Thieves Are Stealing Children's Identities

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
In a recent study by Richard Power at the Carnegie Mellon Cylab, it was found that about 10% of all children’s Social Security numbers had been compromised and in many cases had high debt associated with them.

In most cases, identities endangered by data breaches do not fall under systematic attack, Holland says. The identities are compromised, but don't appear to be taken by someone who then actively tries to capitalize on them.
 
Ive heard of this before. In fact, I read an article a while back about a 6 month old victim of ID theft. The parents were receiving calls from collectors that their 6 month old owed thousands of dollars.

Now a case like this and with other very young children. I say the banks should be held accountable for this is some way. reasons: 6 month old babies cannot own a bank account under their name alone, a 6 month old cannot own a credit card. That is the bank's incompetence for opening an account for someone whose not even a year old.
 
Ive heard of this before. In fact, I read an article a while back about a 6 month old victim of ID theft. The parents were receiving calls from collectors that their 6 month old owed thousands of dollars.

Now a case like this and with other very young children. I say the banks should be held accountable for this is some way. reasons: 6 month old babies cannot own a bank account under their name alone, a 6 month old cannot own a credit card. That is the bank's incompetence for opening an account for someone whose not even a year old.

Why should the bank industry (as evil as it is) be accountable that some waste-of-skin kinda person is making up social security numbers and/or otherwise stealing the information.

Your saying that if I steal by using the name of a child to get credit the bank should pay and not me.

Sadly the banks agree with you, paying off fraud claims is one of the biggest reasons they use to raise prices and fees and lower rates on savings accounts and your buying into the con.

The way the system is set up and supposed to work with visa/mc charge-backs, the merchant that accepted the fake ID, Fake Card, etc is supposed to take the hit. People get so pissy about being asked for ID at the register many retailers stop asking to avoid lost sales. In my years working at Target as a front manager I couldn't tell you how many times someone wouldn't show me there ID. Or how many people "accidentally" super glued their ID into the wallet behind the clear plastic (so you cant tell it have been altered).

So help me out.... how are the banks responsible some loser is at the store writing checks or getting a store brand credit card in someone else's name?
 
It wouldn't be an issue if the banks would do their due diligence when issuing credit.
 
Mmm buy some cool hardware with your children's names and blame it on thieves
 
So help me out.... how are the banks responsible some loser is at the store writing checks or getting a store brand credit card in someone else's name?

Stores and retailer don't issue credit cards and checks. Banks do that. The card may have a store or company's name on it, but behind the scenes, it's handled by a bank. The bank received the application with the stolen ID, they merely look at the name and SSN and some other info, but don't bother to check the date of birth
 
why o why do banks and credit companies still need a social security number to set up an account... *sigh*
 
Why should the bank industry (as evil as it is) be accountable that some waste-of-skin kinda person is making up social security numbers and/or otherwise stealing the information.

Your saying that if I steal by using the name of a child to get credit the bank should pay and not me.

Sadly the banks agree with you, paying off fraud claims is one of the biggest reasons they use to raise prices and fees and lower rates on savings accounts and your buying into the con.

The way the system is set up and supposed to work with visa/mc charge-backs, the merchant that accepted the fake ID, Fake Card, etc is supposed to take the hit. People get so pissy about being asked for ID at the register many retailers stop asking to avoid lost sales. In my years working at Target as a front manager I couldn't tell you how many times someone wouldn't show me there ID. Or how many people "accidentally" super glued their ID into the wallet behind the clear plastic (so you cant tell it have been altered).

So help me out.... how are the banks responsible some loser is at the store writing checks or getting a store brand credit card in someone else's name?

I can't believe you actually need someone to explain too you how this is the banks fault..

I can sum it up in three letters; DOB.

Otherwise known as Date of Birth, you know that thing that you are required to put on every single credit application in existence that banks clearly are not checking. Oh and yes your DOB is tied to the SSN.
 
Practically all parents in lower income families have bills in the kids' names. My sister had a phone bill at 8.
 
Why should the bank industry (as evil as it is) be accountable that some waste-of-skin kinda person is making up social security numbers and/or otherwise stealing the information.

