Truth and Facts Opinion's benchmark's

Status
Not open for further replies.

Anarex

n00b
Joined
Jun 14, 2004
Messages
14
Theres no doubt that Nvidia was going to be the top performer in Doom 3. However with all honesty id was in Nvidia's back pocket from the beginning, if it came down to writing code that was purely OpenGL (non bias) or writing the game to take advantage of one companies fill rate or so forth, id chose bias code just like intel with id. For better or worse this is how they choose to write. As far as fair play or ethics is conserarned well thats something everyone is going to have to decided for themselves. Some will side with them because they own that companys product and others will fault them because they own a diff companies product. So what is the point I'm trying to make?

Well, Half Life 2 was in production before ATi got there act together so Valve wasn't out to make a Tek demo of what was coming in the graphics world as far as Nvidia or ATi was concerned and they weren't going to build it to take advantage of one companies ware's or another. They went out to make a engine that everybody could use thats why they made it PURE Direct X 6 - DX9. They didn't target ATi or Nvidia back in 1999. They built there engine in secret and when the guts were done they showed it to the world and started testing it with both card companies and they showed US what worked best with the Source's strictly Pure DX code.

The only thing they were flaunting was Microsoft's Direct X. Quote from Kyle "From what Gabe Newell says, that is just the handwriting on the wall when it comes to "pure" DX9 based games. (http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=NTE5LDQ=)"

Quote from Kyle
It seems to be truly sad that special code paths are having to be implemented by game developers for their games to run "correctly" on NVIDIA hardware. Standards and DX9 were supposed to be about speeding up development processes
READ HERE "http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=NTE5LDM="

So if you want a real benchmark to judge the two titans by far this is as faire as it is going to be. For those that are going to say Valve recommending ATi. Thats because they finished Scorce engen then tested and chose,what worked best not the other way around, Like id did You remember that feasco over AA? Thats why they sided with ATi amonst other reasons. That was gutsy at the time because they could have made more money baking the big dog like id did. It's no secret that Nvidia Spends a good share of its R&D money on game developers. As far as if thats good for the industry and us or just good for themselves well thats up to you. It looks to me that Doom 3 was a fixed race from the beginning!

Basically Im saying Souce is going to be a far less bias benchmark.

So all you fans of ATi and Nvidia should take a brake get a beer and sharpen your keyboards for the real battle to end the WAR.

But as games go Doom 3 and HL2 are going to be great.

So everybody sing it with me " War! huh-yeah
What is it good for?
Absolutely nothing
Uh-huh

War! huh-yeah
What is it good for?
Absolutely nothing
Say it again y'all

War! huh good God
What is it good for?
Absolutely nothing
Listen to me?

Ohhh? War! I despise
Because it means destruction?
Of innocent Fan boys (sorry had too)
 
Read the other threads before blabbering bout things you have no clue of..

ATI fixed theirselves by not supporting openGL like nvidia did
 
What facts to do you have to back up accusations of Id being in nvidia's back pocket? Do you honestly think a company would purposely sway performance drasticly towards one card over the other and basically divide their potential customer base in half?

This is hardly a "war". It is simply two fantastic companies releasing equally fantastic products which excel in different areas. This "war" atmosphere is created by dueling fan boy's who don't like to look at the whole picture of things.

ATI has spent plenty of R&D on Valve and Half-Life 2, and while the core engine may have been coded in secret before ATI got their act together, they didn't mind taking the gobs of cash ATI offered to become the poster child of the "Get in the game" campaign which was used to sell 9800XT's. Do I think that those R&D dollars would presued Valve to modify code to sway performance drastically towards ATI cards? No, absoultely not. Will the x800 series perform better than the 6800? That is a question that will be answered when the game is released. It's no "war to end all wars". It's simply another (potentially) fantastic game that hopefully runs well on both cards.
 
Well i would have to agree with the poster maybe not to the same extreme, but there really is no getting around companys paying for their cards to have optimized code within games, thats just pure buisness.

"Emret"-
Coding in opengl or dx dosen't make one card better. Its the optimizations that get implemented once the game has been coded with either form.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong. nVidia optimized their card for Doom III, not id optimizing for nVidia. I see nothing at all that points to otherwise.
 
Ummm... I seem to remember the Doom 3 engine was first shown on GeForce 3 hardware cause it was the first with pixel shaders. However, the next demo was done with an ATI card in the machine. If iD was really bias towards nVidia, why the hell would they admit they have an ATI card in that machine. I also remember Carmack saying that the 9700 was the best card at the time, so thats what he would use to show off the engine.

