Swiftech H20-120 Premium

quadnad

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Oct 24, 2005
Messages
7,656
I've been looking at this kit (the most recent revision which features an Apogee waterblock) mainly because my next build is coming up in November and I want to take the plunge (har har) into watercooling. My objective is to gain a little bit more temperature headroom over the air solutions I'm used to, as well as less variation in temperatures as the seasons pass by.

I will only be cooling my CPU, and I'm looking for a relatively inexpensive kit (no more than $150) that is noob friendly; I'm no stranger to installing components/building/rebuilding etc. in computer systems, but I'm still a little jittery about putting water near my system. Call it paranoia, but since I don't have an experienced water junkie to stand next to me when I build, I'm looking for something simple.

So, having said that, does the Swiftech H20-120 Premium fit the bill? I've spoken to a very experienced guy who runs water 24/7 and he seems to think it's my best option.


EDIT: How does this kit compare to my other (less elegant) option, the Corsair Nautilus 500?
 
Just to update: I've found that the Nautilus lags behind the H20-220 (the dual 120mm radiator version of the H20-120 I have been looking at) by ~2C. Therefore my guess is the standard Swiftech 120 should perform as well as or slightly worse than the Nautilus, which makes me go towards that unit.

It is much easier to install, and if it performs just as well as or better, I might as well go with that. Any opinions?
 
definitly swiftech !! if you planning on future upgrades like cooling CPU and GPU get the dual rad , if you just gonna cool your CPU get the single rad , you can always switch rad later .
Where did you read that the swiftech kit performs worse then the nautilus ???:eek:
The apogee gt that comes with the kit is one of the best blocks behind gtx and fuzion .
If youre afraid of leaks , get some worm clams for your tubing and some metal barbs ... and you dont have to worry any more .
just my 2 cents .
 
Where did you read that the swiftech kit performs worse then the nautilus ???:eek:

I saw a comparison between the Nautilus and 220 (the dual radiator version of the 120) here. If the 500 lags behind the 220 by only 2* on load, then I would have to imagine that with only one radiator the 120 must perform about on par with the 500.

I will only be cooling my CPU with this setup, so the ability to add on more blocks doesn't really apply to me. However, I do want good performance and ease of use. The performance so far seems to be about the same between the two kits, while ease of use goes to the 500 by a mile.

Unless someone has a comparison showing the H20-120 (none of them seem to have the comparison using the Apogee block, only the older block) and the 500 directly, my only option is really to guesstimate from that LegionHardware review.
 
Ok.......just from my experience........

I have a Nautilus 500. It is a great performer and I think, underrated.
I have used it on two different CPUs.
First an e6700 OC'd to 3.35 GHz......idle was 28C, load orthos was 45C, gaming was about 35C.

Currently I have a Quad 6600 OC'd to 3.1 GHz that idles at 30C (coreTemp) and runs quad orthos at 47C with gaming at 37-38C.

My room temp is about 68-70F

The Nautilus was so easy to set up, I cant tell you. The quality of parts is excellent, and the waterblock is of very good quality. About a week or so ago I did replace the Nautilus waterblock with a Swiftech Apogee GTX (non-warped) and the temps honestly didnt change by much......maybe a degree or two. I changed over nostly because I had to remove the MB to make some mods to my case, and I honestly didnt like the hold-down mechanism the Nautilus block used, although I never had any problems with it.
another plus for the Nautilus is you dont have to remove the MB to install the block, and it is very quiet.
 
I have that swiftech setup and I LOVE it. I am upgrading the rad to a 2X120 that I got off another [H] member cheap. I cant wait to see what the temps do with that.

I may keep the 1X120 in the loop just for the hell of it lol.

Do yourself a HUGE favor and order the nice chrome metal fittings. Trust me on that one. I broke 3 of the plastic ones when installing them because I cranked down on them too much, which is easy to do.
 
I have a Nautilus 500. It is a great performer and I think, underrated.
I have used it on two different CPUs.
First an e6700 OC'd to 3.35 GHz......idle was 28C, load orthos was 45C, gaming was about 35C.

Currently I have a Quad 6600 OC'd to 3.1 GHz that idles at 30C (coreTemp) and runs quad orthos at 47C with gaming at 37-38C.

wow! So it'll handle a quad without any fuss? To be honest, since it looks like at the very least the Nautilus performs as well as the H20-120, I'll be going with the Nautilus because of it's ease of use.

I appreciate the responses!
 
have a look at the swiftech 120 compact. It is a lot easier to use and about the same performance as the other 120 kit.
 
wow! So it'll handle a quad without any fuss? To be honest, since it looks like at the very least the Nautilus performs as well as the H20-120, I'll be going with the Nautilus because of it's ease of use.

I appreciate the responses!

Before you blow a gasket.......remember, my Quad is at 3.1 and the VCore is 1.4V.
My board wont go any higher, no matter what I do.

Your mileage can vary depending on what you can ramp up the OC to and how much voltage you're willing to swallow.

But, knowing nothing about the Swiftech kit, the Nautilus is so easy to put in.....its a real great system for the money.
Honestly, I'd really like to have one of those big-ass watercoolers with three fans, and I'd buy Swiftech stuff in a minute after owning the Apogee GTX, but my case is too crowded, and Ive put a bunch of time into it modding it to hold what it has now.......the external solution was just the ticket for me.
 
You should go with the Swiftech kit. I was about to take the plunge on it until I found a good deal on used WC parts on the FS/T thread. I'm still new to custom watercooling and I think that the swiftech kit has good parts that can easily be upgraded in the future.
 
Ok.......just from my experience........

