TR SI-97, TT Sonic Tower, TT Big Typhoon?

Tiny

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Oct 31, 2003
Messages
6,346
Ok, so I have the SI-97, and it works great.

However, the look of the Thermaltake Sonic Tower got to me and I ordered it.

Now they (Thermaltake) just came out with the Big Thphoon. That one looks neat too.

I know the good job the SI-97 does, I will soon test the Sonic Tower, and the BigTyphoon looks like the XP-120 from Thermalright.

From reviews they all look to cool well.

What do you all think?

I got the tower one because I am building a custom case and wanted it to be as quiet as possible and still be a good all-around rig.
 
Both those Thermaltakes are extremely heavy. Even if they do outperform your SI-97 (keyword if), the weight associated with them is not worth the time and money. Anyhow, the Big Typhoon is essentially a rip-off of the SI-97.
 
i read one of the reviews on the site and it cools better than a zalman7700 so i am definately considering one for my athlon xp mobile. now the only problem is its a massive 800grams! :eek: thats almost a l ittle more than 1.5x heavier than my slk800u :eek: but i will definately consider one of those or a silent tower, the si97 didnt seem much better than my slk800u..
 
In my custom case the mobo will be on the floor of the case, and I can use a shim on the Sonic Tower, so the wieght shouldn't be that big of concern.

I am actually a little dissapointed with the SI-97. Granted its cooling is in proportion to the kind of fan you use, but with the Panaflo that I have on it isn't that great silent wise. It cools great, but I am looking for quiet.

So the Big Typhoon is out. Cause it is the same as the XP-120.

I just have to wait for the Sonic Tower to get here. If it works out the way I am thinking, I will have just two 120mm fans for the case, and the two silent ones in my PSU.
 
if your si97 combo with the panaflo M cools nicely have you thought of lowering the fan speed of the panaflo? i have a si97 with a panaflo L at 5volts cooling a 2.2ghz 2600+ axpm @ 1.55 volts and idle/load temps are low40s/high40s.
 
I have mine at 5v also. I guess I am spoiled as far as noise goes. Or snobish. :D
 
thats interesting, the pc with the si97 is near silent :p it has a 120mm exhaust fan at 5volts and a seasonic super tornado with a thermally controlled 120mm fan and i suspended the hard drive (samsung spinpoint) so its as silent as can be :)
 
Well, I am now waiting for my new motherboard that will be going in my custom case.

The folding system that I had the Silent Tower on was killed during a thunder storm.

So I decided to take a few pics so people could see it and how big it is.

The pics are taken with it just sitting in a VPRMatrix computer that I found ( I pulled a P43ghz, 2x120gb hdd, 512mb pc2700, FX5200, and a LIVE! 5.1 sound card. All working, YAY! )

The Silent Tower is just sitting on the CPU.

tt29nj.jpg

tt19lz.jpg

tt32lz.jpg


Here is with a 92mm fan sitting on it:
tt43rd.jpg


Here is with a huge Panaflo that I have. This fan spins super fast! I want to test how well it cools at full speed, but that will have to wait. I plan on using a Nexus 120mm on it when it goes into my system.

tt60vt.jpg

tt59we.jpg


So there she is, the Silent Tower. Can't wait until my board and other parts get here so I can start putting my custom case together! :)
 
With equal fans the TT Sonic Tower and Big Typhoon cool about the same. I reviewed both over the past few months....... :eek: You should be really happy with the performance of the Sonic Tower. I'm still using the Big Typhoon on my test rig.

371oq.jpg
 
domoMKIV said:
any updates?

i wonder if this would fit on my K8N Neo2 Platinum with heatpiped 6600GT
http://image2.sina.com.cn/IT/upload...3D547677I18a916d3ec74c291ead11aa0b8a3dac1.jpg

Just ordered my new mobo. So I have to wait some more. Sorry.

I am glad that you posted that pic. I have a 6600GT on the way to me and was wondering how it ran with a heatpiped solution on it. Which one is that and how does it cool for you?
If you could measure it, when I get all my stuff in I could see what room there is. When I get my stuff in I will take pics of it sitting how I will have it in my case (I still haven't got past the design phase of the case cause I was finalizing parts.)

I would like to get one to see if it will fit with a Sonic Tower and Zalman NB HS on a mATX mobo.

Bio-Hazard... good to hear that the Sonic Tower will do fine. Do you suggest a front mounted fan, back mounted, or sandwitched?
 
Tiny said:
Just ordered my new mobo. So I have to wait some more. Sorry.

I am glad that you posted that pic. I have a 6600GT on the way to me and was wondering how it ran with a heatpiped solution on it. Which one is that and how does it cool for you?
If you could measure it, when I get all my stuff in I could see what room there is. When I get my stuff in I will take pics of it sitting how I will have it in my case (I still haven't got past the design phase of the case cause I was finalizing parts.)
I would like to get one to see if it will fit with a Sonic Tower and Zalman NB HS on a mATX mobo.

thanks for the reply.

i havent received the videocard yet, hopefully it'll be here this week along with the mobo/cpu. At that point I will let you know, ive been doing some google searches though and people are saying it reaches upwards of 80C - but then some are reporting major temp drops if they rip the heatsink off and put on some AS5 instead (like 60C instead)
but yeah ill definitely measure it and get back to you on that.

the card is the Gigabyte GV-N66T128VP
ill get you some temp readouts as well.
 
