The Computer on the Space Shuttle Sucks

The tech exists to build much better spacecraft but people are stopping that. If the public- namely the environmentalists would stop being so afraid of nuclear propulsion, space travel would be a heck of a lot easier and faster.
 
The Space Shuttle sucks.

It was a huge waste of money considering its limited capabilities. The sooner they kill it off and accelerate Ares I development the better. If we had kept the Saturn V we could have accomplished the same objectives as the entire ISS/Shuttle program in 30 missions (and for half the price).

Yea.... and spent 10 times the fuel
 
Yea.... and spent 10 times the fuel

Not quite:
Saturn V: (Lunar mission configuration): ~5,600,000 lbs LOX/LH2
Space Shuttle: ~1,000,000 lbs of solid fuel, 500,000 lbs LOX/LH2

30 Saturn V Missions: ~168,000,000 lbs of fuel
128 Space Shuttle Missions: ~192,000,000 lbs of fuel
Obviously the Saturn V's fuel needs would be lower without the Earth departure stage.

30 Saturn V missions could have theoretically lifted 7,860,000 lbs to low earth orbit for ~$72 billion (assuming the cost of an orbital mission was the same as the average cost of a lunar mission, in reality it would probably be cheaper). 128 space shuttle launches could theoretically have lifted 6,860,800 lbs. The total cost of the Space Shuttle program today is $145-175 billion.

Hopefully NASA/the government has learned their lesson and will continue with the Constellation program.
 
I think NASA was well aware of the shortcomings of the Space Shuttle from the start. At that time we were showing off more than anything. We were sticking it to the Russians and showing the world we could make a plane that could go into space.

Thank God that's over. Hopefully we can be a little more levelheaded this time and stop with the epeen contest.
 
The tech exists to build much better spacecraft but people are stopping that. If the public- namely the environmentalists would stop being so afraid of nuclear propulsion, space travel would be a heck of a lot easier and faster.

I'm not aware of any surface-to-orbit methods that involve nuclear propulsion....care to elaborate? It was my understanding that they'd tend to leave the launch-site badly irradiated and destroyed.
 
Anyone remember a few years ago when NASA wanted everyone's old 386 stuff to add to their spares pile? I remember getting a notice about that but we had already trashed that old stuff by that time.
 
Most of you are morons. OH ILL JUST A PS3 IN IT

Yeah, most of these people sound like the same people who go GA GA over Pimp My Ride...

[cuts to Xibit at the Shuttle]

"We got 22" alloy rims for the landing gear, custom paint job, and PS2 in da back!"

Seriously people, it takes years to approve computers and parts in the shuttle. They have to go through a whole battery of tests. Plus if they change out the computer system, they need a new computer system that can flawlessly be implemented to run with the rest of the equipment there. Have you tried running software for a 386 or even a 486 on a Pentium or later chip? Remember these chips work completely different and require differently coded software. In addition to that, newer processors are more finicky than earlier processors, so they can't take as much rigor without being re-designed for this specific application.
 
Yeah, most of these people sound like the same people who go GA GA over Pimp My Ride...

[cuts to Xibit at the Shuttle]

"We got 22" alloy rims for the landing gear, custom paint job, and PS2 in da back!"

Seriously people, it takes years to approve computers and parts in the shuttle. They have to go through a whole battery of tests. Plus if they change out the computer system, they need a new computer system that can flawlessly be implemented to run with the rest of the equipment there. Have you tried running software for a 386 or even a 486 on a Pentium or later chip? Remember these chips work completely different and require differently coded software. In addition to that, newer processors are more finicky than earlier processors, so they can't take as much rigor without being re-designed for this specific application.

Plus the new processors run too damned hot. It takes a lot of energy to cool things.
 
The Space Shuttle sucks.

It was a huge waste of money considering its limited capabilities. The sooner they kill it off and accelerate Ares I development the better. If we had kept the Saturn V we could have accomplished the same objectives as the entire ISS/Shuttle program in 30 missions (and for half the price).

The space shuttle is kind of an amazing feat. Never has been done before and probably never will, but we did it.
 
Well, the Russians did it too... and more advanced and automated than the U.S. version...

The Buran? Seriously? It wasn't even safe enough for manned missions. It was a PR stunt that flew once (2 orbits) and wasn't durable enough for a second mission. Sure it had autopilot, but real pilots don't trust machines to do all thier thinking for them-too many variables and emergencies could happen.
 
The Buran? Seriously? It wasn't even safe enough for manned missions. It was a PR stunt that flew once (2 orbits) and wasn't durable enough for a second mission. Sure it had autopilot, but real pilots don't trust machines to do all thier thinking for them-too many variables and emergencies could happen.

Too many variables for an old crappy 386 perhaps... :)
 
The space shuttle is kind of an amazing feat. Never has been done before and probably never will, but we did it.

