TrendMicro Tackles Chrome OS Claims

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Are these guys on to something...or just on something?

While I applaud the impressive advances in security that are apparent in Chrome OS, to a certain extent we are seeing marketing history repeat itself. How often did the mantra that MacOS was immune to malware need to be repeated until the vast majority of users believed it and continue to do so, even after Apple went as far as incorporating rudimentary AV software into MacOS?
 
from article said:
4 – (Almost) No desktop applications. Every application in Chrome OS will run inside the browser, discrete desktop applications will simply not exist; all apps are effectively web apps. The OS does afford the possibility of browser plug-ins locally so the end user still has some influence over the operating environment. These plug-ins of course will be sandboxed. Google has recently made a Software Development Kit available for the creation of Chrome “Native Apps”

(snip)

So, what do I think? Well, the existence of the SDK seems to demonstrate that the “sterile environment” of an out-of-the-box Chrome netbook, may be about as long lived as an untouched Android device.

When I was reading the list of security enhancements of ChromeOS and saw #4, I thought exactly the same thing the author thought. Sure, right NOW ChromeOS might be secured because there's no apps on it. But wait til someone makes a killer app using the SDK that everyone wants (instant messengers? Angry Birds? Gmail notifier?) That's when hackers will attack ChromeOS - of course when it's popularity grows.
 
I don't know much about much but those "apps" on Chrome are really nothing more than glorified bookmarks. They are not apps by any sense of the word. It literally is just a bookmark with an icon
 
honestly, the author has a point, time will tell how secure chromeOS claims it will be, especially with the that:

..redesigning the underlying security architecture of the OS so that users don't have to deal with viruses, malware and security updates. It should just work.

sounds like Apple all over again..
 
Author should have done some basic fact checking. OS X doesn't have "rudimentary AV software". It has a malware blacklist that displays a warning message when users try to install known malware. As far as I know, Apple's never propagated the notion that OS X is immune to malware and viruses either (in fact they specifically state that it is not). This so-called "mantra" is something propagated by ignorant users.

But wait til someone makes a killer app using the SDK that everyone wants (instant messengers? Angry Birds? Gmail notifier?) That's when hackers will attack ChromeOS - of course when it's popularity grows.
Chrome OS does not have apps, only web apps. Even in the event that the OS itself is compromised, a reboot fixes it: every time you boot Chrome OS it checks its integrity. Any exploit would have to work its way into defeating or circumventing that process and I find it doubtful that such an exploit would be possible.

Trend Micro's only agenda with this article is to try and plant a seed that may eventually blossom into a paid product directed specifically at Chrome OS. Big deal.
 
Author should have done some basic fact checking. OS X doesn't have "rudimentary AV software". It has a malware blacklist that displays a warning message when users try to install known malware. As far as I know, Apple's never propagated the notion that OS X is immune to malware and viruses either (in fact they specifically state that it is not). This so-called "mantra" is something propagated by ignorant users.


Chrome OS does not have apps, only web apps. Even in the event that the OS itself is compromised, a reboot fixes it: every time you boot Chrome OS it checks its integrity. Any exploit would have to work its way into defeating or circumventing that process and I find it doubtful that such an exploit would be possible.

Trend Micro's only agenda with this article is to try and plant a seed that may eventually blossom into a paid product directed specifically at Chrome OS. Big deal.

Go ahead and keep thinking to yourself that ChromeOS is 100% safe.
 
Go ahead and keep thinking to yourself that ChromeOS is 100% safe.

It might be 100% safe, but about 50% pointless. Once you start with native apps then what was the point of a thin client? We'll see what traction this gains in the coming year but I just don't see the point honestly beyond traditional thin client scenarios and that's becoming the province of tablets these days.
 
Go ahead and keep thinking to yourself that ChromeOS is 100% safe.
I didn't say it was 100% safe. I said it's unlikely that malware could defeat its built-in integrity check. If you can't defeat the integrity check, you can't permanently compromise the system.
 
(rant)I've installed Trend Micro on many PC's in the past and all it does is delete cookies and nothing else. I wouldn't believe anything this company says they never find/delete anything useful. (/rant) Otherwise yes Google will be safe for years because hardly anyone will have the OS so the reason to even make a bug for it will be minimal and Google does pretty damn well with exploits. If it gets super popular then yes more people will try and attack it, but I think Google does really well with bugs.
 
"..redesigning the underlying security architecture of the OS so that users don't have to deal with viruses, malware and security updates. It should just work."

sounds like Apple all over again..

