T-Mobile Wants To Stop Network Abusers

And if you click on it, you get this:

tmobile2.png


It's exceedingly transparent and unambiguous.
 
So higher speed routers, additional ports, new fiber runs, etc, don't cost anything?
I suppose all the unicorns do the work for free where you live.

Those are infrastructure costs that are required to support a certain number of users at a certain speed (bandwidth) in a given area during peak hours. None of that has anything to do with the amount of data consumed in a billing cycle. Data != bandwidth. I can't believe there are people on a tech news site that still don't get this.
 
So wait... If I decided to use my mobile phone as a download service, and had the phone simply download/upload files to/from a NAS... that can be accessed by a home server... I would be doing nothing wrong...

The phone is not routing any network connections, its just saving files to a dumb device. The phone is the only thing using the WAN. The server can then access these files, and save .torrent files that the phone can then read from the NAS and initiate P2P downloads using script. Still the phone acessing the WAN.

This involves no tethering.
 
Who cares if they are? It has no effect on anyone. They can peg their connection 24/7, and it won't have any more effect on congestion during peak hours than anyone else. The vast majority of that 2 TB is consumed during off peak hours where it doesn't matter.

mobile networks dont have unlimited radio space so in day time a small amount of users why are going flat out on the data can mess up the area (not sure why they dont just high speed caps them after 10-15GB to 128kbs between 10am-midnight if pass the high speed cap what they norm done in the past t-mobile)
 
T-Mobile has gained many customers, myself included, because they've had considerably more liberal policies and good value in the past. I'd hate to see them change those policies.

Personally, I don't believe that there should be any difference between tethered and untethered data. Data is data. If I'm paying for their highest tier, unlimited LTE without throttling plan, that's what I should get, regardless of how I'm using it -on an android device directly, tethering, or popping my SIM into an LTE USB Modem etc.

T-mobile would be foolish to go after those "hackers", because these users are the most likely to be their best customers and pay for high data plans. The minute that T-mobile attempts to detect what's on my phone and throttle me because I use a particular ROM, root my phone, or similar, regardless of my actual data use, that is acting antagonistically. The better way to handle it is to individually go to users who use "excessive" amounts of data, (ie someone who's pulling down terabytes month after month,, regardless of how they're doing so) and ask if they can dial it back a bit, letting them know if they can't do so, then there will be some changes. I am no fan of "excessive use" clauses especially as many companies use them frivolously, but if they only go after the top 0.000001 percent or what have you, its a better solution than declaring war on "those evil hackers and tetherers"
 
The minute that T-mobile attempts to detect what's on my phone and throttle me because I use a particular ROM, root my phone, or similar, regardless of my actual data use, that is acting antagonistically.

It's not antagonistic to use special software to get around the tethering data cap..?


The better way to handle it is to individually go to users who use "excessive" amounts of data, (ie someone who's pulling down terabytes month after month,, regardless of how they're doing so) and ask if they can dial it back a bit, letting them know if they can't do so, then there will be some changes. I am no fan of "excessive use" clauses especially as many companies use them frivolously, but if they only go after the top 0.000001 percent or what have you, its a better solution than declaring war on "those evil hackers and tetherers"

There is no "excessive use" clause. They have a hard cap on tethering at 7 GB. End of story.
 
When I signed up for T-Mobile even before the current plan they were exceedingly clear that unlimited did not apply to tethering and what the tethering amount was for my plan. I didn't like it but I still signed the contract. A contract goes two ways. Big deal.
 
T-Mobile has gained many customers, myself included, because they've had considerably more liberal policies and good value in the past. I'd hate to see them change those policies.

Personally, I don't believe that there should be any difference between tethered and untethered data. Data is data. If I'm paying for their highest tier, unlimited LTE without throttling plan, that's what I should get, regardless of how I'm using it -on an android device directly, tethering, or popping my SIM into an LTE USB Modem etc.

