Stopping Illegal File Sharing a Low Priority for DOJ?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I am not saying illegal file sharing is okay and we certainly do not advocate piracy....but....I think illegal file sharing probably should be a low priority for the Department of Justice. Am I right?

For nearly a decade, major music and film companies have lamented the loss of revenue and jobs that they blame on illegal file sharing. During that time they have lobbied lawmakers and enforcement agencies for antipiracy help. But after reading reports from the FBI and Department of Justice about efforts to protect the nation's intellectual property, I was stunned to find so few cases involving online file sharing.
 
It should be and is. I love it when a plan comes together.
 
During that time they have lobbied lawmakers and enforcement agencies for antipiracy help.

translation:

They paid to get favorable laws passed so they can get absurd amounts of money form individuals and they want LEAs to do all the work in tracking people down.
 
The government should not be the personal pawns of these jackals. I'm glad this is as it is.
 
It would cost the government more money than the companies are losing to track and prosecute all those involved. Suck it up and create a better business model that delivers value to the consumer, MPAA and RIAA.
 
Murder, rape, fraud, illegal substances, actual theft >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> piracy.
 
I'm sure this is put into a similar category as illegal immigration.

Most people don't realize this, but illegal immigration has its benefits and the lowered interest to come into our country nowadays is one of the reason we're having such a hard time recovering from this recession. They fit into a unique category of consumers which pay rent/mortgage in lower income areas to middle class landlords and purchase tons of goods, including goods that they ship back home. There's a reason why border security has an emphasis on drugs/terrorism.

Similar to that, illegal file sharing actually does stimulate other areas of our economy. A lot of those pirates pay for ugraded telecom packages, hardware, concerts/events/shows and even purchase media based on support for "good" IP. That creates jobs and in turn more taxes for the government.

Yes, it's in "our" best interest to lobby for increased IP protection abroad. ...but since it's our export, it doesn't really make sense that we prosecute Americans (since their unspent income would flow elsewhere anyways...hopefully not for legal bills).

The MPAA/RIAA are just pissed because they want the whole pie, not just a piece.
 
this fool Holder is a fool and a racist....after NOT following through on the new black panther dumbasses and their voter intimidation , the bonehead shouldn't spend one second on "piracy" and concentrate on getting his shyte together
 
Media companies are putting way more money into bribing the government, lawyers and suing people than they are actually losing from piracy.

It's a freaking joke how greedy they are.
 
What these companies keep seeming to misunderstand is that people would NOT necessarily buy the same content that they stole when "carpet bombing" a ton of content for free.

The irony is once all the file sharing does stop (if it does) all these companies will be making WAY more than they would have had file sharing not ever become prevalent... because most people didn't consume nearly as much media prior to file sharing if you ask me, and once they've tasted the forbidden fruit that is large libraries of media, chances are they won't want to go back to just listening to the radio or watching TV...

Honestly I'd put file sharing in the same category as being ticketed for doing 10 over - is it illegal, yes. Is there MUCH better ways to utilize the same resources? Hell yes...
 
Media companies are putting way more money into bribing the government, lawyers and suing people than they are actually losing from piracy.

It's a freaking joke how greedy they are.


Everyone is greedy. People want stuff for free instead of paying for it, companies want ever increasing amounts of profit.
 
Everyone is greedy. People want stuff for free instead of paying for it, companies want ever increasing amounts of profit.

Except the RIAA and MPAA wants 45x more than the existing amount of US dollars in the whole world in any form (iirc it's currently $8.4 trillion existing today) lol
 
Yea, but I'm less concerned about RIAA or MPAA wanting more, since they're just selling a luxury good. I'm more angry about pharmaceutical companies and textbook publishers raping the U.S public.

Why is it that the same drug sold in Canada is so much cheaper than in the U.S, and the same deal with textbook sold overseas.
 
It is more likely because felony copyright infringement is not what 99% of file sharers are doing.

If you are not making money off it, or doing it to intentionally damage the IP's value, or swapping kiddy pr0n you are looking at what is primarily a civil offense and at worst a very petty criminal offense. The FEDS don't go after jaywalkers either now do they?.

Now if kiddy pr0n or for profit infringement, (counterfeiting or maybe even large scale ad revenue), the feds might get involved then. But little Johnny Warez is just not on the FEDs top list of people to go after.
 
It is more likely because felony copyright infringement is not what 99% of file sharers are doing.

If you are not making money off it, or doing it to intentionally damage the IP's value, or swapping kiddy pr0n you are looking at what is primarily a civil offense and at worst a very petty criminal offense. The FEDS don't go after jaywalkers either now do they?.

Now if kiddy pr0n or for profit infringement, (counterfeiting or maybe even large scale ad revenue), the feds might get involved then. But little Johnny Warez is just not on the FEDs top list of people to go after.
Agreed
 
this fool Holder is a fool and a racist....after NOT following through on the new black panther dumbasses and their voter intimidation , the bonehead shouldn't spend one second on "piracy" and concentrate on getting his shyte together

You act like voter intimidation is not conducted by other groups and individuals.

Technically, any time a politician airs a campaign ad stating their opponent's intent would endanger the economy or security of this country, that politician is engaging in voter intimidation (i.e. "if you vote for that guy, you're harming the country.")

