Time for new product names?

Should the "Radeon" and "GeForce" brands be retired?

  • No! Keep them both!

    Votes: 24 44.4%
  • Keep "Radeon", replace "GeForce"

    Votes: 2 3.7%
  • Keep "GeForce", replace "Radeon"

    Votes: 3 5.6%
  • Yes! New names for both!

    Votes: 25 46.3%

  • Total voters
    54

Mohonri

Supreme [H]ardness
2FA
Joined
Jul 29, 2005
Messages
5,775
At the risk of getting myself flamed to a crisp by both the red and green sides here, I want to pose this question:

Are the names "Radeon" and "GeForce" getting long in the tooth?

Over in the AMD forum, there seems to be a general consensus that the "Athlon" (at least 6 generations of chips) and "Pentium" (8 generations) brands are old and busted and need to be retired in favor of new names. Do you think the same is true for "Radeon" and "GeForce"? GeForce, for example, has gone through at least seven generations.

Please vote and comment!
(but please don't flame me!) :eek:
 
radeon and geforce can stay. They need to get rid of 88xxx and x1xxxxgtxtixixi etc. how about keeping this like pro
 
What are we gonna do about the GeForce 9800 :O


In all honesty... the phrase, "No, I don't want one of these 'Core two duels' I want a Pentium 4. The 4 means it's faster"

Sums up why names shouldn't ever be changed.
 
I like the current names. Its the numbering system that needs to be changed. This 7600gt, 7600gs,etc gets annoying, i don't know which is better.
 
WarriorX said:
I like the current names. Its the numbering system that needs to be changed. This 7600gt, 7600gs,etc gets annoying, i don't know which is better.

what you just buy the thing with the biggest numbers and most letters :D
 
Its enough for me that their company names remain the same. If Intel can change their Pentium line to Core Duo without a hitch surely same can be applied on GPU industry.

edit:

A brand name should go about 6 generations at the most. Radeon and Geforce do sound old and used.
 
Radeon and Geforce are perfect names. they just need to fix the numbering system. and go back to pro or non pro.
 
I've always been a bit perplexed by Radeon. GeForce makes sense, to me. But Radeon escapes me.

That said, I think the names should stay, but the numbering scheme has to go. NVIDIA's been a bit more consistent than ATI, but not much. When GeForce hits 10, what are they going to do? 10800? I doubt it. If they don't come up with a new number altogether, they'll have to change the numbering scheme. ATI too. After the Radeon X9000 series, what happens? X10K? I doubt that too.

I don't think anybody is going to confuse a GeForce 9800 and a Radeon 9800, since there will be plenty of time between them, assuming that the GeForce 9800 ever exists to begin with. I don't think NVIDIA will want to "contaminate" their branding like that.

Most people, including me, didn't think Intel would ever abandon the Pentium name. I didn't think they've have the decency to do it. But they did. And it has worked out well for them. ATI and NVIDIA could take a lesson from that.

Personally, I think that G80 would have been the perfect opportunity for a branding change. It is a radically different architecture, and even requires separate drivers.
 
I say get rid of number schemes and go back to cool names like Banshie and TNT with suffixes like pro or ultra. At least give us the impression that marketing can still be creative.
 
Arcygenical said:
Yeah... it should go xx00YYY where YYY:

GS
GT
GTS
GTX
ZOMG

in that order.

I second this. Recently it's been difficult for most who aren't actively looking at video cards all of the time to know which is which!
 
EQTakeOffense said:
I really like the GS/GT/GTS/GTX naming scheme.
I think I've gotten used to it. It is kinda funny if they ever decide to put something in front of the GTX... I think it would be going too far at that point

Well I guess does GX2 count?
 
Well I guess does GX2 count?

I think it should, but it's more of a niche product then anything else IMHO.

For any generation:

GS - Low End
GT - Entry Level
GTS - Buget Gamer
GTX - High End

They just need the generation name infront, and that's where I'm stuck at a lose. I think numbers are old, but I think names are alot harder to remember then numbers.

8800GTX Vs. Banshee GTX

Don't know... I just think names are alot more confusing then numbers. Since you know higher numbers are better, but... Numbers get very old and reptitive fast.
 
