The President On The Section 215 Bulk Metadata Program

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
In a statement released earlier today, the president outlined his plan to end the bulk collection of phone records by the NSA.

Having carefully considered the available options, I have decided that the best path forward is that the government should not collect or hold this data in bulk. Instead, the data should remain at the telephone companies for the length of time it currently does today. The government would obtain the data pursuant to individual orders from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC) approving the use of specific numbers for such queries, if a judge agrees based on national security concerns. Legislation will be needed to permit the government to obtain this information with the speed and in the manner that will be required to make this approach workable.
 
If you like your privacy you can keep your privacy.

I totally believe President Obama since he's never lied to us.
 
Soooooo. They are still collecting it, just not aquiring it. No the private sector will store the data and sell your metadata to the highest bidder.

Next time you dial a repeated number a google ad will play on the phone before you are connected!!!
 
The crux of the matter is the data will now be stored at your phone company and your isp. This will save money on server time, space and power at the NSA and Google.

Same stuff, different day.:rolleyes:
 
It's BS. Even the NYT had an op-ed against this non-move; Obama has the executive power to end this, immediately. Instead he's punting it to a Congressional committee; basically, nothing will happen.
 
Instead he's punting it to a Congressional committee; basically, nothing will happen.

The he "punted it to a Congressional committee", is so he can spend the next election cycle blaming this all on the evil Republicans in congress.

Why fix something when you can use it as a club on the other guy?
 
It's BS. Even the NYT had an op-ed against this non-move; Obama has the executive power to end this, immediately. Instead he's punting it to a Congressional committee; basically, nothing will happen.

LOL if you think any president would do it differently. He's just a puppet for a party that is just a different head attached to the same beast. But at least it's getting bad enough that people might start actually doing something. Hopefully we aren't too far behind Egypt/Syria/Ukraine etc. We need to purge the existing corrupt assholes from power and start over.
 
Soooooo. They are still collecting it, just not aquiring it. No the private sector will store the data and sell your metadata to the highest bidder.

Next time you dial a repeated number a google ad will play on the phone before you are connected!!!

Ever looked at your own phone bill records through your provider's website? They already keep it all, and not just the last 5 years. I can go back 12 years on my current account...which is not to say they delete records after 12 years, just that before that I had a different provider.
 
Hopefully we aren't too far behind Egypt/Syria/Ukraine etc.

Egypt is currently run by the military and is executing the dissidents. Syria has been devastated by civil war. Ukraine is being invaded and conquered by Russia. You might want to rethink that sentiment. :eek:
 
Soooooo. They are still collecting it, just not aquiring it. No the private sector will store the data and sell your metadata to the highest bidder.

Noooo, they must stop acquiring it in 90 days. The private sector already had it and was previously required to keep it, that didn't change. But now, when the NSA drops a request the providers must respond much faster and give up the goods right away.

The difference is, since the NSA can't collect and store the bulk data they don't have the ability to search it for patterns and links in order to formulate their requests to the providers for additional data.
 
Ever looked at your own phone bill records through your provider's website? They already keep it all, and not just the last 5 years. I can go back 12 years on my current account...which is not to say they delete records after 12 years, just that before that I had a different provider.

There is a massive difference between storing calling records and storing the actual calls. No phone company is storing all the data for all your calls going back 12 years.
 
Expect a tax increase because now the govt has to pay for this data. Either way, the govt always gets what it wants. The tax revenue is just a bonus to them.
 
There is a massive difference between storing calling records and storing the actual calls. No phone company is storing all the data for all your calls going back 12 years.

Your right, but what's your point? The bulk meta-data program is the number doing the call, the number called, and the time and duration of the call, not a recording of the actual call itself.
 
Expect a tax increase because now the govt has to pay for this data. Either way, the govt always gets what it wants. The tax revenue is just a bonus to them.

They don't, he's wrong.
 
