l_emmerdeur
n00b
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2004
- Messages
- 7
I built my first computer back in 1995. In the last ten years, I have graduated from building straightforward PC's for myself and friends to light modding and (recently) water cooling. The worst problem I ever faced was getting a Shuttle XPC to reboot and keep my OC settings (a BIOS update fixed it).
Until now.
Last November, I decided to upgrade from my Shuttle XPC/AMD 2400+/ATI AIW 9700 Pro machine to something new. Since I had more time on my hands, I could do something a bit more involved and creative than my last effort, when work was brutal and free time was non-existent.
So I picked up the following:
Lian Li V1100B case
Enermax EG701AX-VE SFMA 2.0 PSU
MSI K8N Neo2 Platinum mobo
AMD Athlon64 3500+ 939 90nm
Thermalright XP-120
Powercolor ATI x800XT-PE w/ ATI Silencer 4
1 Gb OCZ Platinum Rev 2
2 WD 74Gb Raptors
1 Seagate 160Gb SATA 7200.7
3 Smart Drive 2002 Copper Cool HDD enclosures
NEC 3500A DVD writer
Hardcano 13
AcoustiFan/Nexus 120mm fan replacements
As you can see, I wasn't kidding around.
I built the system, installed XP Pro and drivers, but not much else - I wanted to run it for a few weeks with just games (no iTunes, Office, etc.) to confirm stability. Temps were pretty good, HD's never broke 40 degrees Celsius, CPU mid-40's under load, ambient low-30's.
The only problem I noticed was that the memory wouldn't run in Dual channel. And that was the first warning sign.
I used the PC for a couple of weeks, and then began getting boot-up issues, until finally the PC was stuck in an endless CHKDSK loop and wouldn't boot to Windows (except Safe Mode). Reinstall, same problem after a few days.
Hmm. Bad WD drive? Reinstall on the second Raptor. After a few days, same problem. Two drives going bad? Highly unlikely. I decide to take apart the system and rebuild it, in case there is a short somewhere. During the process of removing the XP-120, my hand slips and some bits of solder fly off the mobo. Wouldn't run my memery in Dual Channel, anyway, so time for a new mobo. While I'm at it, I try watercooling and some modding as well:
New parts:
Dremel 400
Asus A8V Rev. 2.0 mobo
Danger Den TDX/MAZE4 chipset
Black Ice Extreme radiator/Danger Den DDC-12V pump
Tygon tubing/Fluid XP+
Fillport/T-line
I get to work on the Lian Li, removing the 3.5" cages, drilling an extra hole between compartments for the Tygon tubing to pass through unrestricted, drilling out the rear fan grill and a side panel hole for an extra 120mm fan (bring down that ambient) and installing laser-cut grills, installing the WC setup (only one leak during test, found immediately), UV lighting, lots of effort to hide the huge number of wires and cables. Looks very clean, all cabling tied off out of the way or hidden from view, external view very understated, with a faint pink glow coming out from the 120mm fan hole through the grill.
Did I mention? VERY quiet. Only a low whine from the pump, which almost disappears after the last of the air bubbles leave the system. Install XP (have to slipstream it with VIA's Promise SATA drivers and SP2 while I'm at it), temps fabulous - ambient mid-20's, CPU upper 30's at load, x800 mid-30's at stock settings, fans whispering at about 1200 rpm.
Dual Channel works fine at 2-2-2-5 on the Asus. Further "proof" that the MSI mobo was at fault. System runs fine for a couple of weeks, then goes through EXACTLY the same behavior as the first revision - CHKDSK loop on boot, eventually won't even go past the Asus POST graphic.
I know it's not my temps - nothing is even reaching 40 degrees Celsius at this point.
I had used my old Shuttle XPC to test the WC system, and had blown out the mobo in that machine in the process. I purchase a SN95G5 with an Athlon64 3000+ to replace it, and migrate the ATI card (had to cut most of the side panel to get the Silencer 4 to fit), the memory and ONLY the Seagate 7200.7 drive to this new XPC.
I'm figuring at this point it is a bad CPU, and I will shelf the project for now and just build a system that WORKS so I can use internet/email/Office/World of Warcraft on a stable machine.
Heh.
After a week with the XPC - same behavior. Can't be the Seagate, it wasn't the system drive on the watercooled machine (it only had mp3's on it). Must be the ATI card or the memory. So I move my old 512Mb BH-5 memory from my old XPC into the new one, and reinstall - this was last night.
I'm assuming the OCZ memory is the culprit here, as I had memory-related problems on the MSI, and it is one of only 3 components common to all these setups. If this turns out to be the case, I'm moving back to Corsair and Mushkin, which have never given me grief. At this point, I've spent more time on these two PC's than on all the other PC's I've built in the last 10 years.
