Tesla Suing Top Gear

I've seen the episode.. the tesla died long before the company said it should. Then Top Gear brought the backup out. Guess what, it shit the bed too. tough tittie tesla, shoulda made a better car. Better luck next time.

Your statement is the EXACT reason that Tesla is suing. The cars were fine / manufactured but for one blown fuse. Top Gear put a mountain of misrepresentation for people like you to buy into and believe the car is junk. You bought the Top Gear misrepresentation, just like Tesla is fearing their target market will.
 
"There is no bad publicity" only applies to individuals in entertainment.

I think Toyota would say there very well is bad publicity.


Not really, Their retail sales shot through the roof. The local dealership could not keep stock up. A friend of mine who worked sales there even stated they thought all the bad publicity was going to really hurt and they ended up make more during that than at any other time. His sales went up 600%. He said it was like that at just about every dealership across the country.
 
Your statement is the EXACT reason that Tesla is suing. The cars were fine / manufactured but for one blown fuse. Top Gear put a mountain of misrepresentation for people like you to buy into and believe the car is junk. You bought the Top Gear misrepresentation, just like Tesla is fearing their target market will.


Making excuses after the fact is BS the car broke during the review. SO it became part of the review. Tesla can say all they want to but Top Gear is still a very loved TV show world wide. They are about to learn what the definition of backlash is. Maybe if they spent the money on engineering instead of marketing they issues would of never come up.
 
Not going to comment on the rest, but 55 miles of range under track conditions is pretty good. I bet you almost any production sports car, with some real power behind it, driven like they drive on the show would get about 1/2 to 1/4 of their rated mileage if driven in the same way. Lets face it. There isn't really anywhere you can actually drive like that. short of a track.

Everyone might as well get used to it. Electric cars are the future. Batteries are getting better and cheaper every year and gas is getting more expensive. Give it another 20 years or so and I'd be willing to bet you can put an equivalent power,size,range gas and electric car side by side and they will be nearly equal except for maybe at the extreme end of performance.
 
Making excuses after the fact is BS the car broke during the review. SO it became part of the review. Tesla can say all they want to but Top Gear is still a very loved TV show world wide. They are about to learn what the definition of backlash is. Maybe if they spent the money on engineering instead of marketing they issues would of never come up.

The car didn't break. One car had one blown fuse. That is the whole point. The part of the review 5 minutes in where they all dramatically look befuddled as the car dies due to a flat battery, then a road crew pushes it to a garage? DIDN'T HAPPEN. That is why Tesla is suing.
 
Not going to comment on the rest, but 55 miles of range under track conditions is pretty good. I bet you almost any production sports car, with some real power behind it, driven like they drive on the show would get about 1/2 to 1/4 of their rated mileage if driven in the same way. Lets face it. There isn't really anywhere you can actually drive like that. short of a track.

I agree. I think one of the things Tesla is ticked off about is that the battery never ran out.... It only got down to 25%. So if they managed 55 miles with > 25% battery life left.... in theory, they could have driven it another 15 miles and reached 70 miles.
 
This story hit CNET and has that episode in question:
http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13746_7-20048815-48.html

Not sure how "frivolous" this really is. There seems to be a fair amount of evidence that supports Tesla on this one. Certainly there have been much more frivolous lawsuits between companies than this. :p
I agree that more frivolous lawsuits have existed. (Hell, Apple and Sony have a ton of such lawsuits they've created.) But Tesla is 3 years too late to respond to that episode and the lawsuit makes them look like litigious bastards rather than those that make gasoline-free sports cars.
 
To say "it's actual range is 55 miles"; regardless of the context is a misrepresentation.

Oh really? Who's doing the misrepresentation here?

Top Gear Transcript included in Legal Filing said:
Although Tesla say it will do 200 miles we worked out that on our track it would run out after just 55 miles.

You can read the filing from Tesla's own site here where the transcript is located: http://www.teslamotors.com/sites/default/files/tesla_-_claim_form_claimants_copy_29_03_11.pdf

Where did anybody on Top Gear say or print that "it's actual range is 55 miles"?
Please provide proof to back up your assertion. I'd say that somebody's misrepresenting what was actually stated on Top Gear, and it's not Tesla.