Basically a bunch of "I am very concerned and am going to change things" up front.
Then a bunch of "You guys handle this till it goes away." on the back end.

Translation: Typical OhBlahBlah political machine.

*Sigh*

NO! He CAN'T!
 
Wait, what day is today? Is today "Obama is a do-nothing powerless empty suit" day or is it "Obama is a power hungry executive ordering dictator who's takin muh freedums" day?

I always forget which one we're on.
 
And .... what about all the data you have collected SO FAR? Destroyed?

Up to 10 years of recordings, who what when where and the conversation ... a powerful chunk of our existence.
 
There is a massive difference between storing calling records and storing the actual calls. No phone company is storing all the data for all your calls going back 12 years.

This announcement is in reference to the storage location of Telephone METADATA, otherwise known as calling records, but not actual calls.

Obama's press release states the metadata should be retained by the telephone companies rather than the NSA. I was simply pointing out to the poster I quoted originally (who was concerned about the phone companies mining this new data trove) that the phone companies already retain all this data, and for far longer than the 5 years the NSA supposedly retains it.
 
Wait, what day is today? Is today "Obama is a do-nothing powerless empty suit" day or is it "Obama is a power hungry executive ordering dictator who's takin muh freedums" day?

I always forget which one we're on.

Ok attempt at defending him. I'll go to you next time I want to make distinctions between foreign policy and domestic policy.
 
This announcement is in reference to the storage location of Telephone METADATA, otherwise known as calling records, but not actual calls.

Obama's press release states the metadata should be retained by the telephone companies rather than the NSA. I was simply pointing out to the poster I quoted originally (who was concerned about the phone companies mining this new data trove) that the phone companies already retain all this data, and for far longer than the 5 years the NSA supposedly retains it.

Then abosolutely, that is correct. The programs NSA uses go beyond that, they also collect and store actual call data though.
 
The difference is, since the NSA can't collect and store the bulk data they don't have the ability to search it for patterns and links in order to formulate their requests to the providers for additional data.

Exactly. Hopefully he's not just blowing smoke, because this move will make it harder for them to fabricate probable cause.
 
Then abosolutely, that is correct. The programs NSA uses go beyond that, they also collect and store actual call data though.

Yes, but remember all the other programs the NSA uses to spy on your every communication are not addressed in this press release. PRISM, xKeyscore, MYSTIC ect ect.

This is like a poorly executed magic trick:
Look over here! We're doing something about your outrage about phone metadata collection!
Just ignore the fact that PRISM, XKeyscore, Tempora and myriad other programs collect every non-telephony electronic communication you make...
Now you can rest easy knowing the NSA has to search a remote rather than a local server for your telephone metadata, with the same rigorous FISC oversight as before.
 
Wait, what day is today? Is today "Obama is a do-nothing powerless empty suit" day or is it "Obama is a power hungry executive ordering dictator who's takin muh freedums" day?

I always forget which one we're on.

The dude with the monopolization of force in a geographical area can be powerless against those he purports to protect us from, while simultaneously being a tyrant within his sphere of influence.
 
Exactly. Hopefully he's not just blowing smoke, because this move will make it harder for them to fabricate probable cause.

Probable cause?

Where is that brick I focus on while beating my head against the wall?

ChockoMonkey, I am glad you see that things might go the way you feel is correct, but man I still worry about you and so many others. The NSA is an Intelligence Service, not Law Enforcement, they don't enforce laws, they don't need or care about probable cause. Probable Cause doesn't factor into anything they do. They watch, listen, analyze, and recommend courses of action to our Military Leadership. They don't do criminal activity. I find it hard to believe that after months you haven't adjusted to this concept.

The NSA does not do Law Enforcement, they are not cops, they are not looking for kiddie porn, copy-write violations, murders, cell phone thieves, non of that.

