Thoughts on my New Build

Joined
Dec 4, 2006
Messages
52
Please let me know what you think about the components I chose so far and if you have any advice on what I should change and why. Thanks in advance.

Here it is:
Motherboard: Asus Striker Extreme
CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo E6600 (or E6700...not sure)
RAM: Corsair TWIN2X2048-9136C5D DOMINATOR 2GB (1142 MHz)
Hard Drive: Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 / 320GB
Video Card: GeForce 8800 GTS
Case: Antec P180B
Power Supply: Thermaltake ToughPower 750W
Ready Boost Flash Drive : Patriot XPorter XT 4GB (For Vista's new Ready Boost feature)

I have debated between getting a higher RPM Hard Drive and the one listed, the CPU's I have listed, and the RAM mostly. I will be using it for everything...some video editing, installing Windows Vista, all types of media, very little gaming, web design, general use, etc...
 
Why do you need GeForce 8800 GTS if you use it for "very little" gaming?
 
I thought it would help with video editing, media uses, and kinda future proof me for a little while with Windows Vista and dx10
 
vsrdan said:
Why do you need GeForce 8800 GTS if you use it for "very little" gaming?

QFT. Don't bother running a high end card like something from the 8800 series if you aren't doing a significant amount of gaming. Depending what you play, consider a 7600GT/GS instead. If you REALLY want DX10 support (remember, the Vista GUI is DX9), buy a very inexpensive second-hand 6600 card as a stopgap until mid-low end DX10 cards appear in a few months. EDIT: Just to point out, your videocard will not help you when video editing.

If you're doing some overclocking then that RAM may be what you want, but otherwise don't bother with such expensive stuff.

Finally, your PSU is VAST overkill for your part selection. This Corsair HX520 is a high quality PSU which will handle everything you need and more. Seasonic S12, another good choice, with it's M12 brother being modular.
 
I have a few questions/comments based on your response. Please let me know if I am off in my reasoning on this. Thanks again.
1. The reason I am getting a higher wattage PSU is basically...why not? If I spend a little extra (and I mean a little because the one I listed is priced low), then I am set for whatever I need. Fore example, if I want to use the SLI option with 2 cards, I could. I would rather have more than less wattage as long as its a good PSU because you do not use the wattage you do not need, but it's there if you need it.
2. There are a few reasons I was looking at the GeForce 8800 GTS. One is because it is so far ahead of what is currently out. It is better than 2 7900's in SLI, so I should get many, many years out of it considering I could put it in SLI with another 8800 GTS in the future for an even bigger upgrade. Another is because I have noticed considerable improvements in the speed of my computer in general when upgrading my video card in the past. Another is that it has a lot of memory at 640 MB. I would not have to worry if I wanted to play a game for a while. I have to imagine that the 8800 GTS will give me better performance in all media applications...why would it not? Here are a few quick things I have copied in as not gaming benefits of the card:
Built for Microsoft Windows Vista:
NVIDIA's fourth-generation GPU architecture built for Windows Vista gives users the best possible experience with the Windows Aero 3D graphical user interface.

NVIDIA PureVideo HD Technology:
The combination of high-definition video decode acceleration and post-processing that delivers unprecedented picture clarity, smooth video, accurate color, and precise image scaling for movies and video.

Discrete, Programmable Video Processor:
NVIDIA PureVideo HD is a discrete programmable processing core in NVIDIA GPUs that provides superb picture quality and ultra-smooth movies with low CPU utilization and power.

Hardware Decode Acceleration:
Provides ultra-smooth playback of H.264, VC-1, WMV and MPEG-2 HD and SD movies.

Hardware Decode Acceleration:
Provides ultra-smooth playback of H.264, VC-1, WMV and MPEG-2 HD and SD movies.

HDCP Capable:
Designed to meet the output protection management (HDCP) and security specifications of the Blu-ray Disc and HD DVD formats, allowing the playback of encrypted movie content on PCs when connected to HDCP-compliant displays.

Spatial-Temporal De-Interlacing:
Sharpens HD and standard definition interlaced content on progressive displays, delivering a crisp, clear picture that rivals high-end home-theater systems.

High-Quality Scaling:
Enlarges lower resolution movies and videos to HDTV resolutions, up to 1080i, while maintaining a clear, clean image. Also provides downscaling of videos, including high-definition, while preserving image detail.

Inverse Telecine (3:2 & 2:2 Pulldown Correction):
Recovers original film images from films-converted-to-video (DVDs, 1080i HD content), providing more accurate movie playback and superior picture quality.

