T-Mobile Wants To Stop Network Abusers

Cool, so the general consensus is nondescript. Essentially a "cell" can hold 12 people at maximum bandwidth, but there may be 20 cells (or more!) on a tower, meaning there could be 240 people at MAXIMUM bandwidth. So it falls in line with my original 'worst case scenario' assumption that a single 'power user' will 'clog' up the lines at about ~%0.6.

Once again, tell me how I'm wrong.
That's not how that works...the cells have to cover 360 degrees and regardless each cell has a maximum bandwidth that is shared among users and a device can only connect to one cell regardless of how many are on the tower; you can't just add them all up and call it total bandwidth available to everyone like it's all part of one pool.

AT&T and Verizon cells were limited to about 16Mbps down and 8 up, Sprint's network was 10/4, and T-Mobile was working toward deploying 37.5 (max, not actual) at last year's press release.
 
That's not how that works...the cells have to cover 360 degrees and regardless each cell has a maximum bandwidth that is shared among users and a device can only connect to one cell regardless of how many are on the tower; you can't just add them all up and call it total bandwidth available to everyone like it's all part of one pool.

AT&T and Verizon cells were limited to about 16Mbps down and 8 up, Sprint's network was 10/4, and T-Mobile was working toward deploying 37.5 (max, not actual) at last year's press release.


Okay, we're getting somewhere!

So essentially, the device's maximum bandwidth is not the same as the cell's maximum bandwidth, as I said, the cell could support 12 average 4G devices at their maximum bandwidth. If all but one of them dropped down to browsing or basic streaming, that user-base could expand.

But as you said, one cell does not cover a 360 degree area, its more of a cone of effectiveness, So if all of the users are ~evenly distributed, then it will pretty much work out as I stated, but that's assuming there isn't a massive chunk of users in one spot. Though if that were to happen, the ISP could configure the tower to have multiple cells pointing in that direction...

Either way, is there evidence that a single 'power user' could effect bandwidth more than 1% at most?
 
....What I'm saying is DO as you advertised. How is this a hard concept?

If the company says unlimited data - allow the users to have unlimited data. Regardless of how they pull said data, if you said unlimited data - the user is entitled to unlimited data.

If you advertise you have a cap, then you have a cap. Simple as that. Use of the word "unlimited" should not be used in conjunction with these caps. And changing your definition of what "unlimited" entails after people signed contracts for "unlimited" is BS too. If you said unlimited, then you shouldn't get all pissy at your customers that REALLY do use it as you advertised.

You cant say "Try our new Unlimited* plan for just $40/month!"




*Unlimited for the first 5GB and then the speed is capped at 50kb/s

Read your contract. You don't get unlimited tethering. Again, I don't know of any company that has an unlimited plan that allows for unlimited tethering. In fact, this is the first one I've seen that officially allows you to tether. And let's not forget that AT&T's idea of Unlimited was 2GB TOTAL. Not 2GB of tethering. Go to Verizon. They'll charge you 80 bucks for 6GB of data total.

You're paying less, getting more and you're upset. What's next, "it says unlimited voice, but I can't make calls from my 1970 AT&T phone!" "Why don't they say that in the advertising." "It's fraud. Call the FTC."

You get fucked every month on your phone (more than likely). Most phone bills have an administrative charge to cover the cost of billing you. You want to bitch, bitch about that. That's fucking bullshit.

This is a gift to their subscribers. Quit complaining or Santa's gonna give you a lump of coal.
 
It's worth noting (again) that there's nothing in the letter regarding bandwidth nor capacity.

That's a conclusion being drawn in this thread based off his claim that user could be impacted negatively by these "thieves." He could also mean that normal customers' experience could be negatively impacted by new policies and/or new pricing structures to compensate for the data these select few are stealing.

At issue may be the very fact that T-Mobile has historically lax on which devices people could bring to the table, how we use them, and what kinds of prices we've been able to enjoy while using them. They were, after all, the first company that let us use our iPhones and "unsupported" smart phones on their data network for $10 dollar legacy accounts. They never forced people off those accounts, at least not that I'm aware, and instead encouraged us on those legacy accounts to switch by choice due to enticements.

But that doesn't mean they have to continue being so lax to us; certainly the other providers don't come close at least in my experience before I moved to Tmobile.
 
And if you click on it, you get this:

tmobile2.png


It's exceedingly transparent and unambiguous.

Holly shit! They give you free international roaming? I may try to convince my parents to go to T-Mobile instead of AT&T.
 
T-Mobile has gained many customers, myself included, because they've had considerably more liberal policies and good value in the past. I'd hate to see them change those policies.

Personally, I don't believe that there should be any difference between tethered and untethered data. Data is data. If I'm paying for their highest tier, unlimited LTE without throttling plan, that's what I should get, regardless of how I'm using it -on an android device directly, tethering, or popping my SIM into an LTE USB Modem etc. T-mobile would be foolish to go after those "hackers", because these users are the most likely to be their best customers and pay for high data plans.

Why would they get a more expensive plan, when $50.00 is unlimited for the phone and 7GB tethered data (and they're bypassing that through whatever means is necessary on T-Mobile's network)?

Answer: they're not.
 