T-mobile would be foolish to go after those "hackers", because these users are the most likely to be their best customers and pay for high data plans. The minute that T-mobile attempts to detect what's on my phone and throttle me because I use a particular ROM, root my phone, or similar, regardless of my actual data use, that is acting antagonistically. The better way to handle it is to individually go to users who use "excessive" amounts of data, (ie someone who's pulling down terabytes month after month,, regardless of how they're doing so) and ask if they can dial it back a bit, letting them know if they can't do so, then there will be some changes. I am no fan of "excessive use" clauses especially as many companies use them frivolously, but if they only go after the top 0.000001 percent or what have you, its a better solution than declaring war on "those evil hackers and tetherers"

they are just moaning about it if its been cloaked they can't tell the difference (they can stop network abusers by using high speed caps at so high limit only affects people that are abusing it like 20-30gb when on LTE and 10gb on 3g if the mast is congested)

less than 5% of very high data users can severely slow down a cell down to very poor speeds if not managed

in the UK giffgaff are in the process of removing unlimited goodybags (witch was not unlimited they had a hidden ban limit around 12-20gb but that's another issue) and they are replacing them with £20 4G unlimited calls and text with 6GB High speed cap of 256kbs {they call it allways on data} (only in effect between midnight and 8am) as its PAYG network they are not locked into contract and can change plans as they want

as the problem they was getting was that people was using 20-50gb a month to replace there home broadband connection (had one family on 3 devices using over 50GB each as they reported that you only need 5-10 houses doing that in one area and you get slowmo data) norm you go for the top 5% that are cursing the 40-60% load on a cell (if that mast is under very high load)

mobile networks can never be unlimited turely due to radio it self but it can be managed to prevent small number of people per mast abusing it, even if they think its their right to abuse it because it says its unlimited does not mean you should try your best to use it as much as you can or use it as a replacement for home broadband as some posters on this topic are
 
Once again I'm wondering if my theory from a couple posts up is not a violation of their contract...
 
mobile networks dont have unlimited radio space so in day time a small amount of users why are going flat out on the data can mess up the area (not sure why they dont just high speed caps them after 10-15GB to 128kbs between 10am-midnight if pass the high speed cap what they norm done in the past t-mobile)

Which still has nothing to do with total data consumed over 30 days. The only thing that affects network congestion is bandwidth times number of users. All of the carriers have zero problem selling service to as many people as possible, and they will upgrade the towers or add more if there are too many people in a given area and congestion is bad. You can max out your connection only during peak hours and you will never come close to hitting your bandwidth cap, so capping does zip to alleviate the problem.

I think I need to put together a graph since people still don't seem to understand this.
 
It's not antagonistic to use special software to get around the tethering data cap..?




There is no "excessive use" clause. They have a hard cap on tethering at 7 GB. End of story.

Putting aside the discussion about fighting against unethical policies, It is nearly impossible to prove that a user is using "special software to get around a data cap, exclusively" For instance, if they decide who is tethering and who isn't by user agent, maybe I'm using a user agent switcher for another use like getting a website to work properly. Thus by nature for them to decide who is tethering and who isn't, it is going to mean blacklisting certain software, regardless of how it is used. That''s far more antagonistic.

And in reference to your second point, not everyone has their most recent plan and thus are not beholden to those particular limits.

Lets face it though, a 7GB cap on a particular kind of data use, is really slimy no matter how public it may be. Hell, people were rightly up in arms when Comcast decided to institute caps of 300GB (then down to 250 etc..) on their service. Imagine if your home ISP said "Oh yeah, you're paying for unlimited, but that's only for a single PC connected via ethernet directly to our modem/router. Anything on switches, wireless access etc... have a global 7GB cap per month. We can't have evil hackers using DHCP to steal bandwidth and put more devices on our line than we intended, can we!".
 
Which still has nothing to do with total data consumed over 30 days. The only thing that affects network congestion is bandwidth times number of users. All of the carriers have zero problem selling service to as many people as possible, and they will upgrade the towers or add more if there are too many people in a given area and congestion is bad. You can max out your connection only during peak hours and you will never come close to hitting your bandwidth cap, so capping does zip to alleviate the problem.

I think I need to put together a graph since people still don't seem to understand this.

How I think it works:

One tower has a maximum bandwidth defined as X.

The number of users of a particular tower is defined by U

Each user on the tower has an equal share of bandwidth defined by S

Therefore S = X/U

So if there is only one user on the tower (U=1), S==X

Extrapolate further, if there are 15,000 users on the tower (U=15,000) Than the maximum bandwidth (S) is X/15000. Which means someone who is CONSTANTLY downloading and uploading is only impacting the bandwidth of the tower by 1/U, in the example here 1/15000, or 0.007% So even if the tower only services 50 users, the most a 'thief' or 'hacker' could impact the other users bandwidth is 2%.