Bad Edit Correction:
When videos are edited after they have been converted from 24 to 25 or 30 frames, the edits can disrupt the normal 3:2 or 2:2 pulldown cadences. PureVideo HD uses advanced processing techniques to detect poor edits, recover the original content, and display perfect picture detail frame after frame for smooth, natural looking video.

Video Color Correction:
NVIDIA's Color Correction Controls, such as Brightness, Contrast and Gamma Correction let you compensate for the different color characteristics of various RGB monitors and TVs ensuring movies are not too dark, overly bright, or washed out regardless of the video format or display type.

Integrated SD and HD TV Output:
Provides world-class TV-out functionality via Composite, S-Video, Component, or DVI connections. Supports resolutions up to 1080p depending on connection type and TV capability.

Noise Reduction:
Improves movie image quality by removing unwanted artifacts.

Edge Enhancement:
Sharpens movie images by providing higher contrast around lines and objects.
 
Most of the "benefits" you listed (most of it is marketing fluff btw) about the card are from Purevideo, which is something all 6 series and beyond nVidia cards do (some more than others, look here for more info) to enhance how DVD playback looks and performs on your PC. None of it will help you in your multimedia productivity because when encoding a video (for example) you're using your CPU and hard drives to do all the reading, writing, and calculations. None of it is sent to the GPU to be worked on. It will not improve the general speed of your computer.

What the 8800 series will help you do is play DX10 games and DX9 games faster than the older parts. Since you yourself say that you'll be doing "very little gaming," that will be entirely lost on you. If you really want DX10 capability, wait until the mid-low end DX10 parts arrive in a few months time (perhaps only a month away). Otherwise, if you really really really want to have overkill which will be deemed obsolete once R600 (ATi's DX10 part) and the refresh of G80 (nVidia's slightly faster parts of G80) arrive, then go ahead. I just think it's a waste for someone that does very little gaming.

As for your power supply, I understand that you want something that will grow with your PC, but that 750W unit is still beyond overkill and is too much money. If it gives you peace of mind go ahead.

One other suggestion; if you're going to be doing video editing, won't you want more HD space?
 
Thanks. I plan on using external hard drives with the eSATA ports for extra space and storage. Also, would it be better to go to a 10,000 rpm or above hard drive vs. the seagate I am looking at? And how much will the improved speed of the RAM I listed above help? And the CPU, is e6700 worth it over the e6600 (i do not see why it would be worth the money)? Maybe quad is worth it???

I guess as far as the video card goes, you are correct that it is overkill for me at this point in time, I just can't get by the fact that it gets better performance results than two of the previous top cards in SLI. I should probably put my $ towards something else though.
 
glenlivet17 said:
Thanks. I plan on using external hard drives with the eSATA ports for extra space and storage. Also, would it be better to go to a 10,000 rpm or above hard drive vs. the seagate I am looking at? And how much will the improved speed of the RAM I listed above help? And the CPU, is e6700 worth it over the e6600 (i do not see why it would be worth the money)? Maybe quad is worth it???

I guess as far as the video card goes, you are correct that it is overkill for me at this point in time, I just can't get by the fact that it gets better performance results than two of the previous top cards in SLI. I should probably put my $ towards something else though.

Starting with the HD: If you're looking to do video editing, perhaps just grabbing two of the Seagates in a RAID 0 array would be the best idea in terms of price vs performance and capacity. The issue with the 10k drives is that they are significantly smaller in capacity and cost so much more.

The RAM isn't going to do much for you unless you overclock.

The quad core processor will offer a lot of extra performance if you do a helluva lot of heavy video encoding (link with benches), but I think for 90% of people who aren't professionally doing media encoding it isn't worth it.

Finally the videocard. I understand that you're impressed with the benches of G80, but I think that for a light gamer it is a waste. Read up on this article for some more info about G80 so you can decide if you think it's worth it. Pay close attention to the ultra-high resolutions the games are being run at, and compare that to what you run games at normally. In my opinion if you want DX10 capabilities for the future, buy a stopgap card now (used off of ebay or the FS/FT forums) for no more than $50, and then grab a proper mid-range DX10 card later during the refresh.
 
Thanks for all your help. Any good RAM you can recommend? I would love to get the quad core, and I probably will not be buying everything until January, but I think it may still be too much. I am probably getting my best "bang for the buck" with the e6600, correct?
 
glenlivet17 said:
Thanks for all your help. Any good RAM you can recommend? I would love to get the quad core, and I probably will not be buying everything until January, but I think it may still be too much. I am probably getting my best "bang for the buck" with the e6600, correct?

