Suggest an upgrade for me

splooger

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 21, 2004
Messages
239
My current system is an Athlon 64 (939 PIN) FX-53 with ASUS A8V mobo, twin 74 GB Raptor 10k drives in RAID 0, 2 GB RAM, and BFG GeForce 6800 Ultra OC. I've been out of the loop for the past few years about the latest hardware and was wondering if there is a relatively cheap upgrade I can do to get significantly better performance in the latest games? It's not that my system is slow, it's just that I can't turn all the option on high at 1600x1200 resolution like I use to (Company of Heroes, for example).
 
The cheapest upgrade would probably be a A64 X2 and possibly a mobo as I am unaware if your board supports DC cpu's. A new gfx would also give a nice little boost aswell.

DFI Ultra-D $100
3800+ X2 $150
7900GT $240

So about $490

For the latest and greatest

Core 2 Duo E6300 $185
Gigabyte DS3 $150
7900GT $240
2gigs of ram $200

Which is around $775 lol, how ironic that the cost is the pin count on cpu.

It really boils down to how much you are willing to spend.
 
If you're looking for more video performance, you'll want to upgrade your videocard. However, because you're still on AGP, you'll need to switch boards.

I'd grab a decent 939 PCI-E motherboard like this one, get a 7900GT, and overclock the processor. You should be able to at the very least sell the videocard to recoup some of the money.
 
This is my system specs:

LIAN LI PC-V1000 ALUMINUM QUIET TOWER no power
Noisetaker P Series EG701P-VE SFMA
ASUS MB A8V-DX K8T800 DDR400 GBLAN 939-PIN SATA RAID AGP8X 5PCI AUD GBLAN WIFI
AMD Athlon 64 FX-53(OEM-939 PIN) ADAFX53DEP5AS OEM
Thermal Grease, Shin-Etsu G675, apply combo(cools cpu better)
Thermaltake AMD K8 Venus 7+ Highest Performance Cooler for AMD Opteron A1770
Corsair 2GB (2x1GB) TWINX2048-3200PRO - DDR, XMS3200, 128Mx64, non-ECC, 184 DIMM, unbuffered, 3-4-4-8, 64Mx8 DRAMs, PRO series with activity LEDs =
WD 740GD 74 GB SATA 10K Raptor
WD 740GD 74 GB SATA 10K Raptor
RAID 0 SETUP FEE
Sony DVD-ROM (DDU1621/SV) 16X Internal IDE/EIDE 512KB 100-85ms bulk
Plextor 52X32X52 PX-PREMIUM/SW Retail Box Beige
FLOPPY DRIVE MITSUMI 35W
CREATIVE AUDIGY 2 ZS, 24BIT, ADVANCED HD SOUND RETAIL
BFG 6800Ultra-DVD256 nVIDIA GeForce 6800-ULTRA DDR3 256 MB AGP Bus Rate 4X 8X

Would I be able to use the following mobo and video card from Newegg and still be able to use all my other components such as RAM, power supply, and Raptors?

Mobo:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16813131530

Video card:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16814102051

Would that be a good idea? Would I get a lot better performance, even with my FX-53?

Thanks.
 
In terms of video performance, you'll get leaps and bounds more performance. In fact, you'll probably notice a slight general performance boost because of the Nforce 4 chipset rather than that via solution in your current board.

Remember: you'll most likely need to reformat when you switch out the mobo.
 
quadnad said:
In terms of video performance, you'll get leaps and bounds more performance. In fact, you'll probably notice a slight general performance boost because of the Nforce 4 chipset rather than that via solution in your current board.

Remember: you'll most likely need to reformat when you switch out the mobo.

But will I be able to keep all my other components? I don't want to have to buy another power supply or RAM, for example.

Something else I thought of. I believe I read Windows XP's copy protection is dependent on your hardware configuration. If I changed my mobo would Windows XP still work?
 
splooger said:
But will I be able to keep all my other components? I don't want to have to buy another power supply or RAM, for example.

Something else I thought of. I believe I read Windows XP's copy protection is dependent on your hardware configuration. If I changed my mobo would Windows XP still work?

What's your PSU?

All of your other components will work with that board. As far as XP, it seems iffy. I put together a brand new system, only carried over one SATA drive, and XP activation went through fine. If you have problems you can call them and tell them it's for a new comp.
 
splooger said:
But will I be able to keep all my other components? I don't want to have to buy another power supply or RAM, for example.