Is this correct?
 
they are just moaning about it if its been cloaked they can't tell the difference (they can stop network abusers by using high speed caps at so high limit only affects people that are abusing it like 20-30gb when on LTE and 10gb on 3g if the mast is congested)

less than 5% of very high data users can severely slow down a cell down to very poor speeds if not managed

in the UK giffgaff are in the process of removing unlimited goodybags (witch was not unlimited they had a hidden ban limit around 12-20gb but that's another issue) and they are replacing them with £20 4G unlimited calls and text with 6GB High speed cap of 256kbs {they call it allways on data} (only in effect between midnight and 8am) as its PAYG network they are not locked into contract and can change plans as they want

as the problem they was getting was that people was using 20-50gb a month to replace there home broadband connection (had one family on 3 devices using over 50GB each as they reported that you only need 5-10 houses doing that in one area and you get slowmo data) norm you go for the top 5% that are cursing the 40-60% load on a cell (if that mast is under very high load)

mobile networks can never be unlimited turely due to radio it self but it can be managed to prevent small number of people per mast abusing it, even if they think its their right to abuse it because it says its unlimited does not mean you should try your best to use it as much as you can or use it as a replacement for home broadband as some posters on this topic are

I'm not sure how things work in the UK - I was under the impression that in the Commonwealth nations that your ISPs, mobile and otherwise, instituted more caps than here in the US.

I understand that by the nature of mobile use not everyone can be maxing out their connection all the time. There are ways to go about managing quality of service, like dealing with the extreme outliers as I noted above by calling and inquiry, followed by warnings and perhaps termination for continued extreme overuse (what used to happen on both mobile and home broadband, but for a very limited number of individuals), or by instituting network QoS policies (ie Sorry, we have to temporarily throttle everyone using towers in group A for over X speed for Y units of time until load subsides etc) but the methods of restriction being discussed here I feel are inefficient and potentially customer hostile.
 
How I think it works:

One tower has a maximum bandwidth defined as X.

The number of users of a particular tower is defined by U

Each user on the tower has an equal share of bandwidth defined by S

Therefore S = X/U

So if there is only one user on the tower (U=1), S==X

Extrapolate further, if there are 15,000 users on the tower (U=15,000) Than the maximum bandwidth (S) is X/15000. Which means someone who is CONSTANTLY downloading and uploading is only impacting the bandwidth of the tower by 1/U, in the example here 1/15000, or 0.007% So even if the tower only services 50 users, the most a 'thief' or 'hacker' could impact the other users bandwidth is 2%.

Is this correct?

Yes, this is correct.
 
Let me illustrate with a chart. It's really bad, but I didn't want to spend much time on this:



This is assuming peak hours defined as 7 PM to 9 PM, which are the only hours that matter for congestion. It's also assuming max bandwidth per user as 10 Mbps, which is the average LTE speed I found for T-Mobile.

Heavy user is pegging his connection 24/7, at 10 Mbps. He has consumed roughly 100 GB for the day, but still only at 10 Mbps during peak hours. So his impact on congestion is limited to 10 Mbps.

Light user just watches Netflix in the evenings and otherwise uses no data. His house is streaming 2 HD shows at the same time, from 7 PM to 9 PM. Each HD stream is roughly 5 Mbps, so that's 10 Mbps. So he is pegging his connection for those 2 hours. In 2 hours, he has consumed roughly 8.5 GB of data.

The heavy user will end up using roughly 3 TB of data if he pegs the connection 24/7 for 30 days in a billing cycle. In most cases he will hit a cap depending on the carrier/ISP. In the same 30 days, the light user will have consumed 255 GB, which is quite a bit lower and typically within most data caps. And yet, these 2 users will have the EXACT SAME IMPACT on network congestion. There is zero difference between the 2. Does this make sense now? Can people finally see the difference between data and bandwidth?
 
un·lim·it·ed
ˌənˈlimidəd/
adjective
not limited or restricted in terms of number, quantity, or extent.
"the range of possible adaptations was unlimited"
synonyms: inexhaustible, limitless, illimitable, boundless, immeasurable, incalculable, untold, infinite, endless, bottomless, never-ending More

Maybe these greedy mofo's need to look up the word unlimited and actual preach what they advertise. Do not say it's unlimited when it's not. F these greedy mofo's.
 