There's actually some merit (albeit very small) in the video's implication that the car stopped on track, but the claim that stating that they only got a projected range of 55 miles ON TRACK is not Libel in my books.

Hey, my car got 6 mpg when I flogged it on the Streets of Willows track. I normally get 19 mpg. The rated value is 23 mpg.

I dare you to sue me for misrepresenting "the facts" for saying I *only* got 6 MPG on Track.
 
Yeah, like Tesla is going to suffer financially from tp's review. What, are they afraid the last few people in the state who can afford their roadster aren't going to buy it now?
 
The car didn't break. One car had one blown fuse. That is the whole point. The part of the review 5 minutes in where they all dramatically look befuddled as the car dies due to a flat battery, then a road crew pushes it to a garage? DIDN'T HAPPEN. That is why Tesla is suing.

I'm sorry, but to me a blown fuse is the car breaking. You or I may know what happened but your average Id10t on the street will not and if it takes a tech to tell you it blew a fuse the car is broken. If heard the term "You get one chance." They should of damn well made sure the cars were perfect. So instead of showing up Top Gear they went the way of all companies that produces a screwed up product. Litigation and that is a major failure on their part.
They should of done something like. "We took what Top Gear said to heart. Fixed the Issue and welcome them to do a review at any time." and left it at that. Nope its the some old BS you don't like the review SUE!

Hmmm who does that remind me of.... Phantom.... maybe.....
 
The video gives the following impression:

-The car will leave you stranded due to its electric motor.

-It is generally unreliable and would be a terrible car to deal with.


Tesla has a case that both of those impressions or implications are blatantly false based on manufactured evidence and bias. Top Gear is in the wrong. /thread.
 
I swear it's like Tesla never watched the show before. Other manufacturers have sent crews with the cars to fix things when something goes wrong, Tesla should have just done the same.
 
The video gives the following impression:

-The car will leave you stranded due to its electric motor.

-It is generally unreliable and would be a terrible car to deal with.


Tesla has a case that both of those impressions or implications are blatantly false based on manufactured evidence and bias. Top Gear is in the wrong. /thread.

/unthread

They had cars which suffered brake issues and a motor issue.

You run out of charge, how are you expected to go anywhere? Spending that kind of money on a car where you can only go 100 miles in any given direction at one time is asnine. I can go 211 miles in my Audi and not have to wait for a recharge when I want to go another 211 miles.

The 211 mile "claims" were generated using a standard mix of highway and city driving, effectively the same tests used to determine MPG. So I would simply ask, what's the point of buying that car if you're simply going to do city and highway driving like a Prius driver...and having the exciting luxury of only go 100 miles away from home before having to turn back?

It's marketed as a driver's car, a sports car for those who don't want the stigma of driving a gutless eco-box electric car. A green performance car.

So who's more at fault for falsehoods? Tesla's marketing department for implying that it's a sports car and can be driven like one all with the beneift of 211mile range? Or Top Gear for thrashing it on a track, showing some weaknesses and scenarios which would be less than optimal when driving it more in the tenor for which Tesla's been pushing it.



So sorry, but if you run out of charge, you're dead, doesn't matter if it's 55miles or 211 miles.
 
And this is the reason why Top GEar America is destined to fail. Any and all reviews that aren't glwoing and favorable will result in a lawsuit. Thank you Tesla for proving what Top Gear UK fans have said what will happen all along. Review an American car and if you don't give it best in show you will be sued.
 
The same reason they do anything, they think they'll get lulz from it. They get to act all superior, and they latched onto fuel cells years ago.

Point: Testing the Prius they had it racing around a track at full power. This is not what a hybrid is built for. Still they concluded the BMW (which they had following it) offered better gas mileage. Now a real test of a hybrid vs tradition would be to have a very boring 15mph, stop / wait 5min / go 2min (repeated until one car ran out of fuel) and the hybrid would win that most likely, because that's what it was built for. Hybrids aren't meant for long, smooth, highway commutes. Nope they're meant for that annoying California (or Virginian or London) 10mph slogging commute.

