The Difference Between Choice and Consequence in Games

Nice video, and unfortunately the vast majority of games that claim they are choice-based games are actually consequence-based (according to the description given by this video). I have always hated this and complained about it, but I have never seen it given a name and specific description like this video does. It drives me crazy when RPGs or other supposedly choice-focused games give you no hint/info that a certain choice will have a completely unexpected negative consequence. The player should be rewarded for finding, identifying, and thinking about the relevant information and making a thoughtful choice based on how you are role-playing.

Instead, a lot of games end up having random consequences to everything you do, making you either give up on the game is it nothing you do matters (Walking Dead, i'm looking at you...though in that game there was no consequence either, nothing you did actually changed anything of significance) or tediously replay large parts of the game with the "correct" choice. I am not arguing for what Mass Effect has, where you are told which is the good choice and which is the bad...but I am saying that thinking/planning should be rewarded if you were/are good at it. But in most games, that is not the case.
 
It drives me crazy when RPGs or other supposedly choice-focused games give you no hint/info that a certain choice will have a completely unexpected negative consequence. The player should be rewarded for finding, identifying, and thinking about the relevant information and making a thoughtful choice based on how you are role-playing.

I don't know the names, but I do recall some having hints in other parts of the game as to what choice would be right. You just have to remember (or back in the day, we took notes and shit in a notebook) which one is which. "The white box is the true box" or some crap. Then, hours later, you have a choice of boxes, the white one included. You're given a choice, and the one of many boxes is the right one.
 
It's also nice when your choices have consequences, as opposed to choices that all lead to the same conclusion and consequences that are born from some vague presentation.
 
I liked the choice between "Rescuing" or "Harvesting" the Little Sisters in Bioshock ... the choice was stark and both resulted in valid game play

Baldur's Gate 2 also had some nice choices, especially in the romance quests, and a number of the choices had irrevocable consequences

Fallout 3 did a nice job with some of the "Good" vs "Evil" choices although since both had consequences ultimately it was really more of a question of game play preferences ... trying to play a "Neutral" path was an extremely difficult choice since you were locked out of so many things you had to make a very conscious choice to do it
 
I think the Chrono Trigger part kinda made it clear I was in disagreement with the video. I liked how those minor choices triggered consequences later on in the game, it made the experience more enjoyable and humorous, and I appreciated the touch. Also I liked not knowing how a minor decision I made in passing affected something (even if minor) down the line, it was unexpected and that was part of the charm.

I don't care if it's a choice or "consequence" in a game, both can add to the fun imho.
 
In Wing Commander IV, toward the end of the game, you had a serious choice to make. There was a star base with over 10,000 civilians on it, but also with heavy military presence that you had to decide on how to deal with. Choice A was to use a weapon that would destroy the base, but allow you to proceed unopposed through the system. Choice B was to not use the weapon and attempt instead to sneak past the base, but you would face heavy resistance going through the system. There was no "right" or "wrong" - neither choice prevented you from actually winning the game, but your character's personality and nature at the end of the game as revealed in the game's epilogue was influenced heavily by that one choice. There's also a choice very early in the game where you are offered a chance to help someone out, or to take a hard line and try to straighten him out. How you treat the guy early on influences how he'll behave when he's encountered later on. If you're nice to him he helps you out. If you're a jerk he clams up and you have to do things the hard way. You were offered choices that had both an immediate result and a late consequence. I do think it's kind of strange that they're just now discussing this sort of thing when it's been around in game design for years though.
 
One of the things i loved about the fallout 1 and 2 games, were that not only did your choices throughout the game effect how the world related to you (through reputation and karma), but after the end of the game, there was a synopsis of how that play through effected the world.

Some simple things you did early on you never got to see the consequences of, as your character had already moved on past that game area. But the follow up gave you an nonjudgmental "this is how your actions effected the world." The first time i finished FO1, i was blown away by this, as this was the first time a game had ever bothered to tell me "your act of saving X resulted in the village of Y flourishing and becoming a beacon of civilization in the wastelands."

Now, that had no effect on the game play, but it sure as hell effected my remembrance OF that game play. That minor skirmish at the beginning of the game had a major impact, not necessarily on me or the game, but on the game world itself. And that didn't even need to be addressed in game, there would have been no point. But it sure felt good after the fact!
 
In Wing Commander IV, toward the end of the game, you had a serious choice to make. There was a star base with over 10,000 civilians on it, but also with heavy military presence that you had to decide on how to deal with. Choice A was to use a weapon that would destroy the base, but allow you to proceed unopposed through the system. Choice B was to not use the weapon and attempt instead to sneak past the base, but you would face heavy resistance going through the system. There was no "right" or "wrong" - neither choice prevented you from actually winning the game, but your character's personality and nature at the end of the game as revealed in the game's epilogue was influenced heavily by that one choice. There's also a choice very early in the game where you are offered a chance to help someone out, or to take a hard line and try to straighten him out. How you treat the guy early on influences how he'll behave when he's encountered later on. If you're nice to him he helps you out. If you're a jerk he clams up and you have to do things the hard way. You were offered choices that had both an immediate result and a late consequence. I do think it's kind of strange that they're just now discussing this sort of thing when it's been around in game design for years though.

It's similar to the Little Sisters choice in Bioshock ... if you harvested them you got more of a boost at the start (but it was the evil choice and gave you the evil ending) ... if you rescued them you had a tougher go at the beginning because of the lower Adam but you received bonuses throughout the game (since the rescued sisters would leave you gifts) and there was a special Plasmid that was only available to the rescuer ... and of course it resulted in the good ending ... both routes made for a playable experience (although the good route was easier in the boss battle because of your "helpers") :cool:
 
Back
Top