Students Make $15 Portable Solar Panel / Light Source

Someone needs to give these guys some money to get this thing off the ground.

No kidding.

I'm currently doing my senior project on some lame parking sensor thing. If only I was partnered up with those guys.. :(
 
oh hey.....i plan on going to U michigan this fall. Hooray for getting into their engineering school
 
$15 translates into $100 after marketing and greed are factored in.

we will never be able to buy this for $15.
 
oh hey.....i plan on going to U michigan this fall. Hooray for getting into their engineering school

Going to be in A2 or Dearborn? One of my good friends graduated from Dearborn, interned with Chrysler, and is now working for Ford. Good school to get into for sure.
 
$15 + packaging cost + distribution costs + school's cut + advertisement costs + sales tax + whatever we want to tack onto it costs = $50+ dollars.
 
After I saw the big "M" I knew it was a scam.
We don't give a damn for the whole state of Michigan, we're from Ohio!
 
After watching the video and reading the fluff piece on the website, it offers absolutely no details as to what makes their device any cheaper and/or more efficient that existing devices which cost a whole lot more.

The problem I see with using any lithium batteries is that they die when they're heated up and I can see the solar panel getting really, really hot in the sun.

Also $15 dollars may be nothing to you and me, but in a lot of developing nations it's at least several day's wages, so the device had better last a few years.

I'd think that the crank LED lights that I can get at a dollar store here in the US for <$5 would be just as useful and more cost effective.
 
They're out to make money. If they weren't, they would have just given the plans out freely on the net for others to just build one themselves. This will never be $15.
 
Hopefully the U doesn't want to take them for 2/3 profits and 1/4 of stock like that post a few days ago. What a crock that was, sounds like robbery to me.
 
I'm trying to find the innovation here, as it stands it looks like they re-made a solar powered flashlight. Small solar cell (not that expensive), charges some batteries, which when you flip a switch get DC power to power LEDs... I guess 100 lumens is their goal, Cree currently has many LEDs that go beyond the 100 lumen per watt barrier, although those typically are a bit more pricey than the ones they used.

The real part that got me was the whole charging your cell phone talk to others in your village piece, how much do cell phones/cell plans cost "over there"?? Overall, I see the idea here is they're trying to make it cheaply as opposed to doing something innovative.
 
Its going to have to be cheap because its aimed at poor developing countries, not the US. This product makes little sense in the US as we access to lights and energy. Solar chargers for cell phones are already for sell here, but make little sense. This could be neat for camping, but it probably won't sell like hot cakes here.
 
It looks like they're trying to hit an affordability goal, but around $20 is still too much for most of the third world as far as I can tell.

see here: http://cgi.ebay.ca/Solar-Battery-Pa...980?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item230de13f54

i have brought several of these to friends in jamaica(a third world country) and they work great! the last one i brought had a super bright white LED on the end for use as a flash light. sorry, these kids are not pioneers and have they not heard of the google?!

oh wait, here's one with a light: http://cgi.ebay.ca/Solar-Panel-LED-...er_MP3_Player_Accessories&hash=item3a56a3865b

Um, how much of the third world do you know has ebay, let alone enough money to cover the cost of product plus actual shipping for those items?
 
It looks like they're trying to hit an affordability goal, but around $20 is still too much for most of the third world as far as I can tell.



Um, how much of the third world do you know has ebay, let alone enough money to cover the cost of product plus actual shipping for those items?

What he's saying is that the product already exists, and they are already ~15 dollars. It doesn't take 3 university students with "a story about their early life" to come up with a solar charger for batteries.

IMO there's no innovation here.
 
I don't really can if it's innovation or not, people working on technology like this is never a bad thing. They could go on afterwards to do something more meaningful. We should be encouraging this type of work, not disregard it because it doesn't meet our "invention" expectations...
 
Um, how much of the third world do you know has ebay, let alone enough money to cover the cost of product plus actual shipping for those items?

It says the ~$16 ish price already includes free international shipping...

So I am also scratching my head now about why this is so special that it merits a $500G award of venture capital... I am not discrediting the effort of someone working on technology like this, but I am trying to understand what's going on here.

The written story quotes one of the guys saying:
There are products now that offer either discrete lighting or basic electricity, but not both. And these products are expensive due to high internal component costs

Well... that seems to be flat-out wrong! As people have just linked, clearly there are products that offer "discrete lighting" as well as "basic electricity" at the same time, and cheaply...

There's got to be something here that we don't know, that would explain why this is better and more innovative than the things already in existence.

We've developed circuitry that solves both of these problems affordably.

Maybe if we knew more details about that, then we would understand...
 
Do the cheap ones that were previously linked have charging and lighting capability at the same time? Does the light offer 100 lumens or more? I don't know how many lumens are equal to "high-bright LED" and the one with the light doesn't state that it can be used at the same time as charging a cell phone.

My point is that those 2 linked products look pretty crappy. It's possible that the one Abdrahamane Traoré has created could be a superior product. Being on a tech related site we all know that price doesn't mean everything when it comes to technology.

"There are products now that offer either discrete lighting or basic electricity, but not both. And these products are expensive due to high internal component costs," Amin said. "We've developed circuitry that solves both of these problems affordably."

"Kerosene lamps provide 60 lumens of light, which is really not much," Amin said. "It strains the eyes. Our product can give up to 100 lumens, which is really ample for reading at night time."
 
...
and the one with the light doesn't state that it can be used at the same time as charging a cell phone.

As far as I can tell, it doesn't say that this new thing can do charging and lighting at the same time either...
 
It says the ~$16 ish price already includes free international shipping...

So I am also scratching my head now about why this is so special that it merits a $500G award of venture capital... I am not discrediting the effort of someone working on technology like this, but I am trying to understand what's going on here.

The written story quotes one of the guys saying:


Well... that seems to be flat-out wrong! As people have just linked, clearly there are products that offer "discrete lighting" as well as "basic electricity" at the same time, and cheaply...

There's got to be something here that we don't know, that would explain why this is better and more innovative than the things already in existence.



Maybe if we knew more details about that, then we would understand...

this is my point exactly! ytf is thier product so inovative and deserving of this 500G?! yeah the products i linked are ugly and cheap but so is the one the guys demo'd in the video! i agree that developing existing tech into cheaper versions for the developing world is important but this is simply nothing new! this seems to me like some class project that got way more attention and credit than it deserved. as far as charging AND lighting at the same time... i have no idea i didn't try it and the video/story did not mention it either.
 
People in Afghanistan which are around the same society/culture as most 3rd world countries, they are lucky to make $1,000 a YEAR.... $16 is a lot, but with donations and shit I bet they can get a lot of these lights out to the people whom need it.

I believe shit like this has already been invented though, I see shit like it online all the time as "solar shed lights"
 
Back
Top