Tri 280's or Crossfire 4870x2's

What Setup 4 best overall game experience

  • Tri 280's

    Votes: 39 49.4%
  • crossfire 4870x2's

    Votes: 40 50.6%

  • Total voters
    79

Renner Technology

Weaksauce
Joined
Aug 16, 2008
Messages
118
Im really confused. I have been looking at reviews for tri 280's and crossfire 4870x2's and I
am just bouncing around between which one is the better option...

For a long long time, I used to buy the very cheapest parts I could and bump them up. But
now a days, I come home from work/school and just need a break from life... I just want to
enjoy my games at the best quality and smoothest quality, so what do you guys
suggest?





-------------------------------------------------------------

Right now I am gaming on my "amazing" LG L227WTG 22" monitor.
I am looking at a 30" when I purchase my graphics upgraded
(any suggestions as to what 30" to go with too?)

sig below lists current setup
 
what are you playing? neither scales really well, Crossfire 4870X2 will let you do some really neat items (24CFAA) while crysis and such might do better on the GTX280. so a lot will be based on what you play
 
Scaling isn't the best for either option. But I agree with picking ATI if you are a AA whore like myself.
 
I don't know if cost is a consideration as well but two 4870X2 900dollars, trisli GTX280 around 1100 dollars. The other consideration is that you can avoid the Nvidia chipsets by going with the crossfire. that would be a big point in the crossfires favor. or wait for the X58 but some early reports suggest it may not be the best gaming platform (I would imagine that new compilers are needed.)

If I was going the nvidia route I would go with just two of them on a EVGA 750i FTW motherboard and a good quad core. hell of a lot cheaper and probably pretty close to the trisli. Unless your willing to go to the skull trail
 
Tri-SLI GTX 260 Core 216 seems like the best bang for buck here.

Judging from his post and sig (i'm jealous) best bang for buck is his last concern and he is not looking for mid range.....And with the high resolution of a 30" not the best.
 
Right now I would choose the 3xSLi 280 coz one its more performance then the 4 ATi 4870 cards....second of all, from judging most of every post gamers and enthus...have posted here....the games they play benefit more from nvidia rather then ATi atm, so either way...both will give you good performance....and most of us average users won't bitch about 50fps @ 1600x1200 Ultra detail in Crysis Warhead (and I've heard Crytek has gone backwards in the gfx performance sector for the new game). But for enthus out there (most online including myself :p) would probably pay more attention to both detail and performance with absolute no "playable" content allowed...

My point:

Tri Sli, nvidia always:D
 
Every review I've seen tri-SLI 280s beats the 4870x2 crossfire, easily. [H]ard found that a dual-SLI setup was much smoother than 4870x2 or crossfire 4870x2. If I was building a system atm and had your budget, I'd go for a 790i with your CPU of choice, and tri-280s. Although, with that budget, you might just wait for the i7 and the 55nm refresh that are supposedly coming out soon.
 
I really play just about anything,
-------------------------------------------------
1) Stalker - Clear Sky
2) Crysis WarHead
3) Brotherers IN Arms: Hells Highway
soon...
4) Call of Duty - World at War
5) Fallout 3
6) a lot of Steam and etc games...


I know its a lot of money. I used to save every cent I could on a build and always wait for
prices to hit the sweat spots. Right now, I just want to come home and be blow away
and enjoy games at their best. I know computers fairly well. I'm just really wondering
whats the best rought to go.

Heck... maybe someone can find some of my good FS deals :p
 
I think its going to come down to a matter of preference then, dual 4870X2 allow for better eye candy for a lot of games (like 12CFAA in COD) but the SLI will give you more horsepower. If I had the money to throw and was looking at a toy I would get the tri sli. For the money and the eye candy I would get the 4870X2 Xfire. for the value point (as much as can be at this level) standard SLI GTX280

JM2C
 
I still wouldnt go tri sli or quad crossfire since the returns diminish too rapidly. Unless of course you game at 2500+ res.
 
I really play just about anything,
-------------------------------------------------
1) Stalker - Clear Sky
2) Crysis WarHead
3) Brotherers IN Arms: Hells Highway
soon...
4) Call of Duty - World at War
5) Fallout 3
6) a lot of Steam and etc games...


I know its a lot of money. I used to save every cent I could on a build and always wait for
prices to hit the sweat spots. Right now, I just want to come home and be blow away
and enjoy games at their best. I know computers fairly well. I'm just really wondering
whats the best rought to go.

