The Coming War On General Computation

The scary part is that it makes sense in the minds of corporations... And politicians/lawmakers
 
Apple are easily the biggest enabler of the kind of stuff this guy is warning about.
 
I watched this video early this morning. Good to see it got picked up here. It is the truth of the matter. Eventually all of this excellent techno freedom we have now will be eroded and everything will have to be moved to open source if it is to truly serve the purposes we require. General computing has moved us into a new age. Sad to see it under fire. It doesn't really seem to me that it ever did anything but create capitol.

In the future, if you want to be the tip of the spear, you will have to settle with your devices being expensive toasters that aren't even that great at making toast.:p
 
I only watched the first 1/3, but I echo the thoughts of the people ^^^. Thanks a bunch for sharing Steve.
 
The woman with the first question really cut all the bullshit and boiled it right down.

I think we will have to be hacking up our own ASIC/FPGA hardware before its over, re purposing industrial parts in unauthorized configurations that could land you in gulag.
 
The woman with the first question really cut all the bullshit and boiled it right down.

I think we will have to be hacking up our own ASIC/FPGA hardware before its over, re purposing industrial parts in unauthorized configurations that could land you in gulag.

do a google search for "open source cpu"...

also, follow the news on the raspberry pi.... components still made by big corp, but that's not the point...

honestly she sounded like a chick who was in a room full of dudes and wanted to sound smart... this "war" is going to be finished before it starts imo...

so i guess i don't feel like it's started yet...

the real question is how are they going to pull this off whilst maintaining a "free market"

i know i'm not going to buy single purpose computers filled w/ drm/spyware

are they going to take all our old hardware from us? no...
are they going to stop us from designing our own computers? no...
 
they can try, and cause untold damage in the process

see "drug war"
 
It is a good video, and I can tell most people don't remember how older electronics worked. Single-purpose computers are very possible and existed widespread long before multipurpose computers became prevalent. Basic electronic devices were all pretty much done this way prior to E PROM. RAM was RAM, and ROM was ROM, and since memory cost a lot and you didn't get much (back when 64K was considered premium) most electronics were driven by factory ROM. There was no such thing as firmware updates because you got what you got and that was it. If they really wanted to pull off the master control scheme they'd have to start going back to that hard-programmed model - word processors are word processors, TV's are TV's, radios are radios, etc. The modular PC would have to be eliminated in favor of multiple single-purpose devices hard-programmed from the factory.

There's a problem with this of course, and that's the fact that PC's are already too widely spread and in the public consciousness, and electronically-programmable computers in just about everything from cars to toasters are too convenient for manufacturers to ever want to go back to single-purpose electronics. After all, it's easier and more cost effective to release a firmware update than to physically rip out and replace an ECM. That genie is long out of the bottle, and I don't see any way they're going to succeed in putting it back in.
 
Cliff Notes version please? Can't really justify spending time to watch some non-nondescript stuff, too busy with Angry Birds.
 
I'd love to share this with friends, but most would not understand. "But iPad!" :rolleyes:
 
Cliff Notes version please? Can't really justify spending time to watch some non-nondescript stuff, too busy with Angry Birds.

don't worry, your government approved appliance will run AB
 
Cliff Notes version please? Can't really justify spending time to watch some non-nondescript stuff, too busy with Angry Birds.

Watch the video it's very informative. You can't cliff notes everything and expect to actually learn or absorb useful info. I'm just listening to the dude while I'm working, you can do the same while playing Angry Birds, I know how addictive those birds are but the guy giving the speech is actually pretty entertaining.
 
You can't cliff notes everything and expect to actually learn or absorb useful info.

I saw this elsewhere as a transcript. Turned a hour long video into a 15 minute read; shorter if you skim for the important points.
 
I saw this elsewhere as a transcript. Turned a hour long video into a 15 minute read; shorter if you skim for the important points.

Or you can work or do other activities while listening, as another suggested... effectively turning an hour long video into 0 minutes of dedicated time.
 
Cliff Notes version please? Can't really justify spending time to watch some non-nondescript stuff, too busy with Angry Birds.