No prob, I love this stuff.

For your RAM, if you aren't overclocking, any decent set of DDR2-800 value RAM from a reliable company like Crucial or Corsair etc. will do fine. Remember, the lower the timings the faster the RAM, but it won't make too huge of a difference in real-world performance.

You certainly will be getting some great bang for your buck (the key expression to think of when looking at PC parts!) with the 6600.
 
Why wouldn't the 1142 MHz RAM improve performance? Also, my reasoning for the motherboard I am looking at is for the ability for future upgrades. Do you agree with me in buying this motherboard? The 680i chipset, the eSATA, and all the other features are why I am looking at this one.
 
glenlivet17 said:
Why wouldn't the 1142 MHz RAM improve performance? Also, my reasoning for the motherboard I am looking at is for the ability for future upgrades. Do you agree with me in buying this motherboard? The 680i chipset, the eSATA, and all the other features are why I am looking at this one.

The 680i is certainly a great chipset, and if you're looking for upgradeability I think you're on the right track.

As for the RAM, unless you're overclocking you should stick with standard DDR2-800 RAM with decent timings.
 
If you are going to keep important data in this system you may want to consider a RAID setup (at least RAID-1) using some extra HDD's.

Get a better PSU, too. Tt is not that good as far as I know.
 
What is wrong with Thermaltake? They seem to get good reviews and the 750W is only a small $ more than most 520W. Also, if I want to setup a RAID (say 1), and I buy two of the seagate hard drives I mentioned above....do I then have double the amount of space available or not?

I am also a little confused as to why the faster RAM would not do me any good without overclocking...is there a bottleneck somewhere that would keep me from utilizing and speed above 800?
 
Looks great to me. I suppose if your budget allows it, you could justify the 8800GTS as it should last a long while and is DX10 compliant. But if you're looking to save a buck and don't game much, you can drop it down to a 7900 or 7950.

For PSU recomendations, check out the stickies in the PSU forum. Great resource for good/bad PSU's.

I saw that the 6700 was on sale today on the egg too =).

Good luck!
 
Most ThermalTake PSUs are on the "stay the hell away" list, but the Toughpower series is an exception. There are other PSUs you could select from Fortron, Seasonic, PC P&C, Tagan, Silverstone....etc. but the Toughpower is good as well.

As for the RAM, the stock spec for Core 2 Duos is DDR2-800, and in order to get any of the extra bandwidth the Dominator sticks can perform at, you'll have to overclock. So if you do want to overclock, go for it, but otherwise any set of 2X1GB sticks of DDR2-800 with reasonable timings will do just fine.
 
Actually, the current Core2Duos run at 1066Mhz FSB, so the stock setting for ram would be DDR2-533. Anyhow, you could get cheaper ram and get the same real world performance. Then again, whats $100 when you're spending $1500+? lol.
 
I copied this from the link above from tickle me emo:

"Obviously with 680i and RD600 ram is asynchronous so you can set whatever speed you would like on all these rams."

I am buying a 680i board....I am confused then as to why I would would not get 800 MHz or 1000 MHz or above RAM. Why would the 533 MHz be max with the core 2 duo? If I go up to an e6700 instead of an e6600 can I then improve RAM speeds without overclocking? They have the same FSB, but that link seems to seperate the two. Sorry for all the questions....understanding what RAM speed to buy is my biggest ??? now. Thanks.
 
enginurd said:
Actually, the current Core2Duos run at 1066Mhz FSB, so the stock setting for ram would be DDR2-533. Anyhow, you could get cheaper ram and get the same real world performance. Then again, whats $100 when you're spending $1500+? lol.

oops, my brain must've been elsewhere when i posted that.... :D
 
I still have a few questions.
1. With the RAID 0 setup. If I use this setup does this mean that I am getting 320GB available storage if I use two 320GB Seagate 7200.10 drives? Will this improve speed as much as going to 10k rpm drive or above also?

2. From my earlier post:
I copied this from the link above from tickle me emo:

"Obviously with 680i and RD600 ram is asynchronous so you can set whatever speed you would like on all these rams."

I am buying a 680i board....I am confused then as to why I would would not get 800 MHz or 1000 MHz or above RAM. Why would the 533 MHz be max with the core 2 duo? If I go up to an e6700 instead of an e6600 can I then improve RAM speeds without overclocking? They have the same FSB, but that link seems to seperate the two. Sorry for all the questions....understanding what RAM speed to buy is my biggest ??? now. Thanks.
 
