Troubleshooting memory problem

Joined
Feb 14, 2005
Messages
6
Hey all. This is my first time posting at this site and compared to the people I see post on these forums, I'm a complete newb. I do know a few things about computers, but not as much as you guys here.

I'm looking for what could be wrong with my system. Full specs are as follows:

AMD Athlon 64 3400+
ASUS k8v se deluxe
Kingston PC3200 512MB ValueRAM KVR400X64C3A/512
ATI Radeon 9800 XT
Creative Labs Sound Blaster Audigy 2 ZS Gamer
120GB ATA HD
40GB ATA HD
40\12\48x Sony CD Burner
Antec 400w PSU that came with the case (Antec SX1040BII case)

When I first assembled this system, everything worked fine except for these random crashes happening ALL THE TIME. I couldn't install WinXP because I could barely even make it to the setup screen without it crashing. I tried slowing down my RAM from DDR400 to DDR333 and that instantly cured the problem. So I figured I got bad RAM. I called ASUS tech support and they agreed that it was prolly the RAM. I ran memtest on the RAM and it would give me all sorts of big errors after around 20 minutes. So I RMA'd it thru NewEgg. Around 3 weeks later I got a new RAM stick (same kind) and I was still having the exact same problems. memtest showed a crapload of errors on THIS RAM as well, but slowing it down to DDR333 again cured the problem. At this point I said to hell with RMA'ing the memory again, I had just built this incredible computer that I was eager to test out (moving up from a AMD Athlon 1.2 GHz) and I figured (rather impatiently) that what the hell, DDR333 is a shitload better than PC100, and maybe I'd fiddle around with it later. 6 months later I'm investigating the possible problem. I've spoken to as many geeks as I can find and many of them say different things. The first guy (who is supposed to know his stuff seeing as how he works at a computer repair place) said something like AMD can't work with DDR memory that fast, even though the motherboard clearly states that it can. Other people I talked to laughed at this. Another guy I spoke with said it might have something to do with the "southbridge" controller on my mobo. Other tech guys laughed at that suggestion, too. The last guy I finally spoke with said that instability at default settings could be indicative of not enough power / PSU not big enough. One thing that gets me though is that I thought BIOS would slow the RAM down by itself if it wasn't getting enough power. BIOS detected the RAM at DDR400, albeit with masive instability. I figured a 400w would be plenty, but I've heard rumors that my mobo is very buggy and I've read the post here on hardforum about how PSU's don't always put out the wattage they say they do, and sometimes when not shutting down "properly" in windows, the computer won't POST after a cold boot (but will a little bit later with a reboot), and I am running an awful lot of things in my computer: 4 case fans (1 with green LED's in it) a CPU fan, a rather large gfx card (with yet another fan on it), 2 HD's, and a large sound card. I didn't think fans ran up that much power...

What would your analysis of the situation be? I sure would hate to have to replace my whole mobo... until uncle sam coughs up my tax refund, I'm looking at a rather empty wallet.

also, I do not OC at all. if that helps.
 
The first guy (who is supposed to know his stuff seeing as how he works at a computer repair place) said something like AMD can't work with DDR memory that fast

= bullshit. A64's work great with DDR400. I know lots of morons that work in shops.

Another guy I spoke with said it might have something to do with the "southbridge" controller on my mobo.

= bullshit, very unlikely the southbridge has anything to do with this

The last guy I finally spoke with said that instability at default settings could be indicative of not enough power / PSU not big enough.

= not bullshit, but probably not your problem. An Antec 400w is plenty for a non-OCer.

If memtest comes back with errors, but you've RMA'd the sticks of RAM, odds are it's probably the mobo, man...

You got a friend with a rig that can take DDR400? Pop your sticks in his and memtest86 loop the thing to death. If the sticks come out known good, check the PSU's output rails in your BIOS. If they're too far off the 3.3/5/12v marks, that COULD be it, though I doubt it severely. I think your board is fucked.
 
Dammit. I was hoping it wouldnt be that. Oh well, maybe this will give me an excuse to get a DFI Lanparty...

I really appreciate your help, thank you very much.
 
Back
Top