Tax Prep Websites Put to the Test

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
If you’re procrastinating doing your taxes, you may want to check this out. PCWorld ran five tax preparation products through some scenarios that are more complicated (but not unusual) than the standard 1040EZ and came away with some surprising findings.

The services I used for this experiment were the same ones I evaluated earlier this year for overall usability:CompleteTax, TaxAct, TaxBrain, TaxCut, and TurboTax. This time, however, I relied on the software's instructions and help to make decisions about some slightly more complicated (but hardly unusual) tax scenarios.
 
my experience has always been that TaxCut saves me more than TurboTax, but based on this and some other comparisions, I think it must vary based on your particular tax return.

The biggest difference I recall was several years ago when I was out of work and Turbo said I owned 300-400. TaxCut said I was owed between 100-200.....needless to say iwent with TaxCut. Since then, I've done a comparison each year, and TaxCut has always won the day (though not by that huge margin).

This year, I just bought the TaxCut software for 34 bucks on Buy.com....I may do a comparison, but unless there's a reversal of fortune by switching I'll use TaxCut.
 
I recently worked for one of these companies supporting the software. Let me just say that it was ok for simple federal taxes where state taxes are not involved. When you start to add in states and complex things like investments and mortgages they fall to pieces. Too often the IRS will reject returns simply because they cant read the electronic form correctly or the electronic form was duplicated with blank entries for some unknown reason.
 
And oh yea, state taxes are all f'd up, especially virginia and california lol
 
Anyone have any experience with TaxAct? $17 for both federal and state is a deal! I usual go with H&R but at that price I'm tempted to check it out.
 
Since I'm a student I don't expect much back on my tax returns but I went ahead and used turbotax. Since it's free for federal filing, I got back 508 bucks in rebates while 80 bucks for Idaho. It cost me 30 bucks to file in Idaho so I didn't really care if I got 50 bucks back. I filed about 3 weeks ago and I got them all the last week. So I'm pretty happy right now. It was pretty easy going step by step on filing.
 
I used TaxSlayer this year. It was free, easy as hell, and quick. My taxes aren't complex, just simple little things. Minnesota state tax forums are really easy as well. TaxSlayer has a pretty nice wizard set-up that guides you through a lot of stuff. I used H&R Block online last year. I liked that too, but I got a lot less back this year than last so I didn't want to lose even more money.
 
Since I'm a student I don't expect much back on my tax returns but I went ahead and used turbotax. Since it's free for federal filing, I got back 508 bucks in rebates while 80 bucks for Idaho. It cost me 30 bucks to file in Idaho so I didn't really care if I got 50 bucks back. I filed about 3 weeks ago and I got them all the last week. So I'm pretty happy right now. It was pretty easy going step by step on filing.

:D. i got back about 750 state and federal and i did them for free myself ;)
 
Back
Top