Two 7900GSs (SLI) vs. X1900XTX

Nitron

n00b
Joined
Oct 15, 2004
Messages
48
What would you take (which setup would perform better)?

Two 7900GS running in SLI or one X1900XTX?

Any incite or links would be appreciated.
 
I'd take the X1900XTX with CrossFire mobo. That way I could slot in a new card later and get more performance.
 
Well imo, SLI of the 7900's gives you something that is better than a single 1900xtx, and comparable to it in crossfire, for the price of a single 1900. From the specs I've looked at the 7900GS lacks on shader operations, and thats really the only major difference, but it lacks by alot.
 
well the crossfire x1900xtx's xfires beat the 7900 gt sli. my friend build a ati computer and i switched to nvidia. due to the costs he only got one card, and right now my setup kills his and he refuses to run 3dmark06 :rolleyes:
another is that i just preffer the sli bridge over them messy dvi cables!
 
Sovereign said:
I'd take the X1900XTX with CrossFire mobo. That way I could slot in a new card later and get more performance.

I agree. The X1900XTX will be about the same as SLI'd 7900GS's as far as speed is concerned, but you'd have room to grow later with crossfire if you want with the X1900XTX. HOWEVER, there is the price to consider. If you can build an SLI rig using the 7900GS's for considerably less than the ATI option, you may want to follow that path because, like I said, the performance is going to be very close.

I'm basing my performance statements on what has been shown so far about the 7900GS (that it's close to a 7800GT but with less power draw and less heat). I look at the avg. scores on this chart:

http://www.hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1027953890&postcount=2352

...and compare the X1900XTX to two 7800GT's in SLI. They are very similar. Of course, 3DMark05 scores are not the end-all be-all of what you will experience day to day or in games, but it's at least a start for comparison's sake.
 
If you caught the woot.com deal, you scored a 7900GS @ $139.99. That is exactly what I did today,.... snagged two of them for $285 shipped. Thats about equivalent to the price of a x1900xt after rebate.

This card is nothing more than a die-shrunk 7800GT. Two of those in SLI manage to beat a x1900xtx by a little in most games except for the most shader-bound titles such as FEAR. Toms has a good chart where you can see how well 7800GTs stack up against the x1900xtx

http://www23.tomshardware.com/graphics.html?modelx=33&model1=281&model2=300&chart=92

These are all at stock....now factor in the enormous overclocking headroom of the G71 chip...along with the amazing price we got these for....and you have yourself a high performance budget SLI setup.
 
thats correct. The chart i linked to at Toms also benches 7800GT SLIs with 450/1300 clockspeeds, which is nearly identical to the 7900GS. I cant wait to try and overclock these though, since the 7900GT has already proven to be a monster overclocker. With any luck, vr-zone / techpowerup will publish some vmods to push these to the limit
 
Why would anyone buy an XTX? I just don't get it?

A 1900XT will get you within 5% of the performance and you pay $100+ less... Why???

Sli doesn't work with all games (while it's getting there) and it's still only 256meg memory buffer if you sli 2-7900GS together. The XT or XTX will have 512 meg butter... Much smoother I would think in resolutions or in heavy battles you want to play..
 
gib said:
thats correct. The chart i linked to at Toms also benches 7800GT SLIs with 450/1300 clockspeeds, which is nearly identical to the 7900GS. I cant wait to try and overclock these though, since the 7900GT has already proven to be a monster overclocker. With any luck, vr-zone / techpowerup will publish some vmods to push these to the limit

You might want to try unlocking the other 4 pipes..
 
Betatester said:
he refuses to run 3dmark06 :rolleyes:


What does 3dmark have to do with anything, period? I haven't even had any version of it installed in years. It is pointless to run. I would go with the single X1900XTX just because of the 3D IQ and avivo.
 
Marvelous said:
Sli doesn't work with all games (while it's getting there)

That's the reason I tortured myself by selling my 7800GTs for a single 1900XT >.<
Prey
 
Betatester said:
well the crossfire x1900xtx's xfires beat the 7900 gt sli. my friend build a ati computer and i switched to nvidia. due to the costs he only got one card, and right now my setup kills his and he refuses to run 3dmark06 :rolleyes:
another is that i just preffer the sli bridge over them messy dvi cables!

omfg 3Dmark 06 is a piece of shit, 1280x1024 0aa and 0af don't mean squat
 
BlueFridays said:
omfg 3Dmark 06 is a piece of shit, 1280x1024 0aa and 0af don't mean squat
Yeah, it should default settings to "Buy a 3007FPW" and set it to 4xFSAA with max resolution...
 
Borgschulze said:
Yeah, it should default settings to "Buy a 3007FPW" and set it to 4xFSAA with max resolution...
Who said you need to be able to see the benchmark? ;)

I'd to wait at an "out of range" message while the benchmark ran if it meant more accurate results for high end cards.
 
Unknown-One said:
Who said you need to be able to see the benchmark? ;)

I'd to wait at an "out of range" message while the benchmark ran if it meant more accurate results for high end cards.
I can play UT2K4 in Window mode at 2048x1536 with 4xFSAA with no lag :D
 
BlueFridays said:
omfg 3Dmark 06 is a piece of shit, 1280x1024 0aa and 0af don't mean squat

Then pay $30 like everyone else and get the full retail so you can crank all the settings and see what it will do.......Im not saying they are totally definitive, but they give a decent idea where you stand, and are good for stress testing OC's and such. Thats what i use them for.......

deanx0r said:
That's the reason I tortured myself by selling my 7800GTs for a single 1900XT >.<
Prey

There is a Prey config......has been for some time now.
 
solobaricsrock said:
Then pay $30 like everyone else and get the full retail so you can crank all the settings and see what it will do.......Im not saying they are totally definitive, but they give a decent idea where you stand, and are good for stress testing OC's and such. Thats what i use them for.......



There is a Prey config......has been for some time now.


You actually paid for 3dmark retail? I laugh at you. No seriously, what a waste of money.
 
pakotlar said:
You actually paid for 3dmark retail? I laugh at you. No seriously, what a waste of money.

Nope :D Work for a company that uses it.......full retail for free for all employees that need it for "Testing" Reasons ;) I just happened to need it to "Test" my home computer :cool:

PS: Try to have a little more tact next time you try to belittle me. I never said I paid for it, I just suggested that you (or anyone else) do.
 
nobody is going to pay for it...let's just quell that storm right now. I used to be a bench junkie back when 3dmark01 was up to date. The only thing 3d mark is good for is to test that there is no serious problems with your setup by checking if it gets similar scores to similar setups.

As far as trying to one up others in the bench department...that is just plain stupid. It involves turning the quality to low, pushing your hardware further than it should be pushed, and sometimes even doing garbage like running the bench with the monitor turned off :rolleyes:

As far as SLI'd 7900gs vs. x1900xtx, I would say neither. Get an x1900xt. The 7900's in SLI will still only have 256mb of effective video memory, which no longer cuts it for the latest games (ie. GRAW). The x1900xt will be just as fast, have 512mb of ram, and doesnt require a SLI board.
 
Back
Top