Top Antitrust Cop Gunning for Google?

Status
Not open for further replies.

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Uh oh, is the nations top antitrust cop gunning for Google or just stating the obvious?

The technology industry, she said, was coming under the sway of a dominant behemoth, one that had the potential to stifle innovation and squash its competitors. The last time the government saw a threat like this—Microsoft in the 1990s—it launched an aggressive antitrust case. But by the time of this conference, mid-June 2008, a new offender had emerged. "For me, Microsoft is so last century," Varney said. "They are not the problem. I think we are going to continually see a problem, potentially, with Google."
 
We *might* see a problem with google? "Potentially?"

Speculate much there chief?
Why not keep your mouth shut until you have some actual evidence of wrongdoing.
 
I'm all for this. Really, in the last decade MS hasn't done much, yet they continue to take the media beating. Somehow, the public has the perception that Google can do no wrong, and it's about time someone pointed out that that's simply not the case.
 
Wow, how about this person get a REAL JOB? Saving the people from big bad MS and Google is so much bs.
 
Unless it can be proved that Google DELIBERATELY made some underhanded moves to squash competitors, they can't be punished just for being the biggest and best.
We *might* see a problem with google? "Potentially?"

Speculate much there chief?
Why not keep your mouth shut until you have some actual evidence of wrongdoing.
Exactly. Until she has some specific examples and a case, she needs to sit in the corner and sip her cup of STFU.
 
Wow, how about this person get a REAL JOB? Saving the people from big bad MS and Google is so much bs.

Feel free to get a law degree and do better, skippy.

Eveyrone hates lawyers until thye need one.
 
I'm surprised the government doesn't just sue Google to help fund corporate welfare for other companies.

Change Corporate America can believe in.
 
I'm surprised the government doesn't just sue Google to help fund corporate welfare for other companies.

Change Corporate America can believe in.

I hope we don't step down to the EU level.
 
"For me, Microsoft is so last century," Varney said.
:rolleyes:

Professional people sound moronic when they try to use "cool" language. I'd like to know what kind of threat Google is to anyone. Is it the SPAM filled boards of Google Finance? Is Android going to make us give up our BlackBerrys and iPhones? Is Chrome taking over? Is Google going to drive all of the other search engines out of business? I could go on all day.

MS had far more market dominance in its OS and office suite than Google has with ANYTHING. Hmmm, isn't MS still intact?

Here is the complaint. Googe is . .
starting to colonize the emerging cloud-computing industry, amassing "enormous market power" and potentially creating an ecosystem that customers would be powerless to escape.

That explains it all.
I see it now. "Must. . . use. . . Google. . ." :eek:

This is a great country we have. Company XYZ is innovating TOO MUCH. We must crush them before they take control of the entire market.
 
Its the government's job to suck the money out of the richest companies they can find like a parasite.
 
They doen't like the competition.

Only the government is allowd to be a dominant behemoth.....
 
Why is everyone screaming like illiterate children about this? She said it might be a problem, not that they were bringing in the bulldozers now. Antitrust policies are there to stop abuse, not success.

Seriously, after hearing everyone rationally and logically scream about the banks being too big to fail and how that shouldn't ever be the case, seeing you guys whine about this is a joke.

We *might* see a problem with google? "Potentially?"

Speculate much there chief?
Why not keep your mouth shut until you have some actual evidence of wrongdoing.

"Coming from Varney, it was a particularly damning comparison. As an attorney who represented Netscape in the late 1990s, she was instrumental in painting Bill Gates and company as overeager bullies. Now, Varney was suggesting that Google was repeating Microsoft's expansionist behavior."

I'd say her mouth being open is far more relevant than yours. (in more ways than one... zing!)

:rolleyes:

Professional people sound moronic when they try to use "cool" language. I'd like to know what kind of threat Google is to anyone. Is it the SPAM filled boards of Google Finance? Is Android going to make us give up our BlackBerrys and iPhones? Is Chrome taking over? Is Google going to drive all of the other search engines out of business? I could go on all day.

MS had far more market dominance in its OS and office suite than Google has with ANYTHING. Hmmm, isn't MS still intact?

Here is the complaint. Googe is . .


That explains it all.
I see it now. "Must. . . use. . . Google. . ." :eek:

This is a great country we have. Company XYZ is innovating TOO MUCH. We must crush them before they take control of the entire market.

1. She wasn't using "cool" speak. Are you, like, 90 or something? Geeze! ;)
2. Google is huge and has a massive market share, so why would you act like they don't? Are we ignoring facts now, in order to be disingenuous?
3. ""If any of my colleagues or friends from Google are here," she said, "I invite you to jump up and scream and yell at me."

