Synology SHR-1 vs RAID 5. Need advice.

FenFox

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 20, 2016
Messages
310
So right now I have a Synology DS918+ NAS and 1x 10 TB WD Red.

My initial plan was to use a single 10 TB drive and buy more 10 TB drives later on, but I'm thinking I should probably buy a second 10 TB drive for the SHR-1 mirror. I know I can't use RAID 5 until I have 3 drives. So here are my questions...

1.) I know that RAID 5 uses striping and parity with 3 disks. I assume SHR-1 does as well?

2.) Ideally, I really wouldn't want to buy more than 2x 10 TBs for now because they're so expensive. But... I can make an exception to buy a third _IF_ it's worth the cost.

a.) Is the striping and parity of a 3rd drive worth it?

b.) Is there any other advantage of using 3x drives over 2 that I haven't mentioned? One user in another forum mentioned this: "Once you have three drives, the Synology can perform regular disk scrubs, pick up this silent data corruption and fix it." So I'm interpreting this to mean that with 3 drives you'll be better protected against bad sectors/data corruption vs two?

Thanks for reading. Thoughts/advice appreciated.
 
You didn't mention it, but the obvious benefit of moving to three disks is that you'll double your storage space - dropping your price per gigabyte of storage. Two 10tb disks in SHR = 10tb storage + 10tb "recovery" vs three 10tb disks in SHR (or raid5) = 20tb storage + 10tb "recovery"

Of course before you bite the bullet you might want to run the calculations to see how likely you are to hit an unrecoverable read error during rebuild if one of your drives fails. I couldn't find the unrecoverable read errors per bits read stat on WD website, but I'm sure it's published somewhere. Standard consumer drives are usually in the 1E14 range, so I'll use that for now. Based on my limited math skills that leaves you with ~ 55% chance of hitting an unrecoverable read error and your rebuild failing.
 
Yeah, I know about having 1x disk for redundancy in both SHR-1 and RAID 5. But I fail to see how that drops my price per gigabyte of storage.

Based on my calculations (using an online calculator), if we're talking about the same thing, RAID 5 - MTTDL for 4 disks is 12.35 Years or 924 years for RAID 6.

So on average it'll take 12.35 years before I'll lose at least some of the data on the array irretrievably with 4 disks.

Still, I want to know if SHR-1 uses striping and parity like RAID 5 and if 3 drives will be better than an SHR-1 mirror because with 3 disks (from what someone told me), you can fix data corruption whereas with 2 I assume you can't because It's just a mirror.
 
Back
Top