The NSA watches how armies fight and communicate, how governments communicate with their armies, how government funded education systems teach their people, how embassies talk to their presidents, how effective RADAR Systems are, do someone's military radios have encryption weaknesses, are radical Islamic groups linking up and working together, are the probes the Chinese just put on the moon really Scientific Probes or are they doing something else up there, how do they talk anyway, they might use the same command and control signal structure on an new weapon system, good to get a head start.

Can you see the difference yet?

I know I am focused on you at the moment, but you are a big boy and I know you are not the only one that keeps turning to this flawed angle when looking at this problem. I'm addressing others as well, it's not personal.
 
.... and the conversation
Jack, there has been no evidence to support this, non presented by Snowden, if you have a link to it I would really love to see it. What you have there is someone's guess about why the NSA was building that new Data Farm in Utah.

Again, if you have anything that supports this please post it because I have not seen it.
 
Same for you NoOther;
The programs NSA uses go beyond that, they also collect and store actual call data though.

Please point me in the direction because I have seen no proof of this, only wild guesses.
 
Probable cause?

Where is that brick I focus on while beating my head against the wall?

ChockoMonkey, I am glad you see that things might go the way you feel is correct, but man I still worry about you and so many others. The NSA is an Intelligence Service, not Law Enforcement, they don't enforce laws, they don't need or care about probable cause. Probable Cause doesn't factor into anything they do. They watch, listen, analyze, and recommend courses of action to our Military Leadership. They don't do criminal activity. I find it hard to believe that after months you haven't adjusted to this concept.

The NSA does not do Law Enforcement, they are not cops, they are not looking for kiddie porn, copy-write violations, murders, cell phone thieves, non of that.

The NSA watches how armies fight and communicate, how governments communicate with their armies, how government funded education systems teach their people, how embassies talk to their presidents, how effective RADAR Systems are, do someone's military radios have encryption weaknesses, are radical Islamic groups linking up and working together, are the probes the Chinese just put on the moon really Scientific Probes or are they doing something else up there, how do they talk anyway, they might use the same command and control signal structure on an new weapon system, good to get a head start.

Can you see the difference yet?

I know I am focused on you at the moment, but you are a big boy and I know you are not the only one that keeps turning to this flawed angle when looking at this problem. I'm addressing others as well, it's not personal.

I must have used the wrong terminology. All i was trying to say was that if they have to connect dots and only then request information, that's a lot better than having all the information with which to connect more dots that they otherwise wouldn't have been able to.

For instance, I have never done anything, to my knowledge, that would make them think me a terrorist. Except perhaps saying some shit during a phone call to a friend while we were bitching to each other about politics. If they that data, I could be put on a watch-list in an automated way.

Now, I still have doubts that this isn't going to happen anyway, but here's hopin'
 
Tempora is(Not an NSA program), a clandestine security electronic surveillance program tested in 2008,[2] established in 2011 and operated by the British Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ).

I hope xKeystore is a worldwide program because the NSA has a world wide mission, but no one has shown that it is used improperly against US Persons.
XKeyscore or XKEYSCORE (abbreviated as XKS) is a formerly secret computer system first used by the United States National Security Agency for searching and analyzing Internet data it collects worldwide every day.

MYSTIC, Same Song;
The National Security Agency has built a surveillance system capable of recording “100 percent” of a foreign country’s telephone calls, enabling the agency

And PRISM;
The Prism program collects stored Internet communications based on demands made to Internet companies such as Google Inc. and Apple Inc. under Section 702 of the FISA Amendments Act of 2008 to turn over any data that match court-approved search terms.

So AFTER they go to the FISA Court and get an approved request for data from a provider, then this data is store and accessed via PRISM. Well I guess they had to call it something. But is stored data that has been turned over to the NSA by Court Order, Subpoena, or other approved form of request, considered a "mass surveillance program". I'll leave it up to you to decide all on your own.
 
Now if you guys have a link to a report where these programs have been used on US Persons without any proper justification or procedure, please point it out because I haven't seen it.
 