Still waiting on my new DVD burner and my 6600GT PCI-e, but here are some pics until then:

What it is going to be cooling:
amd646xg.jpg


front1qu.jpg

side4sm.jpg


How it will be sitting in my case:
full6qx.jpg


How I have to run the fan, since I ran into a problem (more on that soon):
top9hw.jpg


My problem....memory clearance..(my memory will have heatspreaders on each of the 4 sticks):
memclearance2lz.jpg

memclearance28jf.jpg




Wow! That heatspreader on the AMD 64 does a good job! That white spot in the middle was the hottest point!
whitehot4hy.jpg
 
_Korruption_ said:
Both those Thermaltakes are extremely heavy. Even if they do outperform your SI-97 (keyword if), the weight associated with them is not worth the time and money. Anyhow, the Big Typhoon is essentially a rip-off of the SI-97.

Actually the Big Typhoon has been out for quite a bit longer then the SI-97, it's just that not everyone carries the whole TT line, it's a pretty big line ;)
 
OK, I am in a mental pickle.

I have the Sonic Tower, it is a good cooler, even better with the fan on it. But the included fan holders and long fan screws won't work. They threaded the holes to small on the fan holders.

So....I called Thermaltake, they said they can send me some new ones for $8 shipping. No thanks.

This is where I am at. I can either just stick the fan in the middle and ziptie it (my case won't have window), or order the new fan holders and hope they work.

OR

I was really impressed with the CoolerMaster Hyper 6+ review in a number of places. Also, they have a great little NB heatsink/fan that works well too ( I will be changing the NB heatsink on my board as well, so a new one is needed).

I haven't chose what to do yet. I guess I'll see how it all runs on my board and how I can mount the fan and then choose.
 
revgen said:
Get a DeWalt and shove the screws through the holes. Show 'em who's boss. ;)

I'm thinking about that. lol

But that Hyper 6 is looking better and better to me, eventhough it takes a 100mm fan instead of the standard 120mm. I have a couple of idea on how to get around that though.
 
I am stupid. :(

Here is the rundown:

I bought the sonic tower to run on my s939, but I hadn't bought the s939 parts yet, so I stuck it on my sA board and it was great. Got my s939 parts (see pics in posts above), and I am all ready to get this puppy set-up this weekend.

Take a look at what I should have seen many times over, but didn't until earlier tonight:
amd646xg.jpg


Yup....the Sonic Tower requiers the screws for instillation on s939....on my Jetway board I can't use screws. So I can't use the Sonic Tower....it just sits there laughing at me now. :(

So I order the Coolermaster Hyper 6+ cooler (cause it has its own retention bracket) and it won't get here until Wednesday or Thursday. I don't want to wait that long to get this new system up and running. So I drive to CompUSA so I can grab a cheap-o cooler for s939 so I can get this thing at least up and running. I am looking at all the HSF combos (how do they get away with selling the BigTyphoon for $68!?), I just want a the cheapest s939 they have, so I get the TT Silent 939 cooler. Didn't even look at the specs closely...just saw 939 and $18 and grabbed it.

So I get home and install it. Install is the easiest I have ever seen. Under 20 seconds I had the thing out of the package, AS5 on, and plugging in the fan cord.

Turn the power on....YAY IT WORKS!...then I notice this loud noise....from my video card. The CPU HSF that I just got is dead silent, a ghost toot is louder than this thing. The stock fan on my 6600gt is annoying now.

So if you aren't an overclocker....pick up the Silent 939 by Thermaltake....it is indeed silent.

Then I realize that I could just order a new retention bracket that has screw holes in it.....see how dumb I am. To late now.

So to sum it up:

I am stupid.
I have good HSF right now thanks to the TT Silent 939.
I have an unused Sonic Tower
I have the Coolermaster Hyper 6+ on the way already.
I am stupid.


I'll update again when I get the Hyper 6+, I wonder what one I will have to get rid of. :(

*EDIT*

I am even more dumb than I thought! The post I made above about the fan not being able to mount. Well, those "long fan screws" I was complaing about....those are the screws for the mounting of the HS to the retenstion bracket. Wow am I stupid or what? The Sonic Tower does come with screws to mount the fan. I am too dumb to own a computer. :( And to think, I have never bought a system, the first system I had was self built with no help. Go figure.
 
Tiny said:
I am stupid. :(
So to sum it up:

I am stupid.
I have good HSF right now thanks to the TT Silent 939.
I have an unused Sonic Tower
I have the Coolermaster Hyper 6+ on the way already.
I am stupid.

*EDIT*

I am even more dumb than I thought! The post I made above about the fan not being able to mount. Well, those "long fan screws" I was complaing about....those are the screws for the mounting of the HS to the retenstion bracket. Wow am I stupid or what? The Sonic Tower does come with screws to mount the fan. I am too dumb to own a computer. :( And to think, I have never bought a system, the first system I had was self built with no help. Go figure.

Yer stoopid :D No wait, yer dumb.
J/K...it's always the simple things that get overlooked. I once forgot to reinstall my hsf after i ripped my computer apart. But I did learn that an xp1800+ will run for about .6 seconds without a hsf, until it POPS! :eek:
At least I got a new/free/better cpu because of it (good reason to buy retail cpu)
 
lol, yeah sometime I just get in a hurry.

I now have the Zalman 700VGA (the all copper one) on the way too.

They should all arrive around the same time, Wednesday or Thursday.

*giddy*
 
Tt Tech said:
Hey Tiny

Looks like the Jetway has the same %&*(@# frame as the Gigabyte boards...

This is what you need:
http://www.thermaltake.com/coolers/venus/si/a1773.htm

If you contact our parts department at (800) 988-1088 ext 108 from 9am-5:30pm PST Mon-Fri , they should be able to ship it out to your for about $5 or so.

Awesome. Thanks for the heads-up. I'll be calling them on Friday. :)
 
Back
Top