Very few of their tests are honest and electric vehicles are, in particular (even more so than hybrids), hated with a venom by the boys. That's why I never take their tests too seriously. Unfortunately for Tesla, many people do.

I do agree with JC about Porsche though, lazy f*ckin' designers.

well Tesla seems to be suggesting that TG has a alternative motive or perhaps outside influences.

I live right near Tesla and see their cars driving around everyday. I've never seen one on the side of the road or broken down.

I'd like to see what comes of this. I've seen a lot of TV shows loose credibility because of corporate sponsors or just flat out bogus footage. On the other hand they could be unveiling a flaw in the design and that could scare investors.
 
The video gives the following impression:

-The car will leave you stranded due to its electric motor.

-It is generally unreliable and would be a terrible car to deal with.


Tesla has a case that both of those impressions or implications are blatantly false based on manufactured evidence and bias. Top Gear is in the wrong. /thread.
lol no

The car is not a hybrid, so yes, you are stranded when the battery runs out. If you run the car harder than the nice tests used to calculate the 200 mile+ range, that range is severely reduced.

The car is priced, styled and marketed as a sports car. It doesn't handle that task very well.

Tesla is in the wrong. /thread
 
I can't wait 'til "Top Gear UK" resumes Season 17. I assume Jeremy & Co. will respond to this silly lawsuit in their normal comical way. :D
 
Its pretty hard to take "car experts" seriously when they can not spell Camaro correctly

Yeah, I always fuck it up. Oh well, you'd think I learn.

Doesn't change the fact it's an overweight piece of shit that can't turn.
 
"think I'd learn"

It's incredibly annoying that there is no edit feature in this forum.
 
And this is the reason why Top GEar America is destined to fail. Any and all reviews that aren't glwoing and favorable will result in a lawsuit. Thank you Tesla for proving what Top Gear UK fans have said what will happen all along. Review an American car and if you don't give it best in show you will be sued.

There's a huge difference between an unfavorable review, and an outright false one. For example, they review crap cars all the time. However they don't make sh*t up about them because they don't have to. On the other hand, it appears they falsified info outright here. I'll reserve judgement but I'll say it's possible, given how much the boys hate battery electrics and hybrids.
 
There's a huge difference between an unfavorable review, and an outright false one. For example, they review crap cars all the time. However they don't make sh*t up about them because they don't have to. On the other hand, it appears they falsified info outright here. I'll reserve judgement but I'll say it's possible, given how much the boys hate battery electrics and hybrids.
If that were the case, wouldn't Jeremy C. purposely have lost the drag race against that (sexy yellow) Lotus?
 
'grats Tesla, I'll never buy one of your cars...

I look forward to Clarkson ripping on you this summer when the next series airs.
 
I fond this hilarious that any of you folks in the USA think we in the UK take Top Gear seriously and class it as informative journalism.

We all know its staged. They couldnt do most of this stuff they do if it wasnt pre-arranged.

Its called entertainment. It's also called US sense of humour faliure.

Watch the star in a car bits and watch the clock on the fastest lap. You'll see the lap footage is made up from several laps.

Now all Top Gear will do is rip Tesla a new one.
 
There seem to be a lot of people commenting about TG who haven't even watched the show. The show isn't a serious car reviewing programming. One of their reviews they drove a car in an amphibious assault and had Royal Marines firing assault rifles from the vehicle. Some might say that wasn't a "real world test" well it was quite amusing.

TG seem to consider that the vehicle with the brake problem wasn't safe to drive on the track. Tesla Motors believe it was safe to drive (so long as you drive like you grandma).

This lawsuit will just result in the Tesla constantly being slagged off on the program, which will result in damage to their image.
 
I fond this hilarious that any of you folks in the USA think we in the UK take Top Gear seriously and class it as informative journalism.

We all know its staged. They couldnt do most of this stuff they do if it wasnt pre-arranged.