Also, during all the non-peak hours, all that fancy expensive equipment the ISP had to purchase to be able to handle peak loads essentially idles relatively speaking. There is practically no additional cost to the ISP other than the cost of electricity, which is cheap. An ISP might charge you something like $5-10 per GB you go over, when that GB cost them mere pennies. They are raping us and people just accept it because they think data is expensive. It's not, it's super super cheap.
 
What's greedy is labelling data as 'tethered' and charging more for something that is no different to T-Mobile than using the phone to directly access view the data.

My favourite part is when they called tethering "internet access to a computer"... Last I checked, the smartphone IS a computer.
 
Lets face it though, a 7GB cap on a particular kind of data use, is really slimy no matter how public it may be.

It's necessary. They simply wouldn't be able to offer unlimited data on mobile otherwise. If you like the hard cap for all use better, go to Verizon.
 
un·lim·it·ed
ˌənˈlimidəd/
adjective
not limited or restricted in terms of number, quantity, or extent.
"the range of possible adaptations was unlimited"
synonyms: inexhaustible, limitless, illimitable, boundless, immeasurable, incalculable, untold, infinite, endless, bottomless, never-ending More

Maybe these greedy mofo's need to look up the word unlimited and actual preach what they advertise. Do not say it's unlimited when it's not. F these greedy mofo's.

They don't say unlimited everything. They say unlimited data on mobile, and limited tethering.
 
And the tethering is unlimited it just slows down after whatever "cap'' you're paying for.

Get angry all you want. They advertise it the way its set up. It even displays on the bill as the name of the package. (UNL+7GB SMHS).

It honestly might not cost them much to provide the service, but they are a for profit company, and if you find a way to take advantage of them and use more than what you're paying for, that is theft.
 
It's necessary. They simply wouldn't be able to offer unlimited data on mobile otherwise. If you like the hard cap for all use better, go to Verizon.

Yes they would. See my post above about the difference between data and bandwidth. All carriers right now could offer unlimited data, and it would have zero impact on congestion. They don't because data caps = profits. It is 100% about money. And I'm not even against them doing that, but be honest about it. Any carrier that says data caps or throttling of "heavy users" is about network congestion is lying.
 
Yes they would. See my post above about the difference between data and bandwidth. All carriers right now could offer unlimited data, and it would have zero impact on congestion. They don't because data caps = profits. It is 100% about money. And I'm not even against them doing that, but be honest about it. Any carrier that says data caps or throttling of "heavy users" is about network congestion is lying.

I don't agree. Unlimited tethering would bring mobile networks to their knees.
 
I don't agree. Unlimited tethering would bring mobile networks to their knees.

Then you don't understand the difference between data and bandwidth, because that is literally impossible. A single device cannot use more than it's available bandwidth at any given point in time. It does not matter how much data has been consumed during the billing cycle. And during peak hours, bandwidth will self throttle depending on how many devices are on at a time. The key here is the number of active devices at any given point in time. Tethering does not increase the number of devices.

And actually, tethering can REDUCE network congestion in certain situations (it cannot increase it, that is physically impossible). Let's say you have 3 people in a house, and 1 has an unlimited data plan on their phone, and the other 2 do not. And let's say peak bandwidth is 10 Mbps. If they all use their individual phones, they could consume up to 30 Mbps. But if the person with the unlimited data uses his phone as a mobile hot spot (AKA, tethering), and the other 2 users connect to his wifi, they will all be sharing the same 10 Mbps connection. So which causes more congestion, 30 Mbps, or 10 Mbps? Now granted, the 3 users will all experience slower speeds by sharing a connection, but they may not care if they are just worried about using too much bandwidth and going over the limit.
 
While I get that they're focusing specifically on people abusing the tethering aspect (which they rightfully should since it's part of the ToS that you can't just attach anything to it and leech till you're blue in the face), if I had that T-Mobile unlimited plan and I decided to use my actual smartphone and only the smartphone itself to download 1-2TB of data in a month's time, I don't see anything in the ToS preventing me from doing so as long as there's no tethering involved. Of course my device doesn't have 1-2TB of onboard storage, good lord that would be awesome if it did, however. :)

I have a big problem with companies that advertise "UNLIMITED" and then create some kind of artificial limitations on a plan that says it's unlimited - that's my biggest gripe overall. I know that a lot of the prepaid services (NET10, TracFone, Simple Talk, Straight Talk, etc) all use that word "UNLIMITED" in their more expensive plans nowadays but when you read the fine print it basically means unlimited calls, unlimited texts, and then "unlimited" data in the sense they give you a bucket of data at top speed and then when the bucket runs dry you drop down to 2G/EDGE speeds (which typically should be 120-190 Kbps in most any area) that are throttled to sub-dialup speeds meaning even lower than 56 Kbps so barely usable to load even an email nowadays. That's a crappy tactic if there ever was one, IMO.