Uh, the Russians copied the Shuttle, and if they had the funding, added some features the shuttle didn't have (i.e. autopilot).
 
Almost ;) Buran never REALLY worked. (And was a complete copy)

Last time I checked, it did a unmanned flight once. Because the Soviet Union was starting to crumble, they didn't have the funding to continue it.
 
My point still stands. They didn't go through with it, and never really completed the program. Also, the US shuttle now has auto pilot with the use of that special cable. I would not in any way call the Buran a success, it has never performed a scientific mission, and all the partially built ones are not laying crumbled in piles of rubbish.

I mean, if the only space shuttle flight that ever flew was STS-1, I don't think any of you guys would be chalking it up as much of anything either.
 
My point still stands. They didn't go through with it, and never really completed the program. Also, the US shuttle now has auto pilot with the use of that special cable. I would not in any way call the Buran a success, it has never performed a scientific mission, and all the partially built ones are now laying crumbled in piles of rubbish.

I mean, if the only space shuttle flight that ever flew was STS-1, I don't think any of you guys would be chalking it up as much of anything either.

Oops.
 
The space shuttle is kind of an amazing feat. Never has been done before and probably never will, but we did it.

Yes, if your idea of an amazing feat is to make a "reusable" orbital spacecraft that is more expensive than a disposable one with 5 times the lifting capability. Only the US government could be so incompetent. ;)

Someday we'll have single-stage-to-orbit space planes, but we just aren't that advanced yet.
 
Lol, I wasn't trying to argue that, but it still is an amazing feat. It was the most complex thing ever built at the time. Yeah, they probably should have gone a different direction from the start, but they did it, and made it work, and kept with it.
 
Not quite:
Saturn V: (Lunar mission configuration): ~5,600,000 lbs LOX/LH2
Space Shuttle: ~1,000,000 lbs of solid fuel, 500,000 lbs LOX/LH2

30 Saturn V Missions: ~168,000,000 lbs of fuel
128 Space Shuttle Missions: ~192,000,000 lbs of fuel
Obviously the Saturn V's fuel needs would be lower without the Earth departure stage.

30 Saturn V missions could have theoretically lifted 7,860,000 lbs to low earth orbit for ~$72 billion (assuming the cost of an orbital mission was the same as the average cost of a lunar mission, in reality it would probably be cheaper). 128 space shuttle launches could theoretically have lifted 6,860,800 lbs. The total cost of the Space Shuttle program today is $145-175 billion.

Hopefully NASA/the government has learned their lesson and will continue with the Constellation program.

Fully fueled, the Saturn V used more like 6 million pounds of fuel... and its first stage (the most important one for LEO) didn't run on LH2/LOX... it ran on kerosene and LOX...

This makes the Saturn V number 180,870,000 lbs, more on par with shuttle. Saturn has negligible downmass abilities and would not have been able to match the shuttle's time in orbit (where experiments happen). Say they could both stay aloft for 2 weeks, give or take. We would've only had 14 months in orbit with saturn... as opposed to nearly 5 years in orbit with the shuttle.

Well, the Russians did it too... and more advanced and automated than the U.S. version...

Buran had no OMS engines, so it would've been pretty much useless for many of the shuttle's missions (I.E. any of them that required changing orbits, like Hubble servicing missions)

It was never a functional human bearing spacecraft, so it doesn't matter how advanced and superior it would've been HAD it flown.
 
Fully fueled, the Saturn V used more like 6 million pounds of fuel... and its first stage (the most important one for LEO) didn't run on LH2/LOX... it ran on kerosene and LOX...

This makes the Saturn V number 180,870,000 lbs, more on par with shuttle. Saturn has negligible downmass abilities and would not have been able to match the shuttle's time in orbit (where experiments happen). Say they could both stay aloft for 2 weeks, give or take. We would've only had 14 months in orbit with saturn... as opposed to nearly 5 years in orbit with the shuttle.



Buran had no OMS engines, so it would've been pretty much useless for many of the shuttle's missions (I.E. any of them that required changing orbits, like Hubble servicing missions)

It was never a functional human bearing spacecraft, so it doesn't matter how advanced and superior it would've been HAD it flown.

I agree with what you just posted!


lol. The Saturn V and the space shuttle have such different uses.

Buran... is an old, rundown soviet project that never came to fruition.While it was still a prototype, it doesn't exist, now, and therefore, it's moot to bring a byproduct of a nonexistent Red State into this.

Soyuz... is a far better comparison, but still... differing purposes here!
 
The Buran? Seriously? It wasn't even safe enough for manned missions. It was a PR stunt that flew once (2 orbits) and wasn't durable enough for a second mission. Sure it had autopilot, but real pilots don't trust machines to do all thier thinking for them-too many variables and emergencies could happen.