Your saying that if I steal by using the name of a child to get credit the bank should pay and not me.

Sadly the banks agree with you, paying off fraud claims is one of the biggest reasons they use to raise prices and fees and lower rates on savings accounts and your buying into the con.

The way the system is set up and supposed to work with visa/mc charge-backs, the merchant that accepted the fake ID, Fake Card, etc is supposed to take the hit. People get so pissy about being asked for ID at the register many retailers stop asking to avoid lost sales. In my years working at Target as a front manager I couldn't tell you how many times someone wouldn't show me there ID. Or how many people "accidentally" super glued their ID into the wallet behind the clear plastic (so you cant tell it have been altered).

So help me out.... how are the banks responsible some loser is at the store writing checks or getting a store brand credit card in someone else's name?

That waste of skin wouldnt be able to do it if the stupid ass bank would ya know ask for some form of identification before giving out a line of credit or actually look up the social. If you can get a line of credit in the name of a child somethings fucked up with the way financial institutions are allowed to do business.

Retailers are not supposed to ask for ID unless the card is unsigned or says see ID. I get so sick of getting asked for an ID when i use my card knowing they shouldn't be doing it. Part of the agreement retailers have to agree to to accept the cards says they have to adhere to this, instead you get these stores saying fuck it and asking for an ID to cover their own asses.

Thats why people get pissed off when asked for ID. Its not supposed to happen... Problem is the CC providers dont enforce this anymore.

For the record here is an excert from one of the CC agreements retailers have to accept to take the cards.

Cardservice International Merchant Agreement said:
"Before accepting any Card, Merchant shall:
"...(c) not request or record such personal Cardholder information,
such as home or business telephone number, a home or business address,
driver’s license, or other such identification onto the sales draft as
a condition of the sale unless such information is required under
specific circumstances cited in MasterCard or VISA rules and
regulations"
 
That waste of skin wouldnt be able to do it if the stupid ass bank would ya know ask for some form of identification before giving out a line of credit or actually look up the social. If you can get a line of credit in the name of a child somethings fucked up with the way financial institutions are allowed to do business.

Retailers are not supposed to ask for ID unless the card is unsigned or says see ID. I get so sick of getting asked for an ID when i use my card knowing they shouldn't be doing it. Part of the agreement retailers have to agree to to accept the cards says they have to adhere to this, instead you get these stores saying fuck it and asking for an ID to cover their own asses.

Thats why people get pissed off when asked for ID. Its not supposed to happen... Problem is the CC providers dont enforce this anymore.

For the record here is an excert from one of the CC agreements retailers have to accept to take the cards.

I really do not understand this line of thinking..you get pissed for retailers ultimately protecting you by validating your ID with your CC? Really? Is it that much of an inconvenience to pull one more car out of your wallet that you already obviously have in hand? I get irritated when they don't ask signed or not and frankly anyone who signs their card(s) is a dumbass asking to get screwed over. I have lost track of all the times I have spent hundreds in a single purchase, with see Id on my card and never once asked.

I went ahead and bolded the important part since some people don't get the seriousness of credit card theft.
 
I really do not understand this line of thinking..you get pissed for retailers ultimately protecting you by validating your ID with your CC? Really? Is it that much of an inconvenience to pull one more car out of your wallet that you already obviously have in hand? I get irritated when they don't ask signed or not and frankly anyone who signs their card(s) is a dumbass asking to get screwed over. I have lost track of all the times I have spent hundreds in a single purchase, with see Id on my card and never once asked.

I went ahead and bolded the important part since some people don't get the seriousness of credit card theft.

They are not protecting me they are covering their own ass and are violating their fucking contract with the CC merchant just to do so.

Yes its an inconvenience, one that Visa told me wouldnt happen.

You dont have a clue what you are talking about. This is not to portect the consumer and if you think so you dont have the slightest clue how credit crds even work.

If someone steals your credit card YOU ARE NOT LIABLE FOR A FUCKING DIME... The CC company takes care of you and GUESS WHO EATS THE LOSS...
 
