Storage System for HTPC media

EARS = 4K sectors which means XP and WHS will not support them natively without some help.

Also, 2TB drives go on sale all the time. 3TB drives are starting to come out and look like they will be in the $210 range initially (current 3TB external price is ~$208 but limited availability). That is going to put a lot of pressure on 2TB drives to stay under $130.
 
Well I'll read up on that thread but I don't understand why combining the two (HTPC and FS) especially when I doubt more than one user will be connected at a time is a bad idea. It's just not economical to have single function computers laying around.
Just read through the thread. Many people have done the exact same thing you did but even they don't recommend combining the two.
The board didn't work due to it only having vga and no x16 pci-e. The board is fine if the computer is just a file server.
VGA I can understand but the lack of a PCI-E x16 slot isn't that big of deal if you look at it: One of the PCI-Ex8 slots on that motherboard is "open" in the front which means that you can easily fit a PCI-E x16 card into that slot. In addition, it's been shown multiple times that there is no significant difference between a PCI-E x16 card and a PCI-E x8 card.
By expander I meant the SATA Controller Cards you suggested. I'm not sure if by using the term expander I was saying something else. Essentially I think I can get away with using onboard SATA initially and then when I move to more drives add in a controller card.

Yeah you were saying something else when you said "expander". It basically refers to an add-on card that connects to an existing storage controller card and providing that controller with more SATA ports. A bit simplistic of an explanation but should do fine.

Yeah you can use onboard SATA intially and then add in a controller card.

I plan to buy a COOLER MASTER Centurion 590 $60 and a SUPERMICRO 5 Bay Hot-Swapable $100. I do believe I will have to dremel the 5 1/4" little dividers in the case to fit the SM 5in3.
This puzzles me: The Norco 4020 can be stood up on its "side" and therefore transforming it into a standard ATX Tower case. Just remove the "ears on the front side of the case and you get an ATX Tower case. Once stood up, the Norco 4020 is only 5" longer than the Coolermaster RC-590. The Norco is $310 shipped and will provide you with 20 hot-swappable bays + another bay for a OS drive. The Coolermaster RC-590 + 3 of those Supermicro 5in3s will cost $420 shipped and will provide you with only 15 hot-swappable bays.

So why is that Coolermaster route worth the extra $110 and loss of 5 hot-swap bays?
 
Thanks for your help Danny.
Just read through the thread. Many people have done
This puzzles me: The Norco 4020 can be stood up on its "side" and therefore transforming it into a standard ATX Tower case. Just remove the "ears on the front side of the case and you get an ATX Tower case. Once stood up, the Norco 4020 is only 5" longer than the Coolermaster RC-590. The Norco is $310 shipped and will provide you with 20 hot-swappable bays + another bay for a OS drive. The Coolermaster RC-590 + 3 of those Supermicro 5in3s will cost $420 shipped and will provide you with only 15 hot-swappable bays.

So why is that Coolermaster route worth the extra $110 and loss of 5 hot-swap bays?
A less initial cost investment and simply I just don't need it at this time and doubt the future need for 20 drives.

So this is where I'm at currently, keep in mind I'm looking to cut costs since I need to build a HTPC now.
$115 - Intel Core i3-530 CPU
$190 - Supermicro MBD-X8SIL-F-O Intel 3420mATX Motherboard
$113 - Kingston 2 x 2GB ECC Unbuffered DDR3 1333 RAM
$60 - Cooler Master Centurion 590
$100 - Supermicro 5 Bay Hot-Swapable
I'm still looking at drives. I'm thinking about going with the next 512 sector 2TB drives I find on sale. I want 4 drives so I can raid1 mirror leaving me with 4TB mirrored space.

Let say I don't go with the SM 5in3 could I add it later without having any issues?
Is there a certain distro that people are using with this setup? I'd like to boot it off the onboard USB. It has been years since I've played with linux but would like to get back into it. I'm open to any suggested distro.

Thanks
 
You can technically add the 5in3,4in3 etc after the fact without issue, its still all just SATA so no big deal just dont mess up the order you plug them back in ;)

And I have ubuntu 10.2? (whatever the current relerase was 5 months ago) booting just fine from a 1gig thumbdrive that I use on my netbook for random things when I feel like playing with linux. There are numerous guides on the ubuntu site for getting it onto a usb stick and they were easy to follow. Id consider a slightly bigger drive though if you intend to save stuff to it like updates/addons and settings etc.
 
When I think ubuntu I think desktop environment.

Anyone else have a linux distro suggestions?
 
One "nice" thing about Ubuntu 10.04 is that you can use a version without a GUI. Plus it has stock Hyper-V integration components (except for a mouse) so you can run it in Hyper-V alongside WHS pretty easily.
 
What do you mean about Ubuntu 10.04? Ubuntu has had server versions for a long time, and the default server install does not include any windowing environment or GUI.
 
Back
Top