The XB1 alternative storage conundrum.

chimera991

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Sep 4, 2010
Messages
1,170
I'm going to pull a trigger on an XB1 this weekend, i did some research and couldnt find the answer. I know that storing games on the internal is decent, but it is not good enough for my preference.

What I want to know is what would be faster an external ssd or a ultra fast usb drive?

The games ill mostly be playing are Horizon 2 and whenever Forza 6 comes out.

I know that the XB1 uses a usb 3.0 and i want to full utilize that. I actually wish both consoles ran sata3 connections.
 
The simple answer. SSDs are faster than thumb drives. Not only in sequential read / write but random read / write because they have more powerful controllers and there are more channels for the NAND to use, increasing the performance through parallelism. (Writing to more chips of NAND at the same time)

That said if you had a fast USB3.0 thumb drive, it would probably perform well enough that the CPU would likely bottleneck and would be within a second or two of the SSD. Game loads are not all that disk intensive and there is usually something else limiting the speed.

I do see a video showing there is a good speedup for Forza 5 from an Msata drive, 32 seconds vs 46 for the internal, so 14 second increase is always welcomed. I would guess that a 7200rpm drive would probably cut that gap in half due to the decrease in access times.
 
USB 3.0 is a much faster interface than SATA3. If speed is your main concern then get a SSD. Myself, I'm more concerned about space this generation with most AAA games being close to 50GB in size, so I would get a 6TB external HDD. Loading times are almost non-existent using the internal drive already in Horizon 2 beyond the initial loading when first starting the game.
 
There's been some sites that have done benchmarks between standard HDDs and SSDs, and there's a definite difference in loading times, when using an SSD. Same games had bigger performance gains than others, but the SSD was always better. If you're referring to USB thumb drives, when you say "ultra fast usb drive," I haven't read anything about them vs an SSD. I didn't even realize you could use them, although just so you know, there are two requirements, for using the external storage feature. The first thing is the device needs to be USB 3.0, which wouldn't be a problem. However, the other is that it needs to have 256 GB or more of storage space. I'm not sure how many 256 GB USB thumb drives are on the market, but I imagine they're expensive. It's probably more economical to get an SSD.
 
Last edited:
USB 3.0 is a much faster interface than SATA3. If speed is your main concern then get a SSD. Myself, I'm more concerned about space this generation with most AAA games being close to 50GB in size, so I would get a 6TB external HDD. Loading times are almost non-existent using the internal drive already in Horizon 2 beyond the initial loading when first starting the game.

No it isn't. USB 3.0 is a compressed stream of data , SATA is uncompressed and to each channel. SATA 3.0 is 6 GBPS while USB 3.0 is at a max burst of 5 GBPS. SATA supports other data critical features that USB 3.0 simply doesn't as well.

SATA is a much more trust worthy interface than USB and reliable enough for enterprise usage. So its semantics to argue the difference here since the One only accepts USB 3.0. No one in their right mind would use a USB drive at the enterprise level for large data storage for instance. And considering most people don't have uncapped service losing 3-4TB's of data would mean a very long recovery.

As far as what to buy OP , grab a Western Digital or Hitachi drive. Hitachi drives at the moment have the lowest failure rates compared to other manufacturers. Don't buy 6TB drives yet as they have not been stress tested for reliability over time. Buy 3-4TB depending on your needs. I doubt you'll fill 3TB's very quickly even in the next few years unless you obsessively play everything that releases.

I wouldn't buy an SSD because of the price increase and the difference in loading speed is entirely minimal , maybe 5-10 seconds saved on average. Not worth the giant leap in cost.
 
Im not looking for space, im looking for speed. I spoiled myself by running literally everything i have on ssd ( work laptop, ps3, gaming pc, win 8 laptop).

The question is which usb 3.0 enclosure has the fastest chip and is msata a better upgrade than a standard 2.5" or smaller ssd?
 
Im not looking for space, im looking for speed. I spoiled myself by running literally everything i have on ssd ( work laptop, ps3, gaming pc, win 8 laptop).

The question is which usb 3.0 enclosure has the fastest chip and is msata a better upgrade than a standard 2.5" or smaller ssd?

If you watch the digital foundry videos theres very little performance improvement in load times and texture streaming, when they compared a regular 7200 RPM hardrive to an SSD. You would get better value and storage from a hybrid drive then a SSD.
 
USB 3.0 is a much faster interface than SATA3. If speed is your main concern then get a SSD. Myself, I'm more concerned about space this generation with most AAA games being close to 50GB in size, so I would get a 6TB external HDD. Loading times are almost non-existent using the internal drive already in Horizon 2 beyond the initial loading when first starting the game.

LOL can't get away with that on [H]forum...


