Tesla's Home Battery Back-Up System

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I wonder how long you have to own one of these before they actually pay for themselves.

Tesla Motors CEO Elon Musk officially announced two battery backup solutions, one for homes and one for industrial use, at an event at the company's Southern California design studio. The lithium-ion battery modules can store electricity from solar panels and serve to balance loads from the grid, charging up during non-peak energy usage hours, then providing energy to a home or facility during peak hours.
 
Dooms day preppers are going to be ALL over this.
 
if you own your own solar panels...

I can see how if you have the money to invest in it, it would be good.
 
It seems kinda inefficient to put these things on individual homes instead of using like a centrally managed power generation and storage thing-y to serve a large area through the wires and stuff that everyone already uses to get electricity. It's just another gimmicky idea that appeases individual weirdness instead of addressing a concern in like a societal way.
 
Not as long as you think, at least in states with high energy rates.

For instance: California
In a good part of the state, residential rate starts at around $0.115, and quickly scales up as high as $0.531 per kWh as your total use crosses different "tier" thresholds. It's also about 3 times more expensive during the day than it is night

Excess solar power, if you generate a net positive amount, they will buy for about $0.045 per kWh. Right now solar costs between $2000-$4000 per kW to install (depending on size of installation, type of installation, leasing terms, etc). Most people don't install extra solar because it isn't worth it - they just install enough to prevent from going into the obscenely high tier rates, not have to buy the more expensive day-time power, and import the cheaper power at night.

And for industry, they not only have charges based on how much they use, but on their peak demand. A one-time spike in demand at the wrong time of the day can cost tens of thousands of dollars, with each additional kW in demand costing something on the order of $36.00. The 100kWh backup unit mentioned here, if it can reduce a single spike in demand by 100kW by using it at the right time, that saves up to about $3,600 right there in one shot off a monthly bill.

Not every state or utility company has these very convoluted electrical rates. A lot of places are still flat rate and pretty reasonable for their power. But at 53 cents a kWh purchase and 4.5 cent sale, it doesn't take long for microgrid to start to look attractive.
 
It seems kinda inefficient to put these things on individual homes instead of using like a centrally managed power generation and storage thing-y to serve a large area through the wires and stuff that everyone already uses to get electricity. It's just another gimmicky idea that appeases individual weirdness instead of addressing a concern in like a societal way.
Usually the purpose of battery backups are to serve electricity during outages, created due to a downed powerline, construction mistake, brownout, hurricane, etc.

We have had quite a few power outages lately with all the strong winds and hail we had in those storms, but it doesn't affect me as I have five good size UPSes in my home, along with power efficient tablets and lithium emergency lights plugged into extra outlets, and for extended outages like a hurricane I have a Yamaha gas powered generator that plugs into my home's electrical system (although I'd turn off central AC and use the window-AC unit only in my gameroom to hunker down in). Top off the bathtubs with water, and along with my couple gallon water jugs, plenty of food, video surveillance w/ nightvision, and some firepower, I can hold my own if the shizzle were to hit the fan.

My outage was only around five hours, but I didn't even lose convenience features like internet and was good the whole time. :)

But yes, to sell this on economics is ridiculous, as it would never pay for itself, and the people that can afford it aren't worried about that. Its more an extra layer of insurance for people who can afford the luxury of a total-home lithium battery backup solution, which is certainly something I would do if I had the means.
 
A buddy of mine did some math on it and came up with 2-4 years to get your return on investment.. Not bad at all..
 
People keep forgetting that more often than not most things start out "too expensive". The first cell phone cost $3995 in 1983. Think about that for one second....which is probably to long for millennial..but I digress. :p
 
If you had a home with some high risk medical devices it could certainly have it's usages ... if you were in an area with an unreliable power grid where rolling blackouts were common there could be benefits ... as well as their listed example of solar users ... if a device with multiple hours of usage could be constructed for less than $5000 and if the battery had sufficient life before needing replacement then I could see this being of benefit

Large scale industrial locations already use generators and battery backups, depending on their risk from unexpected blackouts ... if the units are cost effective with other competing products then I could see some interest there also.
 