Transcript (I think--work blocks video).

http://joshuawise.com/28c3-transcript#section15160

This sums up the argument, I think.

1418.9 The grievances that arose from unauthorized copying are trivial, when compared to the calls for action that our new computer-embroidered reality will create. Think of radio for a minute. The entire basis for radio regulation up until today was based on the idea that the properties of a radio are fixed at the time of manufacture, and can't be easily altered. You can't just flip a switch on your baby monitor, and turn it into something that interferes with air traffic control signals. But powerful software-defined radios can change from baby monitor to emergency services dispatcher to air traffic controller just by loading and executing different software, which is why the first time the American telecoms regulator (the FCC) considered what would happen when we put SDRs in the field, they asked for comment on whether it should mandate that all software-defined radios should be embedded in trusted computing machines. Ultimately, whether every PC should be locked, so that the programs they run are strictly regulated by central authorities.

1477.9 And even this is a shadow of what is to come. After all, this was the year in which we saw the debut of open sourced shape files for converting AR-15s to full automatic. This was the year of crowd-funded open-sourced hardware for gene sequencing. And while 3D printing will give rise to plenty of trivial complaints, there will be judges in the American South and Mullahs in Iran who will lose their *minds* over people in their jurisdiction printing out sex toys. [guffaw from audience] The trajectory of 3D printing will most certainly raise real grievances, from solid state meth labs, to ceramic knives.

1516.0 And it doesn't take a science fiction writer to understand why regulators might be nervous about the user-modifiable firmware on self-driving cars, or limiting interoperability for aviation controllers, or the kind of thing you could do with bio-scale assemblers and sequencers. Imagine what will happen the day that Monsanto determines that it's really… *really*… important to make sure that computers can't execute programs that cause specialized peripherals to output organisms that eat their lunch… literally. Regardless of whether you think these are real problems or merely hysterical fears, they are nevertheless the province of lobbies and interest groups that are far more influential than Hollywood and big content are on their best days, and every one of them will arrive at the same place – “can't you just make us a general purpose computer that runs all the programs, except the ones that scare and anger us? Can't you just make us an Internet that transmits any message over any protocol between any two points, unless it upsets us?”

One analogy that might have been missed is radio versus cloud-type applications and content hosting. We keep our general computers, keep them unrestricted for the most part, but central computer farms do the work that our limited PCs cannot, serve up the content for the game engines that run on our PCs, provide core functionality for applications and so on. Doesn't matter what our computers can do if someone else hosts data that we cannot directly access.

That old saw about there being a market for five computers in the world might be close to correct in its own way.
 
Cliff Notes version please? Can't really justify spending time to watch some non-nondescript stuff, too busy with Angry Birds.

Then this is not for you.
return (forumPost["Thuleman;103221328"]!=sarcasm) ? this : comment.lolz;

don't worry, your government approved appliance will run AB
rofl

Watch the video it's very informative. You can't cliff notes everything and expect to actually learn or absorb useful info. I'm just listening to the dude while I'm working, you can do the same while playing Angry Birds, I know how addictive those birds are but the guy giving the speech is actually pretty entertaining.
Personally I found this more interesting than a game of Angry Birds. I thought it was a good speech and he's pretty well spoken and energetic. I think corporations and the public have too much invested in general purpose computing to go backwards. In my experience people are very likely to continue down a shitty path so we'll probably just see more retarded software solutions to lock devices down and more hideous laws to prevent people from tampering with the software.
 
One analogy that might have been missed is radio versus cloud-type applications and content hosting. We keep our general computers, keep them unrestricted for the most part, but central computer farms do the work that our limited PCs cannot, serve up the content for the game engines that run on our PCs, provide core functionality for applications and so on. Doesn't matter what our computers can do if someone else hosts data that we cannot directly access.

This is why I hate DRM so much. It's handing over the power and the ownership to someone else. "Yes, our remote server says you can use this. Go ahead". That's not ownership.

Moving everything to the cloud simply means giving up ownership. I think we're on a road to everyone being a renter. "Here's your license agreement for your game [or software, or video, or whatever]". Fine until you cross Big Brother megacorp and they decide you can't use it any more.
 
Back
Top