The Age-old PC/MAC debate...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kr4zy

n00b
Joined
Jul 31, 2006
Messages
7
Okay, I am totally lost here. I don't know whether to get a mac computer or a pc. for one, pcs are WAYY cheaper. So my question is, is the Mac and OS X really better than a PC for working with Audio and Photoshop and Movies and such? And Macs don't have too much support for games. I mean, u can run them with Boot Camp, but u won't be able to upgrade to like a DirectX 10 vidoe card. So, is the Mac really better than a PC for working with the stuff i mentioned? And if there is a difference, what is it and how big is it. Thanks in advance to anyone that responds!

-Kr4zy-

PS - Will Macs be able to run Windows Vista?
 
Kr4zy said:
Okay, I am totally lost here. I don't know whether to get a mac computer or a pc. for one, pcs are WAYY cheaper.
Nice flamebait. :rolleyes:

Both Mac and Windows machines are just as good at whatever task you through at them, they just do them differently. Programs like Photoshop, Adobe Premiere, and Office all have Mac and Windows versions (so you probably won't notice much of a difference). Things aren't better on either side.

Apple hasn't marketed Macs as gaming machines and probably will never do so.

Macs will run Vista, however.

This will probably get locked.
 
Here's the deal . . . you are paying a preimium price on an Apple computer for it's design and use of OS X (a way better OS than Windows anything IMO). If you are heavy into PC gaming, 10 out of 10 times you'll wanna just stick with a PC. However, if you have consoles to fill that gaming void in your life and wanna get a personal computer that has a better OS and will last you twice as long as any PC ever will, pay the extra amount and go with Mac.

Macs are not upgradable unless you are talking about RAM. As far as Photoshop, you won't see a huge difference. Photoshop is Photoshop. However, Mac OS X comes standard with iLife, which includes iMovie and iDVD; great apps for video editing and DVD production.

I've been PC (Windows) free for almost a year and I have to say that it is a great feeling to own a Mac. And yes, I am still a heavy gamer. I have a 360 to fill that void lol. With Tiger on my machine and Leopard on the horizon, I'm proud to say that I'm with an OS that is diving head first into what innovation really is. Go to the Apple store and give all the machines a whirl buddy.

EDIT: Yes, for some reason Vista will run on the Intel Macs. Chances are it will crash and burn due to cheap software :D Yes, this thread will be locked soon.
 
I don't see any reason why this thread will get locked nor should it. Do you macophiles not like to help out the dazed and confused? At any rate, the Mac Pro looks to be a beast and capable of running anything you throw it at. It may take an adjustment period for drivers to show upf or the new hardware.

Will it game? Not in OS X, but just reboot into XP or Vista and you're good to go.
 
a ronin said:
I don't see any reason why this thread will get locked nor should it. Do you macophiles not like to help out the dazed and confused? At any rate, the Mac Pro looks to be a beast and capable of running anything you throw it at. It may take an adjustment period for drivers to show upf or the new hardware.

Will it game? Not in OS X, but just reboot into XP or Vista and you're good to go.

I don't consider myself as a "Macophile" at all. I've had my fair share with Windows OSs over the past 10 years and it hasn't been a good time at all. Yeah, I'll say that Windows is better than Mac OS X at gaming but for everything else, Mac OS X has proven itself to not crash, not delete my important things randomly, make using a computer hard and frustrating, and so on. But hey, this is just my two cents.

Take a look at my last post without the mind set of me being a Mac-acholic. If you want gaming, get a PC. However, if you want a better OS for web surfing and movie stuff like the thread originator states, get a Mac. Again, go to a local Apple store or CompUSA and try them all out.
 
PCs really aren't any cheaper. It's just that Apple offers rather limited configurations that can make users from the PC world (where everything is upgradeable) feel boxed into a corner when looking at Macs. Also, unlike Windows, Mac OS is actually worth paying for.
 
ughhhhh.
OS X does NOT have some magic potion that makes music sound better, photos prettier, and movies more entertaining. The software and OS is just more geared to give you more access to artsy stuff right off the bat.
You can record a damn good sounding album on windows or mac and not tell the difference. It's just preference of software and OS.
Sure I think OS X is better because it won't crash nearly as much....theres no viruses (yet) and it has recording software I like to use.....but If I had to I'd have no problem recording under windows with cakewalk Sonar.............
 
