The Consumer Data Revolt Is Coming

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
This has been talked about for years but nothing ever seems to happen. What will it take for consumers to be so fed up that it leads to a data revolt?

This is going to keep happening, obviously. One big reason is that, for Anthem and lots of other companies that possess our most sensitive data, protecting it isn't the core of their business. Cleaning up after this mess is going to be an expensive pain for Anthem, but the attack is unlikely to drive away customers. If Anthem got a reputation for being dramatically worse at protecting customer data than other health insurers, the corporate human-resources people who choose insurers might start to defect. But as long as it's approximately as bad as the rest, that shouldn't be a worry.
 
The oil industry has been following this plan of reaction to disasters for decades. Data in this age is just as commoditized as oil, so that is why I think nothing is going to happen short of a crash or a real cyberwar.
 
I remember my dentist office used to have this complicated tower system of filing cabinets that slid and moved in such a way that all the dental records could easily be stored in a space about 4 feet wide by 8 feet long and 6 feet high. I would call that basically hack proof, someone would have to physically break into the place and take the records, which might be viable if you wanted someone's specific records but not if you want all the data of everyone. Now they have it all on computer, that they probably lease out a 3rd party to manage, sure all the records fit on a series of hard drives and back up devices, they are now a few keystrokes from being in everyone's hands.

Sometimes I miss the old days pre-internet.
 
With most insurance companies, this wouldn't make any difference. Some insurance companies have a habit of denying all claims from the start, causing a big increase in the amount of work their customers and the doctors' offices need to do in order to get stuff paid. Yet, those insurance companies still have plenty of customers. The reason is because most people are stuck with whatever their company provides. If it sucks in any way, you're stuck with it regardless. What are they going to do, go get their own for twice to three times the price? Complain to their bosses while C-level management makes the decision on what company to use?

The only difference it will make to health insurance companies is they'll get sued a little more often. They already have armies of lawyers to protect them.

Until something is done at the government level to increase penalties for identity theft (like 20 years to life) for the hackers and penalties to businesses that make their data too vulnerable to theft, there won't be any change. There also needs to be laws in place so that banks can't try to collect fraudulent debt from people who have been the victims of ID theft.

This all needed to be done decades ago, as in the early 1990s, but our wonderful government has been disregarding the problem completely.

I have two friends, a married couple, who had a loan taken out on their names for an RV. It was for over $200,000. The ID thief got away scot-free, and the bank keeps putting this fraudulent debt on their credit history and trying to collect. They aren't even trying to find the stolen RV. These friends of mine can't even get a house because of this. They have a baby and a younger kid, but they can't get a house with enough bedrooms because of this ID thief a-hole. They will likely have to deal with the nearly daily collections calls about this debt for the rest of their lives. The laws need to change before any of this can ever change.
 
I remember my dentist office used to have this complicated tower system of filing cabinets that slid and moved in such a way that all the dental records could easily be stored in a space about 4 feet wide by 8 feet long and 6 feet high. I would call that basically hack proof, someone would have to physically break into the place and take the records, which might be viable if you wanted someone's specific records but not if you want all the data of everyone. Now they have it all on computer, that they probably lease out a 3rd party to manage, sure all the records fit on a series of hard drives and back up devices, they are now a few keystrokes from being in everyone's hands.

Sometimes I miss the old days pre-internet.

Thanks to Obamacare, they HAVE to have their records set up electronically, and accessible over the internet with the right authentication. Unfortunately, nothing is unhackable, so things like this happen.
 
Until something is done at the government level to increase penalties for identity theft (like 20 years to life) for the hackers and penalties to businesses that make their data too vulnerable to theft, there won't be any change. There also needs to be laws in place so that banks can't try to collect fraudulent debt from people who have been the victims of ID theft.

The problem is a lot of this is overseas organized crime, specifically routed through countries that aren't friendly with the US. Changing the penalties for the crimes isn't going to do a damn thing to stop them.