1) RAID0 stripes the data across two drives. If you use 2x320gb drives, your total space would be 640gb. Yes, it will improve speed as much as going to a single 10k rpm raptor.

2) The max is whatever the motherboard and ram can handle, and I believe most, if not all, boards can handle asynchronous fsb:ram settings. I just wanted to point out that the stock setting was not DDR2-800. You will be able to set the memory divider in the BIOS, which would run the ram faster than the FSB. So, if your CPU is running at 266*4=1066 and you want your ram to run at 266*3=800 (standard is 266*2=533), then you'd set the memory divider to 4:3.

note: its called a "ram divider" because in the DDR days, DDR ram couldn't run at such high speeds, so people would run the ram slower than the effective system fsb to OC their cpu's clock speed even higher (so they werent limited by slow ram). you can think of it as a ram multiplier now, hehe.
 
glenlivet17 said:
I still have a few questions.
1. With the RAID 0 setup. If I use this setup does this mean that I am getting 320GB available storage if I use two 320GB Seagate 7200.10 drives? Will this improve speed as much as going to 10k rpm drive or above also?

2. From my earlier post:
I copied this from the link above from tickle me emo:

"Obviously with 680i and RD600 ram is asynchronous so you can set whatever speed you would like on all these rams."

I am buying a 680i board....I am confused then as to why I would would not get 800 MHz or 1000 MHz or above RAM. Why would the 533 MHz be max with the core 2 duo? If I go up to an e6700 instead of an e6600 can I then improve RAM speeds without overclocking? They have the same FSB, but that link seems to seperate the two. Sorry for all the questions....understanding what RAM speed to buy is my biggest ??? now. Thanks.

First off, if you run a RAID 0 array, it will greatly improve read/write operations, and will give you 640GB of space. This is because it writes data across both drives at the same time, i.e. it has two heads reading/writing data. I will warn you though, if one of the drives fails, both drives will lose their data. I think that a RAID 0 array is something you should consider based on how serious you are about video editing. It's not like a single 320 will be slow, it's just that RAID 0 will be faster.

As for the RAM, enginurd has it right. I just think you should save the money though unless you're going to be overclocking.
 
What about using RAID 1, would that improve speed? Also, as for the RAM, if 800 MHz is the highest I should go without overclocking, how much could I get with overclocking and what goes into doing that?

Also, I am starting to wonder if I should put two smaller 10k rpm drives in RAID 0 and storing all of my data on an external hd. Would this greatly improve speed?
 
RAID 1 (there are many other types, read up on it here) is a different type of array which mirrors data across two drives. i.e. you have two 320GB drives, and the same data is being written to both so that in the event one fails, you've got another which is identical. You will only have 320GB of data to use, and you will have no performance benefits.

Overclocking (in a nutshell) is a method by which you can set your computer to run at higher speeds via increasing frequencies and voltage levels(the Core2Duos have been generally very good overclockers), but you must maintain safe temperatures and stability usually through aftermarket cooling and long runs of programs like Prime95 (which allow you to test the stability of the system). Honestly, I don't think you should bother as you don't sound like the kind of person who spends hours tinkering with their computer. I think you should just buy some decent DDR2-800 RAM, and then if you choose to in the future you can overclock.

In terms of your second storage idea, that would certainly be the best way to do it (albeit expensive). The best setup would consist of two 150GB Raptors in a RAID 0 array on which you would work with the large files and have a larger backup drive (like the 320 Seagate) in the background as storage. Again, only consider this if you're doing large amounts of video editing.
 
Sorry if this sounds like a stupid question, but I am somewhat new to actually putting in a RAID 0. If I wanted to do what you mentioned and put 2 Raptors in RAID 0, and then have a Seagate 320GB also for storage internally, is this possible with either the ASUS Striker Extreme board or the ASUS P5N32-E SLI board? and (briefly) how do I go about doing this? Am I better off having an external hd through eSATA, or the way explained also?
 
Raid1 won't improve speed much, if at all. Raid1 isnt very cost effective, and is mainly for data backup. Two raptors in Raid0 will be pretty damn fast, but isnt very cost effective either. The speed of the Seagate 7200.10 drives is fast enough for most applications. To increase performance with the least cost, go with 2 of them in raid0. Two raptors in raid0 won't be that much faster.