Visa said:
What happens if someone steals my Visa Debit card and uses it fraudulently?
If your Visa Debit card is lost or stolen and fraudulent activity occurs, you are protected by Visa's Zero Liability policy.* That means 100 percent protection for you. Whether purchases occur online or off, you pay nothing for fraudulent activity.

If you notice fraudulent activity on your Visa Debit card, promptly contact your financial institution to report it. It is important to continually monitor your monthly statement to identify any unauthorized transactions.

The CC company will take care of the customer in event of fraud.

Please educate yourself before making such asinine arguments.
 
They are not protecting me they are covering their own ass and are violating their fucking contract with the CC merchant just to do so.

Yes its an inconvenience, one that Visa told me wouldnt happen.

You dont have a clue what you are talking about. This is not to portect the consumer and if you think so you dont have the slightest clue how credit crds even work.

If someone steals your credit card YOU ARE NOT LIABLE FOR A FUCKING DIME... The CC company takes care of you and GUESS WHO EATS THE LOSS...

You have no clue how it works, and yet likely wonder why fees and such continue to go up. You may not be liable, but in the end you pay for it. You will spend more time fighting a single fraudulent charge then you ever would simply showing your ID. Oh by the way, that fraudulent charge also takes quite a bit of time to get back too you. So if you had plans for your credit, well that could take up to 21 days to be returned. Try reading your actual contract sometime. I know a ton of people who have lost credit cards and had fraudulent charges racked up and it took them days minimum to resolve. Less then two seconds of your time is not an inconvenience, you are just trying to create drama.

Educate yourself
 
You have no clue how it works, and yet likely wonder why fees and such continue to go up. You may not be liable, but in the end you pay for it. You will spend more time fighting a single fraudulent charge then you ever would simply showing your ID. Oh by the way, that fraudulent charge also takes quite a bit of time to get back too you. So if you had plans for your credit, well that could take up to 21 days to be returned. Try reading your actual contract sometime. I know a ton of people who have lost credit cards and had fraudulent charges racked up and it took them days minimum to resolve. Less then two seconds of your time is not an inconvenience, you are just trying to create drama.

My CC has my picture on it. I think this should be the norm rather than the exception.
 
anyone who signs their card(s) is a dumbass asking to get screwed over. I have lost track of all the times I have spent hundreds in a single purchase, with see Id on my card and never once asked.

I never understood people who put "See ID" instead of a signature on their card. Most (if not all) credit cards are not valid unless signed. If the retailer was following the rules, they should either decline the card, or require you to show ID and sign the card before accepting it.

http://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/sign-or-write-see-ID-1282.php
 
I used to have "CHECK ID" written on my credit card, that is until only about 1 out of every 20 people actually looked and then asked for an ID, in fact more would look at the back and then just hand the card back to me like its too much of a problem. Then I figured why bother.
 
Ok look. I've actually worked in banking and fraud the last decade. Here are a few good things to know...

1. Sign your card, don't write "See ID." Fraudsters can then steal your card, make up their own ID and signature; so when the (rare) clerk actually does look at their fake ID, hey look the signature matches, we're good to go!

2. The idiot who gets mad when people ask for ID? I'm sure you'd also be mad if said store let someone just walk up with your CC and rack up thousands in charges, right? A huge percentage of fraud could be prevented by the simple task of more retailers checking ID at the POS. (As an aside, even working in a bank branch some people get mad when you attempt to identify them, even if they're attempting to take hundreds of thousands of dollars out of their accounts. I just don't fucking get it.)

3. Your SSN is not linked to your DOB. Many fraud systems will look up when the SSN was issued, but that doesn't necessarily mean anything. The data isn't very reliable to begin with, and it is a "red flag" to be reviewed. That being said, many credit companies are at fault and they just ignore red flags and issue the card.

4. The whole banks raising the fees due to fraud; yes it is an expense. But the reason why Visa/MC don't want retailers ID'ing people and such is that even with the fraud, they make much, much more money off of the merchant fees by using your cards. Thus, they try to drive volume no matter what. Look at those little RFID keychain cards. God forbid you lose that and don't realize it for a bit.