So it has nothing to do with Carmack programming for one company or another. We just have to face facts that nVidia won the round of Doom 3 and hope that ATI can get their stuff together with either a driver or with their next generation.
 
I see your point, but its a fact that nvidia was in on the early stages of dev with id in the quake series why do you need more prof its in the Hard reviews of motherboard, video cards, CPU's.

Kyle goes off on a rant about it in some of the Conclusion or when he's using a Quake engine to benchmark he warnes people that its bias. And I agree. Dont get me wrong Im not saying it a bad benchmark to judge like overclocking and other areas but when it comes to video and CPU it's always been on the side of intel and Nvidia. But its not a good one to judge say a intel and amd 3400 review or so forth. When you do a review like that with id software its pointless; becouse you know who it's going to faver. The very Idea of a benchmark is

"A standard by which something can be measured or judged: “Inflation... is a great distorter of seemingly fixed economic ideas and benchmarks” (Benjamin M. Friedman)"

id is inflation when it comes to Nvidia and Intel it goes against the very idea of using it as a benchmark. I know you all might not agree with my opinion but I hope you see my point. I don't mean to ruffle feathers.

Thank you for your insight and not being one of the empty comments

oh and to Emret add a link to your meaning becouse I not shur what you trying to say or please be more clear.

and to hmmya have you thought of using a name like R6 say if you liked 600cc bikes?
Just a thought hmmya well uh diff
 
Thank you for that link THAT pretty much say's it all. If your read between the lines

But Hard hardly had a say in the matter if they did we know there would never have been 2 or 4 GB of RAM in the systems among other things. :rolleyes:
and weres the info on the less systems?

Not that I blame HardOCP its not every day you get to be there for a game like this.
 
Im so sick of hearing this crap.Next time your gonna post something doom 3 related put it in the thread topic so all the people sick of hearing about knows not to read it.
 
I would have but hmmyah said this would be a more proper place.

Nobody is forcing you to read this.
 
I'm not sure if you realize this, but DOOM used to require a special rendering path just so the top end NVIDIA cards would not perform badly. You can go back and read John Carmack's plan updates for the nitty gritty, but he plainly spells out the fact that the ATI solutions were vastly superior when used with the generic (ARB2) rendering path.

It is NVIDIA and not id that has made extensive investments in bringing strong performance to DOOM on GeForce hardware. This became abundantly clear when the NV3x specific rendering path was removed from the game-- high end GeForce hardware runs the ARB2 path just like Radeon cards do.

Basically you are acting like an ATI apologist because of their lackluster OpenGL ICD. id is not favoring NVIDIA. id is not biased against ATI. If you have followed John Carmack's plan updates over the years you will see it spelled out quite plainly that he exploits whatever the hardware can give-- the (relatively) poor performance you see out of the x800 cards is ATI's fault just as the poor ARB2 path performance was NVIDIA's fault.

Also, I'd put money on the x800s not making a significantly better showing in HL2. I imagine NVIDIA has been putting considerable effort to make sure their drivers are very much up to par for that game as well.

Your opinion is based on bullshit and old data (old quotes from devs based on old drivers and old hardware on unfinished builds of a game from a developer that fed the community a bald-faced lie). The 6800-series are simply better products this time. The x800 is a fine product, but it is just a refinement of a good thing. The 6800 series is innovative hardware and we should reward that with our checkbooks.

You remind me of those guys from a few years ago that were buying the last couple generations of 3dfx hardware and saying the image quality was just fine. After a seemingly endless line of the same old shit but a little faster that company deserved to go out of business. ATI needs to stand up and deliver another quantum leap like the 9700 PRO. Until that happens, stop spreading your bullshit FUD about id/nv/intel.

-yakz^2
 
for me at the end of the day the NV3x core was pretty poor(even if it was getting good fps the visuals were still poor). however the new NV4x core seems to be fantastic from what we have been seeing. and also don't blame id for what nvidia invested in, the decided that they were going to make a more optimized ogl architecture card just ike ati decided for dx.
 
actually I sold my brand new Voodoo 2 12MB to get the TNT 16MB as I saw it was a better card I saw through the hype I didnt base it on fav I based it on the facts and what I could see with my own eyes. oh at one of the old quakecons when Kyle was giving away video cards and they were demoing Tribes 1. I won a voodoo 2 12MB and sold that as well. I saw the death ratal of Voodoo did you? nvidia had a drive they wear the uderdogs they fought with there hardware not there checkbook. Remind you of anyone now? Don't get me wrong there not there yet. they are getting back on track.