I'll go out on a (small) limb and make the statement that online theft of money and identities is the most lucrative crime opportunity in the history of the human race. You can make huge amounts of money with very, very low risk using good digital and physical anonymity protocols. Put double blind layers of cronies between you and the actual hackers, and it's a bitch to actually find out who is perpetrating the crime.
 
With most insurance companies, this wouldn't make any difference. Some insurance companies have a habit of denying all claims from the start, causing a big increase in the amount of work their customers and the doctors' offices need to do in order to get stuff paid. Yet, those insurance companies still have plenty of customers. The reason is because most people are stuck with whatever their company provides. If it sucks in any way, you're stuck with it regardless. What are they going to do, go get their own for twice to three times the price? Complain to their bosses while C-level management makes the decision on what company to use?

The only difference it will make to health insurance companies is they'll get sued a little more often. They already have armies of lawyers to protect them.

Until something is done at the government level to increase penalties for identity theft (like 20 years to life) for the hackers and penalties to businesses that make their data too vulnerable to theft, there won't be any change. There also needs to be laws in place so that banks can't try to collect fraudulent debt from people who have been the victims of ID theft.

This all needed to be done decades ago, as in the early 1990s, but our wonderful government has been disregarding the problem completely.

I have two friends, a married couple, who had a loan taken out on their names for an RV. It was for over $200,000. The ID thief got away scot-free, and the bank keeps putting this fraudulent debt on their credit history and trying to collect. They aren't even trying to find the stolen RV. These friends of mine can't even get a house because of this. They have a baby and a younger kid, but they can't get a house with enough bedrooms because of this ID thief a-hole. They will likely have to deal with the nearly daily collections calls about this debt for the rest of their lives. The laws need to change before any of this can ever change.

It's not the bank's job to find the stolen RV. It's the police. Have they ever reported to the police? Have they found the RV's VIN number? They should be able to find where the vehicle is registered and by whom. They should be able to mark this vehicle as stolen and track it down.
 
It's not the bank's job to find the stolen RV. It's the police. Have they ever reported to the police? Have they found the RV's VIN number? They should be able to find where the vehicle is registered and by whom. They should be able to mark this vehicle as stolen and track it down.

Doubtful the thief kept the RV themselves; probably turned back around and sold it to somehow else for cash.
 
Thanks to Obamacare, they HAVE to have their records set up electronically, and accessible over the internet with the right authentication. Unfortunately, nothing is unhackable, so things like this happen.

I was waiting for someone to blame Obama.
 
It's not the bank's job to find the stolen RV. It's the police. Have they ever reported to the police? Have they found the RV's VIN number? They should be able to find where the vehicle is registered and by whom. They should be able to mark this vehicle as stolen and track it down.

I said "they" as in the authorities. My friends did report this to both the local police and the FBI, and the VIN is on the paperwork. The registration had false information, of course. They could be driving it all over the country, living in it, using fake date stickers to make it look like their plates are up to date. This whole thing happened nine years ago, and the authorities have done nothing, and the bank keeps trying to collect from my friends.

I've known of a hacker who was homeless, living out of a van with a generator on the roof, who parked in my company's parking lot and hacked into our wifi to get internet access. That van had been parked in the lot for a week, and I thought it was just some employee's van, until I spotted him stepping out to empty his makeshift chamberpot and saw the computers inside. I then alerted management, and they called the police. The police ticketed him for improper disposal of human waste and trespassing and shooed him away, but didn't do anything else. Whoever took that RV could be doing something similar.
 
Normal people are totally clueless about their data and how it is being accessed. Look at information people share on Facebook. In my area, a bus driver is fired for taking a selfie on a school bus acting like they were drinking from a bottle of booze. Shared to FB. Parents saw this. Now fired.
 
I said "they" as in the authorities. My friends did report this to both the local police and the FBI, and the VIN is on the paperwork. The registration had false information, of course. They could be driving it all over the country, living in it, using fake date stickers to make it look like their plates are up to date. This whole thing happened nine years ago, and the authorities have done nothing, and the bank keeps trying to collect from my friends.