For the record I have used and continue to use the awesome T-Mobile $30/month plan that offers 100 mins of talk time (not relevant to me because I use Google Hangouts to make calls but it's there in case I do need it), unlimited texts (again not relevant since Hangouts does SMS/MMS also), and 5GB of data at up to the 4G LTE speed max my smartphone can manage - after that 5GB cap is hit it'll throttle down to 2G/EDGE speeds roughly about 120 to 190 Kbps so pretty slow for the most part but it's usable to some degrees. In almost 3 years of having this plan I've only broken that 5GB cap maybe 3 times and even then it was just barely over the top. I tend to use Wi-Fi whenever and wherever possible; I just checked my usage for last month and it was 4.72GB data on T-Mobile's network and 105GB of Wi-Fi. I do a lot of music listening/audio streaming (Scanner Radio Pro is a fave app of mine, and I listen to radio stations back home since all the local ones suck ass where I live) as well as downloading content from Google Play Movies & TV sometimes so this was what I'd call an "average" month overall.

As for speed, well, I regularly pull down 80-90Mbps on the LTE connection here at my home with a T-Mobile cell site less than 1/4 mile away LOS, when I'm mobile it's typically 10Mbps or higher depending on the location (obviously) but I have zero issues with T-Mobile's coverage of my area.

Sure I'd love to be able to afford the unlimited plan, and I'd damned sure make use of it (no tethering, I don't see a need for it personally) but the $30/month plan has been good to me and I worry that at some point T-Mobile might pull the plug (ironically) on that plan and create something new as time passes. Let's hope if they do they'll grandfather those of us already on it in lieu of something worse.
 
Now granted, the 3 users will all experience slower speeds by sharing a connection, but they may not care if they are just worried about using too much bandwidth and going over the limit.

I meant to say data here, not bandwidth.
 
Then you don't understand the difference between data and bandwidth, because that is literally impossible. A single device cannot use more than it's available bandwidth at any given point in time. It does not matter how much data has been consumed during the billing cycle. And during peak hours, bandwidth will self throttle depending on how many devices are on at a time. The key here is the number of active devices at any given point in time. Tethering does not increase the number of devices.

And actually, tethering can REDUCE network congestion in certain situations (it cannot increase it, that is physically impossible). Let's say you have 3 people in a house, and 1 has an unlimited data plan on their phone, and the other 2 do not. And let's say peak bandwidth is 10 Mbps. If they all use their individual phones, they could consume up to 30 Mbps. But if the person with the unlimited data uses his phone as a mobile hot spot (AKA, tethering), and the other 2 users connect to his wifi, they will all be sharing the same 10 Mbps connection. So which causes more congestion, 30 Mbps, or 10 Mbps? Now granted, the 3 users will all experience slower speeds by sharing a connection, but they may not care if they are just worried about using too much bandwidth and going over the limit.

What on earth are you talking about? With heavy usage, the bottleneck in a mobile network is going to be the backhaul from the tower. Why do you think your 4G speeds downtown are lower at lunchtime than at midnight?

The problem, in the real world, is that it's much easier to consume bandwidth when tethering than when just using your phone. I would probably cancel my $55/month home internet connection and use tethering full-time if I my plan included unlimited tethering.
 
Yes they would. See my post above about the difference between data and bandwidth. All carriers right now could offer unlimited data, and it would have zero impact on congestion. They don't because data caps = profits. It is 100% about money. And I'm not even against them doing that, but be honest about it. Any carrier that says data caps or throttling of "heavy users" is about network congestion is lying.

Thank you and yes I too agree, it's all about the $$$$$$ ala GREED.
 
What on earth are you talking about? With heavy usage, the bottleneck in a mobile network is going to be the backhaul from the tower. Why do you think your 4G speeds downtown are lower at lunchtime than at midnight?