This is just my opinion...

In my experience, PC's are much cheaper. Why do people choose mac's? 99% of the people I have talked to move to the apple operating system to get away from the whole virus/spyware issue on windows. Second main reason, is the OS X operating system is undeniably a more advanced OS.

With that being said, I would also have to say that the majority of people making the move to Apple are not windows literate. They are the people who can't figure out for the life of them why they keep getting these virus' along with slowdowns caused by spyware. They click ALL the popups and read ALL suspicious emails from their friends and can't understand why all of a sudden their computer is being hijacked. They would rather be safe and sound inside an operating system that protects them and allows them to do what they need to do, which is access the internet, check mail, look at their pictures and edit the odd home video.

OSX looks good with all it's features. They are well implemented and look "nice" and rarely cause slowdowns. And now, it's the only PC you will ever need as it can run Vista and XP.

Wait a minute!

Now why would a Mac user want to run Vista or XP? Is it just the ability to say, "Yeah, this computer can do everything your computer can do!". Or is actually for the purpose of being able to run windows for the reasons people run windows!? I might add, if OS X is so superior, then why would this even be an option?

This is just my opinion so please don't flame. These are my reasons why windows is better than OS X.

1. Windows has games. I'm a gamer and that is probably 50% of the reason I own a PC. An apple can now boot into windows, so this is really a moot point when directly compared, but more later.

2. Windows is really not that much more insecure than OS X. There have actually been 7 critical updates for the MAC OS in the previous 6 months compared to 6 on XP. Not much of a difference, and if you try bringing up Virus' and spyware I will ignore you because it doesn't take a genius to figure out how to avoid virus' and protect yourself against spyware.

3. I can do everything on windows and more than what people can do on a mac. Make a list and I can pretty much guarantee their will be very few things windows can't do compared to a big list of what Mac's can't do.

4. Windows allows me to get done what I need to do without all the effects and windows and hotspots getting in the way. They are adding more and more of these effects every release and I'm starting to wonder just how much it actually adds to your experience. I don't like it and much prefer the windows system and how they have it set up to navigate your computer.

5. Last point I'm making is PC's are cheaper than macs. They allow you to upgrade specific components along the way much easier and in the end, PC's will save you a bundle of cash you could put towards your kids education.


So I guess, the way I see it. Macs are for people who only need a Mac. Windows is for everyone else. If I bought a Mac and put windows on, I would find myself using windows all the time. So my question, is why the hell would I buy a mac then. If my windows is just as secure as OS X, I can edit my pictures to the same standard, I can play way more games and I find windows easier to operate not to mention the cost?

No brainer.
 
a ronin said:
I don't see any reason why this thread will get locked nor should it. Do you macophiles not like to help out the dazed and confused?
Gee wiz, I wonder why it will get locked...


Anyway, there is a lot of misinformation here. Here are some FACTS:

Macs aren't more expensive than "PCs." The Mac Pro is a fucking bargain, compared to similar machines from other companies (over $1000 cheaper than a comparable Dell). The reason Macs seem expensive is because they don't always offer the same components or design. Sure, the 17" Macbook Pro costs more than the cheapest 17" Core Duo Dell laptop, but this could be because the MBP is like an inch thick. The iMac costs more than a fulltower Athlon64 X2 system, but this could be because it's a really small all-in-one system. The Mac Pro costs more than a regular fulltower, but this is because it ships with higher-end parts (dual Woodcrests, dual gigabit ethernet ports, etc). And so on and so forth.

Mac OS X is not more safe than Windows, as such. It's just safe in a different way.

Macs are upgradable. Not the iMacs and laptops, though. If you want upgradability, buy a Mac tower. Currently, the Mac Pro is overkill for most people, so I'm hoping they'll release a cheaper and less extreme system. In the towers, you can upgrade things like the video card. It's standard components, mostly.

Mac OS X looks good, yes. But many people seem to think that this comes at a performance reduction. Nothing could be further from the truth! The entire UI in Mac OS X is basically a bunch of textured polygons. Deforming them does not slow the computer down. It's all done on the GPU, and it does not take more processing power to deform the window as it zooms down to the Dock than it does to just shrink it.




