posts? fuck me bro :p

LOL! I knew someone would look up my post count, then quote me saying that if someone had read a SINGLE thing I've ever posted and then complain about the post count.

It's too easy.:D
 
That's what always frustrated me about this, Microsoft doesn't own the hardware.
With Apple, it's understandable since it is their proprietary hardware, of which they allow users to run Windows (unsupported though).

This however, is just Microsoft crossing the line since none of this hardware is owned by them.
If the classic "PC" does end up dying, I hope Microsoft goes down in flames with it; guess that's why they are trying to break into the tablet market.

Fuck Microsoft.

I find it funny that you give apple a pass but not MS, they are both for profit companies, there is no reason any should be treated any different than the other. From MS point of view, any computer bought with windows is meant to be used with windows. And for the better part of history buying a computer from any major OEM and even many aftermarket computer parts would only promise that the hardware worked with the version of windows they shipped it on. I have seen my share of hardware that would only work on one version of windows let alone linux. Nothing new here really. The custom builders motherboards will come with all the options and standards you need for any OS as always.
 
I can honestly say that in all the debates about Windows 8, I've been far more civil than most. I've never have once ridiculed anyone for their opinion of Windows 8. I have definitely pointed out when I thought someone didn't know what they were talking about in regards to Windows 8, particularly when it comes to tablets. Most people in this forum are looking at Windows 8 as Windows 7, as a desktop only OS and have no idea what how it functions on tablets, and it's beyond obvious to a person like me that's used Windows on tablets for a decade.

It's much easier and more macho for one to call someone an employee or a shill than for one to admit that they might not understand something with which they have no experience.

Your last sentence directly contradicts your first two. Numerous times you have dismissed the opinions of others because in your opinion, your opinion is superior due to your experience with Windows 8 on a variety of computing devices.

If opinions are assholes then you are one big fucking 'opinion'.
 
What do you mean. Linux on the desktop has been the next big thing for 20 years!

That isn't going to happen.

Oddly enough, with Microsoft trying to replace desktop OSs with a touchpad OS, it is entirely possible that more than a few people (more than current Linux users anyway) will want android on the desktop.

About the only thing stopping Microsoft from requiring this to be on every motherboard that allows a windows installation is that they don't have the power they had in 1999. The other issue would be adding Secure boot to windows 7. Updating windows 7 in such a way to admit that people will want it for a long time is to admit what plenty of people are saying about Win8. Don't count on being able to install anything Steve Balmer doesn't want you to install once Microsoft gets around to admitting they will still sell Win7 and updating it with Secure boot.
 
Your last sentence directly contradicts your first two. Numerous times you have dismissed the opinions of others because in your opinion, your opinion is superior due to your experience with Windows 8 on a variety of computing devices.

If opinions are assholes then you are one big fucking 'opinion'.

If one looks at devices like the Surface and the marquee devices that OEMs are announcing its pretty clear that Windows 8 is being targeted at hardware that most people even here simply haven't used with Windows. I've said many times that I understand why some may not like Windows 8 on conventional hardware but it is difficult to get a good feel for Windows 8 on conventional hardware because the changes in it simply aren't targeted for conventional hardware. Call that dismissive of other's opinions if you will. I think that it is a reasonable analysis.

But fair enough. Maybe I'm not being very civil to people that keep repeating factually incorrect information when I've attempted to provide correct information in regards to my supposed employment or compensation by Microsoft.
 
Oddly enough, with Microsoft trying to replace desktop OSs with a touchpad OS, it is entirely possible that more than a few people (more than current Linux users anyway) will want android on the desktop.
Why would anyone want Android on the desktop? Furthermore, why would anyone want to replace one "touchpad OS" with another due to the former being a "touchpad OS"?

"I don't like meatballs. I will therefore eat meatballs instead."

About the only thing stopping Microsoft from requiring this to be on every motherboard that allows a windows installation is that they don't have the power they had in 1999
They've never had such a level of power. I don't know why you believe Microsoft could ever achieve that level of control over independent motherboard manufacturers.
 
Why would anyone want Android on the desktop? Furthermore, why would anyone want to replace one "touchpad OS" with another due to the former being a "touchpad OS"?