If the Black Panthers were instead the White Panthers, would you still consider Holder a racist for not going after them?
 
please list your examples of voter intimidation so we may be enlightened.................hmmmm..................exactly....liberal I presume
 
the justice departments own voter task force says that it WILL NOT investigate any voter intimidation claims leveled against "minorities"...you look it up , I already did...you sound just like all generic liberal excuse makers...but then , that's your right I guess....
 
please list your examples of voter intimidation so we may be enlightened.................hmmmm..................exactly....liberal I presume

First off, no, I'm not a Liberal. I'm a registered Independent, and have been since I turned 18. Both Republicans and Democrats are corrupt, the only difference is the details. Believing one side over the other is just plain ignorant. I believe Bill Hicks said it best: "I'll show you politics in America right here: I think the puppet on the left shares my beliefs. I think the puppet on the right is more to my liking. Wait a minute...there's one guy holding out both puppets!"

Fuck you very much for assuming things about me, though...I appreciate it.

Now, as to your question, I already listed one:

"Technically, any time a politician airs a campaign ad stating their opponent's intent would endanger the economy or security of this country, that politician is engaging in voter intimidation (i.e. "if you vote for that guy, you're harming the country.")"

How about you respond to what I said instead of trolling?
 
the justice departments own voter task force says that it WILL NOT investigate any voter intimidation claims leveled against "minorities"...you look it up , I already did...you sound just like all generic liberal excuse makers...but then , that's your right I guess....

Your claim, not mine. The onus is on you to provide proof.
 
"saying" something about "the other guy" is protected speech according to most liberals...standing in front of a polling station with clubs and racist speech IS NOT protected and IS against the law...too easy...but then the liberal mind has trouble with common sense and reality for that matter...have a great day though
 
"saying" something about "the other guy" is protected speech according to most liberals...standing in front of a polling station with clubs and racist speech IS NOT protected and IS against the law...too easy...but then the liberal mind has trouble with common sense and reality for that matter...have a great day though

But of course, you aren't one of those liberals, right? So how do you feel about ads like that?


In five seconds, I found this.
 
"Well, this past Tuesday, Commissioner Gaziano brought such statements to AAG Perez’s attention. In testimony before the commission, former Justice Department attorney Christian Adams said that Deputy Assistant Attorney General Julie Fernandes ordered: “Never bring another lawsuit against a black or other national minority, apparently no matter what they do.” Watch Commissioner Gaziano recount the testimony above.

So far, the Obama Justice Department has refused to allow any current DOJ employees like Julie Fernandes to testify before the Commission. Will they allow more transparency now?

There are many other justifiable lines of inquiry. For example, this January Heritage Foundation senior legal fellow Hans von Spakovsky asked:

The more the Obama administration fights the subpoenas from the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights and denies congressmen’s requests for answers concerning the inexplicable dismissal of the voter-intimidation case in Philadelphia against the New Black Panther Party (NBPP), the more reasonable people wonder what the administration has to hide. And so it is appropriate now to ask: What did the White House know and when did it know it?"

the tip of the proverbial iceberg...nice try on your part, but again , it has been put up your "onus"
 
"Well, this past Tuesday, Commissioner Gaziano brought such statements to AAG Perez’s attention. In testimony before the commission, former Justice Department attorney Christian Adams said that Deputy Assistant Attorney General Julie Fernandes ordered: “Never bring another lawsuit against a black or other national minority, apparently no matter what they do.” Watch Commissioner Gaziano recount the testimony above.

So far, the Obama Justice Department has refused to allow any current DOJ employees like Julie Fernandes to testify before the Commission. Will they allow more transparency now?

There are many other justifiable lines of inquiry. For example, this January Heritage Foundation senior legal fellow Hans von Spakovsky asked:

The more the Obama administration fights the subpoenas from the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights and denies congressmen’s requests for answers concerning the inexplicable dismissal of the voter-intimidation case in Philadelphia against the New Black Panther Party (NBPP), the more reasonable people wonder what the administration has to hide. And so it is appropriate now to ask: What did the White House know and when did it know it?"

the tip of the proverbial iceberg...nice try on your part, but again , it has been put up your "onus"

And where did you find this?
 
oh...and by the way...I belive the DOJ should be investigating ALL cases of voter intimidation...just in case you didn't get that from my posts
 
I found that in a little place called the internet ...try it...google is a fantastic thing...that is only one of a miriad of articles and accounts of that particular series of events...a little less time playing WOW might help...thanks
 
OK, first off, the guy making the original claims, J. Christian Adams, was hired by a guy named Bradley Scholzman, has had his own separate investigation that was fiercely divided amongst party lines.

Secondly, I abolustely LOVE how you rail against liberals, yet then go on to quote the Heritage Foundation...one of the most conservative think tanks in the entire country. So, let me get this straight: you think the extremists on the left are loony, so instead you side with the extremists on the right?

Dude. Seriously. Believing one side over the other is what's truly loony. If you honestly think either side has your interests at heart, there's no helping you.
 
the Washington Times?!...hahahaha...purest liberal spin fishwrap.....ok you win...hahaha

EXACTLY my point. A hyper liberal news org has one take on a story...and the hyper conservative side (Heritage, which is where your quote came from) has the exact opposite take.

When two sides can't agree on what facts are, why are you believing either side?
 
actually I watched the testimony for myself...as one would have to do if one was , say , a jurist....but again , you win hahaha
 
actually I watched the testimony for myself...as one would have to do if one was , say , a jurist....but again , you win hahaha

Yet it took you this long to say it, eh?

I would like to point out you have yet to respond to my previous question:

A hyper liberal news org has one take on a story...and the hyper conservative side (Heritage, which is where your quote came from) has the exact opposite take.

When two sides can't agree on what facts are, why are you believing either side?
 
Tha'ts "off" course a little.

spelling failure at device: 000xxx010
 
Back
Top