I think if they were going to change them, they should have done so for DX10...since the last time they changed was when T&L came out...
 
GeForce and Radeon can stay!

What we need less of is the horrible X-themed marketing. X1950XTX... are you serious? Three X's within the span of 8 characters? I love the way someone else on this forum put it: Imagine if XFX made an XTX... XFX X1900XTX XXX Edition.

I'm sorry, but the whole X stigma has had its 15 minutes for crying out loud! And you don't have to limit yourself to the graphics card market to see the spread of this pestilence!
 
Nihilanth99 said:
GeForce and Radeon can stay!

What we need less of is the horrible X-themed marketing. X1950XTX... are you serious? Three X's within the span of 8 characters? I love the way someone else on this forum put it: Imagine if XFX made an XTX... XFX X1900XTX XXX Edition.

I'm sorry, but the whole X stigma has had its 15 minutes for crying out loud! And you don't have to limit yourself to the graphics card market to see the spread of this pestilence!

rofl...XXX edition... :eek:
 
I'd almost go as far as slotting them by year as video card releases are starting to get.

Radeon 2007 Good
Radeon 2007 Better
Radeon 2007 Best
 
Oh, how I long for the days when there was just the GF Ti 4200, 4400, and 4600.....just three gaming cards. I'm sick of the alphabet soup. Not only do we get ?200's, ?300's, ?500's, ?550's, ?600's, ?650's, ?700's, ?800's, ?900's, and ?950's, we also get GS, GO, GT, GTS, GTX, GX2, Pro, yadayada OC, XT, XTX, and whatever else the card manufacturers come up with. Instead of tacking on stupid suffixes, can't we just increase the number?
 
Instead of tacking on stupid suffixes, can't we just increase the number?

But where do the numbers end? They could (in theory) go on for infinity, and what happens when we have...

GeForce ∞ GTX?

After that do you suppose:

GeForce ∞ + 1 GTX?
 
It sounds like the marketing crews need a refresh just like some video cards do.
I mean I guess the GT and GTX can be catchy... but isn't there something else?

LOL I found the XXX version to be top notch in my book ;)
 
EQTakeOffense said:
But where do the numbers end? They could (in theory) go on for infinity, and what happens when we have...

GeForce ∞ GTX?

After that do you suppose:

Gefore ∞ + 1 GTX?

TOO FUNNY :D
 
Yes, these number schemes need to be much clearer and more defining.

Case and point, a X1950Pro and X1950XT are VERY different. But how is the average joe supposed to know this?

Numbers should reflect the type of hardware configuration, whereas the suffixes should designate the clock speeds or RAM amounts.

For instance, a 8800GTX and 8800GTS are incorrect. It should be 8800 and 8700, because the processor itself is different, not just the clocks. A high-clocked card should have a GTX suffix while a lower clocked would have GT, and lowest GS. It makes more sense to differeniate model types this way. As it is, you really have to do alot of reading to know the differences between a 8800GTX or GTS.
 
Dayvon said:
For instance, a 8800GTX and 8800GTS are incorrect. It should be 8800 and 8700, because the processor itself is different, not just the clocks. A high-clocked card should have a GTX suffix while a lower clocked would have GT, and lowest GS. It makes more sense to differeniate model types this way. As it is, you really have to do alot of reading to know the differences between a 8800GTX or GTS.
But still, Joe Sixpack won't know the what GT vs GS means. Why not just use 8800 and 8850?

And how many different models do they need anyway? Newegg currently shows a whopping fourteen different 7000-series cards and seventeen(!) X1k-series cards. Seventeen! That's not just ridiculous, it's stupid!

We know that the first cards of each generation will be top-of-the-line...for a moment, before being superseded by newer cards. Look at the 7800, then the 7900, then the 7950s in various forms. Why not just start lower, like the GF Ti 4x00 series, and move up from there? Gamer's will be smart enough to know that an H-Force 600 is nVidia's top card for the following generation, and Joe Sixpack will be able to later compare the HF 600 to the HF 800 and see the bigger number.
 
Back
Top