U.S. Testing Universal Internet IDs

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Attention, citizens! The government is here with universal internet IDs to protect you from the evils of the internet. Relax, what could possibly go wrong?

The initiative, called National Strategy for Trusted Identities in Cyberspace (NSTIC), was originally devised as a means to prevent fraud and make it easier to verify identities quickly. This initial rollout only involves websites for those applying for government assistance, as it's merely meant to test whether the idea's feasible.
 
Yeah, just what I want... Easier for our gov to track everything we do... No thanks.
 
The quote Steve picked is misleading. Before everyone goes on their anti-government derpwagon, this is what they're talking about:

issue Americans one online ID they can use across multiple agencies' websites -- sort of like an OpenID for the government

It's just single-sign-on for government websites. That's standard practice for most other industries.
 
The quote Steve picked is misleading. Before everyone goes on their anti-government derpwagon, this is what they're talking about:



It's just single-sign-on for government websites. That's standard practice for most other industries.

Every citizen already has a number. Why do we need anything else?
 
SSNs are not unique and not secure to use in that way.
.

Right, but unfortunately SSNs ARE being used that way, as an ID number. It's not suppose to be, but it is.

Setup a bank account: SSN needed
Check your credit score: SSN needed
Get a job: SSN needed
Eat at Joe's: SSN needed
 
I think it's a good idea, in certain ways. Have a USB key with a certificate encrypted with 2048-bit encryption that could be used for all sorts of things, like starting your car (the car OS would not run without the proper certificate, which could be enabled at the dealership, and the car could not be stolen,) unlocking your bike lock, logging into your banking web site, getting gas, shopping at a store, or shopping online. Any monetary transactions could be secured with a 4-8 digit pin.

Of course, there would have to be strict privacy protections in place before this could happen, making it illegal for any entity, corporate or government, to track your habits using such an indicator unless you specifically opt in(commercial) or a court ordered subpoena (government) were granted.
 
Right, but unfortunately SSNs ARE being used that way, as an ID number. It's not suppose to be, but it is.

Setup a bank account: SSN needed
Check your credit score: SSN needed
Get a job: SSN needed
Eat at Joe's: SSN needed

Damn, even Joe's is on the bandwagon now?
 
Right, but unfortunately SSNs ARE being used that way, as an ID number. It's not suppose to be, but it is.

Setup a bank account: SSN needed
Check your credit score: SSN needed
Get a job: SSN needed
Eat at Joe's: SSN needed
It's not legal to ask for or required to have SSN for those things.
 
SSNs are not unique and not secure to use in that way.



probably an unfortunate inevitability here.

Prior to the NSA revalations, people like you called those who suspected mass government surveillance of, among other things, emails, "tinfoil hat wearers".

With your blind deference to the government, I'd suggest you're the one on the "derpwagon", not the people who rightly view the government's intentions with suspicion.
 
Prior to the NSA revalations, people like you called those who suspected mass government surveillance of, among other things, emails, "tinfoil hat wearers".

With your blind deference to the government, I'd suggest you're the one on the "derpwagon", not the people who rightly view the government's intentions with suspicion.

"blind deference to the government" is a ridiculous strawman. No one is like that.

I worked in the field, I still have friends currently working in military cybersecurity and contracting for government entities doing threat and vulnerability assessments and setting cybersecurity process.

I really have no problem with the NSA surveillance via honeypots etc. The allegations that they've created intentional backdoors or not closed security holes are bad, but they've overstepped their bounds and it was bound to come out. We'll see what comes of it.

Government is people. The NSA is people, they're citizens like us. Making them some evil "Other" is faceless villain-making which is a pretty popular current trend more dangerous than anything they're doing. Anyway, these PEOPLE sometimes make shitty programs to accomplish their goals. If pressure and undue ambition to achieve those goals are causing them to do this, we need to reevaluate those goals and oversight. This isn't the end of the world chicken little.
 
This initial rollout only involves websites for those applying for government assistance

I kind of like this, when it only applies to certain people. If you're on government assistance, you should lose a bit of privacy, feel a bit of shame, etc. Maybe this will make it easier to identify those who spend their government assistance on candy and soda each time, or worse.

But for everyone? :rolleyes:
 
and they have the right to refuse service / not hire you
soo yea thats going to work well
They don't have the right to refuse service or not hire you any more than by color, race, sex, or gender.
 
Prior to the NSA revalations, people like you called those who suspected mass government surveillance of, among other things, emails, "tinfoil hat wearers".

With your blind deference to the government, I'd suggest you're the one on the "derpwagon", not the people who rightly view the government's intentions with suspicion.

Except that that's not at all what this is.

This is a single login - similar to gmail or facebook being accepted at many websites for authentication. Except that this would only be for government websites.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenID
 
How about the government set it sights on secure voters identification act instead of worrying who or what is on the internet. Fools.
 
Yes, the SSN is used as a defacto National ID #, rather than any politician having the courage to push for an actual National ID ... which would solve a whole lot of various issues.

