The definitive good cheap 24"-26"

nabziF

n00b
Joined
Dec 31, 2008
Messages
2
It seems that for general use (some games/movies/internet etc), the consensus for best inexpensive 24" is still the Benq G2400WD, right? It seems to be consistently rated higher (or at least as high) across the board than pretty much any other 24" TN, for all-around use. Or are there any new models that best it?

But I've found much less consensus on inexpensive 26" models, which is not surprising since they are less common than 24". Can anyone familiar with most/all of the currently available 26" displays please weigh in on what looks to be the best all-around model right now (without spending a small fortune)? Some think that TN is a bad idea for this size, but others seem to really enjoy their 26" TNs...

I've been searching these forums and the internet for weeks and I'm started to suffer from information overload. So here's basically what I'm looking for:

Required
1920x1200
24" or 26" (I've read that some consider the dot pitch optimal on 26", and my eyes aren't getting any sharper with age, though I reckon 28" would be a bit excessive)
Non-stretched "aspect" scaling, preferably with low lag (for older games that require 4:3 ratios); also 1:1 pixel mapping, such as for 1080 stuff​

Preferred
Cheap!
Relatively low input lag and refresh (although it's hard for me to know if I'd even notice high lag until I use one)
Relatively low Backlight bleed
Decent Black level/color accuracy (I don't really want to buy a colorimeter; I'd rather have at least somewhat accurate colors out of the box if possible)
Normal Gamut; I'm less sure about this, but from what I've read I think I'd prefer to avoid the headaches of wide gamut at least until software and hardware has matured to better accomodate it; even though I don't edit photo/video for a living, I like knowing that what I'm looking at is somewhat close to what was originally intended; I predict wider and wider gamuts in the future (much like how we've already progressed from monochrome, 16, 256, and thousands of colors), but I'll let the early adopters suffer the growing pains; maybe one day when the bits are increased throughout the entire system to allow for higher gamut without unintended oversaturation..
Modest Brightness; I'll be using it in a relatively dim area, so I don't want something that is so blindingly bright that it looks like crap when I turn it down to a pain-free brightness level
Glossy/Matte doesn't matter much (my desk is in the basement with no bright lights behind me anyway)​

If it seems most of the above seems to describe IPS more than TN, well the G2400WD seems to score well enough in all those areas, and it's TN. It's too bad there isn't some all-inclusive ratings list; Consumer Reports and consumersearch.com are both woefully incomplete and/or outdated. Anandtech's LCD Thread is probably the best list for ratings, but it too is incomplete. There are quite a few models for sale that are seldom mentioned even in these forums, good or bad (el-cheapo brands like KDS, I-Inc, Sceptre). So there might be some underrated diamonds in the rough out there, but I don't really want to be the guinea pig.

So I guess what I'm ultimately asking here is, given the above info, is the G2400WD overall the best 24" for my needs? And what would the best 26" be for my needs?

Thanks!


(Just a quick note of what I'm upgrading from: a 7 year old Apple Studio Display. From what I can find, this used an antiquated type of panel technology known as Advanced Coplanar Electrode (ACE). Apparently it was pretty good quality in its day, maybe closest current day equivalent would be IPS? Dunno. I figure 6+ years of TN development since then has allowed it to catch up a bit in quality. I'll give TN a try, and only spend more $ if I absolutely hate it, but I think I'll be satisfied.)
 
I think you're going to run into the classic engineering dilemma: you can have any two of fast, cheap, and good. All the good 24" monitors are expensive.
 
What do you consider "cheap"? How much are you willing to spend?
 
I think you're going to run into the classic engineering dilemma: you can have any two of fast, cheap, and good. All the good 24" monitors are expensive.

Well from what I've read, I'd consider that Benq good...of course different people have different definitions of "good"...

What do you consider "cheap"? How much are you willing to spend?

I'd consider most of the TN's cheap ($350 give or take). But double the cost just for some better color and wider viewing angle doesn't seem very cheap to me.

Coming from a ACD, you may want to look into this one...

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B001FS1LLI/

...not really "cheap", but a great deal for a 24" IPS.
Yeah if I wanted to spend $600 on a display and wanted wide gamut, that one does seem highly regarded. But I was looking cheaper and standard gamut. The TNs i've seen in the store haven't seem too terrible (of course I should probably check in more detail, perhaps some video to see if any dithering will make me hurl).
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Coming from a ACD, you may want to look into this one...

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B001FS1LLI/

...not really "cheap", but a great deal for a 24" IPS.

I just ordered that yesterday. It's an H-IPS, amazing quality, best colors, and a great price for an IPS panel. Probably can't do better than that HP.

Also, I believe the HP is 92% NTSC colour gamut according to several websites such as this one. HP's website, however, reports 102% for that model. The colors are stunning nevertheless.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Back
Top