Also, during all the non-peak hours, all that fancy expensive equipment the ISP had to purchase to be able to handle peak loads essentially idles relatively speaking. There is practically no additional cost to the ISP other than the cost of electricity, which is cheap. An ISP might charge you something like $5-10 per GB you go over, when that GB cost them mere pennies. They are raping us and people just accept it because they think data is expensive. It's not, it's super super cheap.

Having gone through billing records I can promise you that we get hammered far longer than that period. What you're describing is true for your ISP at home...that's not true for wireless, though that is a heavy period, but peak time for data is generally during the day (SMS, OTOH, is generally from 6pm to midnight). It may vary on an individual cell tower, but that's what I've seen throughout our network.

What's more, I've done speed tests during the day and in the evening and in most cases it's faster at night. Most use wifi at home (because it's faster).

Most places charge you way too much for data. T-Mobile isn't one of them. I'd argue that Cricket is also good, but it's not as good as this plan.

May try them out and see how their coverage is.
 
For some reason during his pedantic tirades, he's completely missing the points that someone sucking as much data down the straw as their device can handle 24/7 throughout the month means the person is going to be impacting "peak time" all the time *and* that "peak time" is not merely a 2 hour window, 7-9pm PST, for a multi-national provider.

It's longer than that for any provider: national, regional, prepaid, postpay. I didn't work on the infrastructure side, but I believe most data is handled by centralized routers. I know Verizon has the same IPs in houston as they have in LA and Arkansas. They have no idea which state the session took place on, which leads me to believe messaging goes back to Houston, but maybe that's only the billing records.
 
I really wish tmobie would step into the full on data business. I would easily dump comcast in a heartbeat if tmobile offered full on unlimited internet. Recent speedtests here in fla are over 60 mbs down and 20 up.
 
I really wish tmobie would step into the full on data business. I would easily dump comcast in a heartbeat if tmobile offered full on unlimited internet. Recent speedtests here in fla are over 60 mbs down and 20 up.
Nothing stops you from doing that. Just buy hotspot data bandwidth as you need it above 7GB/month (should be "if you need it"... 7GB is a generous amount). Prices are incredibly reasonable, only around $5/GB when buying in increments of 2GB. lol
 
That's not how that works...the cells have to cover 360 degrees and regardless each cell has a maximum bandwidth that is shared among users and a device can only connect to one cell regardless of how many are on the tower; you can't just add them all up and call it total bandwidth available to everyone like it's all part of one pool.

AT&T and Verizon cells were limited to about 16Mbps down and 8 up, Sprint's network was 10/4, and T-Mobile was working toward deploying 37.5 (max, not actual) at last year's press release.

*Cough* Carrier Aggregation *Cough*
 
Okay, we're getting somewhere!

So essentially, the device's maximum bandwidth is not the same as the cell's maximum bandwidth, as I said, the cell could support 12 average 4G devices at their maximum bandwidth. If all but one of them dropped down to browsing or basic streaming, that user-base could expand.

But as you said, one cell does not cover a 360 degree area, its more of a cone of effectiveness, So if all of the users are ~evenly distributed, then it will pretty much work out as I stated, but that's assuming there isn't a massive chunk of users in one spot. Though if that were to happen, the ISP could configure the tower to have multiple cells pointing in that direction...

Either way, is there evidence that a single 'power user' could effect bandwidth more than 1% at most?

LTE != 4G no matter what the marketing drones may have you believe. LTE is a stopgap 3.5G measure.
 
Nothing stops you from doing that. Just buy hotspot data bandwidth as you need it above 7GB/month (should be "if you need it"... 7GB is a generous amount). Prices are incredibly reasonable, only around $5/GB when buying in increments of 2GB. lol
And its that ridiculous pricing is why they have peoplle tethering illegallly. I admit 2TB a month is just insane but I thought about doing it. Really think they could be in a great poaition to dethrone the big isps if they wanted.
 
I really wish tmobie would step into the full on data business. I would easily dump comcast in a heartbeat if tmobile offered full on unlimited internet. Recent speedtests here in fla are over 60 mbs down and 20 up.

You'd pay through the nose if they offeredit and if it was actually competitive with Cable/fiber prices, the speed would drop precipitously, because there's only so much bandwidth available. If you don't believe that, go to a very crowded location and use your phone. This summer I was at a fest where my data dropped to 0 near the stage and it was the same for every carrier. Now if you over 50 yards, you were fine, but houses are fixed points.
 
Nothing stops you from doing that. Just buy hotspot data bandwidth as you need it above 7GB/month (should be "if you need it"... 7GB is a generous amount). Prices are incredibly reasonable, only around $5/GB when buying in increments of 2GB. lol

Ahahaha. 7GB is something like 1.3 Game downloads from Steam now days. Then again, maybe you're being sarcastic.
 
You'd pay through the nose if they offeredit and if it was actually competitive with Cable/fiber prices, the speed would drop precipitously, because there's only so much bandwidth available. If you don't believe that, go to a very crowded location and use your phone. This summer I was at a fest where my data dropped to 0 near the stage and it was the same for every carrier. Now if you over 50 yards, you were fine, but houses are fixed points.
Oh I know. I live in a tourist town where the population is about 17,000 and it increases to hundreds of thousands during the season. Running a speed test after a concert connected to the same tower I use at home was showing .01 mbps. Text messages where even being delayed there was so much traffic. I was speaking mostly in want which is what
alot of the people did with the unlimited data plan with undetectable tethering.
 
Back
Top