"I don't like meatballs. I will therefore eat meatballs instead."

I would have to say it is out of convenience or choice. Who knows?

But, there are a manufacturers coming out with all-in-one computers with touch-capable screens.

Metro and Windows 8 would be fitting for those kind of computers.

Android on the desktop PC would be an odd fit but if one were to simplify computing on the desktop PC far enough for children to use, I would not be surprised that's considered an option in the future.

If you notice, most things in the computing world are being simpler and simpler for normal, non-enthusiasts to use. Consoles provide a good amount of streaming media for the living room plus games in quasi-HD. Mobile smartphones and tablets provide another portion for ease of access to media, information and such. Desktop PCs would be the next thing to simplify for "normal" computer users.

Video editing... made easier (and even online now).
Shopping... made easier and online.
Email access and setup... made easier and online.
Transferring music and video to smartphone/tablet... made easier.
Productivity software... made easier and online (Office 365, Google Drive).

Wouldn't the next logical step is to put a simple and easier to use operating system on a desktop PC that people won't have to mess with configurations and settings?

ChromeOS did that. A lot of people like OSX for a myriad of reasons. Android is on many different smartphones and tablets. iOS on iPhone, iPad, and iPod Touch make accessibility to media and information easy as well.

So desktop computers would have to be next logical step in the market.

I'm just stating on how I see it. The market drives the economy and it also drives the decisions that companies make.

Don't blame me for saying it, but blame the normal, everyday non-computer literate consumer who probably can't tell the difference between Bluray and DVD, or hard drive storage and RAM, or that LTE just sounds cooler and faster than 3G.

Those are the kind of people that's dictating how we work on desktop computers, how we live our computing life and making it more mobile, easier to access, and simpler to use.
 
Why would anyone want Android on the desktop? Furthermore, why would anyone want to replace one "touchpad OS" with another due to the former being a "touchpad OS"?

"I don't like meatballs. I will therefore eat meatballs instead."


They've never had such a level of power. I don't know why you believe Microsoft could ever achieve that level of control over independent motherboard manufacturers.

People will want any OS to span all their devices so that 1, any program would run on all them, 2 so they are familar with the OS and it works well with other devices.
 
A thread about Ubuntu that turned into a thread about Heatlesssun's experiences with Windows 8 and tablet computing. How did we get here? :confused:
 
Android on the desktop PC would be an odd fit but if one were to simplify computing on the desktop PC far enough for children to use, I would not be surprised that's considered an option in the future.
Desktop computers are already simplistic enough for children to use. In practice, what trips a lot of younger kids up are mice and keyboards: touch-based devices are much easier for them to comprehend and interact with, as they remove a layer of abstraction between input and effect.

The OS doesn't need to change, but the UI does, to better accommodate touch interaction. That's what Microsoft's trying to do with Windows 8. I'm not really certain how Android would simplify that equation any further.

People will want any OS to span all their devices so that 1, any program would run on all them, 2 so they are familar with the OS and it works well with other devices.
I've really seen no compelling evidence to suggest that people want to use mobile applications on their desktop machines with mice and keyboards. Current Android apps are designed specifically for touch interaction on handheld devices like phones and tablets, and they're completely ill-suited to typical desktop usage (fire up the Android emulator on a PC and you'll see why). I think the level of outcry against Metro on desktop PCs and the general distaste toward many of the iOS UI conventions being brought into OS X is evidence that the consumer base isn't receptive toward a one-size-fits-all computing platform that attempts to scale to a variety of devices and input methods, and probably even less receptive to using applications that don't scale at all (which appears to be what you're arguing for).

Desktop Linux distributions are certainly viable for certain users, but I can't imagine anyone actually wanting to use a mobile operating system on their desktop machines.
 
A thread about Ubuntu that turned into a thread about Heatlesssun's experiences with Windows 8 and tablet computing. How did we get here? :confused:
The same way the Windows threads always end up about Linux :D.
 