Where in the hell do you get your crap information from? The life support system was not installed YET when Buran first flew. The entire program ran out of funding. Wasn't durable enough? Again.....BS. The Soviet Union had 5 orbiters in production when the program was canceled.

Real pilots don't trust machines? LOL what a joke......are YOU a real pilot?
 
Where in the hell do you get your crap information from? The life support system was not installed YET when Buran first flew. The entire program ran out of funding. Wasn't durable enough? Again.....BS. The Soviet Union had 5 orbiters in production when the program was canceled.

Real pilots don't trust machines? LOL what a joke......are YOU a real pilot?

Are you?

Besides, it's moot, as it never was put into service.

It's like saying if there were more STG44, or more King Tigers, or more V2 rockets the Germans could of won. They didn't, so it's utterly moot now.
 
Saturn has negligible downmass abilities and would not have been able to match the shuttle's time in orbit (where experiments happen). Say they could both stay aloft for 2 weeks, give or take. We would've only had 14 months in orbit with saturn... as opposed to nearly 5 years in orbit with the shuttle.

There's no reason why it couldn't have been modified for orbital missions. Heck, NASA was seriously considering a manned Venus flyby mission as part of the Apollo applications program. That sort of mission would have taken about a year.

In my scenario the Saturn V would have served as the heavy lift vehicle for building the ISS and a smaller, relatively cheap rocket like the Saturn IB or a derivative could be used for crew exchange and resupply missions. You probably wouldn't need a full 30 Saturn V launches, I just used that as a way of estimating what the total program would cost.
 
^I forgot to add.
We would've only had 14 months in orbit with saturn... as opposed to nearly 5 years in orbit with the shuttle.

Skylab was in orbit for 6 years, although it was only manned for three missions in 1973-74 due to NASA's shrinking budget. It was launched with a two stage version of the Saturn V.
 
^I forgot to add.


Skylab was in orbit for 6 years, although it was only manned for three missions in 1973-74 due to NASA's shrinking budget. It was launched with a two stage version of the Saturn V.

He's talking about orbit time of the CM/SM vs orbit time of the shuttle itself. (Even though skylab was up there that long, it would always require a saturn CM/SM attached if someone was occupying it.
 
He's talking about orbit time of the CM/SM vs orbit time of the shuttle itself. (Even though skylab was up there that long, it would always require a saturn CM/SM attached if someone was occupying it.

This theoretical space station would have a "lifeboat" like the Soyuz (or Apollo command module, in this case) just like the ISS does now. There isn't a Shuttle up at the ISS 24/7.

The only other reason you would need longer mission times would be for something like the Hubble repair missions. In that case it would make more sense to take some of the $70+ BILLION dollars we would have saved by not bothering with the Shuttle program to build additional space telescopes, assuming the Apollo command module couldn't be upgraded or replaced with a new module to support longer orbital missions.
 
Real pilots don't trust machines? LOL what a joke......are YOU a real pilot?

Yes I am, certified for the past 14 years. If you think automation is that perfect, how come EVERY commercial airliner has two pilots up front? Airlines could save a ton of money with automation, but they don't for a reason. If autopilots are so great, why can't you fly a UAV (Unmanned Aerial Vehicle, like a Predator, Raven, Hunter, Reaper, Global Hawk, etc) over a populated area in the US?
 
Yes I am, certified for the past 14 years. If you think automation is that perfect, how come EVERY commercial airliner has two pilots up front? Airlines could save a ton of money with automation, but they don't for a reason. If autopilots are so great, why can't you fly a UAV (Unmanned Aerial Vehicle, like a Predator, Raven, Hunter, Reaper, Global Hawk, etc) over a populated area in the US?
Well, those are two very different questions, really. On a commercial airliner, you have dozens to hundreds of passengers, so the potential consequences are much greater. For UAVs, do you have to distinguish between truly Autonomous vehicles and those which have the pilot on the ground?
 
Well, those are two very different questions, really. On a commercial airliner, you have dozens to hundreds of passengers, so the potential consequences are much greater. For UAVs, do you have to distinguish between truly Autonomous vehicles and those which have the pilot on the ground?

I think the issue is also with the people on the ground. The UAVs I listed vary from semi-autonomous with autopilot backup to completely pre-programmed (Global Hawk). Both are restricted in the US from flying outside of military controlled airspace except under very special FAA permission. UAVs currently don't have the technology to independently look for and avoid other aircraft (I've seen small UAVs hit or be destroyed by near misses with large aircraft), potentially a huge area of concern to any pilot. Loss of signal or control means that the UAV may crash, possibly on a populated area. And if applying this to an untried space vehicle with '80s Soviet technology, well, I'm surprised it worked. I wouldn't want to be a passenger in that shuttle.
 
Back
Top