The Internet is NOT Killing You

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The internet is NOT killing you. I repeat, the internet is NOT killing you. Matter o' fact, it might actually be good for some of us.

According to the report, "Living with chronic disease is also associated, once someone is online, with a greater likelihood to access user-generated health content such as blog posts, hospital reviews, doctor reviews, and podcasts. These resources allow an internet user to dive deeply into a health topic, using the internet as a communications tool, not simply an information vending machine."
 
I don't know about anybody else here, but the one thing that my doctor always tells me is to stay as far away as you can from the internet "medical" sector. Self diagnosis can easily lead to panic and paranoia.

But, in the abstract, information is free and maybe there are a few out there that will learn something from these resources. Just don't self diagnose.
 
After i broke my radial head (part of the elbow). There were a few websites that really helped me out. More than physical therapy for sure.
 
Yeah, of course doctors will say that. They are masters of the art of defense medicine and shun any and all forms of alternative medicine that can work. Sometimes a change in diet is all that's needed. Yet some doctors are horrible dietitians.

There is a lot of bad information out on the internet. But also if your wise and careful of what you read, you can find a lot of good info too. Not everyone has awesome insurance. There's a lot of questions people aren't willing to pay a $200 visit for. Sometimes it's better that we take care of ourselves.

It's also good to come to the doctor informed, because some doctors either just want the money or the doctor doesn't understand your specific problem. Doctors are less likely to attempt to pull wool over eyes if they see that you're informed. If you're more informed, you're more likely to obey the doctors orders if it's sound advice. You're also better at picking better doctors if you're informed.

Go internet! Doctors shouldn't have a monopoly on medical understanding.


Just some of my rambling thoughts....
 
Good post Par, through the internet I have learned that my one of my favorite food ingredients can cure ear infections(garlic and it does it wicket fast). And a whole list of other natural remedies for things, fuck doctors they are only good at treating a symptom in most cases and they never look at something as a whole.
 
This is why I love the modern world. One guy claims the internet is making us dumber, then someone else says no, it's making us smarter. Can't wait for Round 2.
 
Long live the Internet, I would be bored without the Internet, its the best invention ever ;-) has long they make it more faster, more secured and cheaper, I am a happy customer.
 
I would much rather have the interwebbie out to harm me, that way I know it is.

Other than that people just need to use common sense.
 
there's bad information and but also tons of good information, you just need common sense when doing your research.
 
Yeah, of course doctors will say that. They are masters of the art of defense medicine and shun any and all forms of alternative medicine that can work.

"By definition alternative medicine has either not been proven to work, or been proven not to work. Do you know what they call alternative medicine that has been proven to work? Medicine."

I'm not saying you're wrong, just be careful with accepting "alternative medicine." Once the science is done, and it's been proven to work, it is no longer alternative.

BTW - A healthy diet is not part of alternative medicine.
 
"By definition alternative medicine has either not been proven to work, or been proven not to work. Do you know what they call alternative medicine that has been proven to work? Medicine."

I'm not saying you're wrong, just be careful with accepting "alternative medicine." Once the science is done, and it's been proven to work, it is no longer alternative.

BTW - A healthy diet is not part of alternative medicine.

I don't care about the definition of "alternative," but herbs and such can be considered alternative medicine. Treating your problem comes down to this: what works for one person doesn't do anything for the other because our body is unique and complex. Green tea will do jack squat for some, but for others it make a big difference with certain problems. Infact, green tea might be a problem for others. The best medicine is knowing your own body and what your unique body responds to. Sometimes the doctor has the best solution, and sometimes the doctor won't do the best solution because it's considered "alternative." And a lot of good methods aren't yet known to be "proven" methods.
 
I don't care about the definition of "alternative," but herbs and such can be considered alternative medicine. Treating your problem comes down to this: what works for one person doesn't do anything for the other because our body is unique and complex. Green tea will do jack squat for some, but for others it make a big difference with certain problems. Infact, green tea might be a problem for others. The best medicine is knowing your own body and what your unique body responds to. Sometimes the doctor has the best solution, and sometimes the doctor won't do the best solution because it's considered "alternative." And a lot of good methods aren't yet known to be "proven" methods.

Sigh. It really does come down to what you define as "alternative." Once we know that something works, it is no longer alternative. If we don't know it works, why do it?

You can leave yourself open to the snake oil salesmen. I make the other choice. As our knowledge of the human system expands the charlatans will continue to be pushed further and further to the fringes. I'm ok with that.

Herbs - some taste good, some have been turned into medicine. I'm not quite sure what you're getting at. Green tea - I think green tastes better than black. I'm not a big fan of either, but why all of the hullabaloo about green? It's the same plant, wouldn't you get a lot of the same chemicals from both?