Something else I thought of. I believe I read Windows XP's copy protection is dependent on your hardware configuration. If I changed my mobo would Windows XP still work?

depends if you use an oem or retail version of windows.

quadnad said:
In terms of video performance, you'll get leaps and bounds more performance. In fact, you'll probably notice a slight general performance boost because of the Nforce 4 chipset rather than that via solution in your current board.

Remember: you'll most likely need to reformat when you switch out the mobo.

i've swapped out a mobo before and didnt need to reinstall windows. all i had to do was install the drivers for it. but a reinstallation isnt a bad idea either. that way you may get rid of any potential problems.
 
protias said:
depends if you use an oem or retail version of windows.



i've swapped out a mobo before and didnt need to reinstall windows. all i had to do was install the drivers for it. but a reinstallation isnt a bad idea either. that way you may get rid of any potential problems.

I'm not sure if I have an OEM version or not. How can I tell? If I have the OEM version would it not work if I change my mobo?
 
Yes, those products will all work fine together.
http://www.aumha.org/win5/a/wpa.php
http://www.aumha.org/win5/a/wpa.php said:
What hardware gets checked?
The WPA system checks ten categories of hardware:

1. Display Adapter
2. SCSI Adapter
3. IDE Adapter (effectively the motherboard)
4. Network Adapter (NIC) and its MAC Address
5. RAM Amount Range (i.e., 0-64mb, 64-128mb, etc.)
6. Processor Type
7. Processor Serial Number
8. Hard Drive Device
9. Hard Drive Volume Serial Number (VSN)
10. CD-ROM / CD-RW / DVD-ROM

It then calculates and records a number based on the first device of each type that was found during setup, and stores this number on your hard drive. Initially, this is sent to Microsoft in an automatic dial-up, together with the Product ID number derived from the 25-character unique Product Key used in setting up Windows.

If Service Pack 1 has been installed, the entire Product Key is also transmitted: This can then be checked against a list of known pirated keys

The hardware is checked each time Windows boots, to ensure that it is still on the same machine. Also, if you subsequently perform a complete format and reinstall of Windows, Microsoft’s activation center will have to be contacted again because the information held on the machine itself (the number previously written to your hard drive) will have been wiped out by reformatting the hard drive. If your hardware is substantially the same, this will be done by an automated call without your needing to talk to anyone.

What does ‘substantially the same’ mean? WPA asks for ‘votes’ from each of these ten categories: ‘Is the same device still around, or has there never been one?’ Seven Yes votes means all is well — and a NIC, present originally and not changed, counts for three yes votes! Minor cards, like sound cards, don’t come into the mix at all. If you keep the motherboard, with the same amount of RAM and processor, and an always present cheap NIC (available for $10 or less), you can change everything else as much as you like.

If you change the device in any category, you have lost that Yes vote — but will not lose it any more thereafter if you make changes in that category again. So, for example, you can install a new video display card every month for as long as you like.
You'll probably need to reinstall windows, which is good because its always nice to have a fresh clean start.

splooger said:
I'm not sure if I have an OEM version or not. How can I tell? If I have the OEM version would it not work if I change my mobo?
Where did you get it? lol... if it came with a computer, its most likely OEM. If you bought a retail box, then its retail.
 
enginurd said:
Yes, those products will all work fine together.
http://www.aumha.org/win5/a/wpa.php

You'll probably need to reinstall windows, which is good because its always nice to have a fresh clean start.


Where did you get it? lol... if it came with a computer, its most likely OEM. If you bought a retail box, then its retail.

It came with my computer from Monarch.com, so I guess it's OEM. How does that figure into the copy protection? If I understand the above correctly, by changing the mobo and video card, I would only lose 2 yes votes, and would not have to buy Windows XP again, right?
 
splooger said:
It came with my computer from Monarch.com, so I guess it's OEM. How does that figure into the copy protection? If I understand the above correctly, by changing the mobo and video card, I would only lose 2 yes votes, and would not have to buy Windows XP again, right?
Not quite... changing the mobo changes the NIC, which accounts for 3 yes votes... so you'd lose 5. I'm still not sure how many yes votes you start off with, lol. Theres 10 categories, and each has 1 yes vote except for the NIC, which has 3, right? so you have 12 yes votes to start out with? If so, 12-5 = 7, you should be good :eek: If not, call MS and tell them your mobo died and you're replacing it while also changing the vidcard, but the CPU, RAM, HDD, Optical drive, etc is all the same. So... two HW changes shouldn't require you to purchase a new license.
 
