The CrunchPad Is DOA

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
If this story is accurate, Michael Arrington got majorly hosed in this deal. Cue the lawyers in 3 – 2 – 1.

Chandra said that based on pressure from his shareholders he had decided to move forward and sell the device directly through Fusion Garage, without our involvement. Err, what? This is the equivalent of Foxconn, who build the iPhone, notifying Apple a couple of days before launch that they’d be moving ahead and selling the iPhone directly without any involvement from Apple.
 
Wow that sucks.

Should be fun to see how the shareholders like it when they are pulled into a lawsuit over this. You have to wonder if Chandra explained to them that they don't own the rights to the device thus they can't sell it on their own, of if they just thought that they could take it and sell it anyway.
 
I was kind of looking forward to this device. At least we know definitively that corporate greed and stupidity isn't rampant solely in the US.
 
Yeah I was looking forward to this device but the more I use Windows 7 on my tx2 with its multi-touch capability as well as being a Windows 7 laptop I being to see less use for a standalone device.
 
Shouldve listened to the 48 laws of power, Rule 2 to be exact "never put too much trust in friends, learn how to use enemies" -Robert Greene
 
Hmmm sounds like a profitable business model... let other do all the thinking and testing and then steal the product as your own.... Also, corporate greed goes as far as the morals of those in charge and these days many corporate leaders are just as corrupt and greedy as political leaders.... regardless of country/nation.
 
I'm confused about what TechCrunch brought to the project beside the name. Fusion Garage is creating the software, this other company is designing and producing the hardware, what did Arrington and his team bring to the table beside the name? I don't think it was funding since his article says that he was turning investors down until they released it..

I'm not saying that this doesn't suck and isn't shady, because it seems like it is. I'm just saying that it seems like they might have got shut out for not actually contributing anything of worth to the project.
 
Arrington pretty much helped finance the whole debacle. A team from TechCrunch also worked on the project full time with some of the people from Fusion Garage. Sounds like it was a 50/50 type of deal.

I also read that Arrington was a lawyer type in his previous occupation???

If Arrington is FoS this story will drop away quickly, if he is telling it how it is this is going to get VERY interesting.
 
"...In other words, your “counter” offer is theft of intellectual property.”

Are those stockholder dumb as sh!t?!
 
I'm confused about what TechCrunch brought to the project beside the name. Fusion Garage is creating the software, this other company is designing and producing the hardware, what did Arrington and his team bring to the table beside the name? I don't think it was funding since his article says that he was turning investors down until they released it..

I'm not saying that this doesn't suck and isn't shady, because it seems like it is. I'm just saying that it seems like they might have got shut out for not actually contributing anything of worth to the project.

The name and the product. They didn't do all the work themselves, but they came up with the idea of the device, designed what they wanted then teamed up with Rusion Garage and Chandra to help make it.

You can come up with a great idea but you aren't always going to have the stuff onhand to actually make it. That is where you outsource parts of the project and have somebody else make that parts.

Just look at Apple like the example given. Apple doesn't build the iPhone. They came up with the idea and design and handed it over to somebody to actually build it. The same thing happened here. Arrington came up with the idea and everything, and pulled in two companies to help build the device. I would expect them to be funding the project to some regards also, maybe they just had enough money to keep afloat for right now want to hold off on getting too many investors up front. The article stated that they were waiting to cut down on risk. Which in a way makes sense, had they took all this money from all these groups they would not be in a position to pay it back. This way they aren't in such a position.
 
there is a major difference between this and the iphone/ipod.

Apple designed all of the software and hardware specs for the iphone. then they contacted foxconn for assembly.

tech crunch didn't. i'm fairly confident that tech crunch didn't just have a handful of engineers working on the specs, designing the motherboard, bios, hardware components for this.

they should have went to a big ODM, and have them work with them on the design, to prevent this from happening, or hired their own engineers, or even have something written in contract before starting any work.

While I don't think what chandra/fusion garage did was right, but they just wanted their share for their work, as it seems they paid for alot of the expenses themselves.
 
The name and the product. They didn't do all the work themselves, but they came up with the idea of the device, designed what they wanted then teamed up with Rusion Garage and Chandra to help make it.

You can come up with a great idea but you aren't always going to have the stuff onhand to actually make it. That is where you outsource parts of the project and have somebody else make that parts.

Just look at Apple like the example given. Apple doesn't build the iPhone. They came up with the idea and design and handed it over to somebody to actually build it. The same thing happened here. Arrington came up with the idea and everything, and pulled in two companies to help build the device. I would expect them to be funding the project to some regards also, maybe they just had enough money to keep afloat for right now want to hold off on getting too many investors up front. The article stated that they were waiting to cut down on risk. Which in a way makes sense, had they took all this money from all these groups they would not be in a position to pay it back. This way they aren't in such a position.

Well, the "idea" is a slate pc with a capacitive screen - that''s not exactly revolutionary, or even original. That's why I was wondering what TechCrunch's contribution was to the project.

If TechCrunch put up the majority of funding, case closed. If their sole contributions were an unoriginal idea and hooking up Fusion Garage with the manufacturer then maybe not so much. If the manufacturer and Fusion Garage were self-funded then they took all the risk during research and development and it would seem, to me, that they'd now own the rights to the completed hardware and software but not the name.

I suppose that it'll all come out in the trial. I'm just curious and having some more details would help me form an opinion.
 
Hopefully these things will see light of day somewhere near the $300 price point. That would be awesome!
 
Wonder how much Apple paid FusionGarage to do this so the CrunchPad would be delayed until AFTER Apple's iPad comes out?????????
 
I have wanted one of these ever since I first saw them. A unique idea that IMO would be awesome to have.

Sucks that it has been such a rocky road and now might never come to shelves.
 
Back
Top