And as for the kids SSN being used; I saw it all the time working in a bank branch. Single mom/dad, usually, opening up a savings for little Johnny. Run them through the system, oh look, ineligible for an account because of negative credit at age 5. :(
 
2. The idiot who gets mad when people ask for ID? I'm sure you'd also be mad if said store let someone just walk up with your CC and rack up thousands in charges, right? A huge percentage of fraud could be prevented by the simple task of more retailers checking ID at the POS. (As an aside, even working in a bank branch some people get mad when you attempt to identify them, even if they're attempting to take hundreds of thousands of dollars out of their accounts. I just don't fucking get it.)

For someone who worked at a bank you would think you knew that its against the contract to ask for ID on a CC purchase unless the cards unsigned or says see ID. You would also think you had a basic understanding of people not wanting to be inconvenienced by something they where assured wouldnt happen. :rolleyes:

Apparently im an idiot because i want the retailers to live up to the agreement they made in the first fucking place.

I would care if someone stole my CC but im not concerned. 3 weeks tops and its all back to me.

Checking ID at the sale wont prevent shit all the thief would say is shit i forgot my ID then on to the next store. Also considering most CC fraud takes place ONLINE your argument makes even less sense.

This incredibly ignorant notion that asking for an ID could even remotely prevent CC fraud is absurd and i think you guys really need to sit down and rethink what you are saying. Even if every single retail employee started checking ID all that means is CC fraud online will go up. Most of it already happens online anyway so what exactly is your point?

In the end its an inconvenience that helps no one and is only in place to cover the stores ass and make their "numbers" look good to the district/regional guys. This dont make a dent in CC fraud or help the customer one tiny bit.

I dont know if you guys think when a thief is asked for ID that they just say fuck it and throw the card away or what but some people really need a reality check here.
 
I'm sorry, if safeguarding your own money by showing the ID that is in the same wallet you're pulling your CC out is too much of an inconvenience for you, you're a lazy ass.

And preventing a large percentage of fraud through physical retail locations is by no means insignificant when you're talking about billions of dollars in losses each year. But you're clearly the expert here. :rolleyes:
 
I really do not understand this line of thinking..you get pissed for retailers ultimately protecting you by validating your ID with your CC? Really? Is it that much of an inconvenience to pull one more car out of your wallet that you already obviously have in hand? I get irritated when they don't ask signed or not and frankly anyone who signs their card(s) is a dumbass asking to get screwed over. I have lost track of all the times I have spent hundreds in a single purchase, with see Id on my card and never once asked.

I went ahead and bolded the important part since some people don't get the seriousness of credit card theft.

I have to comment on this. I don't sign the backs of my cards. I was in London a few years back and went to pay for my pub tab. I give the guy my credit card and my ID. He looks at me and tells me that he can't accept my CC because it is not signed, because I could just get the receipt and dispute that the signature on the receipt was my signature.

So he asks me to SIGN the back of the card on the spot. He then accepted the card with a smug look of success on his face while I left him a buck tip and and the phrase "Here you go, dumbass" on the top of the receipt.

Yeah, real effective there dipshit.
 
I'm sorry, if safeguarding your own money by showing the ID that is in the same wallet you're pulling your CC out is too much of an inconvenience for you, you're a lazy ass.

And preventing a large percentage of fraud through physical retail locations is by no means insignificant when you're talking about billions of dollars in losses each year. But you're clearly the expert here. :rolleyes:

How can you claim to work for a bank in fraud and say something so ignorant?

Your money is protected by the CC company. Them asking for your ID is to safeguard THEIR MONEY. :rolleyes:

You about done with the personal insults? It just makes your argument look very childish, especially for someone claiming to have worked in the field you are so ignorant about.
 
The fact that the bank will reimburse your stolen funds does not change the fact that it is your account and your funds. In fact, if you take certain actions and do not sufficiently safeguard YOUR funds, you can then lose your consumer protections and not be reimbursed.