To the OP SSD in a usb 3.0 enclosure is faster and probably a better value as SSD prices are getting quite affordable. Life span of an SSD is probably better as well as the controllers are more advance and the expected usage of a SSD is higher than a usb stick.
 
LOL can't get away with that on [H]forum...


To the OP SSD in a usb 3.0 enclosure is faster and probably a better value as SSD prices are getting quite affordable. Life span of an SSD is probably better as well as the controllers are more advance and the expected usage of a SSD is higher than a usb stick.

USB 3.0 is faster than sata2 and both consoles are sata 2 not 3. I went best 7200 and mass storage in the Xbox preview forum a guy tested all the variations and it was a toss up but the raid setup like mine was the best of both worlds speed\storage.
 
Posts from that thread

DR3:

Load to "A" button:

Internal: 61 seconds

RAID0: 41.5 seconds

20 second improvement!!!

Load to in game:

Internal: 50 seconds

RAID0: 33 seconds

17 seconds improvement!!!

SSD gives a mixed bag:

Wolf:

Same as RAID0.

Forza :(

Same as RAID0.

One sec difference if that. RAID0 was quicker :/

DR3:

SSD was 6 sec quicker on initial load to "A"

3 sec quicker on LeMans!

At least with these 3 games does not appear to be worth the premium

More good news incoming (unless you were planning on going with a SSD!!!)

***The following tests are the average of two tests; however, the times were nearly exact for each speed test!!!

BF4:

Internal HDD

To MP screen aka starting from dash: 29seconds

RAID0

To MP screen aka starting from dash: 20 seconds

RYSE:

Internal HDD

To menu: 31 seconds

Game Load: 1 minute 18.5 seconds

Reload same checkpoint from in game: 7.5 seconds

RAID0:

To menu: 29 seconds

Game Load: 56 seconds

Reload same checkpoint from in game: 6 seconds

SSD (Crucial m4 256GB)

To menu: 27 seconds

Game Load: 56 seconds

Reload same checkpoint from in game: 6 seconds

The RAID0 (and the SSD for that matter) lowers the time to get in game for RYSE. The internal HDD at 1 minute 18 seconds gets to the painful experience! Luckily keeping things external now can cut slightly more than 22 seconds off the loading into game from menu!!!! YMMV depending on drive selected. My suggestion is if you are not RAID0, make sure you go with a 7,200RPM drive, or maybe one of those hybrid drives. Looking forward to some hybrid drive tests if someone can do those, or what about hybrid RAID0 :p

Good news with these results...but 22 seconds quicker makes the painful becoming bearable for RYSE :D, not earth shattering, but a definite improvement!!!

I can confirm SSDs don't give that much if an improvement (compared to some RAID0 setup).

Drive is Samsung 840 EVO (500GB) through some crappy Connectland case.

SSD vs internal HDD. Measurements handmade using a stopwatch.

Forza 5 :

"First" event with BRZ (recent T10 gift) : 31s vs 39s

Back to menus : 9s vs 11s

"Last" event with standard ford race car (V8 supercar) : 32s vs 43s

Back to menus : 8s vs 12s

Last P championship with standard GT One : 39s vs 48s

Modern gran touring event on Le Mans with Vanquish Collector : 40s vs 57s

DR3 :

First "A button" appearance : 37s vs 51s

Start menu at 47s mark vs 1:05 mark

Chap 7 (continue from my previous game) loaded at 1:20 (from initial start up from dash, that is) vs 2:06

Quit game takes a whoopin' 55s vs 1:01

CoD Ghost :

First level load (through new game, skipping cutscene asap) : 27s vs 38s

KI :

Time to display char at select screen : between 3 and 5 seconds vs 5~6s

Load dojo 1 : 9s vs 9s

Load dojo 32 : 9s vs 9s

BF4 :

Time to load proving grounds (training onlinish map) : 23s vs 26s

New game (timing of "EA presents") : 25s vs 26s

Note : BF4 test scenarios may not be relevant due to networking and/or presentation of the first level.
 
USB 3.0 is faster than sata2 and both consoles are sata 2 not 3. I went best 7200 and mass storage in the Xbox preview forum a guy tested all the variations and it was a toss up but the raid setup like mine was the best of both worlds speed\storage.

He said Sata 3 and it doesn't matter what's inside the xbox because it's not suppose to be user replaceable. So you're probably not opening it up, mirroring the original drive, replacing it, and voiding your warranty.
 
Last edited:
Patience got the best of me, I got the assassins creed bundle, ordered a 512gb msata ssd, and an enclosure. Now i dont have any testing equipment, but I will post results based of stock (internal times).
I hope the USB 3.0 makes this a fast game loading SOB.
 
Back
Top