Same for you NoOther;


Please point me in the direction because I have seen no proof of this, only wild guesses.

No. You can believe its conjecture if you want, but there has been plenty of supporting evidence of this. Especially press releases and information from the WH itself. For instance, there was the information leak that the US government had communications from the 911 terrorists detailing their plans to crash into various targets in the US. Gee, I wonder how those communications were obtained? There is also the very common knowledge that has been admitted too frequently that the US gov't actively collects communication data for known terrorists.
 
/repost,

"Edward Snowden: Here's how we take back the Internet" http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yVwAodrjZMY

Published on Mar 18, 2014 by TED Talks


Appearing by telepresence robot, Edward Snowden speaks at TED2014 about surveillance and Internet freedom. The right to data privacy, he suggests, is not a partisan issue, but requires a fundamental rethink of the role of the internet in our lives — and the
laws that protect it. "Your rights matter," he say, "because you never know when you're going to need them." Chris Anderson interviews, with special guest Tim Berners-Lee.

Two days later,


"Richard Ledgett: The NSA responds to Edward Snowden's TED Talk " http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zLNXIXingyU

Published on Mar 20, 2014 by TED Talks



After a surprise appearance by Edward Snowden at TED2014, Chris Anderson said: "If the NSA wants to respond, please do." And yes, they did. Appearing by video, NSA deputy director Richard Ledgett answers Anderson's questions about the balance between security and protecting privacy.
 
CholoMonkey, I like you better every day.
For instance, I have never done anything, to my knowledge, that would make them think me a terrorist. Except perhaps saying some shit during a phone call to a friend while we were bitching to each other about politics. If they that data, I could be put on a watch-list in an automated way.
This is what many people want us to be afraid of. We should be afraid of this. You are right to be concerned and we are right to stand up and pay attention when someone says this is what is happening or could happen. If we don't look out for ourselves sure as hell no one else will.

[/QUOTE]Now, I still have doubts that this isn't going to happen anyway, but here's hopin' [/QUOTE]

Me too, right there with you Brother. When much of this started with the Patriot Act I found myself listening to both sides, the Bush Administration and the Privacy Right's group. I know the government and the privacy guys are always going round and round on things. I wondered then If I should have something to worry about. I asked myself if these changes were something that could be reversed if they proved a bad idea and I decided that as long as we retain the power to change it back then we could afford to see where it takes us and what is done with it.

Well here we are, several years later and Snowden has pulled a lot of Skeletons out of the closet. There first thing that catches my eye, once you got passed the initial information and releases from Snowden, all US media coverage stopped except for linking to foreign coverage, The Guardian and Der Speigle are the only ones that drop "releases", and then there are articles from Industry Specialists and such who have collect this stuff and researched it to come up with more comprehensive pieces. But where have you seen anything from a US Media Source that wasn't just an oped piece or something related to the political struggle itself. It sure wasn't US Media releasing new dirt about an NSA tactic we hadn't heard of before.

Some might think it's pressure from the Government, it probably is, I mean besides the fact that it's the foreign guys Snowden gave this stuff to, it makes sense the government would try to get our own news guys to be careful. Like I have been saying, the new releases over the last few months haven't had anything in them that directly impacts US Privacy concerns. But they have been damaging releases, the kind a US Citizen would go to jail for. The kind Edward Snowden might go to jail for. But in truth, they do not show anything more then how clever the NSA is when it comes to doing the job we pay them to do, what they are meant to do.

Now I will hit "Post" and see how much other stuff people have said while I typed another book.
 
No. You can believe its conjecture if you want, but there has been plenty of supporting evidence of this

Nooo. Show me the links to the documents and releases that you believe support your statements. Don't be too lazy, look it up and point it out please. Really I want you to show me because I want to be correct in my beliefs and what I tell you guys.

I don't want to win, I want to be real. I am in the same boat with you guys, if I am wrong then I need to know so I can channel my effort at the right target.
 
Back
Top