There are no panaceas. Anything billed as a "cure-all" isn't. We don't need to be sold all of the supplements and the juice of whatever the vogue berry of the month happens to be. Much of alternative medicine is simply the unscrupulous trying to make a buck off of the undiscerning.

All I want is to be shown why, how and that a "treatment" works.

We are not unique snowflakes. We synthesize vitamins the same way We metabolize proteins and fats the same way. The processes and systems of our bodies are based on the same chemistry and reactions. Our physiology and anatomy is virtually identical. Sure, we're still learning. We're far from knowing everything, yet as our knowledge grows we are learning more and more about the causes and treatment of disease.

It's better than the alternative.
 
I understand your concern, and you'll never find me buy the next super vodoo cure all from Mr. snake oil salesman. I've never bought anything more than supplements for myself. Those most extreme thing I have tried is grapefruit seed extract has worked wonders for me with colds.

And of course there isn't a "cure-all." I'll make satires of the new vogue "wonder berry" of the month with you. What I am saying is that we are unique. Some people have deficiencies that need remedied. Some people need blood thinner, while others need blood "thickener". Outside the realm of alternative, different drugs "work" on some people while they don't "work" on others. Some people absorb protein well, while others might have reactions to it. Different treatments for different patients.

My point is, we are unique and if something new only treats certain people, it only does so because don't yet fully understand it. It's not yet considered "proper" medicine until we understand it. I'm just saying there's nothing wrong with trying alternative methods so long as there is no health risk concerns. Some things work and many other things don't work. Just like repeated visits to the doctor, which can be a long process of trial and error.
 
. What I am saying is that we are unique. Some people have deficiencies that need remedied. Some people need blood thinner, while others need blood "thickener".

This is what real doctors prescribe actual blood thinners and thickeners for.

Outside the realm of alternative, different drugs "work" on some people while they don't "work" on others. Some people absorb protein well, while others might have reactions to it. Different treatments for different patients.

This is how real medicine works.

My point is, we are unique and if something new only treats certain people, it only does so because don't yet fully understand it. It's not yet considered "proper" medicine until we understand it. I'm just saying there's nothing wrong with trying alternative methods so long as there is no health risk concerns.

There ARE health risk concerns. Hell, alternative medicine used to advocate smoking as a DIY remedy to some illnesses. People that aren't professionally trained and that have been exposed to the science of it have all the right to experiment on themselves if they have no regard for their own health - but don't you DARE go posting online where others may follow and get fucked up by these quack' recommendations.

You keep talking about herbs and such, but I don't think you realize this - oftentimes the only difference between "herbal" or "diy home remedies" and professional medicines is tightly controlled dosages, timed delivery methods, and other various ingredients that enhance and activate the ingredients to make them more professional.

As Decibel touched on, if something truly works, it is no longer "alternative" and is integrated into professional medicine. People that enjoy playing doctor and post such information online should be criminally prosecuted, imho.

Speaking as someone who's mother has MS and whose life has been made truly worse by "alternative medicine".
 
This is what real doctors prescribe actual blood thinners and thickeners for.



This is how real medicine works.



There ARE health risk concerns. Hell, alternative medicine used to advocate smoking as a DIY remedy to some illnesses. People that aren't professionally trained and that have been exposed to the science of it have all the right to experiment on themselves if they have no regard for their own health - but don't you DARE go posting online where others may follow and get fucked up by these quack' recommendations.

You keep talking about herbs and such, but I don't think you realize this - oftentimes the only difference between "herbal" or "diy home remedies" and professional medicines is tightly controlled dosages, timed delivery methods, and other various ingredients that enhance and activate the ingredients to make them more professional.

As Decibel touched on, if something truly works, it is no longer "alternative" and is integrated into professional medicine. People that enjoy playing doctor and post such information online should be criminally prosecuted, imho.

Speaking as someone who's mother has MS and whose life has been made truly worse by "alternative medicine".

meant to say "more effective", not "more professional".
 
My mother would be dead now without the internet.

She was diagnosed with a rare blood disorder about 10 to 15 years ago. I did whatever passed for internet search then (it wasn't Google), got her going on a listserv which communicated between patients and the doctors who were working on treating it, and from that she got information and treatment that her doctor had no way of knowing about or obtaining. Without that treatment, she would have been dead in 5 years; today she is healthy and travelling all over the country.
 
My mother would be dead now without the internet.

She was diagnosed with a rare blood disorder about 10 to 15 years ago. I did whatever passed for internet search then (it wasn't Google), got her going on a listserv which communicated between patients and the doctors who were working on treating it, and from that she got information and treatment that her doctor had no way of knowing about or obtaining. Without that treatment, she would have been dead in 5 years; today she is healthy and travelling all over the country.

++

Doctors are not God.

