Technology-Free Classrooms Improve Courses?

The problem with higher education today isn't too much or too little technology. Certainly, more technology will work well with a more tech savvy teachers and students, and less will probably work better with those less tech savvy.

I don't deny distraction as the real possibility here. Like many here, I agree with the general sentiment that paying helps, but on the other hand, as has been noted the problem is also that you sometimes have to pass these god awful boring courses to get some generalized curriculum out of the way.

It's really ridiculous. How much general curriculum do you remember after you leave school as a percentage after 5 years? Maybe 20%? At best.

More training would be better done with internships and other methods for learning how to take on a career. We need a lot less mandatory general education and a lot more specialized training. Of course, the government's involvement in education throughout the entire process ensures it's mediocrity or ... worse, depending on how the funding works.

In the US particularly the problem is that we grant these huge loans to students, and give away "free money" to them as well to let them get in. The problem is a lot of those students will get into jobs that don't require them to have gone in the first place, even if they do graduate. And.. the "even if" is a real question, since about 45% don't get through (going by http://www.higheredinfo.org/dbrowser/?level=nation&mode=graph&state=0&submeasure=27)

We need to stop "mandating" college by eliminating licensing for careers that people are interested in. Let consumers drive private certification programs via their interest in them and stop mandating we all pay for this via the state which only ensures a ton of wasted time on the part of students taking courses they could care less about.
 
Laptops and cell phones and other tech should be banned from classes. It's time to go back to the old fashioned way of teaching and learning. When I see kids from third world countries doing science and math, they seem to be ahead of many; they have no technology and only use their brains for everything.
 
Bwhahaha. Wow. Way to miss the point. Then again, maybe at YOUR school at YOUR dept a few blips don't really matter; however, at my university they absolutely do.

First, not all professors are tenured. In fact, the trend now is to hire only lectures because it is cheaper and if they start to get out of line the dept can fire them without hassle. A scant 23% of my total overall dept is tenured.

... and you know I guess that conversation that my dean had with me after I failed three students, deservedly so, my first teaching semester was all a dream.... yes, a very vivid dream in which I had my ass chewed out for failing too many students. I will make sure to mention that to the dept head next time I see him.

I just hope you don't plan on entering academia since it's obvious you have little to no grasp on the politics at work.

Well FYI, I am in academia, and yes I realize the politics can be quite gruesome and difficult to comprehend as rational.

Yes I know not all professors are tenured, I simply shot that out there as a point of reference, i.e. those professors (who often are the "bad teachers" as they're so into the system knowing they have a guaranteed job that they get set in their ways)

And I truly feel sorry for you if your failing of three students brought the attention of the dean upon you. Was this because they protested their grade? Did you fail them due to their actual "score" in the class or simply because you felt like it due to something?

If you're getting chastised for failing three students (out of how many?) then you have a shitty environment that you're working in. Students fail, it's a fact of life. Hell looking back at last semester's grades I gave a total of 10 Fs between all my classes, and I've given a good handful of Fs in just about every semester for all the years I've been teaching (about 5 right now, so I'm not tenured, I'm not an old experience teacher, or anyone with any sort of "power") and never have I been questioned on my grades by the dean.
 
Anyone who has attended a college class in the last 5 years should be able to attest to this. The really good professors at my undergrad would ban laptops from the classroom. I agree that they are a massive distraction.



+1 completely agree
 
If the course material is sufficiently challenging and engaging, then more students will feel the need to participate, or at least remain attentive, in order to stay current with the curriculum.

In those instances, it's more likely that technology will be leveraged for the benefit of the students. They may be quickly referencing notes and studies in class to gain a more complete understanding of the subject material.

However, as is the case within most undergraduate and many post-grad settings, the level of rigor is not sufficient to stimulate such behavior, and we can plainly see technology becoming a distraction. Conversely, one can infer that I'm implying that the average proficiency of students is drastically lower in the less rigorous classes.

You won't find nearly as many slackers in a senior-level electrical engineering class as in... anywhere within undergraduate social sciences, for instance.

Though I majored in EE, I was able to ditch nearly every class, every time, and still easily coast by through quantitative economics. What a joke of a school within the UC system. I've always told my peers that they're likely not going to do any real work until grad school unless they are: Studying a math, science, or engineering field, or they are highly skilled and/or motivated - especially within language (English, for instance, can be as challenging as we allow it to be) and arts.

The technology will help those students worthy of its use. The rest - don't matter...at least not until they change their mindset.

Fin.
 
I am a high school Business teacher and my wife is a high school art teacher. Technology in the classroom in the students hands is just not needed 95% of the time. I have computers in my room and they are either used to display my powerpoint, or to do small things here and there. We will eventually get into office for the intro classes, and of course computers are needed for that.

However, many teachers use technology improperly, I saw it all the time when I was substituting around the different schools. Technology is a scapegoat for working as many mentioned, if schools allow students to use cell phones or surf the web during class time.

Our school is 100% no cell phones allowed for teachers or students. 1st time its seen out, they have to pay $15.00 and have their parents pick it up, 2nd time it is kept for the ENTIRE year. I am very thankful for this policy in my school and for the remote desktop/monitoring tools provided. Granted I never once sit in my desk during school hours, I am too busy walking around interacting. When students need to get on the computers for their "Bell Ringer" assignment, I get to lay the smack down and cut them off if they are not working or have gone past the allotted time.
 