I've known of a hacker who was homeless, living out of a van with a generator on the roof, who parked in my company's parking lot and hacked into our wifi to get internet access. That van had been parked in the lot for a week, and I thought it was just some employee's van, until I spotted him stepping out to empty his makeshift chamberpot and saw the computers inside. I then alerted management, and they called the police. The police ticketed him for improper disposal of human waste and trespassing and shooed him away, but didn't do anything else. Whoever took that RV could be doing something similar.


Oh noz, he hacked the wifis for internet! The wifi should only be for internet access, and isolated from anything else on the network. If not, your company has some shitty security/policies.
 
It's not the Internet without grumpy old guys who link everything to politics so they have something to complain about with other grumpy old guys.


It's just too bad the old guys are the only ones still worrying/caring about politics, while the not old guys are too busy wasting time on facebook/twitter/othersocialmedia and ignoring what is happening around them in their country. Guess we are going to have to get screwed something awful before they wake up and do something about it... -not old guy
 
It's just too bad the old guys are the only ones still worrying/caring about politics, while the not old guys are too busy wasting time on facebook/twitter/othersocialmedia and ignoring what is happening around them in their country. Guess we are going to have to get screwed something awful before they wake up and do something about it... -not old guy

Making molehills into mountains one post at a time.
 
It's just too bad the old guys are the only ones still worrying/caring about politics, while the not old guys are too busy wasting time on facebook/twitter/othersocialmedia and ignoring what is happening around them in their country. Guess we are going to have to get screwed something awful before they wake up and do something about it... -not old guy

The young guys care about politics. Or at least the trendy activist reason to revolt of the week. Then, nothing until the next big thing. They protest, then fade away. The old guys know this. Nothing will change until there is a huge awakening and by then - something will be screwed.

My information is out there. There are a few things that I don't mind. I get a service and the price is to let them use/sell my data. Others, the data needs to be kept private. That "what's shared and what's not" line is moving constantly, though.

Speaking of data sharing - does anyone know what data is shared with fitness watches and applications? Probably anonymous, but curious as to if they are using that to make profiles of the average person that buys those things (I am looking to buy one).
 
Speaking of data sharing - does anyone know what data is shared with fitness watches and applications? Probably anonymous, but curious as to if they are using that to make profiles of the average person that buys those things (I am looking to buy one).

It's likely going to be different for each one, and there isn't necessarily a legal/regulatory framework requiring what they do with it. It's likely anonymously sold to 3rd parties, but internally, they're likely building as complete of a profile of you as possible.
 
Thanks to Obamacare, they HAVE to have their records set up electronically, and accessible over the internet with the right authentication. Unfortunately, nothing is unhackable, so things like this happen.

Yeah, they HAVE to have their records set up electronically... however hospitals and dentists have been doing this well in advance of Obamacare. So now kindly go sip your coffee and turn Rush back on.
 
You think American companies are bad, look at our government: http://dadaviz.com/i/3206

Between Jan 2013 to June 2014, the United States government has requested nearly the same amount of information as the entire rest of the world COMBINED.

Think about that for a minute...
 
Everyone's data is out there. For Christ sake they MAIL your W-2 with your SSN on it.

We have to find a way to make the data useless, how? I don't know, if I did I wouldn't be working right now.

The SSN and tying every thing to it was the biggest blunder that no one saw coming.
 
As opposed to nothing but useless posts/trolling? Yes. And this actually is a mountain, claiming otherwise pretty much proves my point...

Taking something seriously and then ranting in a serious manner on the Internet about it is by far less useful. If you genuinely care, you could enter the political arena and attempt to make a positive difference instead of armchair grumbling about it to me. But you don't so that makes it pretty obvious we both think it's a molehill not worth anything but some fun (and your grump-face). :p
 
Back
Top