Seems you dont know as much as you thought?
 
Conspiracy theories may be entertaining but these things are mostly fictional. John Carmack has always been good about giving his unbiased opinion of hardware. First he liked 3dfx, then nvidia, then ATI and now nvidia is back on top. Even when he mentioned one card as being the better, he would still tell us what failings it had, instead of simply trumpeting it as best.

Nvidia's advertisements at the start of games are just that, advertisements. No major game maker is stupid enough to design their game around performing well on some HW and ignoring their competitors. Nvidia is better at OpenGL. Nvidia supports the new shading features. Nvidia is best in Doom 3. This ain't coincidence.
 
Just becouse it uses the same path; does it mean it wasnt aimed at a type of card?
does it not seem odd to you that it beat the ATi even with the GT so much. uh you here that the Nvidia is screaming somthing. WE PAYED FOR BIAS CODE I not saying nvidias wrong Im saying just that it was leaning all the code in Nvidia's way.Im not knoking the game or Nvidia Im talking about judgeing it all on one peace of code. As far as a benchmark it's not a good benchmark.your twisting my words this isnt a flame to Nvidia or Doom if its used to judge Nvidia to nvidia or 2.8c to 3.2c thats fine the bias wont afect the bench but doing ATi to Nvidia would fudge the resoltes. See what Im getting at. Would you think that 3D mark was a good bench if it was dev in co op with ATi but at the end of dev if they worked some code in for Nvidia or if ATi made there card cater to the 3d mark? No you would say it wouldnt be good for judging one vid against another vid brand but it would be good for judjing brand A with brand A and B with B. See were Im going? Im saying HL2 will be better for judging A with B.
 
According to the latest "PC Gamer" hardware article, Doom3 has high graphics setting that are not supported by ANY card in existence right now, meaning that we’ll only be able to see those addtional cool special effects in the video cards of tomorrow.

What does it mean? It means that Doom3 is one of these games that is pushing hardware, that’s all, there is no bias. Currently, Nvidia is in the lead -- tomorrow it might be ATI.

And as usual, we gamers are the winners.
 
Anarex said:
Just becouse it uses the same path; does it mean it wasnt aimed at a type of card?
does it not seem odd to you that it beat the ATi even with the GT so much. uh you here that the Nvidia is screaming somthing. WE PAYED FOR BIAS CODE I not saying nvidias wrong Im saying just that it was leaning all the code in Nvidia's way.Im not knoking the game or Nvidia Im talking about judgeing it all on one peace of code. As far as a benchmark it's not a good benchmark.your twisting my words this isnt a flame to Nvidia or Doom if its used to judge Nvidia to nvidia or 2.8c to 3.2c thats fine the bias wont afect the bench but doing ATi to Nvidia would fudge the resoltes. See what Im getting at. Would you think that 3D mark was a good bench if it was dev in co op with ATi but at the end of dev if they worked some code in for Nvidia or if ATi made there card cater to the 3d mark? No you would say it wouldnt be good for judging one vid against another vid brand but it would be good for judjing brand A with brand A and B with B. See were Im going? Im saying HL2 will be better for judging A with B.

You seem to be getting pretty worked up over this, but it's really pretty simple. Nvidia has much better OpenGL support in addition to several next generation hardware features that Doom 3 happens to use. ATi, whose new X800 line is no slouch, decided to throw more speed into their new cards but they didn't include a lot of next gen features.

That said, Half Life 2 benches may well be a better way to compare the two cards -- in D3D. The only problem is that all of the D3D benches I've seen so far have the comparable 6800s and X800s performing pretty much equally. I don't see that changing a whole lot in HL2, but I guess it's possible.

I think that Nvidia has simply won this round. Their cards have more next gen features, better OpenGL performance, and D3D performance that's equal to that of ATi.
 
The one thing I am a little suprised about is when the Doom 3 Alpha leaked and OCP ran some benchmarks then, the ATI hardware was showing a definate lag behind then as well even though they had the best card out. Yes it was only Doom Alpha code, but there was an obvious issue seen at that time and I have to assume ATI saw it then as well. So now we get a chance to see it with release code and once again ATI is lagging behind with the OpenGL and Doom 3. So my question is has ATI just decided they are not going to really worry about Doom 3 performance and bank most of their time with HL2 ? I don't really see it as some kind of an ID / Nvidia conspiracy as much as ATI just seemingly not wanting to put forth much effort with it up to this point.
 