They doen't like the competition.

Only the government is allowd to be a dominant behemoth.....

Do you know what a monopoly is? And how it affects competition?

And

Do you know what a government is?

And for the kicker

Do you even what you are talking about?
 
Why is everyone screaming like illiterate children about this? She said it might be a problem, not that they were bringing in the bulldozers now. Antitrust policies are there to stop abuse, not success.
Because when policy makers talk, the market listens? People in positions of power shouldn't run their mouths off.

Seriously, after hearing everyone rationally and logically scream about the banks being too big to fail and how that shouldn't ever be the case, seeing you guys whine about this is a joke.
Those two things are vastly different.


"Coming from Varney, it was a particularly damning comparison. As an attorney who represented Netscape in the late 1990s, she was instrumental in painting Bill Gates and company as overeager bullies. Now, Varney was suggesting that Google was repeating Microsoft's expansionist behavior."

I'd say her mouth being open is far more relevant than yours. (in more ways than one... zing!)
She has a history of going after big companies. I call that a chip on your shoulder, not automatic legitimacy.


2. Google is huge and has a massive market share, so why would you act like they don't? Are we ignoring facts now, in order to be disingenuous?
3. ""If any of my colleagues or friends from Google are here," she said, "I invite you to jump up and scream and yell at me."
What facts? That high percentage of market share = automatic target in the eyes of the goverment? Must be evil doers to be so sucessful!

Do you know what a monopoly is? And how it affects competition?
ATT&T in the 70's = yes
Google now = no

Do you know what a government is?
The goverments job is to raise taxes and fuck up everything they touch.

And for the kicker

Do you even what you are talking about?
Yes, thanks.
 
The goverments job is to raise taxes and fuck up everything they touch.

You forgot goverments job is also to create bureaucracies and GROW...


To quote Thomas Paine:
Government, even in its best state, is but a necessary evil; in its worst state, an intolerable one.
 
Do you know what a monopoly is? And how it affects competition?
Do you know what a government is?
And for the kicker
Do you even what you are talking about?

Do YOU know what you are talking about?

The problem with monopolies that that you have no choice but to buy thier products due to a lack of competition. The monopoly can then raise it's prices and rack in the bucks.
If I don't like Microsoft, there are alternatives such as Apple or Linux. If I don't like the high federal taxes (or spying, or drug laws, etc), there's not much I can do unless I want to leave the country.

One of the reasons our founders created a limited the federal government, was to allow competition between the states. If you didn't like the law/taxes in one state, you could just move.

The federal government has now grown so large and so intrusive, that the difference between the states has been greatly marginalized.
 
Do you know what a monopoly is? And how it affects competition?

Sure, its when you own all the colors on one side of the board. Which you can then build houses and hotels on, which gives you a better chance of winning. Duh!
 
really google?
HOW ABOUT FUCKING A T AND FUCKIGN T or i dont know THE RIAA AND MPAA FFS
 
I'm surprised the government doesn't just sue Google to help fund corporate welfare for other companies.

Change Corporate America can believe in.

and ATT and the other telcoms PLUS **AA's still get a free ride
 
oh last post
three letters

IBM

yea... thats what i thought
Google just has a product people want some one will come along with some thing better and people will move on
 
I think Google is worth keeping an eye on, especially with the new Chrome OS which is shaping up to be a total Google ecosystem (Google OS, Google Software, Google Web Browser, Google Cloud Services, etc.). However, for the time being, Google hasn't done anything wrong, except innovate so much that they can't help but be the biggest and best.

Now, as soon as Google starts acting like the 1990s-era Microsoft, yeah, time to bring the hammer down. Until then, I think the antitrust guys need to STFU and GTFO.
 
1. She wasn't using "cool" speak. Are you, like, 90 or something? Geeze! ;)
2. Google is huge and has a massive market share, so why would you act like they don't? Are we ignoring facts now, in order to be disingenuous?
3. ""If any of my colleagues or friends from Google are here," she said, "I invite you to jump up and scream and yell at me."

[/QUOTE]

No, I'm not 90. I am 35, and when I am at work I use intelligent language so that others will take me seriously. I have been in many meetings where individuals thought it would be a good idea to use language such as this. I also watched their credibility go down afterwards. Of course politics and business are not the same thing.

I did a quick search and found the following.
Google's search engine market share for June 2009 was 81.22% it has moved less than half a percent since November 2008.
MS Windows market share is over 88% as of February 2009. It had over 90% market share months earlier.
So why is MS no longer a threat, and instead, we have to go after Google?