Lol at someone's earlier comments. Education != Entertainment. Professors have to get evaluated all the time. No one will seriously take student feedback that says "He's a bad teacher because he's boring and I find myself browsing the Internet instead. I PAID for this and I want it to be interesting or entertaining!!"

The self-entitlement of the above statement is ridiculous.
 
Oh, BTW, you all would be proud to know that in my into Business class, I made all the students learn and take a test on all hardware components(motherboard, cpu, ram, hd, etc...)
 
It is quite obvious that you haven't yet been taught or bothered to learn how to properly punctuate a sentence.

Maybe that is why you can believe it.

All you got out of that post was one missed period? I mean that is a tiny thing to nitpick about, you don't know how my class is or what my knowledge base consists of. It could just be that this is an internet forum so punctuation is not a necessity.
 
i'd argue the opposite in a sense. If i actually gave a crap about the class or the professor was engaging i didn't need my laptop.

professors that complain i can't help but liken to the music industry in a sense, they don't know how to adapt so they bitch and moan.

I disagree and would backup the previous poster. I've attended a university first year course within the lsat 5 years and I can only say less than 20% were used for taking notes. About 50% were facebook clients machines were all tahtw ay being done was facebooking and the other 20-25% were some type of online game involving the epic battle between plans and zombies. Then the other 20% were mmorpgs.

Even those who did legimately take notes from time to time would stray to facebook or youtube, especially when the professor would go onto tagents about 'Here's a cool sotry from when I was in university first year!" or "how this subject applied to my third job in the field!" etc etc. If you banned those laptops and replaced them with pen/pencil, most students would have learned far more about the subject matter at hand. Especially considering 50% or more of their attention wouldn't have been on facebook/gaming.

The irony is these are the same students who complain that Calculus I's first mideterm was sooo hard while those without laptops comment how easy it was...go figure.
 
All you got out of that post was one missed period? I mean that is a tiny thing to nitpick about, you don't know how my class is or what my knowledge base consists of. It could just be that this is an internet forum so punctuation is not a necessity.

Ok fine, how about the fact you need to capitalize the e in English, as common words derived from proper nouns still require capitalization, so English is capitalized, however history, math, and social studies would not be :D
 
Again, internet forum i know it is giving you a hardon to give someone shit for something they do because it is the internet, but I'll just be my stoner slacker student self and go some some more weed and go to class.
 
And I truly feel sorry for you if your failing of three students brought the attention of the dean upon you. Was this because they protested their grade? Did you fail them due to their actual "score" in the class or simply because you felt like it due to something?

If you're getting chastised for failing three students (out of how many?) then you have a shitty environment that you're working in. Students fail, it's a fact of life. Hell looking back at last semester's grades I gave a total of 10 Fs between all my classes, and I've given a good handful of Fs in just about every semester for all the years I've been teaching (about 5 right now, so I'm not tenured, I'm not an old experience teacher, or anyone with any sort of "power") and never have I been questioned on my grades by the dean.

Well in that case, I apologize good sir. I urge you to please remember that not all depts run as smoothly as your own. To answer your question, I failed three out of 35 students because they did not complete the required assignments (ie they didn't turn in their papers). Pretty cut and dry right? Nope. I was literally told that it doesn't matter if they don't do the assignments, I have to prove that I gave them every opportunity to fulfill the class reqs; for example, I have to provide an email log that shows I reached out to them a number of times to annoy them into doing the work and offering extra time etc etc. As it was, it was strongly impressed on me that I should give incompletes instead of f's in order to further coddle these overgrown children in the dean's view. I have this argument with my colleagues all the time when they moan about how students don't pay attention... treat people like children in need of a babysitter, I always say, and they will act like children.

I would be thankful that you work in a decent environment. As for me, as soon as I publish I am out of here like a leaf on the wind.
 
I disagree and would backup the previous poster. I've attended a university first year course within the lsat 5 years and I can only say less than 20% were used for taking notes. About 50% were facebook clients machines were all tahtw ay being done was facebooking and the other 20-25% were some type of online game involving the epic battle between plans and zombies. Then the other 20% were mmorpgs.

Even those who did legimately take notes from time to time would stray to facebook or youtube, especially when the professor would go onto tagents about 'Here's a cool sotry from when I was in university first year!" or "how this subject applied to my third job in the field!" etc etc. If you banned those laptops and replaced them with pen/pencil, most students would have learned far more about the subject matter at hand. Especially considering 50% or more of their attention wouldn't have been on facebook/gaming.

The irony is these are the same students who complain that Calculus I's first mideterm was sooo hard while those without laptops comment how easy it was...go figure.

If the professor strays off course, then I have every right to stray off note taking as I see fit when he strays off course.
 
My parents taught HS forr 30+ years and I did for 10. My parents taught in missionaries in several third world countries on and off. If you have a solid education in math, science, and language, technology is a no brainer, especially if your young. The kids in Cambodia and Vietnam ghettos learning from American Math, Science, and Grammar textbooks printed in the 1950s would put a huge percentage of Amerrican students to shame. Eventually when they got money for technology, they absorbed it in a matter of months. Calculators were a tool, not a crutch. Using technology confidently is about a frame of mind, not intelligence.

On the other hand, how many schools, especially experimental low income ones where they pumped tons of tech into, have failed because their kids have no foundation. I can point 10+ schools here in west Texas alone. Even if the kid graduated with "honors", it was a false confidence easily destroyed in the first few years of college. Even now, basic classes in college are a joke. Standards have been lowered greatly. I see kids in college and medical professions that would not havve cut it years ago.
 
Back
Top