Heck... maybe someone can find some of my good FS deals :p
I'd go crossfire with that list of games. The only game that would really benefit the Nvidia solution would be Crysis Warhead. All others should be equal or in favor of ATI
 
I'd go crossfire with that list of games. The only game that would really benefit the Nvidia solution would be Crysis Warhead. All others should be equal or in favor of ATI

There is one that leans Nvidia (crysis) and one that leans ATI (Stalker clear sky) the rest would be crushed by the setup. It doesn't really matter which card can run TF2 at 1000fps if they're both running them at over 100fps.
 
tf2 runs at max everything 16x10 on my kids e6850/9600gt rig. so it doesnt take much to run it.
anyway, when the gtx cards came out, i read in a few places that average scaling for 2 gtx cards was around 30% better frame rates than 1 gtx card, and 3 gtx cards ran about 5% better frame rates than 2 gtx cards. so why bother? i dont know about scaling with the 4870x2 cards. i run 4870 cf and at 1920x12 it can run anything, crysis included, at max.


also - sweet and route.
 
tf2 runs at max everything 16x10 on my kids e6850/9600gt rig. so it doesnt take much to run it.
anyway, when the gtx cards came out, i read in a few places that average scaling for 2 gtx cards was around 30% better frame rates than 1 gtx card, and 3 gtx cards ran about 5% better frame rates than 2 gtx cards. so why bother? i dont know about scaling with the 4870x2 cards. i run 4870 cf and at 1920x12 it can run anything, crysis included, at max.


also - sweet and route.

GTX scaling is not that at all. In CoD4 you get near perfect scaling from even the third card. A single 4870x2 at 1920x1200 can't run crysis at max settings with max AA.

Crysis all settings "high" No AA, only gets 28 fps average

Seriously, get a life fan boy.
 
ooooh a fanboi calling another guy a fanboi (hey Irony me too LOL!)and a "life" on the internets
Breaks out the /popcorn
btw you forgot the "a" :)
 
Few qestions for you guys, maybe this will also help/inform others:
(some are noob questions, but just want to check my own data)


1) How much power will tri sli pull and how much will xfire 4870x2'x

2) The only game for each card to really shine is; Stalker -> ati & Crysis -> nvidia

3) How are the driver levels for each card?

4) Will my Q9450 bottle neck any card?
 
Few qestions for you guys, maybe this will also help/inform others:
(some are noob questions, but just want to check my own data)


1) How much power will tri sli pull and how much will xfire 4870x2'x

2) The only game for each card to really shine is; Stalker -> ati & Crysis -> nvidia

3) How are the driver levels for each card?

4) Will my Q9450 bottle neck any card?

1) idk, I'd assume close to the same... they'd both be using a lot of power.
2) Yes.. there's other games that benefit one over the other, but from your list, stalker=ati, crysis=nvidia. Every other game will run fine on either setup.
3) Decent. You'll most likely have a few problems with either setup.
4) Not at the resolution you'll be playing at.

Go with whatever's cheapest imo.
 
1) How much power will tri sli pull and how much will xfire 4870x2'x
If your buying either setup, I don't think your going to care about the 10$ more in electricity a month it will cost vs running nothing. The difference between one or the other will be less than 2$/month. That being said, your looking at ~600-700 Watts on the GPUs alone, max draw.
2) The only game for each card to really shine is; Stalker -> ati & Crysis -> nvidia
Pretty much. There is some minor differences in other games. For example, CoD4 maxes at 4x AA while ATI can go higher, but if your playing at 2560x1600, it's really hard to notice higher than 4xAA.
3) How are the driver levels for each card?
Better now. There are still some stutter problems on the 4870x2s. Not sure why this is happening, but [H]ard reports it in nearly all of thier reviews. The 4870x2s will probably give you higher max frame rates, the GTX will generally give you higher min frame rate.

4) Will my Q9450 bottle neck any card?
Highly doubtful at the resolutions your talking, even at the stock 2.66ghz.
 
GTX scaling is not that at all. In CoD4 you get near perfect scaling from even the third card. A single 4870x2 at 1920x1200 can't run crysis at max settings with max AA.

Crysis all settings "high" No AA, only gets 28 fps average

Seriously, get a life fan boy.

"fan boy"? look at my sig, college boy. "get a life"? you are the one who is getting her little panties in an uproar because i stated an opinion that differed from yours. "seriously".
 
"fan boy"? look at my sig, college boy. "get a life"? you are the one who is getting her little panties in an uproar because i stated an opinion that differed from yours. "seriously".

After reading you claim SLI scaling caps around 30%, I assumed your signture was a lie.
 
I have had my tri-sli set up for a while now and love it! However, with that said, the 4870X2's are beast as well and two of those things are going to be just as good. Honestly, it boils down to a few factors. Do you have a brand loyalty? Is money a huge concern? What mobo will you be popping these into?

You cant go wrong with either card which makes your choice really simple. Put two pieces of paper with ATI on one and Nvidia on the other in a hat and pick one.
 
I have had my tri-sli set up for a while now and love it! However, with that said, the 4870X2's are beast as well and two of those things are going to be just as good. Honestly, it boils down to a few factors. Do you have a brand loyalty? Is money a huge concern? What mobo will you be popping these into?

You cant go wrong with either card which makes your choice really simple. Put two pieces of paper with ATI on one and Nvidia on the other in a hat and pick one.

My feelings *kinda* exactly

Things are pretty much on about par =]
no one should feel bad with what ever choice they make.

I was just wondering if one was really ahead of the other.
it seams that its almost to close to call really

No matter what route you choose, you have data to back your decision.



My MB
Asus x38
EVGA 780i
Abit IP5 (i think ^_^)
and a few lesser ones..


If I go sli I was thinking about sticking with my 780i

if I go xfire I was going to go with Asus something.. not sure what :/





Maybe I will just get both cards, that way I cant complain and enjoy life in both worlds ^_^
jk
 
Back
Top