The problem, in the real world, is that it's much easier to consume bandwidth when tethering than when just using your phone. I would probably cancel my $55/month home internet connection and use tethering full-time if I my plan included unlimited tethering.

So again, you don't understand the difference between data and bandwidth. Slower speeds during lunch or peak hours are 100% caused by the number of users times the available bandwidth. None of that has anything at all to do with data over the course of a billing period. T-Mobile is defining heavy users as those who are consuming a certain amount of DATA over a month long period. DATA DOES NOT EQUAL BANDWIDTH. You CANNOT consumed 2 TB of data just during your lunch or peak hours of 7 - 9 PM. It's physically impossible, no matter how much tethering you do.
 
So again, you don't understand the difference between data and bandwidth. Slower speeds during lunch or peak hours are 100% caused by the number of users times the available bandwidth. None of that has anything at all to do with data over the course of a billing period. T-Mobile is defining heavy users as those who are consuming a certain amount of DATA over a month long period. DATA DOES NOT EQUAL BANDWIDTH. You CANNOT consumed 2 TB of data just during your lunch or peak hours of 7 - 9 PM. It's physically impossible, no matter how much tethering you do.

The thing you're missing is that data caps limit usage. If I had unlimited data on Verizon, I would consume more data, and thus consumer more bandwidth. If I had unlimited tethering, I'd be using it all the time and consuming bandwidth.

It's not like data and bandwidth are completely separate. Data, when being consumed, consumes bandwidth. Using more data means using more bandwidth.

Data does not equal bandwidth, but they are intimately linked.
 
So again, you don't understand the difference between data and bandwidth. Slower speeds during lunch or peak hours are 100% caused by the number of users times the available bandwidth. None of that has anything at all to do with data over the course of a billing period. T-Mobile is defining heavy users as those who are consuming a certain amount of DATA over a month long period. DATA DOES NOT EQUAL BANDWIDTH. You CANNOT consumed 2 TB of data just during your lunch or peak hours of 7 - 9 PM. It's physically impossible, no matter how much tethering you do.

The point of the matter is, huge amounts of data necessitates accessing the available bandwidth for long periods of time, thus affecting the performance of all users on the network.
 
The thing you're missing is that data caps limit usage. If I had unlimited data on Verizon, I would consume more data, and thus consumer more bandwidth. If I had unlimited tethering, I'd be using it all the time and consuming bandwidth.

It's not like data and bandwidth are completely separate. Data, when being consumed, consumes bandwidth. Using more data means using more bandwidth.

Data does not equal bandwidth, but they are intimately linked.

Data caps limit usage for a completely arbitrary reason that has nothing to do with network congestion. As illustrated in the chart I provided, a heavy user and a light user will have the exact same effect on the network during peak hours. What you are saying is that the heavy user will hit the cap, and for the rest of the month he will have a smaller impact due to throttling. This is true, but it's not really fair since he didn't cause any more network traffic during peak hours than the guy who just watches netflix during dinner. There is zero reason to do a cap based on accumulated data over the course of 30 days. The only thing that matters is bandwidth used during peak hours, everything else is irrelevant. And the ISP's don't have to do anything to correct this. IP networks will self throttle everyone equally during congested times, and that is fair because everyone during those times is causing the congestion, not just the heavy users.

Let me explain it using roads as an analogy. Let's say you have a 4 lane freeway. The 4 lanes are only needed during rush hour, when the freeway is at capacity. Everyone on that freeway during rush hour is equally contributing to the slower moving traffic. It doesn't matter who was on the freeway at 3 AM when traffic is super light. The light "netflix user" would be the guy who is commuting to and from work during rush hour. Otherwise he isn't on the road. His total "data usage" AKA miles driven, is low for the month. Now the heavy user is the guy who is driving on the freeway back and forth constantly, 24/7. He is also driving on the road during rush hour, contributing to traffic congestion. But his additional driving during off peak hours is zero impact on congestion because the freeway is being underutilized during those hours. His total "data usage" or miles driven is quite high because he is driving constantly, but his actual impact on congestion during rush hour is IDENTICAL in every single way to the lower usage "netflix guy". Tethering in this case would be the difference between having a single person in the car (not tethered), vs having the car packed full of people (tethered). That car is only going to use the exact same amount of space on the freeway regardless of how many people are in the car. And if people are tethering to create a wifi hotspot to share a single unlimited data connection, then that is the equivalent of car pooling, which actually LOWERS congestion. Does this make sense now?
 