But such a thing has to be done very carefully. There is a way to make an truly secure ID, with strong biometrics while NOT allowing any government database to exist that stores your biometrics. There is in fact no need for any database if the ID is done right, only a database storing the decryption keys, with no direct correlation to an individual.

This concept for a global Government "password" is flawed on it's face. If it is compromised you are globally fucked... SSA, IRS, VA, HHS, DOJ, etc .... very bad idea from the start, only a cyber security idiot would even propose it. We've been chided for 30 years to NOT use the same password for everything for precisely this reason alone.

I love how it starts ... gets the foot in the door ... to FUCK THE POOR people. I wonder what party affiliation the proponent of this shit has. Three guesses. Oh yeah, and a piss test and long-form birth certificate are also needed for Log In.

How about we start with members of Congress and staff be required to be the guinea pigs? While we're at it, let's make Congressional salaries MINIMUM WAGE, why the hell are we paying these 535 shitheads to do basically NOTHING for the last 4 years?

So the US Government continues to have people who have no skill in the science to be making policy decisions about, whatever. Here it is cyber security by idjits.

Rather than have a real discussion about solving ID security overall, ending ID theft and solving Cyber security issues. How many millions have had their ID's stolen to some extent over the last 30 years? Has the government ever done ANYTHING truly viable to stop this? No.
 
I think it's a good idea, in certain ways. Have a USB key with a certificate encrypted with 2048-bit encryption that could be used for all sorts of things, like starting your car (the car OS would not run without the proper certificate, which could be enabled at the dealership, and the car could not be stolen,) unlocking your bike lock, logging into your banking web site, getting gas, shopping at a store, or shopping online. Any monetary transactions could be secured with a 4-8 digit pin.

Of course, there would have to be strict privacy protections in place before this could happen, making it illegal for any entity, corporate or government, to track your habits using such an indicator unless you specifically opt in(commercial) or a court ordered subpoena (government) were granted.

Yea...because any of the strict privacy laws we already had weren't completely side stepped by the NSA already.
 
Except that that's not at all what this is.

This is a single login - similar to gmail or facebook being accepted at many websites for authentication. Except that this would only be for government websites.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OpenID

Until they offer it to the private sector to help combat "identity fraud" or some other innocuous sounding stated purpose.

The fact that you rely on the government actually revealing their intentions is laughable.
 
While we're at it, let's make Congressional salaries MINIMUM WAGE, why the hell are we paying these 535 shitheads to do basically NOTHING for the last 4 years?

I'd rather they do nothing that pass bad laws like the poorly named ACA.


Beside, the current congress has pass alot of stuff (some of it even good stuff), but it's all been shut down by the less than 60 people in the Senate, lead by that guy from Nevada.....
 
How about the government set it sights on secure voters identification act instead of worrying who or what is on the internet. Fools.

Funny how so many people think the Government could provide a secure login, when the government can't even secure the boarder or stop voter fraud. It’s almost as if they want things to get so bad, that we’ll have no choice but to adopt a national ID card.
 
They don't have the right to refuse service or not hire you any more than by color, race, sex, or gender.

Gee, let me think back on the number of things that I've done that have required my SSN to do:

Apply for a job
Apply for college
Apply for insurance
File taxes via IRS
Obtain a driver's license
Get a credit score
Get a credit card
Get an account at a credit union
Apply for a loan
Get airline tickets
Get a rental car
Purchase a car

I'm sure I'm forgetting many others, but, those are the ones that have stuck in my mind as of recent. Refusing to fill in the SSN results in refusal of service (such as the credit union, rental agency, insurance, license, and university) or refusal of consideration (job). Using the SSN as an identification number most certainly IS illegal. But, it is also ABSOLUTELY used exactly as such both by government agencies and the private sector. Pretending otherwise is beyond being woefully naive and I would say is best described as horrifyingly inept and ignorant. Hell, SSNs are used for identification in lieu of actual credit cards for stores that offer their own credit cards such as Best Buy and Kohl's. SSNs are so routinely used as identification numbers, and the whole system is so woefully insecure, that is in large part why the US has such a massive problem with identity theft precisely because if you find out a person's address, name, and SSN you have immense power for doing nearly anything in their name. Without their knowing even, until the bills come of course.
 
Just like they told us that the issued Social Security Number would be used for nothing else, and now its used for virtually everything.

Yeah, an anonymous internet is a good internet.
 
SSN @ Taxes, Work, and College.

Everything else gets a made up, yet consistent, social security number.
I am not required by law to give them my social security number.
 
Some good could come of this. I personally would be in favor of websites giving you the option of linking your government universal ID to a login. A good example would be steam. You link your Universal ID to steam through some verification process. Then from there on out you can only have that linked to a single account. And server admins can choose to restrict the players allowed to join a server only to those with a real ID. If you cheat and get vac banned, no more making a new steam account and coming back the next day. If you commit fraud and steal someones ID to do it you now go from being a hacker / cheater to being a felon.
 
I've already been "beast-marked" with multiple MAC addresses. Hail communication!
 
Back
Top