TGI Friday Drone Crashes Into Woman's Face

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I have a great idea! Let's hang mistletoe from a drone and fly it around a crowded restaurant! What could possibly go wrong?

Yet that’s exactly what happened to a photographer who visited a restaurant with a reporter last week to capture the restaurant’s two drones in action. A smaller, 10-inch drone was supposed to land in the reporter’s hand, but instead flew into the photographer’s face, cutting her nose and chin.
 
the photographer, Georgine Benvenuto, posted on Facebook. “Not a toy I would buy for a child this year or any year…”

Seriously? I had a gas powered remote control car when I was 8. It's called teaching the child responsibility.
 
There are drones that have cages over the props so they can bounce off walls all day. I feel bad for the photographer, as she wasn't the pilot. To be fair, she should be allowed to electrocute his balls with a tazer or use foaming bear mace on him.
 
Okay, serious question.

Who the fuck would willingly go to a TGI Friday's for food?
 
Sometimes when you get skin off the face it never heals right who's ever cute idea this was OK....
 
Okay, serious question.

Who the fuck would willingly go to a TGI Friday's for food?

Some of their food is pretty good, even if it is overpriced for what you get.

I would rather go there than Olive Garden.

I would choose it any day over PF Chang's.
 
The operator blames the reporter for flinching when the drone was about to land in her hand, which he says sent it careening into her colleagues face. The photographer, in turn, blames the drone operator for thinking it was a good idea to land a toy with whirling blades in someone’s hand to begin with.

Yeah I'm gonna go with it was a bad idea to land a machine with whirling blades in her hand.

I've used these kinds of drones for aerial videography and yeah, you don't really want that thing in your face. It's pretty much all plastic on the outside, but it will fuck your day up.
 
Very bad judgement flying a weed wacker near exposed skin.

So, what was the fate of the drone fleet? Hopefully grounded.
 
When are people going to realize there is a difference between "drones" and basic ass RC Quadcopters? Can you program it to do things autonomously? No? GTFO with that "drone" bullshit then.
 
Who the fuck would willingly go to a TGI Friday's for food?

Back quite a while (17+ years ago), the one in Vancouver, WA has an amazing knockout gal working there at the bar. I almost became an alcoholic because of her. :D
 
When are people going to realize there is a difference between "drones" and basic ass RC Quadcopters? Can you program it to do things autonomously? No? GTFO with that "drone" bullshit then.

A lot of them have drone capabilities such as DJI's autonomous flight, return to home point upon losing communication or low battery, auto land on critical battery, maintaining restricted altitude near airports, etc.
 
A lot of them have drone capabilities such as DJI's autonomous flight, return to home point upon losing communication or low battery, auto land on critical battery, maintaining restricted altitude near airports, etc.

Well, if the one in question was in fact a "drone"...it obviously didn't have a good auto-stabilization program. I've built a couple similar sized ones as a hobby and I can hit one of them with a tennis ball and it will auto-stabilize immediately.
 
Maybe it's too autonomous and got scared when touched.

bn-ss-drone-disaster-at-tgifridays-2014-12-12-bk05_sl.jpg
 
OP was using the term "woman" very loosely. Watch her try to sue now, saying her beautiful face has been disfigured and demanding a million dollars. In the pilot's defense, if you're concentrating on the RC aircraft watching it intently, and then out of nowhere you come upon that face, it would be hard not to lose focus and twitch a bit at the controls. That's just human nature, flight or fight response. :D
 
I thought ducted fans were more efficient anyways?

Hell no. Ducted fans only become efficient at high speeds. They're good at making something that's moving fast move a little bit faster.

Big scoopy slow-fly props are much more efficient.
 
I think the main problem here is "pilots" who don't have enough respect for what they're doing and overestimating their skills.

The common trend seems to buy a turnkey a dji rig (buying expensive gear is totally pro) with autolevel and a barometer, start an aerial photography company and fly around in dangerous situations that anyone who knows what they're doing wouldn't touch with a 10 foot pole.

I'll land my tiny quadcopter with 2" props in my own hand, but anything much bigger than that, no way.

The big hexcopter in the photos (not the one that hit the reporter) looks to be spinning 10" props. Plenty of gore photos available on the web of accidental takeoffs and RTF incidents in that range.

It pisses me off, because I like to fly my RC multicopters and planes responsibly, and every idiot who does dangerous crap flying their "drones" over crowds and populated areas gives more and more ammo to the people who want to regulate the crap out of it.
 