enginurd said:
Not quite... changing the mobo changes the NIC, which accounts for 3 yes votes... so you'd lose 5. I'm still not sure how many yes votes you start off with, lol. Theres 10 categories, and each has 1 yes vote except for the NIC, which has 3, right? so you have 12 yes votes to start out with? If so, 12-5 = 7, you should be good :eek: If not, call MS and tell them your mobo died and you're replacing it while also changing the vidcard, but the CPU, RAM, HDD, Optical drive, etc is all the same. So... two HW changes shouldn't require you to purchase a new license.

thats cheating and technically "illegal." but as far as oem licenses go, it get put on and dies with the mobo. so you will need a new license to actually install windows to be completely legal.

i could go into ways to get around it, but that is not allowed on these forums.
 
protias said:
thats cheating and technically "illegal." but as far as oem licenses go, it get put on and dies with the mobo. so you will need a new license to actually install windows to be completely legal.

i could go into ways to get around it, but that is not allowed on these forums.
There are two versions of OEM Windows XP systems. One can be purchased separately, with qualifying subsidiary hardware, and installed with that hardware to an existing machine, to which it becomes bound. The software may be reinstalled and reactivated indefinitely as with a retail system as long as it is still on the original machine. It may not be transferred to a different computer. It is activated as described above, but if it were installed to hardware seen as not substantially the same, the activation would be refused as falling outside the license.

In the other OEM form, the system is provided pre-installed by a major supplier. Instead of activation, the system is ‘locked’ to the BIOS on the motherboard. The validity of this lock is checked at boot. As long as this is satisfied, other hardware may be changed freely, but any replacement motherboard must be for a compatible one supplied by the original maker.

If a BIOS-locked system is installed to a board where the lock fails, it enters a normal Activation process at startup. However, beginning 1 March 2005, the Product Key supplied on a label by the computer manufacturer, and used for the initial intallation, will not be accepted for activation. A new copy of Windows XP, with a license allowing installation on a different machine, will be needed. This means that any replacement motherboard (or upgrade to its BIOS) must be supplied by the original maker, who will ensure the lock is maintained.
So if you go through MCS to replace the mobo, they can maintain your license (IF its that type of oem license). If its the other type, then what I originally stated should still apply. Here's why... the issue would be, is it still the same computer? If 7 votes are yes, then it is still the same computer.

Changing a couple parts is valid within the license... changing too many parts constitues a new computer, invalidating the oem license.
 
My personal Windows XP Pro OEM copy that I got within a month of XP's debut has been installed at least 20 times now. I've only ever had it installed on one PC at a time, as in on my own personal system. In that time I've switched out more components than I can remember, but at least 4 different CPUs, 6 hard drive configurations, 3 video cards, and 4 motherboards (Socket A, 754, 939). It's usually been one or two components at a time that have been replaced, and a bunch of OS reinstalls with no hardware change. Yeah, I'm a tweaker and a power user.

I've slipstreamed SP2 so that the install goes faster, and I just about always have to call the number for MS and tell them that, yes, it's only installed on one computer. I'm always truthful about what I'm doing.


I also build systems at work, for friends, and family and I've used retail, OEM, and Dell branded CD's (from OEM vendors on pricegrabber) for systems. Just today at work I activated a Dell OEM. The mobo died, I ripped all the guts out and replaced them - I mean everything (I hate the stuff Dell builds!) - and reinstalled with the Dell OEM CD that came with the system. Called MS and got activated. I'm not buying a new OS because a Dell crapped out and I decided to build a more current system with more power requirements. I've done similar to this at least 50 times in the last few years.

For client builds I do always insist on retail, OEM, or a 'branded' Windows XP. I don't care to be a pirate. And I also will not install a non-original CD (except my personal slipstreamed one on my own pc) or one that I know someone else has installed on another system. I think Windows XP, while it has it's moments, is a great piece of software and MS should be paid for it. I don't care to pay $200-300 for it when I can get one for $60-80 for an OEM or Dell branded copy though.

What I'm getting at is that if you are just going to 'idle' the replaced parts - either sell them or store them - but not install the same copy of Windows on them then I'd go for it and not worry. Part of that defiition is that they are "parts" that are left over, and not a "system". And there is no 'copy protection' per se, but you will likely have to call MS and go through the hoops to activate after reinstalling. The 'hoop' is answering ''just this one system' to "How many computers is this copy of Windows installed on?" Personally, I think you're 100% legit here to replace mobo, cpu, ram, video card.

If MS started some copy protection to inhibit upgrades and upgraders like me I'm sure they'd lose a bunch of business. It'd probably actually be the thing that would finally push me into a version of Linux. Besides, it's kind of a built-in "feature" of Windows that power users need to reinstall every 6 months max, and until they address that we're stuck with the current situation!
 
Back
Top