Usually the purpose of battery backups are to serve electricity during outages, created due to a downed powerline, construction mistake, brownout, hurricane, etc.

We have had quite a few power outages lately with all the strong winds and hail we had in those storms, but it doesn't affect me as I have five good size UPSes in my home, along with power efficient tablets and lithium emergency lights plugged into extra outlets, and for extended outages like a hurricane I have a Yamaha gas powered generator that plugs into my home's electrical system (although I'd turn off central AC and use the window-AC unit only in my gameroom to hunker down in). Top off the bathtubs with water, and along with my couple gallon water jugs, plenty of food, video surveillance w/ nightvision, and some firepower, I can hold my own if the shizzle were to hit the fan.

My outage was only around five hours, but I didn't even lose convenience features like internet and was good the whole time. :)

But yes, to sell this on economics is ridiculous, as it would never pay for itself, and the people that can afford it aren't worried about that. Its more an extra layer of insurance for people who can afford the luxury of a total-home lithium battery backup solution, which is certainly something I would do if I had the means.

Disaster prep is a good point. I really didn't think about it much so yeah, I can understand the appeal there. If I were in a situation like that, I'd totally pull on the zombie food t-shirt I bought from ThinkGeek and just wait for the inevitable though. :) It takes like a million times less effort to do that or just go hang out with someone who would be all like, "Oh, I'll protect you and your cat. Just come over with some pancakes."
 
People keep forgetting that more often than not most things start out "too expensive". The first cell phone cost $3995 in 1983. Think about that for one second....which is probably to long for millennial..but I digress. :p

I tried, but I got distracted by something shiny on my desk and never really finished my th--
 
People keep forgetting that more often than not most things start out "too expensive". The first cell phone cost $3995 in 1983. Think about that for one second....which is probably to long for millennial..but I digress. :p

This
 
Solar power (in CA atleast) works by a process called net metering, basically power generated by the panels during day time (low usage phase) is fed into the grid and then reclaimed in the evening thru a 1-1 ratio.

However at the end of 2015 this will change, they call the new rule Net Metering 2.0 and its unclear know what ratio they will use but its a fair bet that it wont be 1-1. Thus you either build a bigger solar system to offset the loss or you install a battery that collects the days production for evening use.

However with a 900kwh system (per month) the days need is ~30kwh and you would most likely need 2 of these to cover it 100% so in San Diego at present time that would be ~20% of the solar system cost.
 
This could actually be "better" than solar panels for the utility companies because it could potentially ease peak loads when the power grid is actually stressed, as opposed to solar panels which provide unnecessary power much of the time when the power grid has a low load.

One problem is that some power companies don't charge more or less at different times of the day. For people who pay a flat rate for power, this thing only makes sense if it is combined with solar panels that can charge it with excess power produced during the day for use when the solar panels aren't helping. Local storage of excess power produced by solar panels is actually a really good idea. There are a lot of good ideas on how to store excess solar power (heavy flywheels, compressed air, pumping water to a tower or uphill reservoir, etc) but those other techniques are not practical for home use. Cheap enough battery storage that is also reliable and "easy" enough for consumer use is just the ticket.

The price ought to start fairly low and drop in another year or two, once Tesla's new battery factory ramps up production. That factory will see huge economies of scale and will need a larger customer base than just tesla car owners.
 
For instance: California
In a good part of the state, residential rate starts at around $0.115, and quickly scales up as high as $0.531 per kWh as your total use crosses different "tier" thresholds. It's also about 3 times more expensive during the day than it is night
It's important to note that the highest rates are generally available to people who "benefit" from having a deregulated power company. Municipal power utility rates tend to be much lower. An individual rate payer at the lower end won't tend to see the ridiculously high rates that other customers see. For example, my municipal utility charges $0.13/KW-Hr for the amount I use and maxes out at $0.17/HW-Hr if I excessively consume electricity (which takes over 30-something KW-Hr per day every day for a month to begin even getting charged for power beyond that at the highest rate).
 
I do think the capacities are a bit on the low side... I live in Vegas and my daily use during the worst part of the summer is about 100kWh. Their large 10kWh unit isn't nearly enough to get me through the worst part of the day, between approx 2-6pm. Combine it with a handful of solar panels angled for afternoon sun angles and it could work really well though.
 