Additional cheesy side-remark: one of the two OCZ sticks came with the warranty sticker loose, and it fell off as I was installing it. So no returns if the memory is faulty.
I shoulda gotten a Dell. (OK, just kidding)
Until now.
Last November, I decided to upgrade from my Shuttle XPC/AMD 2400+/ATI AIW 9700 Pro machine to something new. Since I had more time on my hands, I could do something a bit more involved and creative than my last effort, when work was brutal and free time was non-existent.
So I picked up the following:
Lian Li V1100B case
Enermax EG701AX-VE SFMA 2.0 PSU
MSI K8N Neo2 Platinum mobo
AMD Athlon64 3500+ 939 90nm
Thermalright XP-120
Powercolor ATI x800XT-PE w/ ATI Silencer 4
1 Gb OCZ Platinum Rev 2
2 WD 74Gb Raptors
1 Seagate 160Gb SATA 7200.7
3 Smart Drive 2002 Copper Cool HDD enclosures
NEC 3500A DVD writer
Hardcano 13
AcoustiFan/Nexus 120mm fan replacements
As you can see, I wasn't kidding around.
I built the system, installed XP Pro and drivers, but not much else - I wanted to run it for a few weeks with just games (no iTunes, Office, etc.) to confirm stability. Temps were pretty good, HD's never broke 40 degrees Celsius, CPU mid-40's under load, ambient low-30's.
The only problem I noticed was that the memory wouldn't run in Dual channel. And that was the first warning sign.
I used the PC for a couple of weeks, and then began getting boot-up issues, until finally the PC was stuck in an endless CHKDSK loop and wouldn't boot to Windows (except Safe Mode). Reinstall, same problem after a few days.
Hmm. Bad WD drive? Reinstall on the second Raptor. After a few days, same problem. Two drives going bad? Highly unlikely. I decide to take apart the system and rebuild it, in case there is a short somewhere. During the process of removing the XP-120, my hand slips and some bits of solder fly off the mobo. Wouldn't run my memery in Dual Channel, anyway, so time for a new mobo. While I'm at it, I try watercooling and some modding as well:
New parts:
Dremel 400
Asus A8V Rev. 2.0 mobo
Danger Den TDX/MAZE4 chipset
Black Ice Extreme radiator/Danger Den DDC-12V pump
Tygon tubing/Fluid XP+
Fillport/T-line
I get to work on the Lian Li, removing the 3.5" cages, drilling an extra hole between compartments for the Tygon tubing to pass through unrestricted, drilling out the rear fan grill and a side panel hole for an extra 120mm fan (bring down that ambient) and installing laser-cut grills, installing the WC setup (only one leak during test, found immediately), UV lighting, lots of effort to hide the huge number of wires and cables. Looks very clean, all cabling tied off out of the way or hidden from view, external view very understated, with a faint pink glow coming out from the 120mm fan hole through the grill.
Did I mention? VERY quiet. Only a low whine from the pump, which almost disappears after the last of the air bubbles leave the system. Install XP (have to slipstream it with VIA's Promise SATA drivers and SP2 while I'm at it), temps fabulous - ambient mid-20's, CPU upper 30's at load, x800 mid-30's at stock settings, fans whispering at about 1200 rpm.
Dual Channel works fine at 2-2-2-5 on the Asus. Further "proof" that the MSI mobo was at fault. System runs fine for a couple of weeks, then goes through EXACTLY the same behavior as the first revision - CHKDSK loop on boot, eventually won't even go past the Asus POST graphic.
I know it's not my temps - nothing is even reaching 40 degrees Celsius at this point.
I had used my old Shuttle XPC to test the WC system, and had blown out the mobo in that machine in the process. I purchase a SN95G5 with an Athlon64 3000+ to replace it, and migrate the ATI card (had to cut most of the side panel to get the Silencer 4 to fit), the memory and ONLY the Seagate 7200.7 drive to this new XPC.
I'm figuring at this point it is a bad CPU, and I will shelf the project for now and just build a system that WORKS so I can use internet/email/Office/World of Warcraft on a stable machine.
Heh.
After a week with the XPC - same behavior. Can't be the Seagate, it wasn't the system drive on the watercooled machine (it only had mp3's on it). Must be the ATI card or the memory. So I move my old 512Mb BH-5 memory from my old XPC into the new one, and reinstall - this was last night.
I'm assuming the OCZ memory is the culprit here, as I had memory-related problems on the MSI, and it is one of only 3 components common to all these setups. If this turns out to be the case, I'm moving back to Corsair and Mushkin, which have never given me grief. At this point, I've spent more time on these two PC's than on all the other PC's I've built in the last 10 years.
Additional cheesy side-remark: one of the two OCZ sticks came with the warranty sticker loose, and it fell off as I was installing it. So no returns if the memory is faulty.
I shoulda gotten a Dell. (OK, just kidding)