Two Hundred PS3s Used To Hack SSL

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A group of hackers, using 200 PlayStation 3 consoles, have found a way to exploit a known weakness in the MD5 algorithm to create a rogue Certification Authority which allows them to create their own SSL certificates. The research will be presented at the 25C3 conference in Germany.

Researchers at the Centrum Wiskunde & Informatica (CWI) in the Netherlands, EPFL in Switzerland, and Eindhoven University of Technology (TU/e) in the Netherlands helped in the design and implementation of the attack using an advanced implementation of a known MD5 collision construction and a cluster of more than 200 PlayStation 3 game consoles.
 
and yet still no cure for cancer.....i say put those bad boys on the folding team and put them to better use
 
Germany's answer to cheap super computing. hehe

I agree about putting them to better use folding as well
 
Well, as long as they do not issue their cirtificate algorithyms to hacker using DNS takeovers, I guess we are ok for now. Hopefully CAs will stop using MD5 and browsers will remove trusts for MD5 cirtificates soon.
 
Oh, I agree, they should be used for folding as well. I just think the folding team uses invalid basic assumptions in the data they are looking for, making the whole thing useless.
 
These guys have way too much money and way too much time ion their hands.

Anyone putting in this much effort has to have a nefarious use in mind.
 
These guys have way too much money and way too much time ion their hands.

Anyone putting in this much effort has to have a nefarious use in mind.

Pinky: "Gee Brain, what do you want to do tonight?"
The Brain: "The same thing we do every night, Pinky—try to take over the world."
 
Has folding at home actually accomplished anything other than wasting money and resources?
 
The article didn't go into the details of the system architecture, so I am not really sure why they decided to use PS3 as their computing muscle.
I think that it would be more wise for them to use a bunch of Nvidia Teslas, they are x10 times faster than PS3 and more sensible for this purpose.
 
How long did it take to get to the moon?

It didnt take a PS3..

I have no problem with them figuring out these exploits, because if they are doing it, the Chinese and Russians were probably trying to do it as well. I would also think the Pentagon would be doing things of this nature too.

How else better to sink an economy than to remove all trust in the security system of one of the major branches of sales and communications?
 
These guys have way too much money and way too much time ion their hands.

Anyone putting in this much effort has to have a nefarious use in mind.

The only way to effectively test security is to try to break it. Not everyone who puts a lot of effort into breaking something is trying to do so for illegal, harmful, and/or selfish reasons.

Besides, we're talking about researchers here; not some script kiddies working in their parent's basement trying to have some (not so cheap) thrills.
 
Has folding at home actually accomplished anything other than wasting money and resources?

http://folding.stanford.edu/English/Papers (In short, Yes)

How is it news that MD5 collisions are easy to be found? Someone figured that out like 5 years ago. I would hardly call it breaking SSL, anyway, just re-breaking what everyone knew was already broke (that MD5's suck for security purposes)
 
This is a good thing, I'm sure someone else (read: governments) has already cracked the security but kept it private. This means that the system will be more secure in the future.
 
i wonder if that technology used to display gt5p at some ridiculously high resolution can be scaled...you know, to like a gillion by a bazillion(p). :p

that room could be the backbone for one hell of a racing arcade.

my ps3 is folding right now. :)
 
These guys have way too much money and way too much time ion their hands.

Anyone putting in this much effort has to have a nefarious use in mind.

How do you propose security be tested then?
As you can probably surmise, security is what they do, so why should it be strange that they make a system to do the job quicker using much less costly hardware?

Now if they didnt release the results and you only found out what they achieved after computers were compromised, then you would have a point about nefarious activity.
However, this is exactly the opposite and you are inaccurately calling out the good guys.
You should be thanking them not accusing them.
 
Opens the doors to the black market CA. Get your certificates here, get them while their hot!
 
Well, as long as they do not issue their cirtificate algorithyms to hacker using DNS takeovers, I guess we are ok for now. Hopefully CAs will stop using MD5 and browsers will remove trusts for MD5 cirtificates soon.

The algorithm for fast MD5 collision generation was released something like 4 years ago.

The only news here is that someone is running it on a PS3 cluster.
 
Well ill post a picture of me hacking it on my Commodre-64... will that make the Hard News.
 
A group of hackers, using 200 PlayStation 3 consoles, have found a way to exploit a known weakness in the MD5 algorithm to create a rogue Certification Authority which allows them to create their own SSL certificates. The research will be presented at the 25C3 conference in Germany.

Wow thats insane. 200 ps3's lol. Imagine how expensive that would be.
 