Oops I meant to post on the general topic too.

The Tesla home battery packs start at $3500 and have a 10KW-Hr capacity. The 7KW-Hr model is $3000. For someone with an off-grid sized solar panel installation but is still reliant on the grid for morning/night power, this could be something that lets them cut the utility off. With the ridiculous surcharges proposed (which are often higher than what I pay for electricity in a month), this could be a perfect thumb in the eye for these corrupt industry bills winding through legislatures.
 
Filling the battery with off-peak power and using it during peak times would make sense where I live.
 
I do think the capacities are a bit on the low side... I live in Vegas and my daily use during the worst part of the summer is about 100kWh. Their large 10kWh unit isn't nearly enough to get me through the worst part of the day, between approx 2-6pm. Combine it with a handful of solar panels angled for afternoon sun angles and it could work really well though.

It's not really financially feasible to build a home battery backup system capable of running AC. Drop the AC and you'd be fine.
 
if you own your own solar panels...

I can see how if you have the money to invest in it, it would be good.

The battery has long been the missing piece for solar cells. The panels themselves are relatively trivial now, its batteries we need.
 
I would buy these in a heartbeat.

We have a deregulated system (Texas) and it is a pain to get a company that has both cheap rates AND nice buyback.

Throwing this in with our 7kw system would greatly expand our choice and ease of operation. We currently produce enough to handle our monthly needs.



Now.... we just need them to take the extra step of smartly integrating the on grid inverter so they can talk to each other and keep production running even without a grid (and shutting off the inverter when the battery was low).
 
nice post hardocp, just thought of old school lectures where we energies in wisconsin would offer lower costs if you signed up for their program where they axe your power during the day and let you go nuts at night at a lower cost.

why? it costs a crap ton and more energy to power down at night, if they could keep less power sources running 24/7 its cheaper than using 2x during the day and 1/2 at night. This way they could keep power sources churning off hours > store in batteries... then during the day those customers can use the battery instead of more expensive daytime grid power.

pretty clever!!!
 
Someone made an interesting argument about this selling to Businesses like hotcakes due to potentially being able to manipulate the "demand charge" cost of the equation under business plans.

https://www.nationalgridus.com/niagaramohawk/non_html/eff_elec-demand.pdf

Pg 2:

On every demand-billed customer’s energy service bill, charges for consumption and demand are separate.

This exaggerated example illustrates how the two work:

Suppose you have a commercial building with lighting, cooling, machinery, and electric equipment. Its fully installed load totals 15 kW. You are not using the building and have no employees. On the first day of each month, you come into the building and turn on all electrical equipment and leave it on for 15 minutes. Then you shut everything off again and lock up the building until the following month. What would your electric bill look like? It would show very little consumption; in fact, only 4 kWh, at a cost of about 28 cents.
...
But what about your demand charge? At an average cost of $8.32 per kW and
the meter reading at 15 kW, the demand charge would be $124.80
...

For example, suppose you have a 10 kW motor in one part of the
building and a 15 kW motor in another. If you operate both units simultaneously,
the demand meter will record 25 kW. However, if you can use the motors
alternately, operating the 10 kW unit only when the 15 kW unit is off, the maximum
demand reading will be only 15 kW. The 10 kW saved would save about $83 per
month, or $996 per year.

So maybe it could be popular for load balancing peak times and such for example.
 
So i have a 10kwh battery that will put out 2000 watts. So... I "might" be able to run a toaster and a small hair drier during an outage. No way i could run a well pump, fridge, oven, alot of lights...

This great for those rich folk that dont want to pay for peak 50 cents an hour during the day. This is worthless for preppers or intermittent power.

20 amps at 120v for 5 hours... does it have an apple logo on it?
 
The battery has long been the missing piece for solar cells. The panels themselves are relatively trivial now, its batteries we need.

new battery technologies are developed that seems to make this even more viable.
 
Did Tesla manage to build a light weight battery to promote wall mount in homes? I can't imagine drywall supporting even one let alone multiple. Makes more sense for weight to rest on ground but the pics clearly don't show it that way. Haven't found any specs on it yet.
 
