Target Pays $3M For E-Mail Defamation

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It seems people don’t like it when you circulate an e-mail accusing them of a crime when all they tried to do was buy something from your store. Hopefully this woman has fun spending the $3.1 million in a different store.

A federal jury has ordered Target Corp. to pay a Greer woman $3.1 million after the jury found that the company distributed information that wrongly accused her of trying to pass a counterfeit bill while shopping.
 
Happens a lot. I worked retail many moons ago and went to make the deposit,. I dropped it off in the night box, never thought anything of it. Corporate called a few days later asking about the deposit and why it was short.

Long story short, someone had paid with a pre 70's hundo, the bank thought it was fake because they, apparently are idiots. They call the SS, they call corporate, yada yada, yada.

Kinda funny in a way. Although had that been my deposit, I would have flipped out.
 
pwn3d.

But seriously. A 1974 series $100 note? WTF? Of course they were suspicious, but they were still tools for what they did.
 
I had one of these in my possession the other day at work

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:US_$5_1963_USN.jpg

Kind of wish I bought it and kept it with my other currencies I 'collect'
 
I wish Target would accuse me of a crime I didn't commit, I could use a new mansion.
 
Right... 3.1 million is an appropriate amount for her "hardships".

Maybe not, but they had absolutely no right to accuse her of any wrongdoing without any proof that she was paying with fake currency, which she apparently wasn't doing. Ever hear of innocent before proven guilty? Also, I doubt this will have any impact on the pricing of Target's merchandise. They probably pull in a lot more than $3.1 million every quarter.
 
Target wont raise their prices, doing so would be like begging thier customers to shop somewhere else. Being sued or not they still have to compete.
 
You're right, raising prices wouldn't work. There's always closing a store, laying employees off, or just letting the shareholders eat it. I hope you sense the sarcasm. I'm not saying this lady wasn't treated poorly... just saying $3.1 million is ridiculous.
 
You're right, raising prices wouldn't work. There's always closing a store, laying employees off, or just letting the shareholders eat it. I hope you sense the sarcasm. I'm not saying this lady wasn't treated poorly... just saying $3.1 million is ridiculous.

They make more than enough to eat the loss and learn from the mistake. I hope you sense the sarcasm when i say, i really truly feel sorry for a company paying out cash for thier fuck up.
 
They make more than enough to eat the loss and learn from the mistake. I hope you sense the sarcasm when i say, i really truly feel sorry for a company paying out cash for thier fuck up.

3 million is hardly worth this mistake. Besides, it was 1 employee not the whole damn company. :rolleyes: Like it's real hard to send out a notice stating there was an incorrect notice sent out. :rolleyes:
 
3 million is hardly worth this mistake. Besides, it was 1 employee not the whole damn company. :rolleyes: Like it's real hard to send out a notice stating there was an incorrect notice sent out. :rolleyes:

Im not saying it was worth 3 million im just saying i dont feel sorry for them.
 
while 3mil is a little high and will probably drop down to maybe 1m tops (the actual 100K will probably stay)

Target, not only accused her of counterfeiting (barely give them that as dumb as they are) but they also sent photos of her, and accused her of shoplifting/stealing which in NO WAY could they stand behind that one.

I have no problem if she is allowed to keep the full amount, that way all managers might develop a brain and be told to use it or be fired.

The loss of $100 of merchandise is so much easier to deal with rather than the potential loss of a lawsuit, even IF they had won they still would have be nailed to the wall by all the publicity
 
Yeah, they should have just parted with the $100. I think REI does a good job here. They don't like to confront shoplifters in a way that would draw attention, even if they lose on the deal. They know the importance of image.
 
I'm with the woman on this.

Target has no business being the gestapo and going out of their way to tell everyone in existence that this woman paid with a counterfeit bill - even if she had. Should've just reported it to the proper agencies, and had them deal with it.
 
Target gives away $5m to charity a month, they won't even notice a missing $3.1m

Never worked in accounting have you? What about public relations? The total cost of this is beyond $3.1M. They will probably be able to work it down but include lawyer fees and advertising/PR fees. Probably won't stop most people from shopping at Target but in this kind of economy any hit like this is a kick to the groin.

It's hard to quantify losses from something like this, but you can bet this story will be aired wide and loud. Probably worth a couple minutes on every radio talk and call-in show in the country.
 
After a three-day trial, the jury sided in Cantrell's favor, awarding her $100,000 for actual damages and $3 million in punitive damages.

Punitive = punishment. This isn't about what the woman deserves but the fact that $100.000 is peanuts to a company like Target. Punishment needs to strike a blow to have an effect, and is the reason why punitive damages are typically higher the larger a company is.

In corporate terms, if it were only 100.000 dollars then no one might have answer to upper management. Make it 3.1 million and someone will.
 
I agree with the outcome of this trial, except for the awarding of punitive damages to the plaintiff. I think punitive damages should be put in a fund to help individuals defend themselves against corporate lawsuits, such as those the RIAA uses, so people aren't "guilty until proven innocent, if you have enough money to prove it" in the tort system. Not directly relevant to this case, but I question the awarding of punitive damages to individuals and their lawyers.
 
our court system = working

fixed

article said:
The email led the U.S. Secret Service to question Cantrell while she was at work at a Belk’s department store in Greenville, where she was employed in the store’s loss-prevention department, the complaint alleged

she works loss prevention and these kind of accusations could have cost her her job. Target was wrong and they are paying the price.
 
Wow, I'm at work not a mile from that Target in Greer. I guess that this lady won't be working for Belk's much longer!
 
And up goes the price of merchandise at Target. Thanks Lady.

Not like they were cheap to begin with.

And before you say she's the cause of upping the price, you should see our new local target, it's the first ever store as such to be built on two stories with a parking garage below it... it cost them millions for the lot and millions to put the entire building ontop of a parking garage.... hell, to get your cart to the second floor they have cart escalators to take the cart up and down.

I don't feel sorry for Target, what they should have done was made a proper investigation to find out the legitimacy of the bill instead of going "oh it's an old bill, must be fake"
 
Back
Top