Inviting people to jump up and scream and yell is not professional. Nor, does doing it or not doing it prove anything. Nor would Google appreciate its employees doing so.

We went through this with MS. It just wasted a lot of tax payer dollars, everyone's time, and accomplished nothing measurable.

MS was visible, Google is visible. That is why we are hearing this.

Why didn't we ever hear about that evil monopoly Cisco had in the 90's? They pretty much were the Internet for a long time. Now they are just a major player. No one had to go bust them up. The market took care of that on its own. Their market share was astronomical. Their stock went up over 120000% from 1990 to 2000. Microsoft only went up 95000% over the same period. Even if you take MSFT all the way back to its IPO it can't match that.

Google is still growing. They will settle down, and the market will take care of itself.
 
Google does more to promote competition than any other company its size. I doubt they are going to find themselves in trouble.
 
Because when policy makers talk, the market listens? People in positions of power shouldn't run their mouths off.
You're going to need to explain that because, while it may somehow make sense in your head, to everyone else it sounds like ramblings of an ignorant fool. Elaboration avoids things like this. So, now, how does "the market listen"?

Those two things are vastly different.
How so? Are you saying the internet industry cannot contain monopolies that can potentially be abusive or limit competition?

She has a history of going after big companies. I call that a chip on your shoulder, not automatic legitimacy.
You mean like Microsoft, the company you admit was a monopoly?

What facts? That high percentage of market share = automatic target in the eyes of the goverment? Must be evil doers to be so sucessful!
Well its a good fucking thing that she isn't doing anything to them yet, isn't it?



I'm not even sure why you responded to these next ones, which weren't even directed at you, in such a manner because it just showed how blatantly ignorant yo are:
ATT&T in the 70's = yes
Google now = no
Who said Google was? Voices in your head? Might want to get that checked out.

The goverments job is to raise taxes and fuck up everything they touch.
You shouldn't be complaining if that is what they are here for.

Yes, thanks.
Uhhh... no problem, though, not only was I not addressing you, you are also amazingly wrong.

Do YOU know what you are talking about?

The problem with monopolies that that you have no choice but to buy thier products due to a lack of competition. The monopoly can then raise it's prices and rack in the bucks.
If I don't like Microsoft, there are alternatives such as Apple or Linux. If I don't like the high federal taxes (or spying, or drug laws, etc), there's not much I can do unless I want to leave the country.

One of the reasons our founders created a limited the federal government, was to allow competition between the states. If you didn't like the law/taxes in one state, you could just move.

The federal government has now grown so large and so intrusive, that the difference between the states has been greatly marginalized.

Ok, you don't know what you are talking about apparently, because you completely failed to answer the questions I actually typed. You even worked the "if you don't like it, you can move" redneck slogan into it. Haha....

Sure, its when you own all the colors on one side of the board. Which you can then build houses and hotels on, which gives you a better chance of winning. Duh!

Sad thing is people grew up knowing this game and how it works, yet still scoff at the idea of a "monopoly" being a bad thing, especially if you even think about observing a large company who may become one.

I think Google is worth keeping an eye on, especially with the new Chrome OS which is shaping up to be a total Google ecosystem (Google OS, Google Software, Google Web Browser, Google Cloud Services, etc.). However, for the time being, Google hasn't done anything wrong, except innovate so much that they can't help but be the biggest and best.

Now, as soon as Google starts acting like the 1990s-era Microsoft, yeah, time to bring the hammer down. Until then, I think the antitrust guys need to STFU and GTFO.

Quoted for logic and reason.

No, I'm not 90. I am 35, and when I am at work I use intelligent language so that others will take me seriously. I have been in many meetings where individuals thought it would be a good idea to use language such as this. I also watched their credibility go down afterwards. Of course politics and business are not the same thing.

Nigguh she da top spot she don't gotta show no pretend, whack ass, pseudo intelligence that you are trying to portray here or at your job. Business is full of pretentious, presumptive, and posturing snobs in superficial attempts either impress or intimidate their way into promotions or product deals. Government is full of the same. However, she doesn't have to deal with that superficial shit, because she is at the very top already and has jobs for life, having served during Obama in sucha prestigious position.

I did a quick search and found the following.
Google's search engine market share for June 2009 was 81.22% it has moved less than half a percent since November 2008.
MS Windows market share is over 88% as of February 2009. It had over 90% market share months earlier.
So why is MS no longer a threat, and instead, we have to go after Google?
Congratulations, you don't know what makes a monopoly dangerous. Hint: Its not their %, its their actions and influence in the market, with regards to competition.

