To EO or not to EO, that is the question

Louis

n00b
Joined
Dec 28, 2004
Messages
14
I’ve decided to put together an Intel rig on a 775 socket instead of AMD 939. This machine will be optimized for Digital photography / Photoshop. I really don’t care about games. I want maximum performance within my budget ($1,500 or less without a monitor) and I do want to overclock. I’m planning on water-cooling.

I’ve researched the various Intel CPUs that are available and the confusion is enough to make me go back to AMD. :)

Here is what I think I know about available Intel processors. Of the Intel chips that are currently available, these features seem to be considered most important based on what I’ve read:

- Everybody says get the CPUs with the “J.” These include EO stepping for reduced thermal load and other related features.
- Thermal design power of 84W instead of 115w
- Drop multiplier for overclocking to reduce stress on the system and get more headroom.
- Retail verses OEM for extended warranty

It seems impossible to get all these features in the same chip.

Option 1: My first choice has been to get a 3.4 (550J). They are at a good price point although they seem to be rather scarce right now. You can get this CPU with EO, 84W, retail but does not include the drop multiplier feature. To get the drop multiplier feature I’d have to go with a DO version and loose the EO.

Option 2: If EO feature is important, and as there are no EO Intel CPUs below 3.6 that you can drop the multiplier, then I’ll need to get a 3.6 (560J). They don’t cost that much more than the 3.4 (550J) and they are more available, at least right now. But … there is always a but … the 560Js that include the “drop multiplier” don’t appear to be available in a retail version; just OEM. I prefer retail for the warranty but I suppose I could risk it. I also haven’t seen any of the OEM versions listed online.

So help me understand what is really important here. The biggest holdup seems to be the drop multiplier. How important is this really? Maybe I’m just better off buying faster ram and not worry about it. I was considering the new PDP Patriot PDC22G4200 XBLK matching 1 GB sticks.

Thanks!

Louis
 
Just pop over to zipzoomfly.com and pick up a 530J (3Ghz) for $196 w/free 2 day shipping if you're looking for a cheaper J/E0 processor than the 550J.

And as for the memory don't worry about it unless you're really craving low timings cause most any run-of-the-mill ddr2 right now will run 1:1 as high as the front side bus on any of the current motherboards will go so you really don't need the extra bandwith. Just get the cheapest reliable stuff you can get (corsair, kingston, a-data, etc.).

Hope that helps.
 
I don't see the need for an extreemly fast processor in your case. If you want to deal with photoshop a fast processor is nice but what you really need is lots of ram. loading lots of big uncompressed images takes up a lot of ram. If this is what the computer is built for, and with your budget, I would not settle for under a gig. Processing power is only needed in photoshop when doing a lot (and I mean a lot) of dynamic actions, like, for instance, usign a tablet and doing a lot of digital painting on a large image. Even then, ram is still the most important. If you are going to be moving files around a lot think about getting a 10K drive as a scratch disk.

Take it this way- I use Photoshop CS on a daily basis (I work as an artist for a photography studio) and I deal with very large files... anywheres from 6-8 megapixels... and I usually have 5 to 6 of these files open at any given time on the desktop of my 1ghz eMac and it does just fine. Never witness any slowdown. Nowdays clock speed really doesn't mean much. You might even want to consider going the AMD 64-bit route as I would think that the increased memory pipeline would allow faster times in Photoshop.. Check some benchmarks (Maximum PC always does a Photoshop test with their processor benchmarks).

But seriously... I work with huge files here at home on my Athlon 2000+ (running at 1.775ghz, up about 100mhz) and 512MB of ram adn I seriously do not need anything more, even for images that are upwars of 20-30 inches at 300 DPI.

Maybe save some money and go for Dual monitors or a nice Apple Cinema display. Dual monitors can help immensly in photoshop as you can have all your tools and such laid out all the time. It is a good investment if you are dealing with lots of windows or near-fullscreen windwos alot. It saves a lot of time. And a good display can really improve your experience. Just use an Apple HD Cinema display for a little bit after using a crappy old CRT for a long time.

Hope I helped.
 
Vegeta,

Thanks for the reply. Here is the total system I'm considering. Sounds like it may be overkill for photoshop based on what you say and it is over budget.

Intel 560J
ASUS P5AD2-E Premium
PDP Patriot PDC22G4200 XBLK - dual 1 gig sticks
2 - 300 g Maxtor III SATA drives
Antec SLK3000B case
ATI 800XL graphic card - When they become available
500 watt powersupply

Louis
 
Back
Top