When are people going to realize there is a difference between "drones" and basic ass RC Quadcopters? Can you program it to do things autonomously? No? GTFO with that "drone" bullshit then.

Or just GTFO with the drone bullshit and call it what it is either way. "drone" doesn't have any specific meaning with regards to autonomy. The earlier uses of the term, as in "target drones" weren't autonomous, they were basically just small aircraft that were converted to be radio controlled so anti aircraft crews could shoot them down for practice. The current "predator drones" aren't autonomous either, they're simply FPV controlled.

Drone is just a term that a lot of noobs like to use because they think it sounds cool and military-like. Media like to use that because it makes them sound scary and military-like.
 
I thought ducted fans were more efficient anyways?
Its really complicated, and the answer is "it depends".

Generally speaking, especially at cruise, the most efficient design would be a single bladed prop. The reason is simple, the prop disturbs the air as it passes, and by being a single blade, it has clean air. Its kind of why triplanes for example, even though providing additional lift, are less efficient than monoplanes. But a single blade isn't balanced and would shake apart, so you have two blades. But to get more static thrust you would want the blades to be longer, but then you run into three problems:
1) The tips are effectively going faster and faster, and eventually approach the sound barrier which is inefficient.
2) The blade becomes weak and could break
3) You run into space issues where the blades will hit crap

So like on WW2 panes you see some planes with props that have a ton of blades, which gives you extra thrust and top speed since you can spin the prop faster, but reduced efficiency.

Putting the blades in a duct helps alleviate the tip sound barrier/vortice issue (as long as it fits REAL tight), and you can spin the smaller props crazy fast to develop mucho thrust. But in the case of RC stuff, the electric motors I believe take a really big efficiency drop if you try to spin them crazy fast, negating the benefit, and the shroud just adds weight and drag.

So long story short, I learned a long time back that if you want mucho efficiency, go with gigantic two bladed props, as long as your landing gear will permit, and the ducted fans were only ever really used to simulate jet engines on the cheap in sound and appearance.
 
Or just GTFO with the drone bullshit and call it what it is either way. "drone" doesn't have any specific meaning with regards to autonomy. The earlier uses of the term, as in "target drones" weren't autonomous, they were basically just small aircraft that were converted to be radio controlled so anti aircraft crews could shoot them down for practice. The current "predator drones" aren't autonomous either, they're simply FPV controlled.

Drone is just a term that a lot of noobs like to use because they think it sounds cool and military-like. Media like to use that because it makes them sound scary and military-like.

Actually predators are relatively autonomous. They spend 99% of their time on programmed flight plans with contingency return missions (lost satellite link, bad nav hardware, etc). The only times a pilot is controlling anything is during takeoff,landing, during active kinetic engagements, or if crazy weather pops up in the airspace. The sensor operator is a different story.
 
I think the main problem here is "pilots" who don't have enough respect for what they're doing and overestimating their skills.

the article says the reporter flinched (pulled their hand away) and sent the drone careening into the photographer. Basically the reporter swatted the drone and it flew into someone else.
 
Its really complicated, and the answer is "it depends".

Generally speaking, especially at cruise, the most efficient design would be a single bladed prop. The reason is simple, the prop disturbs the air as it passes, and by being a single blade, it has clean air. Its kind of why triplanes for example, even though providing additional lift, are less efficient than monoplanes. But a single blade isn't balanced and would shake apart, so you have two blades. But to get more static thrust you would want the blades to be longer, but then you run into three problems:
1) The tips are effectively going faster and faster, and eventually approach the sound barrier which is inefficient.
2) The blade becomes weak and could break
3) You run into space issues where the blades will hit crap

So like on WW2 panes you see some planes with props that have a ton of blades, which gives you extra thrust and top speed since you can spin the prop faster, but reduced efficiency.

Putting the blades in a duct helps alleviate the tip sound barrier/vortice issue (as long as it fits REAL tight), and you can spin the smaller props crazy fast to develop mucho thrust. But in the case of RC stuff, the electric motors I believe take a really big efficiency drop if you try to spin them crazy fast, negating the benefit, and the shroud just adds weight and drag.

So long story short, I learned a long time back that if you want mucho efficiency, go with gigantic two bladed props, as long as your landing gear will permit, and the ducted fans were only ever really used to simulate jet engines on the cheap in sound and appearance.