Inviting people to jump up and scream and yell is not professional. Nor, does doing it or not doing it prove anything. Nor would Google appreciate its employees doing so.
She isn't pandering to anybody, so I seriously doubt she gives a fuck about how people are expected to act as employees or professionals. We have had enough bullshit from politicians and DC, yet you still want them to be fake about everything? Get off of your pretentious high horse.

We went through this with MS. It just wasted a lot of tax payer dollars, everyone's time, and accomplished nothing measurable.
Spoken like someone who has no understanding of those times. :rolleyes: and, what about that "trickle down" "theory" rofl....

MS was visible, Google is visible. That is why we are hearing this.
It couldn't be the fact that Google is setting themselves up to be in a position of commanding complete dependence in the future, no sirrreeeee!!

Why didn't we ever hear about that evil monopoly Cisco had in the 90's? They pretty much were the Internet for a long time. Now they are just a major player. No one had to go bust them up. The market took care of that on its own. Their market share was astronomical. Their stock went up over 120000% from 1990 to 2000. Microsoft only went up 95000% over the same period. Even if you take MSFT all the way back to its IPO it can't match that.
If the market took care of it, then there was no need for antitrust actions, now were there? What was your point again?

Google is still growing. They will settle down, and the market will take care of itself.
I'm glad you think that, Internet User #25871523. Unfortunately for you, someone who actually has vast amounts of experience in this kind of thing thinks otherwise and has the brains to actually keep an eye on things. Unlike you, intelligent people understand that this vague notion of the "INVISIBLE HANNNNDDDD" that is supposed to regulate a free market DOES NOT EXIST.
 
What are these so called innovations Google has brought us? They brought a marginally superior search engine that caught on like wildfire and have since grown into an enormously successful corporation. Since then they've used their newfound resources in such a manner that they are dabbling their hands all over and spitting out things that have been around for years and just slapping on a "bright new" interface on it, or tossing together half-assed chunks of software that people give a pass because it's Google.
 
What are these so called innovations Google has brought us? They brought a marginally superior search engine that caught on like wildfire and have since grown into an enormously successful corporation. Since then they've used their newfound resources in such a manner that they are dabbling their hands all over and spitting out things that have been around for years and just slapping on a "bright new" interface on it, or tossing together half-assed chunks of software that people give a pass because it's Google.

oh yea and its free thats kinda the big one
when its free it doesnt need to be perfect
 
I never said they needed to be perfect.. I was merely pointing out that they put out half-concocted software or stuff that's been around for years and they slap on a new look/ feel to it. Yet it never seems to fail that someone calls this "innovation".
 
I'm all for this. Really, in the last decade MS hasn't done much, yet they continue to take the media beating. Somehow, the public has the perception that Google can do no wrong, and it's about time someone pointed out that that's simply not the case.

I feel quite the same. But I think also Google has been playing fair and all what they've done have been quite beneficial, for us internet users. I could not complain or accuse about anything really, only big buyouts maybe, even if that.. I'm not even paying anything for them..
 
You're going to need to explain that because, while it may somehow make sense in your head, to everyone else it sounds like ramblings of an ignorant fool. Elaboration avoids things like this. So, now, how does "the market listen"?
Oh hai, im a big company looking to do business with google, but oh wait, the federal government is about to bend them over. "We dont like the googles, they are too big". Guess ill take my business elsewhere.

Anyone who has spent ANY time in the stock market knows public perception is VERY important. A person of her status and position shouldn't say anything deningrating about a company unless she has evidence. Get it now? She opens her mouth, Googles business could suffer. Its called SLANDER.

How so? Are you saying the internet industry cannot contain monopolies that can potentially be abusive or limit competition?
Who said it wasn't possible? not me. Im just saying have edvidence before making public accusations.


You mean like Microsoft, the company you admit was a monopoly?
MS is not a monoply. Plenty of OS choices out there. Powerful, yes. Dominant player in certain markets, yes. Monopoly? NO. Did MS in the 90's abuse their position? Sometimes yes, and they got their shorts snapped for it. NOT a monopoly however. In the 60's and 70's if you wanted a telephone, you HAD to buy an ATT phone, and pay ATT service, PERIOD. That is a monopoly.


Well its a good fucking thing that she isn't doing anything to them yet, isn't it?
Other than making baseless accusations and tarnishing thier image? Yeah, no damage there. How about someone of her stature accuse you of being a child molester with no evidence. I wonder how your neighbors would react? Baby raper.