CIWS said:
The one thing I am a little suprised about is when the Doom 3 Alpha leaked and OCP ran some benchmarks then, the ATI hardware was showing a definate lag behind then as well even though they had the best card out. Yes it was only Doom Alpha code, but there was an obvious issue seen at that time and I have to assume ATI saw it then as well. So now we get a chance to see it with release code and once again ATI is lagging behind with the OpenGL and Doom 3. So my question is has ATI just decided they are not going to really worry about Doom 3 performance and bank most of their time with HL2 ? I don't really see it as some kind of an ID / Nvidia conspiracy as much as ATI just seemingly not wanting to put forth much effort with it up to this point.

My thoughts exactly, this coupled with years of people at rage3d SCREAMING for opengl performance equates to Ati not really caring about doom3/opengl.

I don't think they expected for doom3 to have as big of an impact as it has, I am really shocked, I didn't really get hyped until the official release date.
 
First you accuse id software of writing biased code to only help one video card developer and then you say Valve would never do the same. How in the hell do you justify this? I don't see a single shred of truth or facts in your entire post.

You don't mention that about two years ago when id had their Doom experience at E3 and Quakecon that they were using ATI cards (which ATI then managed to leak the alpha being played). You don't mention that ATI and NVIDIA use the EXACT SAME coding path (which is a standard path in OpenGL). You don't mention that ATI has ALWAYS had trouble getting OpenGL working correctly. Even with Valve's most famous game, Counter-Strike.

So please, explain in all the technical details what id is doing to bias their cards. Just because ATI has problems with OpenGL doesn't make an OpenGL engine biased. It means ATI needs to make some decent OpenGL drivers.
 
Anarex said:
Theres no doubt that Nvidia was going to be the top performer in Doom 3. However with all honesty id was in Nvidia's back pocket from the beginning, if it came down to writing code that was purely OpenGL (non bias) or writing the game to take advantage of one companies fill rate or so forth, id chose bias code just like intel with id. For better or worse this is how they choose to write. As far as fair play or ethics is conserarned well thats something everyone is going to have to decided for themselves. Some will side with them because they own that companys product and others will fault them because they own a diff companies product. So what is the point I'm trying to make?

Well, Half Life 2 was in production before ATi got there act together so Valve wasn't out to make a Tek demo of what was coming in the graphics world as far as Nvidia or ATi was concerned and they weren't going to build it to take advantage of one companies ware's or another. They went out to make a engine that everybody could use thats why they made it PURE Direct X 6 - DX9. They didn't target ATi or Nvidia back in 1999. They built there engine in secret and when the guts were done they showed it to the world and started testing it with both card companies and they showed US what worked best with the Source's strictly Pure DX code.

The only thing they were flaunting was Microsoft's Direct X. Quote from Kyle "From what Gabe Newell says, that is just the handwriting on the wall when it comes to "pure" DX9 based games. (http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=NTE5LDQ=)"

Quote from Kyle
It seems to be truly sad that special code paths are having to be implemented by game developers for their games to run "correctly" on NVIDIA hardware. Standards and DX9 were supposed to be about speeding up development processes
READ HERE "http://www.hardocp.com/article.html?art=NTE5LDM="

So if you want a real benchmark to judge the two titans by far this is as faire as it is going to be. For those that are going to say Valve recommending ATi. Thats because they finished Scorce engen then tested and chose,what worked best not the other way around, Like id did You remember that feasco over AA? Thats why they sided with ATi amonst other reasons. That was gutsy at the time because they could have made more money baking the big dog like id did. It's no secret that Nvidia Spends a good share of its R&D money on game developers. As far as if thats good for the industry and us or just good for themselves well thats up to you. It looks to me that Doom 3 was a fixed race from the beginning!

Basically Im saying Souce is going to be a far less bias benchmark.

So all you fans of ATi and Nvidia should take a brake get a beer and sharpen your keyboards for the real battle to end the WAR.

But as games go Doom 3 and HL2 are going to be great.

So everybody sing it with me " War! huh-yeah
What is it good for?
Absolutely nothing
Uh-huh

War! huh-yeah
What is it good for?
Absolutely nothing
Say it again y'all

War! huh good God
What is it good for?
Absolutely nothing
Listen to me?

Ohhh? War! I despise
Because it means destruction?
Of innocent Fan boys (sorry had too)



Yeah you think you have a case or something ? Anyone here knows that your a babbling crying fanboy.


suck my PENIS
 
Mushroom Prince said:
Yeah you think you have a case or something ? Anyone here knows that your a babbling crying fanboy.


suck my PENIS

There is a warning posted at the top of the forum and Flaming is against the rules. This kind of response is completely unacceptable here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top