The ducts would also have to be designed so they don't rob the air of a lot of energy. Being too wide or too narrow would counterproductive even if the electric motors were running at peak efficiency.
 
The ducts would also have to be designed so they don't rob the air of a lot of energy. Being too wide or too narrow would counterproductive even if the electric motors were running at peak efficiency.

Well, it's not so much that the ducts rob energy, as that they don't really have much benefit on a large low speed prop, which is what works best for hovering. That said, the photo he linked wasn't a conventional EDF like you would use on an RC jet either. it would function more as a prop guard, and would have little effect on thrust. It might reduce yaw authority a bit, since I think part of that comes from air spilling off the prop tips (but mostly just reaction torque)

As far as props go, there's several factors involved. The most obvious two (and the way they're generally specified) are just length, and pitch. However even in the same size and pitch, they can be optimized for different loads and air speeds. Some props are designed to deal with more loads at low airspeeds, and others for lighter loads at higher speeds.

If I bought every 8"x4.5 I could find and tested them all on a quadcopter and on a powered glider, I would be willing to bet that the prop that gives the longest flight time would be different in each case.
 
the article says the reporter flinched (pulled their hand away) and sent the drone careening into the photographer. Basically the reporter swatted the drone and it flew into someone else.

I'm guessing the pilot probably tried to save it from hitting the floor when she moved her hand out of the way and gave it way too much stick.

Regardless, If he had sufficient respect for what he was doing, he would know better than to try an land it on a reporter's hand.

The problem is that a lot of people just don't take them seriously. I've had relative beginners flying around right near the flight line and over our heads when we've had group meetups to fly. I don't think they actually realize how dangerous they are, and you just have to hope they hurt themselves before they hurt someone else.
 
Well, it's not so much that the ducts rob energy, as that they don't really have much benefit on a large low speed prop, which is what works best for hovering. That said, the photo he linked wasn't a conventional EDF like you would use on an RC jet either. it would function more as a prop guard, and would have little effect on thrust. It might reduce yaw authority a bit, since I think part of that comes from air spilling off the prop tips (but mostly just reaction torque)

As far as props go, there's several factors involved. The most obvious two (and the way they're generally specified) are just length, and pitch. However even in the same size and pitch, they can be optimized for different loads and air speeds. Some props are designed to deal with more loads at low airspeeds, and others for lighter loads at higher speeds.

If I bought every 8"x4.5 I could find and tested them all on a quadcopter and on a powered glider, I would be willing to bet that the prop that gives the longest flight time would be different in each case.

Depending on the size and shape of the duct, it can definitely cause a great deal more turbulence in the moving air...which would reduce lift. I don't mess with ducts on my 'copters so I just speak from a theoretical point of view.

As for overall efficiency, I've been experimenting on variable pitch rotors (of my own design) to see how much they help in the real world. Problem is that they don't play well with my stabilization algorithm when I do anything other than hover (over or under corrects depending on the pitch and then crashes obviously). I wrote everything myself so I need to go back and do a rewrite because the input values I put in there after the fact are not working like they should.
 
I'm guessing the pilot probably tried to save it from hitting the floor when she moved her hand out of the way and gave it way too much stick.

Regardless, If he had sufficient respect for what he was doing, he would know better than to try an land it on a reporter's hand.

The problem is that a lot of people just don't take them seriously. I've had relative beginners flying around right near the flight line and over our heads when we've had group meetups to fly. I don't think they actually realize how dangerous they are, and you just have to hope they hurt themselves before they hurt someone else.

I have to agree, no matter if the person moved or not. The pilot shouldn't have tried to land it on a person anyway. It is their fault for not having respect for what he was doing.
 
Seriously? I had a gas powered remote control car when I was 8. It's called teaching the child responsibility.

Yeah this. Parents that can afford to buy things for their children like yours and mine were a lot better at being parents than those lame working class ones. Stick it to the labor caste Nick! They totally deserve to be snubbed for being irresponsible losers who live in crappy trailers, but smoke, have satellite TV, and are suck up welfare.
 
than isnt a cut on her nose, its a M&M shell piece.

'Blah, i have a better picture somewhere of what my multicopter did to my leg with 10" props lol
 
I have a small quadcopter Proto X, it has 1.5" blades and one time I flew it too close to my wife, it drifted and got caught in her hair :D
 
Back
Top