Storage upgrade (A8V-VM + Adaptec 5805)

A3D

n00b
Joined
Aug 2, 2007
Messages
9
Hi,

I need to drastically increment my storage and ensure high availability (computer must be 24/7 on). I need it to be a computer not a NAS.

Currently I have a "server" that was made of left-overs. It consists of:
Motherboard: Asus A8V-VM
CPU: Athlon 3500+
RAM: 2 GB
OS: WinXP PRO 32
HDD 1 (OS): Maxtor 160GB
HDD 2 (DATA): Maxtor 500GB
HDD 3 (external, backup): WD 500GB
PSU: generic 650W

I would like to upgrade the current setup to the following:

Case: Lian-Li PC-A77
Mobile rack: Supermicro CSE-M35T-1B
HDD 1 (OS): 2x160GB RAID 1
HDD 2 (DATA): 3x1TB WD RE3 in RAID 5
RAID: Adaptec 5805
Motherboard: same as previous
RAM: same as previous
PSU: ???

Questions:

1. Any idea if the Adaptec will function in the A8V-VM motherboard?
2. Is this configuration too shabby? (I read a lot on NAS and basically are low powered computers). Guess this one should work.
3. Basically I am worried about shelling 500€ on a RAID adapter that might not work with the proposed configuration.

Notes:
- current build is very stable (120 days on)
- I cannot upgrde storge as the case is very small (Aspire X-QPack)
- the current data growth made me choose the case. Another mobile rack can be added later.

Thanks.
 
I guess you missed my ranting about Adaptec, but I'd like to steer you away from that if I can:

1. Iffy SATA drive compatibility (most seagate drives incompatible, CCXX 1.5tb seagates dont work, most SSDs dont work except intels - BSODs)
2. LOOONG kernel boot time (almost a minute long)
3. Dodgy windows drivers (dpc latency issues - causing audio dropouts in workstation)
4. Unhelpful support (don't care much about non-enterprise customers)
5. Online capacity expansion / raid migration is a joke (couple weeks to expand a few drives?)

My woes are outlined in more detail in a thread in this forum.
My areca works great, but it's a bit expensive. They do have a 8 port card for about 400-500ish.
The highpoint 4320 is currently on sale for quite cheap @ the egg (320ish), it usually is 600ish.
That might be a good alternative, seeing you're already willing to shell out 500 euros for the adaptec.

That said, the Adaptec card is pretty fast, but that's about it.
But it's optimized for SAS drives, so sata tunneling protocol will introduce overhead
when using w/ SATA drives.

Also, since you seem to be in europe, doesn't chieftec have a decent case w/ lots of drive expandability? I know getting the norco 4020 might be hard over there.
 
Pffff... I was almost decided with Adaptec 8050 :confused:
It seems to be more expensive than the rest, but I made up my mind for this model because Adaptec seems to be the most established mark. And resumably has the best support.

Which Areca model do you have? How does it compare to the 8505?
The 4320 Highpoint model is unavailable so I'll start to check on the Areca model.

As for the cases, I had a look at the chieftec cases. Are they made of plastic?
WH-02 model seemed most apropriate.

Is there anything wrong with the Lian-Li PC-A77 as a server case?

Thanks a lot for your time :)
 
5. Online capacity expansion / raid migration is a joke (couple weeks to expand a few drives?)

I have first hand experience with this... Do ONE drive at a time with OCE or you'll be in the "weeks to a month" time frame.
 
I have several raid cards...

Areca 1231ML w/ BBU
Adaptec 51645 w/ BBU
Adaptec 31605 w/ BBU
Highpoint 4320
Highpoint 2314
LSI 8344ELP

In terms of performance, Areca is one of the top performers, and it has a replaceable DIMM module that's upgradable to 2GB (or 4GB for the SAS model), whereas the Adaptec has onboard 512MB. I think performance wise, it's similar or maybe faster than the Adaptec. The reason I got the 12xx series versus the 1680ix is for the better SATA drive compatibility.

I mentioned the Chieftec case because it might be a cheaper way to go, since I believe they have a case that has 8 internal bays already - you would just need to add two 4 in 3 mobile racks to max it out to 16 drives. You could get the mobile racks later when you exceed 8 drives. The Lian Li with 3 of the 5 in 3 would work as well, but you need to get the mobile racks right away. The old Stacker case could work here as well, if you can find it. You have to be careful with the 5 in 3 mobile racks, because they won't fit in cases that have the metal tabs for 5.25 bays - so check beforehand. Of course, a norco 4020 or similar may be best since the hotswap bays are already there, but they might be hard to get where you are.
 
Alamone,

Thanks a lot for your wise answers.
Cases: I want a tower as I don't have a place where to mount the rack. Lian-Li has good cases so at 200€ I don't think this is an issue.

Controller: I am not sure whether a 12 port controller is not overkill.
I am thinking starting with an 8 port controller.

Mobile rack: I am ordering Supermicro M35S (see link in previous post to an image of a Lian-Li with a few of these).

I am mostly worried if the MB will work with a RAID adapter (no reason for it, just lack of knowledge).
 
It's indeed hard to say about mobo and raid card compatibility. Most raid card vendors have compatibility lists, but they're usually sparse and not very helpful. Bottom line, you just have to try the card to see if it works, or verify someone else has the same configuration working.

That said, I've had my Adaptec, Areca, Highpoint, and LSI cards in several different motherboards (gigabyte X48DQ6, asus P6T Deluxe, asus 790FX chipset - mobo model number escapes me at the moment) without problems. The Highpoint 2314 was a bit finicky with working with certain 4x slots, however, but I assume you'll be using a 16x slot for the raid card.

It's also tough because high-end raid cards aren't generally available in retail, so there's no easy way to try and return cards w/out incurring restock fees, etc. It's kind of a leap of faith.

That said, I believe a lot of members here are running the areca 12xx cards on a lot of different motherboards, and I think they generally have good compatibility. The Adaptec seems to work on a lot of boards fine too.
 
I did my homework and after reading again and again, I settled for Areca 1220.
The case will be the same (Lian-Li PC-A77).

So tomorrow I'll start ordering the mobile rack.

Thanks a lot :)
 
Back
Top