Thoughts on my <$1500 build

tspinning

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 1, 2007
Messages
73
So, alas my 4 year old AMD XP 2700 based AGP (x1950 GT) system is on its last legs and I've just gotten a new job that should allow me to fund a new computer, and bring me into the mulit-core relm!

Here is what I'm looking at, what are your thoughts!

http://www.freewebs.com/tspinning/index.htm
 
Well drop the RAM and HSF. Dominator RAM is horribly overpriced and there are better/cheaper sets of RAM that can OC better than Dominator. Also, you wont' notice the difference between CAS 4 and 5 in games, so don't pay the premium for it.

As for the HSF, there are much better cooling HSf than the old 9500. I recommend going with either the Scythe Ninja or Tuniq Tower 120:
http://pclab.pl/art28806-3.html

Scythe SCNJ-1100P Ninja HSF - $36
Tuniq Tower 120 HSF - $45

And some questions that you need to answer:
- What size monitor do you have?
- What will you be using this system for?
- If gaming, what games are you planning to play?
- Will you be overclocking?
 
Well, presuming that you will be using this system for playing modern games, it looks pretty good, though, as said Danny Bui said above, there is no point in buying such expensive memory. Just buy some GSkill PC6400. I would recommend that you get the newer and cheaper P182, which is slightly better when it comes to cable management. Get a different cooler, as Danny yet again said, Tuniq Tower 120 is your best bet. As you have selected one of the best overclocking boards on the market, I do presume you are going to overclock, so I think that you have made the right choice there. Change the processor, if possible, to the Q6600 G0, which you will find as the energy efficient versions of the processor. You will be able to get some really nice overclocks with it. I would personally change the hard drive to the Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 500GB model, it is faster. Finally, change the power supply to the Corsair HX520, you don't at all need a 500 watt power supply, let alone a 600.

Hope this helps!
 
OK, this is the constructive criticisms i was hoping for!

I am hoping to get the G0 stepping, however I'm not sure how to insure it.. .any ideas? I read in newegg reviews it's somewhat hit/miss, and I live in MA and very close to the NJ distributer if it helps

I appreciate the RAM and Tuniq cooler input, very good to know, I was only going off what I had used (XMS) in the past, and that one looked rather impressive, as for cpu fan, i had no idea!

what I PC for~ (in no particular order)

Gaming (wow... easy i know, battlefield, CS, crysis when the time comes (ugg for vista though)
mechanical design/drafting stuff- Pro-E, autodesk
DVD ripping/encoding, and burning (thanks blockbuster!)

some photoshoping, no real video editing at this time though

OC is in the cards, although it won't be the first stop, as all this in standard form will whip the pants off my current anemic setup. I choose the mobo due to amazing reviews, good spec sheet, and wonderful experience with my current DFI Lanparty board (NF2Ultra B)
 
I agree with Danny and Lambo, for the most part.

The new revision P180's have the better wire management subtlties of the P182. The Spinpoint is on par with the 'cuda as far as performance goes; it is, however, much quieter than the 'cuda.

To ensure you get a G0 stepping Q6600, get it from clubit.com instead of newegg.

The ninja (scnj-1100p) is $35 at the egg, and the Tuniq is $45 at the egg as well, but OOS.

This is all the power you need:
$100 - Corsair HX Series CMPSU-520HX 520W Modular PSU ($10MIR)

RAM:
2GB: $70 - G.Skill 2GB (2x1GB) DDR2-800 F2-6400CL5D-2GBNQ
4GB: $175 - G.Skill 4GB(2x2GB) DDR2-800 F2-6400CL5D-4GBPQ
 
You forgot to answer one question:
And some questions that you need to answer:
- What size monitor do you have?

I'll also add: Are you also planning on getting a bigger size monitor?
 
Bah!

19" viewsonic at this time, will go widescreen someday...

I went w/ the PCP&C silencer 650 after reading the (dare i say) glowing review of its big brother the 750 here @ [H]

I do believe clean, efficient power is worth paying for, and don't mind feeding my components the good stuff
 
For a 19" monitor, all you need is the 8800GTS 320MB. For a 19" monitor, that GTS 640 is a bit overkill.
 
19inch??? 8800gts????

even my Sahppire X600Pro could support a 19inch piss

what GFX card you getting??

if your getting the GFX you suggested you need a good widescreen 22inch??
no point getting good GFX and have shit screen
you waste your money cause you get nothing from a good gfx

i suggest you get a good screen

or get a cheaper GFX


what do you mostly do on your computer??
 
19inch??? 8800gts????

even my Sahppire X600Pro could support a 19inch piss

what GFX card you getting??

if your getting the GFX you suggested you need a good widescreen 22inch??
no point getting good GFX and have shit screen
you waste your money cause you get nothing from a good gfx

i suggest you get a good screen

or get a cheaper GFX


what do you mostly do on your computer??


Like he said get a good screen do that you can max out the potential of your computer ! I have this monitor and its AWESOME i got it referibished too. I would highly suggest getting this

http://www.buy.com/retail/Product.a...04766&Type=PE&Category=Comp&Gad=0&dcaid=15894
 
Monitor size is somewhat of personal preference. So, if you're happy with your 19", stick with it. If not, upgrade.

Support? Sure, any card will support a 19"... the question is, how well would it perform when he tries to game. I doubt an X600Pro could perform well at 1280x1024 with high detail, trying to play any of the most recent games, especially Crysis. Granted, we all have different levels of acceptable FPS for playability... but seriously, an 8800GTS 320MB would be perfect for the latest games on a 19" monitor. Heck, ask some hardcore gamers, and they'll tell you to get a GTX for that size screen.
 
enginurd and brahim are correct

if you want max out your GFX you need a kick ass screen

if you really can't get a good 22' + then a 19' would be ok

and for newer games a gtx would be great to future proof your comp for the next 2 year

a X600pro can play CS 1.6 and Warcraft 3 on full graphics with about 65-70fps and thats fine for me

but its really how 'hardcore' you want to play games and build your comp
 
If you do have the funds for an upgrade, you could get another monitor and use both for 2D and the newer one for gaming.
 
Ah, I thought I would comment on the graphics card. You won't really need something as powerful as an 8800GTS, you would be able to play current and future games fine on an X1950 Pro. You could also try to find an older X1800XT, which at stock is a faster performer, but when overclocking both cards, the X1950 Pro will be either on par or faster. I think that you would be fine playing with this card at 1600x1200, let alone at 1280x1024. That means that you could save the money, and spend it later on an upgrade that is more worthwhile.
 
Back
Top