Hackers are the good guys. They just do their good deed illegally.

Technically those would be crackers, not hackers. ;)

This is a good thing, I'm sure someone else (read: governments) has already cracked the security but kept it private. This means that the system will be more secure in the future.

Yes, I'm sure tons of governments, black-ops, and espionage/counter-espionage agencies are all running phishing scams :rolleyes: That is all this "news" actually allows for, is better phishing scams. That is it. That is all it allows for.
 
it only costs about 30 bucks to fold 24/7 I think
I know mine does, and my PC

But, 200 PS3s, thats enough render power to blow Pixar out the water for a small dev team. I remember a while ago reading how 5 PS3s linked together in Linux (3 cores each, not 6-7) could render in motion most scenes from Cars. Imagine 200 of them, you could render anything and never wait for the output!
 
and yet still no cure for cancer.....i say put those bad boys on the folding team and put them to better use

There will never be a "cure" because it's vastly more profitable to treat it than cure it once and for all. As already stated, "but then again this is the world we live in" becomes a mantra of sorts to live by.
 
I don't think that logic works. If there was a cure, then whoever has it could put companies who "treat" cancer out of business. How is treating it more profitable than that?

I still think all you folders are really helping the NSA process recorded phone conversations.
 
it only costs about 30 bucks to fold 24/7 I think
I know mine does, and my PC

But, 200 PS3s, thats enough render power to blow Pixar out the water for a small dev team. I remember a while ago reading how 5 PS3s linked together in Linux (3 cores each, not 6-7) could render in motion most scenes from Cars. Imagine 200 of them, you could render anything and never wait for the output!

Source? I can't seem to find any sort of reference on that and I'm calling BS. 5 PS3's linked together would be fast, no doubt, but it won't take a 20 hour render job and make it real time - not by a long shot (20 hour render per frame from here: http://www.informationweek.com/news/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=189501146 )

After all, at 3.2ghz we are talking ~25 GFLOPS per SPE. Assuming perfect scaling and a full 6 cores available (PS3 has 7, one reserved for OS), that is only going to be 5 * 6 * 25 = 750 GFLOPS. A single 4850 has more processing power (assuming there is a compiler for both platforms allowing both chips to hit their theoretical max). That is also assuming single precision floating point. Double precision floating point would drop it to 14 GFLOPS per SPE, not 25.

For what its worth, 200 PS3s in Linux (with 3 SPEs as per what you stated, I have no idea on that) would muster 200 * 25 * 3 = 15 TFLOPS, or the power equivalent of 15 4850s or 6.25 4870X2s. Given that its possible to fit 4 4870X2s into one PC, I could have more power than 200 PS3s ($400 * 200 = $80,000) in just 2 PCs ($500 * 8 + ~$2000 == $6,000).

You can do pretty much the same thing with Nvidia as ATI if you prefer CUDA :)

So the Cell can do floating point work better than a CPU, but who really cares about that. CPUs don't do much floating point work to begin with, and the Cell lacks things like branch prediction. A GPU walks all over the Cell when it comes to floating point, so I don't get the point of using the PS3s to do cryptography or rendering work or anything like this, it certainly isn't an effective use of resources...
 
Source? I can't seem to find any sort of reference on that and I'm calling BS. 5 PS3's linked together would be fast, no doubt, but it won't take a 20 hour render job and make it real time - not by a long shot (20 hour render per frame from here: http://www.informationweek.com/news/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=189501146 )

I've seen something similar to what he was talking about. It wasn't rendered with all of the bells and whistles, it looked more like a really nice animatic.
 
Has folding at home actually accomplished anything other than wasting money and resources?
That is what I always wonder...

and even if it helped discover a cure for a major disease, is that a good thing? Do we need more dumbass over-clocked apes fucking up this world more than it already is?
 
I don't think that logic works. If there was a cure, then whoever has it could put companies who "treat" cancer out of business. How is treating it more profitable than that?

Finding a cure would only lead to that conclusion if the person/group that finds the cure has absolutely no links at all to any pharmaceutical company. It's much more profitable from the pharmaceutical companies' perspective to keep on treating with no cure.
 
That is what I always wonder...

and even if it helped discover a cure for a major disease, is that a good thing? Do we need more dumbass over-clocked apes fucking up this world more than it already is?

We've already beaten natural selection as a species - might as well go all out with it. Then again, I would be so pissed off if I get disease that F@H was close to providing the keys to cure but then everyone stopped folding. ;)
 
Back
Top