I have a chronic medical condition called ulcerative colitis. I've seen four doctors and they all have nothing to offer by way of treatment other than 3 or 4 classes of drug. They dismiss alternative treatments out of hand. While some drugs work for some people, they don't work for all people, and some of them have nasty side effects.

Through my own research, using my own brain, and finding forums of other people who have this disease, I discovered a solution that is not a drug per se, but essentially a concoction of billions of bacteria. It's been tested and proven effective in double-randomized clinical controlled trials and a few doctors know about it, but most are clueless. Without getting into great detail, let's just say that it makes perfect sense that it would work.

So after seven years of dealing with this condition, I've finally found a solution that makes me about 90% normal. Had I simply relied on doctors, I'd still be in pain.
 
This is what real doctors prescribe actual blood thinners and thickeners for.



This is how real medicine works.



There ARE health risk concerns. Hell, alternative medicine used to advocate smoking as a DIY remedy to some illnesses. People that aren't professionally trained and that have been exposed to the science of it have all the right to experiment on themselves if they have no regard for their own health - but don't you DARE go posting online where others may follow and get fucked up by these quack' recommendations.

You keep talking about herbs and such, but I don't think you realize this - oftentimes the only difference between "herbal" or "diy home remedies" and professional medicines is tightly controlled dosages, timed delivery methods, and other various ingredients that enhance and activate the ingredients to make them more professional.

As Decibel touched on, if something truly works, it is no longer "alternative" and is integrated into professional medicine. People that enjoy playing doctor and post such information online should be criminally prosecuted, imho.

Speaking as someone who's mother has MS and whose life has been made truly worse by "alternative medicine".

I'm sorry for the suffering of your mother. And yes, SOME people should be prosecuting for being dangerous alternative medicine cowboys. But, you're speaking in very broad and generalized terms. SOME of alternative medicine is quackery, just like SOME of doctor's recommendations. It takes a lot of research and learning from other people who know their stuff in order to be wise about what you listen too. Same goes for who you chose to listen to. Forums tend to be better places to learn rather than from websites who are pushing to sell their miracle pills for big $'s. With forums if someone comes up with a bad idea, it usually gets shot down by someone who knows their stuff.

"Alternative" is not synonymous with "does not work." I'd be more inclined to say that "Alternative" is more close to "New and relatively undiscovered." It's like trail blazing. Yet in all actuality, sometimes "new knowledge" is actually old knowledge forgotten. Or only small circles of people know about it as mentioned above. Medicine is always discovering "new" things that worked for people a 1000 years ago.

Doctors are definitely far from Gods. Their approaches can really mess up your body bad too.
 
"Alternative" is not synonymous with "does not work." I'd be more inclined to say that "Alternative" is more close to "New and relatively undiscovered." It's like trail blazing. Yet in all actuality, sometimes "new knowledge" is actually old knowledge forgotten. Or only small circles of people know about it as mentioned above. Medicine is always discovering "new" things that worked for people a 1000 years ago.

Give me one case.

I'll agree with you, alternative does not mean does not work. It means has not been proven to work.

You missed something critical in the story above:
It's been tested and proven effective in double-randomized clinical controlled trials...

No one here is saying that doctors are gods. They aren't omniscient beings with a knowledge off all that can go wrong in a human body. They are men and women doing what they can with the knowledge and experience they have. Some are good, some aren't.

There is a saying, "When you hear hoofbeats, think horses not zebras." Rare conditions are hard to diagnose and hard to treat. That doesn't mean we should start accepting the spurious claims of alternative medicine.

So far you've brought up alternative medicine, herbs, green tea, and grapefruit seed extract. You're not making a very good case that you'll "make satires of the new vogue "wonder berry" of the month..." with me, and that you haven't already "...[bought] the next super voodoo cure all from Mr. snake oil salesman."

Just spend a couple of minutes reading the actual studies done about grapefruit seed extract. Start at the NIH -> http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10399191

...It is concluded that the potent as well as nearly universal antimicrobial activity being attributed to grapefruit seed extract is merely due to the synthetic preservative agents contained within. Natural products with antimicrobial activity do not appear to be present.

There are a couple of things about alternative medicine that scares the crap out of me. For one, a lot of proponents push this idea that there is some conspiracy keeping these supposed cures down. I've heard everyone from the FDA to big pharma blamed. These people are ignorant of the way that real science works. Second, a lot of this crap has been studied and been proven to have no more effect than a placebo. It doesn't stand up to the claims made on it's behalf. Some of it has been proven to not only have no effect, but to have deleterious effects and to interact badly with real medicine.


* * * * *

Matrices and evilsofa, great stories. This is what the internet is for, spreading knowledge and getting it to the people that need it.


And porn. :D
 
Give me one case.

Sorry, I should stop you. This is a trap.

There are a couple of possible outcomes:

1 - You come up with a medicine derived from a natural source and have the studies to back it up... Not alternative.