Its called entertainment. It's also called US sense of humour faliure.

Watch the star in a car bits and watch the clock on the fastest lap. You'll see the lap footage is made up from several laps.

Now all Top Gear will do is rip Tesla a new one.

There are many people in the US who believe Fox News is actually real.
 
I think some people are still sore about the Alabama stunt, probably because the posters never signed a release. :D
 
Why is it only now after three whole years that tesla is doing something?

I take it three years ago they didnt mind at the time?

Are they that desperate for cash and attention at the moment? Cant be easy selling fast milk floats in the current economy.
 
If they had a clever marketing department they could have set up something interesting for a special episode to make something entertaining yet show off features of their cars. Instead they responded with the engineering asperger's.
 
Before the C6, he regularly mentioned how the Corvette was junk because of its solid axle (Corvettes have had IRS since the early 60s).

I thought the America bashing got so bad I stopped watching a few seasons ago, now they seem to have let off more.

I'm a fan of the Corvette, and I still love watching their show. Actually, I'd rather they continue to make fun of American cars. It's what makes the show funny.

It's a semi serious car review show, that does a lot of things car review shows wouldn't do. They can influence car purchases, but it's mainly for entertainment. If you used their show to go buy a car, then you're doing something wrong.

So do stuff that's so retarded, it's brilliant.
 
I swear it's like Tesla never watched the show before. Other manufacturers have sent crews with the cars to fix things when something goes wrong, Tesla should have just done the same.

Your right, the T1 Caparro is more well known for it's problems than it's blistering speed, part of the under tray came loose while Clarkson was driving it, and there was an issue getting the thing to fire up again, there was a crew there the whole time to fix it.

It's also famous for bursting into flames, Jason Plato from 5th gear got burned due to the car, another guy was almost killed because of a suspension strut breaking loose, these were all mentioned while Clarkson drove the car.

I think Top gear did them a favour, they set some facts straight about the Tesla, it has tremendous power in a straight line, handles like a 400lb drunken whore on the corners, and your charging source for the car is the power plant down the road (which in the US is mostly coal burning), so it's no greener than a regular gas car. If you still want that car, then buy one, don't take TG's word for it until you drive it, if you like it then buy it.

And I have seen several Tesla's around the immediate area, so it's not doing that badly.
 
There is one that autocrosses in Boise and it regularly sets fastest raw time of the day, and there is also a Viper that autocrosses in the same events.

That says something.
 
I'm going to have to side with Tesla on this one. Top Gear is entertainment first, review second. But this time they went a little far...

Yeah, of course if the Tesla runs out of juice, it would need to be towed/pushed to a charger. But that's why the car has a charge gauge and warnings that appear before the car goes dead. If you intentionality drive the car past this point and get yourself in a situation where you need a tow it's really your fault. Add on the fact that they totally staged the "incident" doesn't sit well.

Top gear did state the brakes failed in their review. If in fact it was the vacuum pump that failed (rather the fuse to the pump blew) they did NOT fail. Loss of vacuum to the brake booster is NOT brake failure, period. Take this from a mechanic and a mechanical engineer.

Sure Top Gear is a a show for entertainment, rather then serious reviews. However, the problem is they are perceived by much of the public as a legitimate review source, thus Top Gear has some responsibility here.


To me, it looks like Top Gear took advantage of the novel situation (review of first electric sports car) to put together a sensationalized review for ratings on TV at the expense of Tesla's reputation.


I am sure some people are upset by the fact that their car review source is really in fact drama/entertainment/production.
 
Fuck top gear. I hope Tesla makes them hurt for lible. Top Gear trashes every single American made car unless it has jointly made with Eurotrash. They love making anything made in the USA look half assed all to kiss the ass of European viewers AND their sponcers. Fuck Top Gear and the BBC

They heavily favor British cars over non-British European cars, and European cars in general over non-European cars. So what? Who actually would watch Top Gear to get a fair review of a car? Its more a comedy show than anything, its supposed to be fun to watch, not informative. Also FWIW most American cars pretty easy to rip on-- they only like sports cars, so wipe out all non-sports cars.... of remaining maybe Z06 and latest Mustang? What else should get a favorable review? Anyways it doesn't actually matter, its more of a coin flip what kind of review a car will get. BTW, Jeremy bought himself a GT40 when it came out, and Hammond owns and has owned many classic muscle cars.