As for the RAM, how much you could get out of OC'ing always varies. An E6600 runs at 9*266 by default, yielding 2.4Ghz. If you bump that fsb to 400, that would give you 3.6Ghz while running your ram at 1:1 (2*400). This would probably be a good OC for you, should you decide to OC at all. If not, just set your ram divider to 4:3 and you're good to go with your CPU running at 2.4Ghz and your ram speed set to DDR2-800.
 
glenlivet17 said:
Sorry if this sounds like a stupid question, but I am somewhat new to actually putting in a RAID 0. If I wanted to do what you mentioned and put 2 Raptors in RAID 0, and then have a Seagate 320GB also for storage internally, is this possible with either the ASUS Striker Extreme board or the ASUS P5N32-E SLI board? and (briefly) how do I go about doing this? Am I better off having an external hd through eSATA, or the way explained also?

RAID is most definitely possible with almost all decent boards today including both of the Asus boards you mention. Setting up RAID arrays isn't very difficult, but the setup varies across motherboards because the controller can be different. It is explained thoroughly in the manual, and usually consists of only a few minutes worth of setup time.

Enginurd is correct in saying that the best bang for your buck lies in two Seagate 320s, but as I mentioned earlier if you really think you'll want that extra bit of performance it's tough to beat two 150GB Raptors.

In my opinion it makes the most sense to have all the drives internal, perhaps short of your third storage drive should you choose to move it to another computer.
 
OK, I think I am pretty set with everything except for the decision of getting an E6600 or an E6700. What advantage would the E6700 give me as far as overclocking (if any) and also as far as my RAM speed? Also, you say if I do not overclock, then going higher than DDR2 800 would not do me anything. What if I get the E6700 or overclock? I guess what options do I have in that area as far as a CPU/RAM combination with/without overclocking. Thanks again for all your help.
 
For your RAM, any set of RAM running at DDR2-533 or above will run well. I suggested DDR2-800 on the off chance that in the future you'll overclock, but go for a decent set of DDR2-533 2x1GB sticks with reasonable timings.

Let me explain something quickly about why we mention different RAM speeds, and why some are rated faster than others but the extra speed doesn't come into play until your overclock: When overclocking, you're upping the frequency of the Front-Side-Bus (FSB), which controls both the speed of the RAM and the processor. Problems with stability can arise however when you run the RAM faster than it's rated speed. This is why some people choose to purchase RAM that is capable of faster speeds so that they don't have to worry about stability when overclocking.

Don't worry though if you choose to go with the DDR2-533 RAM and in the future decide to overclock; there are things called "dividers" which allow you to still overclock the processor but maintain the RAM at it's standard speeds.

In my opinion the difference between the 6700 and 6600 isn't large enough to warrant the $200 (!) price difference. Go for it if you don't mind spending the money. It won't change your overclocking results significantly.
 
I am going to go with the E6600 then...I may end up upgrading to a quad processor in the future (when prices come way down) anyways. If I go with the DDR2 800 RAM are there any settings I should be looking at if I do not overclock to fully utilize it? (and if I do overclock?) Also, if I went with a higher RAM, such as a DDR2 1000 am I future proofing things for a bit, or is it just a waste (in other words, is DDR3 or some other RAM/FSB technology supposed to change things anyways)?
 
glenlivet17 said:
I am going to go with the E6600 then...I may end up upgrading to a quad processor in the future (when prices come way down) anyways. If I go with the DDR2 800 RAM are there any settings I should be looking at if I do not overclock to fully utilize it? (and if I do overclock?) Also, if I went with a higher RAM, such as a DDR2 1000 am I future proofing things for a bit, or is it just a waste (in other words, is DDR3 or some other RAM/FSB technology supposed to change things anyways)?

The extra bandwidth provided by the RAM isn't going to translate into any significant gains, so it would be a waste. You'll be able to dictate RAM speed in your BIOS.
 
If you get DDR2-800 and don't want to OC the CPU just yet, then set the ram divider to 4:3 (or equivalent) to run the ram at its rated speed. Otherwise, it will run at the 1:1 speed of DDR2-533. If you OC, you can leave the ram at 1:1 just bump the FSB (incrementally) to 400Mhz. Follow an OC guide for more details.

Just to reiterate quadnad again, hehe, DDR2-533 is all you really need, but since the price difference isn't much for DDR2-800, you might as well get that instead. The price jump to DDR2-1000/1067 really isnt worth it unless you're goin for an extreme overclock with watercooling. DDR3 isn't planned in the roadmaps until 2008 I believe (someone can correct me if I'm wrong).
 
Back
Top