A thread about Ubuntu that turned into a thread about Heatlesssun's experiences with Windows 8 and tablet computing. How did we get here? :confused:

Too many shit flinging trolls trying to attack the person making the argument instead of the argument itself. If you can't argue why X or Y sucks, then just say the person sucks because he's a Microsoft shill.
 
Too many shit flinging trolls trying to attack the person making the argument instead of the argument itself. If you can't argue why X or Y sucks, then just say the person sucks because he's a Microsoft shill.

Trolls are an important part of forum ecology and conservation efforts should be aimed at them because numerous other aspects of the forum ecosystem depend on these fabulous, but underappreciated creatures. The often neglected ignore button and its vital function is a direct offshoot of the presence of the troll. Other important features like they eyeroll and the hyperlink to a credible, refuting source are also dependent on the troll for their survival. It's a popular belief that responses to trolls account for approximately 25% of all posts made, giving urgent attention to the reply button. One can also never discount the value of the troll as an arch nemesis or as the apathetic (or often unknowing) target if enraged anger. Sometimes trolls are the spark which ignites a flame war that provides the forum with critically needed heat energy that it would otherwise perish without having.

I hope this factual posting has provided insight into the importance of maintaining careful balance in a forum and helps you not only understand the troll, but also realize its place as a finite resource. It is one more vibrant element among many mutually depending elements.
 
Trolls are a scourge and serve only to disrupt what would be an otherwise productive and enlightening conversation just so they can get a few shits and giggles at the expense of everyone else actually trying to debate.

FTFY.
 
I love grub2. It's so easy to make changes :) Glad they're keeping it.

MS adding the SecureBoot feature is both a security feature and them attempting to further lock down devices. BIOS viruses are a potential threat to corporate, research and government institutions (and your average user too, I guess) so UEFI's secure boot feature ensures that the OS is loaded in a "clean" way.

UEFI secure booting is a means of booting an operating system while making sure that pre-boot environment (BIOS, boot loader) were not compromised by virus or malware.

The only keys are given to Win8 on OEM devices. If you want another key then you need to buy from an OEM that offers a separate OS. This means MS is able to pin down all of your hardware and potentially restrict the upgrading of hardware at the OS level. Basically, if you upgrade your video card MS will know and they may require that you pay an additional fee. Currently, the motherboard's serial number is sent to MS and that's how your OEM version of Windows is determined. You can replace any component you want so long as it isn't the motherboard as the license is determined by Mobo. You might get away with a similar motherboard but even there you may run into issues. Generally Microsoft is pretty lenient and authorizing the Win key means having to call them and speak to them and they usually do it without any problems. This has changed recently and they've been far more strict and tell users to go fuck themselves or buy a new Win7 key.

Whether MS abuses this for more profit will depend on how it's carried out and what their policies are. So long as it's able to be flipped off it isn't an issue, but with the way MS has been heading as far as proprietary hardware/software and OEM competition goes, I wouldn't be surprised to hear that increasing your RAM might mean you pay Microsoft a fee.
 
I find it funny that you give apple a pass but not MS, they are both for profit companies, there is no reason any should be treated any different than the other. From MS point of view, any computer bought with windows is meant to be used with windows. And for the better part of history buying a computer from any major OEM and even many aftermarket computer parts would only promise that the hardware worked with the version of windows they shipped it on. I have seen my share of hardware that would only work on one version of windows let alone linux. Nothing new here really. The custom builders motherboards will come with all the options and standards you need for any OS as always.

Until Microsoft starts selling Microsoft proprietary hardware, they can go fuck themselves.
Yes Apple gets a pass in this area, because it is Apple hardware.
 
A thread about Ubuntu that turned into a thread about Heatlesssun's experiences with Windows 8 and tablet computing. How did we get here? :confused:

Yin and Yang my friend.
Every Microsoft thread that appears turns into a thread about Red Falcon's experiences with Linux and enterprise computing. :D :D :D

It's about time poor old heatlesssun got his turn. :)
 
Too many shit flinging trolls trying to attack the person making the argument instead of the argument itself. If you can't argue why X or Y sucks, then just say the person sucks because he's a Microsoft shill.

