TMG vs. Squid

six_storm

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Mar 29, 2005
Messages
1,251
I am an IT instructor at a trade school and am going to be implementing a transparent proxy/Internet caching (accelerator) device for our network. Our current bandwidth is 3u/3d (bonded T1s) and with 30 faculty + 100 students constantly using it, things can get a little slow. Yes, yes, I'm working on getting this changed ;) , but until then I must come up with a better solution to block items like streaming media and torrent/P2P downloads, cut down on the harmful/time wasting sites (Facebook, Pirate Bay, etc) and hopefully boost some of our Internet speeds in the process.

I have not implemented either solution for these reasons before so bare with me.

After doing some research, I'm seeing a lot of love and hate for both Squid and ForeFront TMG, and wanted to see what the community thought about the two. Either one better than the other? I will be using my class alone (26 students) as a guinea pig test before implementing it to the rest of the network.

Does it come down to a Windows vs. Linux decision? Fairly easy to manage for the reasons mentioned above?
 
I use TMG, easy to setup and admin, super easy to setup blocking lists. Apparently MS has no plans to continue development in this field though so don't expect any upgrades anytime soon. Which means no IPv6 support. Other than IPv6 you'd probably be good for a long time with it so long as they keep the lists updated.
 
I enjoyed being an admin on TMG. Sad to hear MS isn't going to continue down the path.
 
Have you looked into something like an Untangle or Barracuda appliance?
 
Check out untangle. We use squid as our work proxy but I don't really have too much experience with actually managing it yet.
 
Squid is a great proxy but isn't the easiest to configure and you'll still need things like a packet shaper to prioritize traffic.
 
Untangle users, can you specify times for blocking certain website categories? For example, I want to only allow Facebook.com during breaks, not during study time.

Pricing doesn't look too bad, but I'll definitely be putting it through some thorough test this week.
 
I tried to install Untangle today with 2 different CDs but it kept rebooting itself. Installed Ubuntu and it worked like normal. Installed Server 08 and am working on getting TMG installed. Not sure what happened.

I have some new workstations coming in soon for lab purposes, so I'll try Untangle again next week.

Now is the fun part of configuring TMG to be a transparent proxy and started blocking stuff! :)
 
I tried to install Untangle today with 2 different CDs but it kept rebooting itself. Installed Ubuntu and it worked like normal. Installed Server 08 and am working on getting TMG installed. Not sure what happened.

I have some new workstations coming in soon for lab purposes, so I'll try Untangle again next week.

Now is the fun part of configuring TMG to be a transparent proxy and started blocking stuff! :)

enjoy!
 
It pretty much boots up the first time as a transperent proxy and might even come with some default blocking rules, I forget exactly it's been a while (I have 2 rules in mine called "Blocked Web Destinations" and "Allow Web Access for All Users" I'm fairly sure those are the default rules it came with because there's no way I'd have given them those names). After that it's setting up any specific rules you need, the specificer the better.
 
It pretty much boots up the first time as a transperent proxy and might even come with some default blocking rules, I forget exactly it's been a while (I have 2 rules in mine called "Blocked Web Destinations" and "Allow Web Access for All Users" I'm fairly sure those are the default rules it came with because there's no way I'd have given them those names). After that it's setting up any specific rules you need, the specificer the better.

I have to confess that I'm certified for ISA 2006 but I don't remember jack about it (2009). From what I do remember, it's completely locked down out of the box, then you whitelist your policies and such. I'll be messing with this stuff all day today and hope to roll it out to my classroom by the end of today.
 
Last time i looked at caching, I found a lot of sites were dynamic and said not to cache.
Also squid wouldnt cache youtube etc, had to buy some addon.

Still doesnt cost much to implement, and a school 'needs' to have something doing access control.
 
The main problem I have with TMG is it's absurd memory requirements... I ran it for like a year with "only" 4GB but if I leave dynamic memory uncapped it balloons to like 8GB.
 
After about two days of thorough testing, TMG is not turning out to be a viable option for our class, much less our entire school for web filtering. Using TMG as a gateway had some mixed results as some firewall rules were not properly being used, while using it as a web proxy worked for the most part.

I'm trying Untangle again starting next week and maybe even Squid if UT doesn't work.

If none of these work, I'm just going to replace these horrible Fireboxes with a Fortigate and use the built-in web filtering for the school.
 
Check out Untangle's content filtering as well. This whole project you're talking about screams for an all-in-one solution.
 
Sonicwall has a wicked cf, why no try one of those ?

Let us know how untangle works out, see if we can assist you !
 
Check out Untangle's content filtering as well. This whole project you're talking about screams for an all-in-one solution.

I totally agree; an all-in-one is what I've been looking for.

So I found out what was wrong with my first Untangle install. I installed 32-bit the first time but it kept randomly rebooting on me. Once I downloaded 64-bit, everything appears to work fine. I haven't done any testing on this yet, but I plan on doing so on Monday.
 
Back
Top