Solar power (in CA atleast) works by a process called net metering, basically power generated by the panels during day time (low usage phase) is fed into the grid and then reclaimed in the evening thru a 1-1 ratio.

However at the end of 2015 this will change, they call the new rule Net Metering 2.0 and its unclear know what ratio they will use but its a fair bet that it wont be 1-1. Thus you either build a bigger solar system to offset the loss or you install a battery that collects the days production for evening use.

Yep, that's what they do out here in California, change the rules after you already spent the money.
No wonder I keep getting calls several times a week from companies wanting me to install solar. After this change it will take even longer to break even, and their sales will likely drop.

Even with the 1-1 ratio, Solar still doesn't make sense unless you have a high power bill most the year.
My home is reasonable efficient (led lights, etc.), so for most the year my bill is <$70, even with the high rates. It's only a few hot months of the year where the bill rises to over $200, so my break even with Solar would be over 15 years. Add a battery, and it would likely be over 20 years. By that time I'll likely be retired and have moved to a lower cost state.

The main advantage of the battery would be in case of a long term power outage. It would be nice knowing that the fridge, etc., would keep working even if I was out of town for the week.
 
I will take 2 and this will be great with a 20Kw natural gas generator for the hurricanes!!!!!!!!!!!
 
if you own your own solar panels...

I can see how if you have the money to invest in it, it would be good.

Not necessarily, it's capable of operating with the grid (no panels) and is designed to use battery during peak hours, then charge during non-peak hours.

Additionally, if you do own your own solar panels, you'll likely want one of these as feeding back to the grid is wasteful since they only pay wholesale.
 
.

Even with the 1-1 ratio, Solar still doesn't make sense unless you have a high power bill most the year.
My home is reasonable efficient (led lights, etc.), so for most the year my bill is <$70, even with the high rates. It's only a few hot months of the year where the bill rises to over $200, so my break even with Solar would be over 15 years. Add a battery, and it would likely be over 20 years. By that time I'll likely be retired and have moved to a lower cost state.

The main advantage of the battery would be in case of a long term power outage. It would be nice knowing that the fridge, etc., would keep working even if I was out of town for the week.


Solar panels really only have a good ROI if you do the majority of the work yourself. Or with Solar City, likely never. Their business model evolves around becoming one of the largest providers of power. I've talked to people who enter their leases and clearly didn't read the fine print - they all think that after 15yrs, SC will just "give them the panels" like DTV/Dish does with the dishes. That's counter-intuitive to their business model. You either re-lease, or they remove the panels (you're responsible for your own roof repairs).
 
It's not a generator.

It's a battery.
The point is that a prepper or just anyone that wants to ensure that they don't go without power, you could get a very powerful generator for the price of the battery, and the generator could run for days with much greater output.

With a natural gas one, you could have it fed directly from natural gas lines, with a line for emergency tank use instead if need be.
 
If it saves you $50/mo., then at $3k, it'll take 5 years for a payoff.

I wonder how much resale value they'll add to a home? Maybe 50% of its cost (i.e., $1500)?

For $3-3.5k, it better include installation and a 5-10-year warranty.
 
If it saves you $50/mo., then at $3k, it'll take 5 years for a payoff.
Very unlikely. Remember one of the first rules you learn in physics; you can't even break even!

That's why my UPSs bypass the battery 99.9% of the time and feed direct AC current, as its much more efficient, and the batteries just trickle charge to stay topped off... so its vampiric, but at least not massively inefficient since you hardly ever rely on that power conversion process to power your devices.

There is inherent loss in converting electricity into stored battery power back into electricity. Even if you're getting the power cheaper at one time of day than another, you're likely to run at a loss. Regardless, how much power are you possibly storing anyway? If its not a significant amount of your daily electricity usage, there isn't going to be much savings.
 
People keep forgetting that more often than not most things start out "too expensive". The first cell phone cost $3995 in 1983. Think about that for one second....which is probably to long for millennial..but I digress. :p

And you nailed it. Supply will be the biggest issue for now but I can see this finally challenging traditional grid supply systems at last.
 
Back
Top