Well in heatlesssun's defense, he might be a Microsoft shill, but that in turn would completely make me a Linux shill.
We're two peas in a pod, and somewhere in the mix is SkribbelKat. ;)
 
Until Microsoft starts selling Microsoft proprietary hardware, they can go fuck themselves.
Yes Apple gets a pass in this area, because it is Apple hardware.

The OEMS already sell MS proprietary hardware, you just dont think of it that way you think of it as Dell Proprietary hardware etc.. But sure people like me I dont buy any desktop hardware from Dell, HP, apple or anyone else for exactly this reason its not modular with most other hardware. I just don't get why people think that there is some magical separation. I can tell you for the better part of history and even today that while MS implements proprietary features all the time the deal we get with MS is far better than the deal with get with Apple, the standard stays supported much longer and much wider.

MS creates a partnership with their OEMs and Hardware makers where they release fairly public yet proprietary standards for implementing things. Instead of being close minded think of MS proprietary hardware as MS plus all their hardware makers plus all their end user OEMs. What you have is a giant yet proprietary organization. And just like always linux players will find a way to reverse engineer or work around whatever exists.
 
Well in heatlesssun's defense, he might be a Microsoft shill, but that in turn would completely make me a Linux shill.
We're two peas in a pod, and somewhere in the mix is SkribbelKat. ;)

I don't wanna be in a pod with you and Heatlesssun! :mad: Why do you have to drag me into this like I'm somehow involved? I never even post anything on this forum unless I have something super meaningful that is profoundly world-changing.
 
The OEMS already sell MS proprietary hardware, you just dont think of it that way you think of it as Dell Proprietary hardware etc.. But sure people like me I dont buy any desktop hardware from Dell, HP, apple or anyone else for exactly this reason its not modular with most other hardware. I just don't get why people think that there is some magical separation. I can tell you for the better part of history and even today that while MS implements proprietary features all the time the deal we get with MS is far better than the deal with get with Apple, the standard stays supported much longer and much wider.

MS creates a partnership with their OEMs and Hardware makers where they release fairly public yet proprietary standards for implementing things. Instead of being close minded think of MS proprietary hardware as MS plus all their hardware makers plus all their end user OEMs. What you have is a giant yet proprietary organization. And just like always linux players will find a way to reverse engineer or work around whatever exists.

It isn't "Microsoft proprietary hardware" at all, do you even know anything?
These are supposed to be 100% IBM compatible PCs, aka classic PC architectures.

Apple does not use this system architecture as they use EFI and other hardware differences which are owned and sold by Apple, Microsoft does not do this.

Microsoft + OEM partnership is not the equivalent to Apple selling Apple hardware.
 
It isn't "Microsoft proprietary hardware" at all, do you even know anything?
These are supposed to be 100% IBM compatible PCs, aka classic PC architectures.

Apple does not use this system architecture as they use EFI and other hardware differences which are owned and sold by Apple, Microsoft does not do this.

Microsoft + OEM partnership is not the equivalent to Apple selling Apple hardware.

The vast, overwhelming majority of people don't buy a PC because its IBM compatible, IBM doesn't even make PCs anymore. People buy PCs because they run Windows.
 
The vast, overwhelming majority of people don't buy a PC because its IBM compatible, IBM doesn't even make PCs anymore. People buy PCs because they run Windows.

That's why I said "classic PC" architecture. ;)
Also, don't talk that way about IBM, you might hurt my dual 970MP's feelings. :eek:

Oh well, the whole point is mute because if one doesn't like secure boot, just buy non-OEM motherboards! Solution, ftw.
 
You mean moot, don't you?

Anyways. It really seems like a non issue for PC. Unless they outright lock you out of other OSes or proceed to head that way which may be true I guess... Don't think they will though, since they don't make the hardware, and can't really enforce it unless they use wads of cash.

Then again, other "groups" have done so to get their way. But that might be an "anti-competitive ting to sue over if that does happen.
 
I use Linux every day, and far more so than you do with your "couple experiences trying it out". :rolleyes:
Linux isn't the issue, or have you just not been paying attention to the thread.
I was paying better attention than you do to your own broad brushing comments about who uses Linux. But I guess you have a view that Linux should forever be in the back closet for you to play with.
 
Back
Top