To Reformat or not?

la_guy

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 18, 2010
Messages
194
I am building a new rig and was wondering if I should reformat to avoid stability problems. I am coming from a Core to duo on an Asus P5B deluxe to a Sandy Bridge build.

Also how should I approach this reformat? I was thinking of building everything out then install my fresh copy of Windows 7 and just update all drivers from there.
 
When you install a new MB, fresh install of Windows (recommend), or at the very least, upgrade OS option.
 
Build your system, boot to the Windows 7 install disc. You can format the partition from the disc. Then install Windows a voila. Windows 7 should find all the drivers for you, but I would install the updated graphics card drivers.
 
i'd recommend reformatting as well, last time I changed my mobo, even MS office asked me to re activate, such a pain in the ass to deal with.
 
I also believe it's always best to reformat/reinstall. At the very least it gives you an excuse to start everything fresh and remove all the unnecessary clutter/programs.

That said, I moved from a P5Q-E (C2Q) to an SB P8P67 Pro, didn't do a reinstall and everything's good so far (2 weeks now). Have used it everyday, played games and did some photo and video editing. I did have to install the drivers and reactivate my Windows 7 license. I chose not to reinstall as I saw someone else say in the forum they didn't have an issue and wanted to try it as I just did a fresh reinstall a few weeks ago when I moved to an SSD (which by the way is awesome).
 
I am building a new rig and was wondering if I should reformat to avoid stability problems. I am coming from a Core to duo on an Asus P5B deluxe to a Sandy Bridge build.

Also how should I approach this reformat? I was thinking of building everything out then install my fresh copy of Windows 7 and just update all drivers from there.

Windows 7 doesn't need a reformat. It's actually smart enough to remove all the old devices and reinstall everything; all you need to do is to install the chipset drivers and USB 3.0, and whatever. It may need a few reboots to act properly again, and then it will bitch at you about activation "needed now" (obviously).

Windows XP, unless you used a cloning program to store the data and then wipe the hardware HAL (the best way), you need to do a repair install. My repair install went fine.
 
If you have the disk and key, then format and reinstall. IMO, it is always better to start fresh with a new build.
 
I jujst went from an AMD Phenom 955/nforce 750a motherboard to an Intel 2500K/Asus P67 chipset motherboard and Windows 7 x64 adjusted fine to the change. Prior to switching I uninstalled the video, sound, network and chipset drivers. I did have to call mIcrosoft to re-activate but Win 7 has had no issues so far. Not sure I will bother to reinstall now. BTW- I am really impressed with the 2500K- haven't had an Intel chip for years and the system seems a lot snappier then with the Phenom 955.
 
As long as you are staying on the same platform (InteL to Intel) and using Win 7, there is no pressing need to re-install. It never hurts, but isn't a requirement the way it kinda sorta used to be.
 
la_guy
[H]Lite

100% Full Clean installation with the updated installation of all core drivers.

Currently we are seeing many users not perform a clean installation and run into considerable issues because of this. This is due to the assumption that because the OS works nothing else needs to be installed such oversights like this lead to the ME driver not being installed or incorrect RST driver for the PCH being present and not ensuring correct single drive or raid array performance.
So again to clarify we would definitely advise that you complete a full installation. Additionally if you are reusing an SSD I also strongly advise a full cleaning of the disk prior to the partition and format to ensure performance is where it should be.
Hope this helps. Please enjoy the rest of your day.
 
Thanks everyone I will build it out then do a clean install of Windows 7.
 
WIn7 can handle it in a pinch, but yeah the right way is a reformat.
 
I don't buy the advice that one must reinstall Win7 after a mobo/proc upgrade. I just moved from a p35 to a p67 (p8p67 pro) with an SSD and all went well. I managed to avoid a lot of the problems I hear about here. It did take a while to ensure that all devices were recognized in the control panel, but some of that was just getting all the drivers straight.

Some installations of Windows are more complex than others. Lots of software to reinstall and settings to redo. And if you use an SSD, you may wish to play around with storing some things on another drive (like email). which brings additional work. Perhaps if your system is for gaming primarily, a reinstall is the best bet, but mainly because it might be is simpler (or not). Some people have time constraints.

And of course no one can prove that a re-installation is required. It's just conservative wisdom. Has anyone actually studied this for Windows 7? Any links on some of the tester websites? And besides, if you do find it doesn't work, it's pretty easy to just do it over a again, assuming you have backups.
 
Last edited:
I'd format and reinstall after a MB upgrade. Just feels right... although you maybe able to get away with it. I think I was able to get away with it once on vista, but then it just wasnt working as good in my eyes.
 
I'd feel dirty if I didn't format. But, I format roughly every 6 months anyways so (old habit)...

As far as I know, you don't have to format and a simple Startup Repair might suffice but I have never tried it myself.
 
I just upgraded from a Foxconn X38a mobo, Q6600 CPU and 4 GB ram to a new sandybridge system with a Foxconn P67A-S mobo, i2500K cpu and 8GB ram. As a test I decided not to reformat, just took out the old and put in the new and started up. It worked perfectly. Just one reboot after installing the chipset drivers.

Everything seems to fine. Games all work great, any stress test has went without a hitch. It's been a whole week now and no issues of any kind. Really am very happy with how quick and easy windows 7 has made a mobo switch :)
 
I just upgraded from a Foxconn X38a mobo, Q6600 CPU and 4 GB ram to a new sandybridge system with a Foxconn P67A-S mobo, i2500K cpu and 8GB ram. As a test I decided not to reformat, just took out the old and put in the new and started up. It worked perfectly. Just one reboot after installing the chipset drivers.

Everything seems to fine. Games all work great, any stress test has went without a hitch. It's been a whole week now and no issues of any kind. Really am very happy with how quick and easy windows 7 has made a mobo switch :)

That's good to hear. I'll be upgrading soon from an X38 to a P67 too soon. Did you at least have to reactivate Windows? I assume it revalidated without requiring the call to MS.
 
That's good to hear. I'll be upgrading soon from an X38 to a P67 too soon. Did you at least have to reactivate Windows? I assume it revalidated without requiring the call to MS.

Yeah, I had to reactivate windows, but I didn't have to make any call to MS. So you assumed correctly :)
 
Back
Top