I have a Nautilus 500. It is a great performer and I think, underrated.
I have used it on two different CPUs.
First an e6700 OC'd to 3.35 GHz......idle was 28C, load orthos was 45C, gaming was about 35C.

Currently I have a Quad 6600 OC'd to 3.1 GHz that idles at 30C (coreTemp) and runs quad orthos at 47C with gaming at 37-38C.

My room temp is about 68-70F

The Nautilus was so easy to set up, I cant tell you. The quality of parts is excellent, and the waterblock is of very good quality. About a week or so ago I did replace the Nautilus waterblock with a Swiftech Apogee GTX (non-warped) and the temps honestly didnt change by much......maybe a degree or two. I changed over nostly because I had to remove the MB to make some mods to my case, and I honestly didnt like the hold-down mechanism the Nautilus block used, although I never had any problems with it.
another plus for the Nautilus is you dont have to remove the MB to install the block, and it is very quiet.

cooling not only depends on the block , its also limited by the radiator , pump and tubing . So if you change the block and already got 2° improvement ...you would have gotten possibly more by switching to a decent rad and pump . ;)
 
You should go with the Swiftech kit. I was about to take the plunge on it until I found a good deal on used WC parts on the FS/T thread. I'm still new to custom watercooling and I think that the swiftech kit has good parts that can easily be upgraded in the future.

The problem I have is that the H20-220 APEX Ultra (the dual radiator, larger tubing version of the H20-120) only performs slightly better than the Nautilus 500 [link] [link2]. That kit costs well over $200!

Which would put the H20-120 behind the 220, and probably at or behind the Nautilus. Since $150 is already stretching the limit of what I can really justify on cooling for this new build, upgradeability isn't really paramount either (though you can still add a radiator or new block to the Nautilus as well).

I guess I'm just having an issue going with the one that is significantly more difficult to set up, the same price, with equal or slightly worse performance. As far as I'm concerned, I would have no problem upgrading the Nautilus in a year's time (if I wanted to) with another rad that I could bolt onto the back of my case, then run into the system with the quick-disconnect.
 
You should go with the Swiftech kit. I was about to take the plunge on it until I found a good deal on used WC parts on the FS/T thread. I'm still new to custom watercooling and I think that the swiftech kit has good parts that can easily be upgraded in the future.

second that
 
The review that shows the nautilus is only a bit worse than the Swiftech kit is cooling an X2 CPU... Throw in a Q6600 and you'll really see a difference.
 
The review that shows the nautilus is only a bit worse than the Swiftech kit is cooling an X2 CPU... Throw in a Q6600 and you'll really see a difference.

But the Swiftech Kit in that review has larger tubing and twice the radiators of the H20-120 kit. Do you really think that the standard 120 would outdo the Nautilus given that?
 
The review that shows the nautilus is only a bit worse than the Swiftech kit is cooling an X2 CPU... Throw in a Q6600 and you'll really see a difference.

I also forgot to mention that if you'll notice, the second link in that post [here] shows it cooling the Pentium 660 (stock TDP of 115) running at 4.3 ghz lagging only 1*C off of the H20-220. In other words, that TDP is significantly higher than that of a stock Q6600 (105 if I remember correctly, even lower with the new revision), and yet it still cools almost as well as the H20-220.
 
One thing you will find in watercooling, just like anything else, is the price difference between 50th percentile performance and 75th is much less than between 75th and 95th. Basically, the higher up you go, the faster the price increases.

The 220 is much better than the Nautilus, et al., but probably isn't 40% better (as the price is about 40% more). But I'd go with the 220; you can add to it much easier than with a 120.1 rad.
 
The 220 is much better than the Nautilus, et al., but probably isn't 40% better (as the price is about 40% more). But I'd go with the 220; you can add to it much easier than with a 120.1 rad.

If I had the money to go with the 220, this thread wouldn't exist. The issue is that I'm deciding between the H20-120 and the Nautilus (both sell for ~$150). The reason I have been comparing the Nautilus to the H20-220 is because there are no comparisons between it and the H20-120, and since the Nautilus lags only slightly behind the H20-220 I'm having a hard time justifying the H20-120.

EDIT: I'm beginning to warm up to the flexibility of the H20-120 (it is easier to upgrade, and allows for internal/external mounting), but I'm still hung up on the performance. Nobody seems to compare it with anything more useful than the damn stock cooler...
 
So is there an expert consensus as to which I should go with?

Should I go with the H20-120 to take advantage of the flexible installation options and easier upgradability (remember though, I'd only be looking to upgrade for more CPU cooling, as that's the only component I'm cooling)? Or does the Nautilus with it's easier installation and potentially better performance (unless someone can prove otherwise) make it worth the cash?
 
If you want two separate parts (rig and cooling unit) buy the Nautilus. If you have a convenient place to put the 120 rad and don't want 2 separate parts, then buy the Swifty kit. They're about the same.
 
So is there an expert consensus as to which I should go with?

Should I go with the H20-120 to take advantage of the flexible installation options and easier upgradability (remember though, I'd only be looking to upgrade for more CPU cooling, as that's the only component I'm cooling)? Or does the Nautilus with it's easier installation and potentially better performance (unless someone can prove otherwise) make it worth the cash?

flexibility and future upgradability for only around $10 - $15 more ....should be worth it .
 
I've decided in the end to scrap the idea of going with either kit, because I'm just not persuaded that the performance of a $150 kit will be good enough for my needs (or significantly better than air cooling).

It looks as though watercooling isn't worth it unless you make sure that all the major components are top notch, so instead I will be upping my budget to $250, and have begun another thread dedicated to a custom kit.

I'd like to thank everyone for their contribution to this thread, and I'd appreciate it if you would leave you comments in this new thread about my part selection.

Link to the new thread: [link]
 
Back
Top