Anyways as for actually story of Tesla suing Top Gear... WTF did they expect? They ALWAYS rip on hybrids/electric cars/gas taxes/traffic laws/anything that does not support sports cars. I've never seen them say anything positive about anything 'green' (for lack of better clasification). Tesla gave them a car? WTF they're idiots. I would have bet a million dollars on how the review was going to go, no fucking way was it going to be positive.
 
"Specifically, Top Gear misrepresented that:
1. The Roadster ran out of charge and had to be pushed into the Top Gear hangar by 4 men.
2. The Roadster’s true range is only 55 miles per charge (not 211).
3. One Roadster’s motor overheated and was completely immobilized as a result.
4. The other Roadster’s brakes were broken, rendering the car undriveable.
5. That neither of the two Roadsters provided to Top Gear was available for test driving due to these problems.

The breakdowns were staged and the statements are untrue. "


Why would Top Gear stage these things? I don't get it.
Are you serious?

Why would Jeremy Clarkson represent a car unfairly for the sake of drama? Have you, uh, ever watched the show?

He lies about half the cars on there, especially if they are American or British in origin.

For example, he drove over a tiny pebble in the Corvette and pretended that it broke his back, exaggerating that it has a stiff suspension, when its actually one of the most compliant suspensions you can get on a vehicle of its performance. When he reviewed the Lotus Exige (which my neighbor owns, well, an Elise) he said the suspension was heavenly.... but its absolutely hard as nails compared to a big soft GT car like the Vette. He also allowed a Corvette to lose in a drag race against an Acura NSX, the same weight, skinnier tires, doesn't have the same launch control aides, and is waaaay down on power. It goes on and on.
 
Anyways as for actually story of Tesla suing Top Gear... WTF did they expect? They ALWAYS rip on hybrids/electric cars/gas taxes/traffic laws/anything that does not support sports cars. I've never seen them say anything positive about anything 'green' (for lack of better clasification). Tesla gave them a car? WTF they're idiots. I would have bet a million dollars on how the review was going to go, no fucking way was it going to be positive.
So Tesla should have known that Jeremy Clarkson would as usual blatantly lie and slander the vehicle, and therefor the guilty party here is... Tesla?

Thats like blaming rape victims that they should have known better than to leave the kitchen. Its her fault. Slut.
 
There are many people in the US who believe Fox News is actually real.

Yeah, that's the most inconvenient truth I've read in this thread so far. People flip to Fox so they can check out Megyn Kelly and Gretchen Carlson (I don't remember her last name) and get misinformed out the ass. Tea Party rally-ers = Fox News watchers.
 
Top gear did state the brakes failed in their review. If in fact it was the vacuum pump that failed (rather the fuse to the pump blew) they did NOT fail. Loss of vacuum to the brake booster is NOT brake failure, period. Take this from a mechanic and a mechanical engineer.

Okay, the exact quote from the transcript of the show is:
Transcript of Top Gear Show said:
Clarkson: ... only to find that while it was being charged its brakes had broken.

TG did not say the brakes "failed". You're an engineer, there's a whole lot of difference between "failure" and something's that just "broken". Although I agree "broken" does imply that they didn't work at all, more than just "loss of power assist." But in laymen's terms, "brakes had broken" is accurate enough since it prevented TG from taking the car out on track. (I'd definitely NOT take a car out on track if it had lost power assist to the brakes, and I'd doubt the Tesla would like it if Clarkson did as well.)

So how would you describe the "loss of vacuum to the brake booster" to your grandma?

I'd personally tell her that her brakes were broken if she had lost power assist to the brakes and definitely would NOT recommend my grandma drive her car without power assist to the brakes if it came with power assisted brakes.
 
Back
Top