I know that it is all digital and housed in a bank; but I don't see how you then think that absolves you of all personal responsibility and your sole worry is convenience, not the integrity of your money.
 
As for not signing the back - the Post Office - of all places, will not let you use an unsigned card.
 
I have to comment on this. I don't sign the backs of my cards. I was in London a few years back and went to pay for my pub tab. I give the guy my credit card and my ID. He looks at me and tells me that he can't accept my CC because it is not signed, because I could just get the receipt and dispute that the signature on the receipt was my signature.

So he asks me to SIGN the back of the card on the spot. He then accepted the card with a smug look of success on his face while I left him a buck tip and and the phrase "Here you go, dumbass" on the top of the receipt.

Yeah, real effective there dipshit.

Same thing happened to me over there. Maybe the Brits are just more anal. I do love that you tipped him. I tried leaving a gratuity at other pubs in London and had more than one bartender annoyed at my ignorance. :rolleyes:
 
The fact that the bank will reimburse your stolen funds does not change the fact that it is your account and your funds. In fact, if you take certain actions and do not sufficiently safeguard YOUR funds, you can then lose your consumer protections and not be reimbursed.

I know that it is all digital and housed in a bank; but I don't see how you then think that absolves you of all personal responsibility and your sole worry is convenience, not the integrity of your money.

The only thing that will stop you from getting the funds reimbursed is if they use your PIN or find out you gave the person the card.

Again considering you claim this was your job you really dont seem to have a clue.

I dont give 2 shits whether or not you agree with me you SHOULD NEVER BE ASKED FOR ID. This is a fact. Whether or not you agree with this fact is a whole different matter.

this argument is annoying. Im glad you dont mind showing your ID but quit trying to force your opinion on everyone else.
 
The merchant is asking to see your ID in order to protect themselves. If a thief uses your card to buy something at a store, and then you report your card as stolen, the CC company will back charge the merchant. The merchant is now out of their inventory and did not get paid by the CC company.

Sure, you should be protective of your card information, but the bottom line is that the merchant is not looking out for you when they ask for ID. They are protecting themselves.
 
I really do not understand this line of thinking..you get pissed for retailers ultimately protecting you by validating your ID with your CC? Really? Is it that much of an inconvenience to pull one more car out of your wallet that you already obviously have in hand? I get irritated when they don't ask signed or not and frankly anyone who signs their card(s) is a dumbass[/SIZE] asking to get screwed over. I have lost track of all the times I have spent hundreds in a single purchase, with see Id on my card and never once asked.

How much more protected are you by a clerk violating the merchant agreement? What is the rate of fraud for merchants who don't ask for ID, versus those who do ask under similar circumstances?
 
And preventing a large percentage of fraud through physical retail locations is by no means insignificant when you're talking about billions of dollars in losses each year. But you're clearly the expert here. :rolleyes:

I'd be interested in seeing the research on this "large percentage of fraud," if you have it available for consideration.
 
Easy.. don't force a SSN on your child, allow them to make the choice when they are older and informed. It can be done.

You cant steal and abuse what does not exist.
 
I'd be interested in seeing the research on this "large percentage of fraud," if you have it available for consideration.

Unfortunately I don't have any research to back me up, I'm just using my own experience as a guide. I know of countless cases where asking for ID would have prevented that fraud. Could it have pushed it online? Could it have pushed it to another store? Absolutely. But any rise in the cost and / or difficulty of committing the fraud will result in a decrease in it. To me, even a 10% decrease would be considered "large" and would save hundreds of millions if not billions of dollars annually.

And I know that my expertise has been called into doubt by a previous angry commentor, but the changes I implemented in my financial institution resulted in $2 million dollars a month YOY decrease in fraud, while we had nearly 1 million additional accounts in the portfolio. Similarly, the bank branches I managed always were below their loss targets, mainly due to responsibly identifying who you are doing business with and training your staff. At the retail level, it isn't rocket science.
 
Easy.. don't force a SSN on your child, allow them to make the choice when they are older and informed. It can be done.

You cant steal and abuse what does not exist.

Its not optional. Every American citizen has to have one.
 
Back
Top