2 - You come up with something that only has anecdotal evidence... Not shown to work. You'll need more evidence to support your claims.
 
First you have to honestly define "alternative." If you define it simply to mean "quack garbage", then obviously you have done nothing but establish a tautology.

There are some naturally occurring extracts and herbs that have a remedial or therapeutic effect. Fish oil, whether in capsule or regular form, is widely recognized as beneficial for reducing triglycerides (in high doses) and anti-inflammatory and pro-heart health effects (in lower doses). There are other natural remedies that have been proven in some studies to work as well as certain drugs or enhanced the effect of regular drugs (such as boswelia).

You don't have to be a conspiracy theorist to recognize that there is a built-in disincentive for companies to tout the efficacy of natural medicines, or to do research that shows their usefulness. They can't be patented and sold at exorbitant prices unlike researched, proprietary drugs.
 
First you have to honestly define "alternative." If you define it simply to mean "quack garbage", then obviously you have done nothing but establish a tautology.

My definition of alternative medicine is on the first page. It is "medicine" that has not been shown to work.

Does this make it quack garbage? By and large, absolutely.

Is this a tautology? Maybe, but it's not my tautology.

There are some naturally occurring extracts and herbs that have a remedial or therapeutic effect. Fish oil, whether in capsule or regular form, is widely recognized as beneficial for reducing triglycerides (in high doses) and anti-inflammatory and pro-heart health effects (in lower doses). There are other natural remedies that have been proven in some studies to work as well as certain drugs or enhanced the effect of regular drugs (such as boswelia).
Fish oil - There are known benefits of Omega-3 fatty acids. Not alternative.

Will you see me taking it in capsule form? Not bloody likely.

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2010/03/03/BARO1C9RD3.DTL

I do like sushi though. Mmmm....

Boswellia - I'm not too familiar, but there is some interesting research going on. Who knows? Maybe this will lead to a new class of drugs like study of willow led the the salicylates, Aspirin being the prime example.

I did find a study relating to colitis and boswellia, here: http://ajpgi.physiology.org/cgi/content/full/288/4/G798

A couple of notable quotes, first from the abstract:

In summary, boswellia does not ameliorate symptoms of colitis in chemically induced murine models and, in higher doses, may become hepatotoxic.
So in mice, doesn't work on chemically induced colitis, and might mess up your liver.

And from the discussion:

Patients actively seek credible information on complementary therapies from various sources. Most frequently, physicians, pharmacists, and pharmacy technicians are not adequately equipped to provide satisfactory advice, largely because of a scarcity of peer-reviewed scientific information on this subject. Patients are therefore often left to turn to herbal supplement manufacturers' advertising, leading to a number of prevalent misconceptions and myths, such as that herbs are equally or more effective and have fewer side effects than conventional pharmaceuticals, or that being natural, they are pure and can be taken safely without consulting a physician. Many consumers do not realize that herbal products do not undergo the same scrutiny from the Food and Drug Administration as do conventional medications and that herbal product manufacturers are not required to demonstrate the safety or efficacy of an herb before marketing it.

One such herbal medication widely advertised as being effective in reducing the symptoms of ulcerative colitis and other inflammatory conditions (osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, bursitis, asthma) is B. serrata, or more precisely, an alcoholic extract from the gummy oleoresin. Boswellia is typically referred to as generally safe when used as directed, with rare side effects such as diarrhea, skin rash, and nausea. Determining the reported doses of boswellia and their direct comparison with our experimental model is complicated by the fact that the methods used to obtain them, as well as the composition of the extracts, are never disclosed and are bound to vary greatly not only between manufacturers but also among lots.
I know that one is long, but it hits a lot of my issues with the supplement market.

You don't have to be a conspiracy theorist to recognize that there is a built-in disincentive for companies to tout the efficacy of natural medicines, or to do research that shows their usefulness. They can't be patented and sold at exorbitant prices unlike researched, proprietary drugs.
You don't have to be a conspiracy theorist to recognize that there is a built in incentive for companies to taut the efficacy of "natural medicines," sold without doing any research to back up their claims, without any oversight from the FDA, and no standards or controls in place with regard to efficacy or purity. They don't have to be patented and are sold at exorbitant prices.

Why does "Big Pharma" get smeared when other companies with non-existent R&D or QA departments, that exist purely on marketing, get a pass? It is not logically consistent.

It's not only the pharmaceutical companies doing research anyway. Universities around the world run studies. The NIH and other organizations give out grants. The fact is, if a claim is made about something, you have to be able to back it up.

I see alternative medicine like this - What if I told you I could ride like Valentino Rossi? You'd tell me to prove it. That's what I'm saying to the charlatans and quacks making money in this gray area of unproven "medicine." Prove it.
 
Back
Top