The point of the matter is, huge amounts of data necessitates accessing the available bandwidth for long periods of time, thus affecting the performance of all users on the network.

No, it only affects users during PEAK HOURS. The amount of data used off peak is completely irrelevant. Congestion is only caused by a lot of users on at the exact same time. It has nothing at all to do with data used over a long period of time.
 
No, it only affects users during PEAK HOURS. The amount of data used off peak is completely irrelevant. Congestion is only caused by a lot of users on at the exact same time. It has nothing at all to do with data used over a long period of time.

Exactly... peak hours. You know, those times other users who are paying for access to the network are wanting to use the network, are following the rules without trying to cloak their activity, are paying for use of the network, and are now suffering poor performance because of some greedy individuals who think using 2TB of data on a wireless network doesn't hurt anyone else?

Because everyone knows bandwidth is infinite and free.
 
Data caps limit usage for a completely arbitrary reason that has nothing to do with network congestion. As illustrated in the chart I provided, a heavy user and a light user will have the exact same effect on the network during peak hours. What you are saying is that the heavy user will hit the cap, and for the rest of the month he will have a smaller impact due to throttling. This is true, but it's not really fair since he didn't cause any more network traffic during peak hours than the guy who just watches netflix during dinner. There is zero reason to do a cap based on accumulated data over the course of 30 days. The only thing that matters is bandwidth used during peak hours, everything else is irrelevant. And the ISP's don't have to do anything to correct this. IP networks will self throttle everyone equally during congested times, and that is fair because everyone during those times is causing the congestion, not just the heavy users.

Let me explain it using roads as an analogy. Let's say you have a 4 lane freeway. The 4 lanes are only needed during rush hour, when the freeway is at capacity. Everyone on that freeway during rush hour is equally contributing to the slower moving traffic. It doesn't matter who was on the freeway at 3 AM when traffic is super light. The light "netflix user" would be the guy who is commuting to and from work during rush hour. Otherwise he isn't on the road. His total "data usage" AKA miles driven, is low for the month. Now the heavy user is the guy who is driving on the freeway back and forth constantly, 24/7. He is also driving on the road during rush hour, contributing to traffic congestion. But his additional driving during off peak hours is zero impact on congestion because the freeway is being underutilized during those hours. His total "data usage" or miles driven is quite high because he is driving constantly, but his actual impact on congestion during rush hour is IDENTICAL in every single way to the lower usage "netflix guy". Tethering in this case would be the difference between having a single person in the car (not tethered), vs having the car packed full of people (tethered). That car is only going to use the exact same amount of space on the freeway regardless of how many people are in the car. And if people are tethering to create a wifi hotspot to share a single unlimited data connection, then that is the equivalent of car pooling, which actually LOWERS congestion. Does this make sense now?

Dude, I'm a professional network administrator. That's my job. I understand bandwidth and data. Ypu don't need analogies.

Data caps limit how often users consume bandwidth.
 
Dude, I'm a professional network administrator. That's my job. I understand bandwidth and data. Ypu don't need analogies.

Data caps limit how often users consume bandwidth.
For some reason during his pedantic tirades, he's completely missing the points that someone sucking as much data down the straw as their device can handle 24/7 throughout the month means the person is going to be impacting "peak time" all the time *and* that "peak time" is not merely a 2 hour window, 7-9pm PST, for a multi-national provider.
 
For some reason during his pedantic tirades, he's completely missing the points that someone sucking as much data down the straw as their device can handle 24/7 throughout the month means the person is going to be impacting "peak time" all the time *and* that "peak time" is not merely a 2 hour window, 7-9pm PST, for a multi-national provider.

No, but there are... lanes, you see, and you still go the same distance to get home! DON'T YOU SEE
 
Exactly... peak hours. You know, those times other users who are paying for access to the network are wanting to use the network, are following the rules without trying to cloak their activity, are paying for use of the network, and are now suffering poor performance because of some greedy individuals who think using 2TB of data on a wireless network doesn't hurt anyone else?

Because everyone knows bandwidth is infinite and free.

I never once said bandwidth is infinite or free. No one is talking about bandwidth, we are talking about data. The heavy users also paid for access to the network. The amount of data consumed off peak has dick all to do with network performance. No one is downloading 2 TB of data during peak hours. It's impossible given current wireless speeds.
 
Back
Top