Tyan S2885, Enable 4GB RAM?

Sunstoned

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Aug 20, 2001
Messages
1,105
Hey, just got a tyan s2885 with a pair of opteron 246's and popped in eight 512 ecc pc3200 dimms. bios registers 4gb ram, but windows xp (32 bit version) only recognizes 3 gb. i understand that 32bit systems can't access above 4gb without special tricks, but i have only 4gb... i read something about windows reserving the last gig (3 gb - 4 gb) for pci addressing, or some such... but what i'm concerned about is how do i enable that last gig? i'm not willing to run a beta 64-bit system, as reliabiltiy is more important than anything else. ideas? please don't suggest linux, or beta stuff, or any such measures... i'm a microsoft junkie, so i'm not switching. thanks! maybe even a nifty prize for a good answer...
 
Unknown-One said:
hmm, I though windows XP could address up to 6GB of RAM :confused:

limitation of a 32-bit system (and 32-bit windows xp) is 4GB. there are tricks (PAE, etc) to recognize above 4GB in a 32-bit OS, but this is only for the server versions of Windows. However, with XP Pro, I shouldn't need tricks to access 4GB of memory...

I've seen tons about the /PAE switch in the boot.ini file, which I don't need as I don't have *more than* 4GB... Also, I've seen plenty about the /3GB switch, which simply changes the allocation between kernel and application memory, but does not do anything to affect how much total memory is recognized.

The issue, as explained by Tyan, is this:

*************************
Lets first start with the memory detection issue. The issue that you are seeing is based on an older architecture design for memory addressing (32-bit addressing). All the systems architecture up to this point have been based on a maximum of 4GB of total memory, the limit of the 32-bit address space. In addition to operating System addressable memory space, PCI devices require memory address ranges so that they can properly execute their commands. These address ranges were mapped in the upper sections of 4GB of memory space. Since nobody thought you would be using up to 4GB these address ranges started around the last 500MB of the memory ranges. This range is called the T.O.M. or Top of Memory range. This is the point in the bios where it places on hold the amount of memory that is required by the various PCI devices that are found on the motherboard. Thus when you have PCI cards or AGP cards installed on your motherboard these devices hold on to memory for their own use and take away from the system memory that is available to the operating system. The amount of memory can vary from a little as 200MB to 1.5GB of memory in typical workstation scenarios (or even more in select cases). The memory reserved for system use (not operating system use) depends upon how many AGP/PCI/PCI-X/PCI-E devices that are installed.

There is really no way to get around this basic design limitation when running a 32-bit operating system. The only way to get around these type of issues is to use hardware that have 64-bit architectures that allow memory to be mapped in area's above 4GB. The new Intel Xeon designs and the AMD Opteron designs are built around 64-bit technology. This is only ½ of the equation that you would need to find success. You would also need to use an OS that is actually 64-bit aware. Alternatively in a 32-bit OS such as Windows 2K/XP/2K3 you can use Physical Address Extensions to trick the OS into mapping addresses over 4GB. Windows 2000 and Windows 2003 would fit both of these criteria. Windows XP Pro uses PAE, but is known to have issues with systems with over 4GB of memory installed.

Microsoft has addressed the PAE issue in the following Microsoft Article (291988)
http://support.microsoft.com/default.aspx?scid=kb;en-us;291988

To maximize memory usage in 64-bit operating systems, a change in the BIOS of some boards is required There is an option in the bios that will help you with your memory configuration on some AMD Opteron based boards.

Go to the Chipset tab of the bios
Go to the Memory Configuration portion
Change the Adjust Memory/Software Memory Hole option to AUTO/Enabled

Now what you have done here is allowed the bios to act in a more 64-bit friendly manner and this will allow you to better utilize your 4GB of memory for 64-bit based OS's. This option is available for the S2880, S2881, S2882 and S2885 motherboards.
***************************
now, i'm not sure how to interpret this, but I'm sure there's a way to get XPPro32 to use more than 3GB RAM... I need to know *how* to do that...
 
Sunstoned said:
now, i'm not sure how to interpret this, but I'm sure there's a way to get XPPro32 to use more than 3GB RAM... I need to know *how* to do that...

You answered your own question. That address space is being used by your devices.

Every device in the computer needs address (memory) space. A 32 bit operating system can only address 4GB total, so in order to affect the fewest people, your PCI and AGP devices use address space from 4GB and down till they have all that they need.

If you set that BIOS setting to enabled, it will let 64bit OS's "see" all 4GB of your RAM, but there is no way to get a 32bit OS to "see" all that RAM because some of it is needed by your devices.

You could remove/uninstall devices to get more RAM (SCSI, Video card, Sound Card, IDE controller etc.) but otherwise that RAM is "gone" (still there but not addressable by a 32bit OS)

To understand this better go into "Device Manager" and look at the properties of any device, click on the tab labled "Resources" and you will see under "Resource Type" a bunch of things called "Memory Range" each of those is some memory in the upper part of the 4GB range that this device needs to work. If you are going to use this device with a 32 bit OS you will "lose" that part of memory to it.

==>Lazn
 
ughh. so, i've got six monitors, plugged in to an nVidia Quadro4 700 XGL (AGP) and nVidia Quadro NVS 400 (32-bit/33mhz PCI), with 64 and 32 MB RAM each. I understand the addressing actually takes twice the memory for video cards? I have a SCSI RAID card with 16MB Cache. Aside from that, I've disabled as much as I can (Primary IDE, all four SATA). Still, I'm losing a whole gig.

another thought i have... the main thing i need this memory for is working in huge photoshop files. since an application in XP can't use more than 2GB memory anyway, i'm wondering if using a RAMdisk would work... Can I restrict windows to 2GB of ram, then create a 2GB RAMdisk for my photoshop scratch disk? this would work just as well.
 
Sunstoned said:
ughh. so, i've got six monitors, plugged in to an nVidia Quadro4 700 XGL (AGP) and nVidia Quadro NVS 400 (32-bit/33mhz PCI), with 64 and 32 MB RAM each. I understand the addressing actually takes twice the memory for video cards? I have a SCSI RAID card with 16MB Cache. Aside from that, I've disabled as much as I can (Primary IDE, all four SATA). Still, I'm losing a whole gig.

another thought i have... the main thing i need this memory for is working in huge photoshop files. since an application in XP can't use more than 2GB memory anyway, i'm wondering if using a RAMdisk would work... Can I restrict windows to 2GB of ram, then create a 2GB RAMdisk for my photoshop scratch disk? this would work just as well.

Not unless you are using some kind of 64bit RAMdisk program that loads before windows does. I have never heard of such an animal.

==>Lazn
 
Back
Top