Nah. Apple only introduces security flaws into their flavor of BSD. This is a different situation entirely.
 
Author should have done some basic fact checking. OS X doesn't have "rudimentary AV software". It has a malware blacklist that displays a warning message when users try to install known malware. As far as I know, Apple's never propagated the notion that OS X is immune to malware and viruses either (in fact they specifically state that it is not). This so-called "mantra" is something propagated by ignorant users.


Chrome OS does not have apps, only web apps. Even in the event that the OS itself is compromised, a reboot fixes it: every time you boot Chrome OS it checks its integrity. Any exploit would have to work its way into defeating or circumventing that process and I find it doubtful that such an exploit would be possible.

Trend Micro's only agenda with this article is to try and plant a seed that may eventually blossom into a paid product directed specifically at Chrome OS. Big deal.

eh what about all the users that got infected by rogue malware using Chrome? I mean shit Java Adobe chrome is using it and will always be exploited like all the other browsers simple
 
I didn't say it was 100% safe. I said it's unlikely that malware could defeat its built-in integrity check. If you can't defeat the integrity check, you can't permanently compromise the system.

You are forgetting that there's a new reality. The prize isn't the use of your system resources, its getting your credentials. If all they need is temporary control to gain your g-password then who cares if its wiped when the system is rebooted. People who want a botnet are still going to go after desktops, for lower powered devices and phones your info is wanted as anything more is going to get noticed.
 
*cough *cough STUXNET *cough *cough
Yes its true Chrome can't get infected.
 
It might be 100% safe, but about 50% pointless. Once you start with native apps then what was the point of a thin client? We'll see what traction this gains in the coming year but I just don't see the point honestly beyond traditional thin client scenarios and that's becoming the province of tablets these days.

Cult following like Apple could happen if Google dumps eleventy billion into marketing. You can make people want to buy anything. I agree I don't see the point beyond a thin client, and then cloud apps would have to be better than native.
 
My question: On my new spiffy Chrome Pc (should I at some time decide to get one) how will I play a shooter, an MMO, Skyrim, or whatever application I might choose to buy? How would Steam work if everything is in effect run though the browser?

I downloaded a VM hard drive with Chrome OS to check it out, it seems like a nice spiffy browser, I dont know it is, as yet, much more then that. I dont see how I would do many of the things I do on this Win 7 box in that OS, well except maybe Porn, that seems like it would work fine. So I guess the OS will be a success because the multitudes can use it for self gratification.
 
In case anyone else wants to try it out. Download the Sun VM packadge -- free for home users, and go to http://techcrunch.com/2009/11/19/guide-install-google-chrome-os/

I found google docs to test out basic word processor, spread sheet etc, however as soon as I loaded it up in Chrome OS the virtual machine bogged to a slide show like crawl.

Since I can run win 98, XP and have application running inside the 'guest' OS with out problems I think it has more to due with Chrome then the VM environment.
 
It is basically the browser is the OS in a little netbook (hopefully good on the power) that you will need wifi/3G in order to do anything with it. You will never be using Steam or FPS's in it (well...Quakeworld? Probably wouldn't run very fast)
 
all the apps are basically in the cloud right? this is entirely different then Apple saying their OS can't get virus
 
My question: On my new spiffy Chrome Pc (should I at some time decide to get one) how will I play a shooter, an MMO, Skyrim, or whatever application I might choose to buy? How would Steam work if everything is in effect run though the browser?

I doubt we'll be seeing ChromePCs much. All of the Chromebooks are Atom based, so we're not talking about that much overall horsepower. If Google decides to release something that would be a ChromePC (attach a keyboard and monitor, etc), it'd likely be about the same specs. Think Zombu miniPCs (http://www.zonbu.com/shop/product.php?productid=28&cat=2&page=1) and not what we all would consider to be a proper desktop.
 
all the apps are basically in the cloud right? this is entirely different then Apple saying their OS can't get virus
There are extensions which are installed locally, but they're basically just web apps wrapped in a shell that have access to some additional Chrome APIs. Like web apps, they don't have system access.
 
What I am seeing and hearing is that while it might do OK as a tablet/phone OS it will never, ever, even once, make it as my desktop OS.

I like to be able to do things, like, oh tweak my hardware and play with my system settings. Oh and use real applications.
 
I still don't understand why I want to buy an expensive netbook thats basically a dumb terminal...
 
I still don't understand why I want to buy an expensive netbook thats basically a dumb terminal...

Cheaper than other netbooks of comparable spec and size, included 3G data, everything's online even if your Chromebook gets stolen...
 
Back
Top