octoberasian
2[H]4U
- Joined
- Oct 13, 2007
- Messages
- 4,081
Wholeheartedly agree with the article. Yes some may classify that as a sensationalist article, but lets look at the general direction the BIG OEMs are going towards:
smartphones
tablets
sleeksbooks
macbook airs
ultrabooks.
These are the computers that the majority of consumers want and buy. All of those devices are moving to get thinner, lighter, and faster. How does one get to that, you design parts that are unserviceable and sealed out of the box (look at the retina macbooks).
Yes will enthusiasts continue to clamor for modular sleek devices that they can tinker with; of course
Will the market slowly respond to the majority of consumers; Yes
Can both coexist; depends on the enthusiasts.
That and many of the ones you listed above have little to no replaceable parts.
Heck, Apple is notorious for this; you just have to look at the iFixit articles and their repairability ratings they give their iPads and iPhones, including laptops.
And, Intel's upcoming Broadwell is supposedly OEM, BGA-only for laptops-- it's also smaller than Haswell and has no on-die VRMs. It's not pin-compatible with Haswell.
The idea of not having a repairable PC means more money for OEMs. It means that they can force consumers to buy a new PC instead of repairing it. That, and as you said, as the mobile devices and PCs get more energy efficient and slimmer like a lot of ultrabooks and notebooks nowadays, it also means more and more proprietary parts to make the parts within them unreplaceable by consumers and unrepairable as well unless sent to the manufacturer for replacement or very limited repairs.
As sensationalist as the article is and seeing the market trend moving towards more and more mobile devices such as tablets, it becomes the inevitable future of computing. The enthusiast and custom PC market built by technically capable consumers become more and more of a niche market. I am sure companies like MSI, ASUS and Gigabyte make more money from proprietary OEM products than individual PC parts like motherboards. Look at Foxconn. They make the majority of nearly all of Apple's products. ASUS I believe makes most of the Nexus products for Google. OEMs are most likely reaping profits from proprietary, non-replaceable products and parts than selling the components individually. I'd imagine Intel will try to push towards BGA-only for most of its entry-level to mid-range products in the distant future while retaining high end midrange and high end processors in limited capacity for the future niche-enthusiast market.
It's literally all about the money. A lot of us on [H] and other PC enthusiast sites are more likely to be relics of a bygone PC era.