I'm not even sure why you responded to these next ones, which weren't even directed at you, in such a manner because it just showed how blatantly ignorant yo are:
Because they were stupid comments and I felt like responding to them. I dont need your permission.
 
The next person to act like an idiot gets banned for a month. I dare you.
 
No, it's pointing out your insulting other forum members and getting obnoxiously defensive over a woman you've never met.

+1

This conversation broke down fast. I'm not even interested in responding to posts filled with profanity. I thought there might be an intelligent conversation to be had here. I guess not. :(
 
Personally, I think the fact that this person in power gunning for Google is just another shot in the dark, taking aim as something that's successful. It's a sad state of affairs when any one or any thing happens to be successful and then there's the "Oh fuck, they HAVE to be doing something wrong/illegal... there's just no way they can be that successful without screwing people over... we'll dig forever till we find some dirt, and if we don't, then we'll manufacture it..."

Or words (and potential actions) to that effect.

Sad day indeed.
 
I think Google is worth keeping an eye on, especially with the new Chrome OS which is shaping up to be a total Google ecosystem (Google OS, Google Software, Google Web Browser, Google Cloud Services, etc.). However, for the time being, Google hasn't done anything wrong, except innovate so much that they can't help but be the biggest and best.

Now, as soon as Google starts acting like the 1990s-era Microsoft, yeah, time to bring the hammer down. Until then, I think the antitrust guys need to STFU and GTFO.

Meh, Apple and Microsoft does the same thing with their operating systems. Their own browser, media player, apps, and so on.

I've always found it amusing how Microsoft got singled out for this.
 
Oh hai, im a big company looking to do business with google, but oh wait, the federal government is about to bend them over. "We dont like the googles, they are too big". Guess ill take my business elsewhere.

Anyone who has spent ANY time in the stock market knows public perception is VERY important. A person of her status and position shouldn't say anything deningrating about a company unless she has evidence. Get it now? She opens her mouth, Googles business could suffer. Its called SLANDER.
Saying a company is getting large and on the verge of becoming a possible monopoly is not slander. Google has started doing more and more questionable things and is losing its "Do no evil" image.

There is absolutely nothing wrong with keeping an eye on them. There is especially no grounds for crying about public comments made by her about Google based on some vague idea that people won't want Google's vast treasure troves of money because the government was keeping an eye on them, because even if that were to happen, scaring away people who are afraid of antitrust problems is probably a good thing. However, that is unlikely going to be the case because money talks in business and money is what Google has. Going by your logic, with Microsoft having actually been hit hard and fined multiple times by various contries, you'd think no one would be doing business with them. Not only that, the government should not be doing things based on the outcome of stock prices. Business and shareholders are already obsessed enough about short term stock prices as it is, which is what led to the complete collapse in the financial and housing industries.

The Government is already on a short enough leash for corporations as it is, so I have no pity for any corporation when someone says, "bu... bu... but.... stock prices :( ", when all we are talking about is talks of keeping an eye on them and nothing about filing charges or anything of that sort.

Who said it wasn't possible? not me. Im just saying have edvidence before making public accusations.

Ahem...
"They are not the problem. I think we are going to continually see a problem, potentially, with Google."
Instead of dominating the desktop, Varney said, Google was starting to colonize the emerging cloud-computing industry, amassing "enormous market power" and potentially creating an ecosystem that customers would be powerless to escape.
For much of its history, Google has responded to most criticism with two words: Trust us.

No one has accused them of having a monopoly that needs to be taken care of. They have been said to be possibly on track to become a problem and simply require observation and notice.


MS is not a monoply. Plenty of OS choices out there. Powerful, yes. Dominant player in certain markets, yes. Monopoly? NO.
Yes, I know that it is 2009
Did MS in the 90's abuse their position? Sometimes yes, and they got their shorts snapped for it. NOT a monopoly however.
A fine example of cognitive dissonance.
In the 60's and 70's if you wanted a telephone, you HAD to buy an ATT phone, and pay ATT service, PERIOD. That is a monopoly
You are right, that was a very extreme example of a monopoly.

Other than making baseless accusations and tarnishing thier image? Yeah, no damage there. How about someone of her stature accuse you of being a child molester with no evidence. I wonder how your neighbors would react? Baby raper.
You are making up accusation about google. Varney, the "antitrust cop", said they need to be watched, not gone after. The only person making baseless accusations here is you.

Because they were stupid comments and I felt like responding to them. I dont need your permission.
I'm a big kid now!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top