Here are some opinions:

I think Mac OS X is preferrable in a great number of ways. I think the basic metaphores of the user interface are much more efficient. I think the UI is better organized. I work faster in it. Things like having the menu bar at the top, Exposé, applications-have-documents instead of windows-are-applications, etc etc etc, make a BIG difference to me. Especially in applications like Photoshop. The fact that I can have twenty images open in Photoshop (or Cinepaint), and use Exposé to switch between them, is such an incredible workflow enhancer.

Being a 3D artist, I spend a lot of time polishing my workflow. To me, it feels as if Apple spent a lot more time thinking about the workflow than Microsoft did. Microsoft just added a bunch of features together and didn't worry too much about it. Sure, there are integrations between different applications and such (like between the Office apps), but the basic workflow of the OS is very basic. And Windows is not nearly as customizable as Mac OS X is, what with AppleScript, shell scripts, Automator, global customizable keyboard shortcuts, etc.

The whole "Mac OS X is just eyecandy" is bullshit. The fact that Exposé is smoothly animated may look like a gimmick, but it really helps you to figure out which window you want faster. Humans are much better at dealing with objects that move, than they are at dealing with objects that pop up without warning.
 
2. Windows is really not that much more insecure than OS X. There have actually been 7 critical updates for the MAC OS in the previous 6 months compared to 6 on XP. Not much of a difference, and if you try bringing up Virus' and spyware I will ignore you because it doesn't take a genius to figure out how to avoid virus' and protect yourself against spyware.


Not ENTIRELY true. Even with some of the most advanced anti-spyware and anti-virus software on my PC, I managed to get something from a crack website ;).

But you're right. It's a no-brainer. If you are a gamer, windows is your friend. If you just want to get stuff accomplished, like school or design work, I'd always recommend OS X. There's nothing superior to a Mac's ability to handle graphics or sound (except for out of the box compatibility)... But where the OS really shines is it's ROCK SOLID ability to work when you need it.

I can't even count the times where my PC has let me down when I needed it the most... Countless re-installs of XP coupled with lost files, work and productivity. I've had my G5 Tower for 2 years now... I've only ever had to restart it for updates.

The new core duo's are great... They allow me to play oblivion under XP once every couple of days when I get time, and to actually be productive during the school year under OS X. THAT, is a no-brainer ;).
 
Kr4zy said:
Okay, I am totally lost here. I don't know whether to get a mac computer or a pc. for one, pcs are WAYY cheaper. So my question is, is the Mac and OS X really better than a PC for working with Audio and Photoshop and Movies and such? And Macs don't have too much support for games. I mean, u can run them with Boot Camp, but u won't be able to upgrade to like a DirectX 10 vidoe card. So, is the Mac really better than a PC for working with the stuff i mentioned? And if there is a difference, what is it and how big is it. Thanks in advance to anyone that responds!

-Kr4zy-

PS - Will Macs be able to run Windows Vista?

1. They're not cheaper, congradulations on being suckered into a myth.
2. I don't know many laptops or form factors of the like that you can upgrade video cards too.... The Mac Pro...maybe. But why would you want to with that 4500? :drool:
3. I find working easier on a Mac, it all comes down to preference though. In my opinion, Mac is going to always be more a recreational type computer, and Windows will be business. Apple's creeping up there though.

PS...Vista on a Mac? Why would you even want to?
 
wow, thanks A LOT guys. This has really helped me out. So based on what I read, I guess I've made my decision. I'll be getting a Mac, just because my real focus is music production, and I checked out some websites, and I saw that the Mac has a lot more support for music programs. Guess I'll be either checking out a MacBook Pro or a Mac Pro. :) Once again, thanks for all the great help guys!
 
B. W. said:
Apple hasn't marketed Macs as gaming machines and probably will never do so.

If only they would make one. There are already a lot of games though for Macs though which is nice, I just wish more games would take the Blizzard cue and give you both versions of the games so you can play in either environment. Hopefully that won't become moot with Bootcamp becoming included.

Anyway...to trail back on target, I think the perception has always been that Apple makes more expensive computers. The main reason for that, they have always made expensive computers. It's hard to compare apples to oranges when looking at Power processors and x86 based processors. Now that's over and it's easier to see, piece for piece Apple really does come in a decent price point for the market and their systems are generally very high end and deserving of their pricetags. Systems like the Macbook and Mac Mini are breaking this mold nicely though and getting sytems into the hands of the more casual computer user at cheaper prices.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top