Hi All,
I've got an ASUS DSBF-D12/SAS that I've been using the onboard LSI1068 SAS/SATA RAID Controller with two WD Black 500GB [WD5001AALS] and two WD Black 1TB [WD1001FALS] hard drives in two RAID1 arrays with Linux. I've also got two WD Green 1TB [WD10EACS] drives that are set has hot spares for the 1TB mirror since the LSI1068 can't do more than two arrays. I'm starting to run out of space on my 1TB RAID1 array [the /home partition] and am looking at ways of getting more space on this server somewhat cheaply. I have a few questions or request for comments on some potential "upgrade" scenarios.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Get a better RAID Controller that would be able to turn all four 1TB WD drives into a RAID5 array thus giving me 3TB of space with a hot spare.
I am leery about mixing the Black and Green drives for obvious performance reasons, and especially after reading other posts about WD and their turning off TLER for their consumer level drives. Although these drives were manufactered before mid 2009, so I think it wouldn't be so much of a problem.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Don't use the LSI1068 controller for the RAID1 on the 1TB drives and use Linux software RAID for the 4 x 1TB drives.
Performance might still be an issue, but taking the RAID controller out of the mix to alleviate the TLER situation might be better in the long run. My only problem though is that even though I'm very familiar with Linux, I've never setup a RAID array in Linux and aren't entirely certain of the ins and outs of doing this [How to expand a RAID array? What if a drive goes bad? Etc].
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Buy 2 x 2TB drives and use the LSI1068 to make a RAID1 array out of them.
This is where I have issues because of the TLER problem that rears it's head when it comes to consumer level hardware being used in RAID. I've read that the Hitachi 2TB drives seem to fare well in these situations, but I've only really ever known WD drives.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And just to clarify, this system is just a file sharing server that I'd like to have some redundancy built in with an eventual plan for data backup to external drives someday.
I'd like to keep this cheap, but if there are compelling reasons for going one way or another, I'd really like to hear them.
I've got an ASUS DSBF-D12/SAS that I've been using the onboard LSI1068 SAS/SATA RAID Controller with two WD Black 500GB [WD5001AALS] and two WD Black 1TB [WD1001FALS] hard drives in two RAID1 arrays with Linux. I've also got two WD Green 1TB [WD10EACS] drives that are set has hot spares for the 1TB mirror since the LSI1068 can't do more than two arrays. I'm starting to run out of space on my 1TB RAID1 array [the /home partition] and am looking at ways of getting more space on this server somewhat cheaply. I have a few questions or request for comments on some potential "upgrade" scenarios.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Get a better RAID Controller that would be able to turn all four 1TB WD drives into a RAID5 array thus giving me 3TB of space with a hot spare.
I am leery about mixing the Black and Green drives for obvious performance reasons, and especially after reading other posts about WD and their turning off TLER for their consumer level drives. Although these drives were manufactered before mid 2009, so I think it wouldn't be so much of a problem.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. Don't use the LSI1068 controller for the RAID1 on the 1TB drives and use Linux software RAID for the 4 x 1TB drives.
Performance might still be an issue, but taking the RAID controller out of the mix to alleviate the TLER situation might be better in the long run. My only problem though is that even though I'm very familiar with Linux, I've never setup a RAID array in Linux and aren't entirely certain of the ins and outs of doing this [How to expand a RAID array? What if a drive goes bad? Etc].
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3. Buy 2 x 2TB drives and use the LSI1068 to make a RAID1 array out of them.
This is where I have issues because of the TLER problem that rears it's head when it comes to consumer level hardware being used in RAID. I've read that the Hitachi 2TB drives seem to fare well in these situations, but I've only really ever known WD drives.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
And just to clarify, this system is just a file sharing server that I'd like to have some redundancy built in with an eventual plan for data backup to external drives someday.
I'd like to keep this cheap, but if there are compelling reasons for going one way or another, I'd really like to hear them.